5 ms·
Pentagon moves to declassify some secret space programs and technologies
- dgrin91 3y agoI wonder if this will lead to any more info about the X-37
- sandworm101 3y agoNot likely. This seems to be about moving things from very very top secret to only very top secret, low enough to share with more civilian contractors but still far away from public knowledge... until someone with a high-mobility cubesat starts puttering around taking pictures up there.
- facialwipe 3y agoRiiight because a “high-mobility cubesat” (whatever that is) could ever intercept an orbiting X-37.
- sandworm101 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tw04 3y agoThis is essentially about letting Space-X in on more military missions that today they can only pass through Boeing and co. Presumably Space-X wasn't willing to take an entire chunk of staff and dedicate them to military-only missions and/or had staff that couldn't even pass the stringent security clearance requirements. The US government still wants to utilize them for missions, especially with starship and its payload capacity on the near horizon.
- alephnerd 3y agoIt will also help Boeing, Lockheed Martin, and other military contractors as well. It's good to see the changes happening to help better support our R&D capacity. The old method of having a single contractor monopolize an entire SKU was slowing down innovation and procurement.
- dylan604 3y agoIt'll only help Boeing if they can pull their head out of their backside. To me, this is DoD realizing the Boeing can't do what they claim they can and need a new vendor. It's just that new vendor needs to have the rules modified a bit so they can qualify.
- alephnerd 3y agoBoeing Defense, Space & Security (BDS) is still fairly competitive. The issues with Boeing are occurring in Boeing Commercial Airplanes (BCA), which is basically just McDonnell Douglas. BDS and BCA are both essentially independent of each other.
- dylan604 3y agoWell, you're not reassuring me since Starliner cannot get off the ground.
- AlexAndScripts 3y agoOr keep its doors attached.
- dylan604 3y agoWhen has Starliner not kept its doors attached? Following the content of a thread is a pretty basic expectation. Derailing it onto other subjects is not helpful nor appreciated.
- maerF0x0 3y ago[flagged]
- igleria 3y ago> The policy does not mean that these programs and technologies will now be fully unclassified and revealed to the public; instead, it will lower their classification levels in order to share some technologies and programs with private industry and international allies to help the U.S. build an "asymmetric advantage and force multiplier that neither China nor Russia could ever hope to match," Plumb said in a DoD statement. is this... propaganda for internal and/or external consumption?
- MichaelZuo 3y agoHard to say, the vast majority of people with 'Top Secret' clearances don't ever read a single actual regular 'Top Secret' document, even if they work at the same place for years. So if it's declassified down it's unlikely more than maybe 50k people will ever know about it. But then again it could be some super secret thing where previously only 500 people knew about it, or had the full picture, so that would represent a substantial loosening of restrictions.
- FuriouslyAdrift 3y agoTop secret really isn't that uncommon of a security clearance. The timeliness of the information is usually what makes it top secret with compartmentalization a norm for all programs (need to know). Most common thing I saw that was TS:SCI were future or active deployment orders (as foreknowledge could have disastrous consequences). The really important stuff is under codeword programs. Even if cleared, if knowledge isn't directly needed, then you don't get regardless of clearance.
- MichaelZuo 3y agoYes, the statistic is that apparently over a million people have 'Top Secret' clearances of some kind.
- scottyah 3y agoIf this is somewhere you work, you need to report this to Fraud and Abuse. Clearances and billets cost money, if they are not being used they have no Need to Know. From what you've said, this is pretty clearly fraud. https://www.dodig.mil/components/administrative-investigations/DoD-hotline/ https://www.dodig.mil/components/administrative-investigatio...
- BWStearns 3y agoAside from increasing contractor availability this has the bonus of increasing the access to these capabilities for actual operations (both ours and our allies'). If your magic satellite that can tell who in a crowd is running a fever is SAPed then you might not be able to use it to help your troops or your allies hunt down artillery launches (as an example). So then you need to either do some parallel construction to mask the actual source of the information or just sit by and not help at all. So hopefully this means that we'll see some previously exotic space capabilities trickle down into more pedestrian use cases.
- nonameiguess 3y agoSource redaction has been possible and mostly automated for a long time. Getting information to the front line or "tactical edge" as they call it these days is more about file size, as collections and the initial processed products carry quite a bit of metadata and resolution that isn't needed, in formats not commonly read by tablets and regular software. As it stands, I recall seeing at least a few images of objects in space in the news attributed to sources I know for an absolute fact were not the real sources and no one I'm aware of ever questioned it. So at least some of this stuff is already getting disseminated to the public. It's pretty rare for the content of an image to be classified. More often, it's specifics of the collection capability, i.e. collection angles, occlusion, weather conditions, or in many cases the fact that something can be collected from space at all, but if you tell the viewer it came from a ground telescope, or a collection of the ground was from aircraft rather than satellite, they'll believe it. They have no way of telling otherwise without collection metadata. Hopefully, this effort can further enhance the way files get portion-marked to make it easier to release content when metadata has been redacted, though. My still favorite anecdote is analying test data in which the file was literally just plain ASCII text of the preamble to the US Constitution but it was marked TS/TK/NF because the collection capability was sensitive enough that every file it generated automatically got marked as such even though it had no metadata at all. It was just text. The metadata was in a completely separate file.
