4 ms·
Today's architects can learn from a 19th century's lost ventilation system
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mxroeoek 3y ago[dead]
- newsclues 3y agoHeat recovery ventilation
- bobchadwick 3y agoCan someone smarter than me figure out if this is more efficient than mechanical ventilation using a HRV/ERV? I looked at the paper the article references, but I didn't understand the comparisons between various ventilation approaches.
- bombcar 3y agoIt would enhance HRV/ERV setups. Just as old temperature maintenance was done via "no moving parts" (mainly large thermal masses), so old ventilation was done via "temperature drafting". For a long time we've overcome temperature maintenance via just forced air induction heating/cooling, which is not the most efficient. We're now saving some heat by using HRV/ERV but there's likely ways we can utilize things like this is talking about to reduce the energy needed to do it.
- coryrc 3y agoUsing a fan to ventilate is far more efficient than a thirty degree temperature differential.
- amelius 3y agoToday's architects can learn a lot from 19th century's aesthetics too.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- efields 3y agoI read this to the bottom and I don't have a clear explanation of what the lesson is. > By re-reading archival documents, the researchers were also able to clarify the role of British hospital specialist Henry Saxon Snell, who mysteriously backed away from the project after developing its original designs. The board of governors pushed Snell to step down after local consultants argued his ventilation scheme wasn't fit for the cold winter. Implies the design doesn't work??
- mcbishop 3y ago> ...possible to recover heat through partition walls and floors while maintaining a steady ventilation flow. That's as technical as this article gets. I don't think the author understands the ventilation-system design.
- Bloating 3y agoI don't remember if it was Poplar Forest or Monticello, but I vaguely remember something about Jefferson using convection to draw cool air through tunnels to help cool the structure(s). Not related to ventilation, but I found the Trompe compressor to be an interesting example of forgotten technology
- eutropia 3y agothe pdf of the researcher's paper: https://www.cell.com/action/showPdf?pii=S2589-0042%2823%2902842-0 https://www.cell.com/action/showPdf?pii=S2589-0042%2823%2902... Essentially, carefully managing the path that air takes into the building and out allows for heat to be recovered (like a counter-current heat exchanger, or radiator). This is similar to how heat boxes for efficient chimneys work - make the path for hot air to escape necessarily impart the heat into the surrounding brickwork. TFA: > Further analysis shows significant heating savings are possible in mildly cold seasons compared to natural displacement (74%) and natural mixing (60%) ventilation. The 'ducting' for the airflow was hollow cavities in the various masonry walls in the building, forming a circuitous route long enough to recover the heat while maintaining good airflow for ventilation.
- callalex 3y agoI’m amazed how many words this article managed to use without telling us a single thing about how the architecture works.
- M95D 3y agoWasn't the original (disabled) ventilation system that accelerated the Glasgow School of Art fire?