4 ms·
Hunter-gatherers were mostly gatherers, says archaeologist
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Qem 3y ago> The evidence, from the remains of 24 individuals from two burial sites in the Peruvian Andes dating to between 9,000 and 6,500 years ago The findings are based on remains from people that lived post megafauna extinction. I bet there are good odds the conclusion would be different if those remains were from people that lived during pleistocene, over 10.000 years ago, before people hunted Glyptodonts, Eremotherium and other big game to extinction.
- proc0 3y agoI wonder then if the start of carnivorous diet began around the time humans are thought to have developed language (or more specifically symbolic thinking and/or imagination), I think 20,000 year ago?. Maybe that was the beginning of dominating animals and realizing we can hunt with tools, or maybe there was an abundance of meat and that fueled brain growth which then allowed for symbolic thinking.
- CorrectHorseBat 3y ago20,000 years ago is way too recent. Aboriginals arrived in Australia 50,000 years ago after which they were basically isolated from the rest of the world until the British arrived. Unless you believe humans developed language at least twice it has to have happened before that. Also there are several stories which are believed to be quite a bit older than 20,000 years.
- hackerlight 3y agoI thought it was before that, as soon as we came down from trees and learned to use throwing rocks as a weapon, something like 50k years ago.
- proc0 3y agoFrom reading popular evolutionary science, if I recall, it's the dates of the first cave drawings or other evidence of symbolic thinking like scratch marks on bones to count something. These point to 20-40K years ago.
- andsoitis 3y agoWe have evidence that humans used symbols for self-expression at least 72,000 years ago: https://www.amnh.org/explore/videos/humans/symbolic-thinking https://www.amnh.org/explore/videos/humans/symbolic-thinking
- Fricken 3y agoEvidence regularly turns up that pushes back the dates for how long our ancestors have been doing the special things that make us human.
- Qem 3y agoAnatomically modern humans existed since ~300.000-200.000 years ago[1], and behavioral modernity[2] arised between ~150.000-50.000 years ago. That begs the interesting question, why did civilization appears to have arised only in the last 10.000 years or so? IIRC, the usual explanation is that the climate back in pleistocene was too unstable for agriculture. But I also wonder, perhaps people just didn't feel the need for anything resembling civilization, at least while there was plenty of megafauna to hunt. So humanity spent about 50.000 years just hanging around and enjoying low-hanging calories from the giant beasts, unsustainably, depleting their numbers slowly with stone-age tech. By the end of the ice age we got them completely eradicated almost everywhere. So people had to survive on small-game and gathering, eventualy resorting to labour-intensive agriculture to make ends meet. Once people were forced by self-made scarcity to develop agriculture, civilization followed. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Early_modern_human https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Early_modern_human [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Behavioral_modernity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Behavioral_modernity
- nradov 3y agoAnother interpretation of the available archaeological data is that there was an earlier civilization which was destroyed around 11,000 years ago by a series of bolide impacts (Younger Dryas impact hypothesis). There's no reliable way to date stone structures; we only have circumstantial evidence. And most remnants of a hypothetical Ice Age civilization would likely now be underwater due to sea level rise. I don't necessarily believe this interpretation myself, it's somewhat of a fringe idea and there are lots of holes in the data. But until there is definitive evidence we should be open to the idea that human civilization is older than 10,000 years. https://grahamhancock.com/ancient-apocalypse/ https://grahamhancock.com/ancient-apocalypse/
- GuB-42 3y agoProbably plenty of factors, including chance, mostly chance I suspect. A combination of particular needs, like what you are describing, opportunities, like the right species of plants and animals, the rights ideas, enough success for the agricultural tribes to survive and a willingness to expand and develop the ideas. It can take quite a while before everything goes together.
- arp242 3y agoEh? Homo Erectus ate meat and almost certainly hunted. There's tons of evidence for this. There's also evidence for this for Neanderthals, homo habilis, homo ergaster and probably other early humans. This behaviour goes back millions of years, and has been a major factor in human evolution. Tool in hunting use goes back much further than 20,000 years – at least 400,000 for spears in a quick check, but that's just what we have conclusive evidence for. I wouldn't be surprised if it's actually much older. We have evidence of stone scrapers and axes from millions of years ago, and do you think people using stone scrapers to butcher animals and axes to chip down trees couldn't figure out how to make a pointy sticks? It's just that stone preserves well and pointy sticks don't.
- proc0 3y agoWell then that contradicts the claim of the research in the article, which is fine. I'm just assuming it's correct and then asking questions based on that, mainly how it relates to when humans developed language (not the spoken word necessarily, just the capacity for imagination/language, and that is not that old from what I recall reading).
- bell-cot 3y agoUm, yes? I wasn't aware that any competent professionals in this area (vs., say, machismo wanna-be's pushing their Paleo Diet fantasies on YouTube) believed otherwise.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sharadov 3y ago[flagged]
- matteoraso 3y agoThis is incredibly obvious if you've ever foraged before. Plants are everywhere and stay still while animals are rare to see and constantly run around. You can also get a lot of calories from nuts and grains, so it's not as if you're going to starve if you go a week without catching an animal.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- NotGMan 3y agoOne large animal can feed a family for many months if the meat is preserved/dried. There were no grains before agricultural revolution.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoPeople were making products like acorn flour and breads from that for millennia. Even in societies that never cultivated wheat.
