4 ms·
If you bought into the idea that OpenAI was developing advanced ML/AI technology as a public utility, isn't that a bit on you? They don't actually owe anybody a
by tptacek 3y ago
If you bought into the idea that OpenAI was developing advanced ML/AI technology as a public utility, isn't that a bit on you? They don't actually owe anybody anything, and never have, so (a) the time to really hammer them on this stuff was a decade ago and (b) they didn't actually take anything from the public to do this, so even a decade ago they could have said "ok whatever" and gotten on with their day.
It would be different, maybe, if everybody else in the industry stood aside and let OpenAI monopolize development of transformer-style-AI (or whatever it is we're calling this) for the common good. But nobody did that; the opposite thing happened. This space has been a Gem Saloon knife fight just waiting to pop off for the entirety of OpenAI's existance.
- blibble 3y ago> They don't actually owe anybody anything non-profits in most countries have to be operating to produce some form of public benefit is this not true in the US?
- swalsh 3y agoI'm not completely convinced OpenAI is not a public good. I've started using it at my company, we found literally millions in value... and it cost us about $60 in tokens.
- tptacek 3y agoIt's a company, with a good product. I like Lao Gan Ma chili crisp way out of proportion to what it costs me, but they're still just a firm. :)
- brcmthrowaway 3y agoHow did you quantify millions?
- swalsh 3y agoWe used the AI to help us find gaps which were being incorrectly billed. So we could just measure the incorrectly billed dollars directly.
- pasc1878 3y agoHopefully you then confirmed that these issues actually existing using another method, Relying on a system to say that you are not charging correctly sounds rather like UK's Post Office Horizon system and we know that ChatGPT will hallucinate things,
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- brcmthrowaway 3y agoYour organization sounds like amateur hour, no offence
- swalsh 3y agoWhat would you reccomend?
- JohnFen 3y agoThat you find value in the product doesn't make them a public good. OpenAI is in it for the money, not for some "public good".
- jonathankoren 3y agoCan’t you say this about literally anything you consume? How is this different than, “I read a scientific paper, and unlocked millions of dollars of value, and all it cost was $250 for 8 pages of text. So I guess Axel-Springer is a public good.”? Just buying and selling something doesn’t make it a public good. Valuable sure, but selling something for a profit makes it by definition not a public good.
- warkdarrior 3y agoOpenAI promised in their IRS statements to provide documentation on their operations. So they owe the public something, and now they reneged on their promise. This article is just pointing out that OpenAI went back on their promises of financial transparency.
- tptacek 3y agoWhat favorable tax treatment has OpenAI received?
- wewtyflakes 3y agoThey were founded as a non-profit; https://openai.com/our-structure https://openai.com/our-structure.
- tptacek 3y agoRight, but the operating organization wasn't.
- pwb25 3y agothey are literally called... wait for it... OPEN-AI not closedAI
- wolverine876 3y agoWe all owe everyone a lot. 99% of what OpenAI - or anyone - has was provided by someone else, from technology (the entire history of computer technology), to science, to infrastructure, an educational system that produces employees, a legal system, financial system, economy, even language, etc. etc. etc. Our communities don't work on their own; they don't work only by government action; it takes all of us. When we forget that, our communities fall apart, if you haven't noticed yet.