- aaroninsf 3y agoIdle comment, among the many forces at work, one is the pressure resulting from the recent intense push for UAP disclosure. Among the specific actionable allegations that have brought by whistleblowers (notably David Grusch) is that there is an exceptional and unwarranted amount of money finding its way to defense and aerospace companies for secret programs which are not subject to congressional oversight; and that one of the conditions for this state of affairs is the out of control evolved intensely siloed classification system. Independent of any allegations about e.g. NHI, numerous Reps have clearly been motivated into action in this specific area—following the money, which might better have been spent in say their own districts—by what they have been told, e.g. in a much-publicized SCIF briefing a week or so ago. And specifically by being repeatedly stonewalled. If there's one way to attract Congress' attention, it's to make it clear that money they should have discretion over is being spent in ways that are intentionally hidden from them. Related: the estimated $1T the Pentagon has not been able to account for in repeated audits.
- psunavy03 3y agoThe Gang of Eight has the keys to the kingdom. 4 Democrats, 4 Republicans. The Speaker of the House, House Minority Leader, Senate Majority and Minority Leaders, and the Chair and Ranking Members of the House and Senate Intelligence Committees have full access to every classified program in the government. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gang_of_Eight_(intelligence) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gang_of_Eight_(intelligence)
- RetpolineDrama 3y agoThey're supposed to, but Harry Reid went on record that as a gang of 8 member he was denied access.
- readyplayernull 3y agoBut are they declassifying the actual documents this time? > The CIA started feeding flawed shuttle designs — NASA rejects — to the Soviet spies, which they passed off as new “improvements.” It worked. Included in the phonies were outdated heat shield designs that could have risked the spacecraft burning up on reentry. https://www.discovermagazine.com/the-sciences/real-life-rogue-one-how-the-soviets-stole-nasas-shuttle-plans https://www.discovermagazine.com/the-sciences/real-life-rogu...
- wolverine876 3y agoDeclassification for contractors and the CIA passing disinformation to enemy intelligence are very different things.
- golergka 3y agoIs it? Wouldn't enemy intelligence see these contractors be the prime targets for infiltration?
- huytersd 3y agoHow cool. I wonder if we still do awesome things like this.
- nwah1 3y agoClinton tried to give fake nuclear weapons designs to Iran. Unfortunately, the nuclear scientist patsy they used, who was supposed to just deliver the designs, noticed some flaws. So he corrected them. So they now have the real designs. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Merlin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Merlin
- huytersd 3y agoThat’s just cool from an Iranian perspective. What a boss move.
- mjhay 3y ago
- aikwerhjliawj 3y agoIt's important to note the cost savings of declassification. Overclassification is incredibly expensive and burdensome (though it also covers the asses of a lot of incompetent bureaucrats). I used to work in the naval nuclear community. There are honestly only a handful of numbers related to the nuclear power plant on each class of ship that actually need to be classified, but every single scrap of paper associated with the program is stamped classified and it's incredibly time consuming and exhausting to work with that mess. I remember back in school one student got called in front of the program CO and threatened with jail time for removing "classified material" from the school building after barracks inspectors found nuclear-related paperwork in the student's bedroom. (This was years before the student was assigned to an actual ship where they could learn the half dozen actually important secret numbers.) The student pointed out that they did not remove any paperwork from the school; the papers in their bedroom were printouts from wikipedia. The student was ordered in writing to not read about nuclear engineering outside of the school building, regardless of the source. Even though it's all publicly available information that is taught in any undergrad engineering program.
- MrDresden 3y ago> ..only a handful of numbers related to the nuclear power plant on each class of ship that actually need to be classified.. What do you actually mean by numbers in this context?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ta93754829 3y agonice try Iran
- danpalmer 3y agoI imagine it's things like the maximum power output of the power plant, the volume it runs at, things like that. Similarly, the max depth of submarines and their audible signature are closely guarded secrets.
- sheepybloke 3y agoOne thing this really drives is competition in the industry as well. I've been doing some work in the industry and there is a lot work that's needed just to handle the data properly. Basically, Space Force is stuck in bed with the big DoD contractors, since they are the only ones who have access, can handle, or have the money to even bid on projects, let alone execute on them. If this lowers the bar a bit more to let smaller and more innovative companies compete, I think that's a huge win.
- dsq 3y agoGenerally speaking, how can a reasonably informed coding entrepreneur get into the "space business" as a non specialist (i.e., not an astronaut, physicist or aerospace engineer)?