- RoyalHenOil 3y ago"Grain" refers to small, hard, edible seeds. They include not only cereals, but also peas, beans, sunflower seeds, flax seeds, mustard seeds, buckwheat seeds, chia seeds, etc., etc. Grains can come from a huge variety of both wild and domesticated plants. While grains are less important to hunter-gatherering societies than they are to farming societies, grains nevertheless have been a part of the human diet since long before agriculture. The big difference here is that most hunter-gatherers ate extremely diverse diets. Their diets were not dominated by a couple species of cereal grains, like later diets were. Instead, they were eating a huge array of different grains, nuts, fruit, tubers, mushrooms, fish, insects, etc., on a seasonal and regional basis.
- brnt 3y agoIt is not likely meat was preserved for any length of time back then. There were no methods to do so. Look at how predators work now: they eat what they can and the rest is lost.
- NotGMan 3y ago[flagged]
- RoyalHenOil 3y agoThe whole world did not instantly switch to farming upon the invention of agriculture. It took thousands of years for it to spread around the world. Much of the world was still hunting and gathering before European colonization (~1600s to 1800s) put a stop to it, and there are still some cultures that hunt and gather today.
- arp242 3y agoI am not very knowledgable on the history of the Peruvian Andes, or even South-America in general, but I do know that the "agricultural revolution" was not a singular event after which all of humanity on the planet switched to agriculture. Usually the "10,000 years" figure refers to the cultures in Eurasia, which had exactly zero contact with the cultures in South-America. For example, my 40 seconds of in-depth research revealed this map of the state of agriculture in 2,000 BC: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:World_in_2000_BC.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:World_in_2000_BC.svg I have my own criticism of this article, as I posted in my top-level comment, but your criticism just makes no sense and profoundly misunderstands how these things work. It actually makes the same mistake as the authors by over-generalizing the situation from one region to the entire human population in all regions.
- defrost 3y ago[flagged]
- tengbretson 3y agoHe should watch the TV series "Alone"
- belorn 3y agoThrough the last decades there been multiple studies and books arguing for one side or the other. Usually the hunter-side will look at existing native populations in the world and rituals, while the gatherers-side looks at archaeological evidence. Both sides also have strong arguments against them. For the gatherers argument, a main issue is that burial sites themselves implies a immobile natural resource where humans would remain in a single location and still be able to find enough nourishment, generally for a lot of people and for several generations. Cultivation of plants is thus a logical conclusion. The hunters would be constantly moving to new hunting grounds based on where prey animals would be most easy to hunt (in time with seasons), and thus do not leave such burial sites for archaeologists to find. It is a similar problem in defining what tools people used. If all you find left from a time period is stone artifacts like arrow heads, it is easy to make the assumption that people did not use wooden material like sharpened sticks.
- defrost 3y agoStudies of modern hunter-gathers show both behaviours in parallel, both plant cultivation (not modern agricultural market gardening) at seasonal sites, and seasonal hunting. Movement isn't random, it's a progression around a larger territory that may take a decade to fully revisit all parts. Plants, roots, leaves, fruits, etc are gathered around sites where people stay for three months or more, competing unwanted plants are pulled up, weeded out, desired seeds are spread, ground tubers are only partially used with the remainder left to regrow. Animals are hunted about the area, attention is paid to breeding numbers - often plants are used to hunt animals (particular types of young saplings for spears, particular ground up leaves to stun fish in pools). And then they move on to both hunt and gather elsewhere .. with a great deal of the food being gathered. Doing this for 70,000 odd years sees patterns of midden mounds (discarded shells from tidal and river molluscs), bone piles, ock art, etc develop across the landscape .. and living custodians have been pretty good on telling the oral stories of songlines - the movements with yearly and decadal seasons.
- arp242 3y ago"For this specific time period, in this specific location" is the qualifier that should always be used for these type of things. Humans ate ... whatever was available, and that varied quite a bit. And it's not The Guardian misrepresenting the authors with a sensationalist title here, the authors of this study themselves are extrapolating a small and limited study to all early humans. This is complete nonsense, as anyone with the most basic of understanding of the matter will tell you. The hand-waving away of all earlier research with FUD about "male archaeologists from western cultures" is exactly that: anti-intellectual FUD. Hell, if there's any field that is dominated by lefty vegetarian hippie types then it's archaeology (not a complaint, just an observation). In general there's a lot of nonsense peddling surrounding this in vegan circles. I say this as a vegan. People go on about "primal humans being vegan, so that's the natural state" or some such and then you ask about it and they come back with some early human from 4 million years ago. yeah ... that's like a different species mate. The unwarranted anti-intellectual statements make me not trust any of this research. This seems like the sort of "researcher" who will do their damnest to find evidence for their conclusion, no matter what.
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]