6 ms·
The juror who found herself guilty
- Tryanasorus 3y ago[flagged]
- lins1909 3y agoThat's _your_ takeaway from the article?
- wtfwhateven 3y agowhat do you mean?
- Tryanasorus 3y ago[flagged]
- Kranar 3y agoDo you think that in 1990 two loud and pushy black women could have persuaded 10 other men to give in?
- Tryanasorus 3y ago[flagged]
- froggertoaster 3y agohttps://archive.is/6ASif https://archive.is/6ASif
- jbm 3y agoThe short version is after many years of regret, she made several phone calls and was surprisingly taken seriously when she was persistent. > She knew how hard it was to take a stand. She knew how hard it was to do the right thing. And now she was going to do it. > She called the El Paso Police Department and told the woman on the line that she had been a juror on a 1990 case, and that even after all these years she didn’t think the guy was guilty. The woman told her it was too late to do anything and hung up. > Estella called back and talked to someone else. She explained everything again, recalling details from the trial. This time the person told her to dial the office of Jaime Esparza, the district attorney. Estella called and explained again what was on her mind. She was transferred to Tom Darnold, the head of the appellate division. > DA’s offices get unusual calls all the time, including from jurors having doubts about cases, but usually these come immediately after a trial. Estella was calling about a case from when Bill Clements was governor. She told Darnold what she’d told the others: she didn’t feel right about the verdict. Something she said convinced Darnold to take her seriously, and he promised her he’d look into it. He read the appellate opinion and didn’t see any obvious red flags. He told his boss Esparza about the unusual call from the juror and about his research, and Esparza told him to keep digging. Darnold read the trial transcripts and saw that the case wasn’t the strongest the office had ever prosecuted. He noted the discrepancies with the car and clothes, and also that Carlos had a strong alibi. He went back to Esparza, who decided it was time to take the whole thing to the next level. “We decided,” said Darnold, “just to be on the safe side: let’s look further.”
- BugsJustFindMe 3y ago> The woman told her it was too late to do anything and hung up. Yeesh. Talk about a real role model.
- justinclift 3y ago> The short version is after many years of regret ... Thanks. These articles where the author is clearly paid by the word, so do their utmost to include everything they can think of, are ridiculous. :)
- attentionspan 3y agoWhat's actually ridiculous is the short attention span of kids these days who can't keep it together for longer than a tiktok clip. That writer didn't just sit in a room dream this all up. Unbelievably many hours went into the making of this piece, including flying back and forth across the country to dig up information, speak to people, connect the dots, finding all the background information, staying persistent. That's hard work. You may not like the style, but it's quite offensive to just brush it off as "nah, paid by the word, ridiculous"
- justinclift 3y agoNah. They could have taken the time to condense it down to something useful, but nope... they decided to pad it out as far as they could. Pretty sure text generators / AI will be used for this sort of thing by some authors too, though I have no idea if it's the case in this instance.
- attentionspan 3y agoTbh. I also skipped over parts of the article. But I'm not blaming the author for that.
- pcthrowaway 3y agoThis is like saying a movie can be condensed into a several-sentence summary of its plot. The author of the article was deliberate with their words. A lot of what you might see as "useless filler" served to humanize all the characters, and give us much greater insight than we would get from a summary. I teared up when I read about Jaile's situation: how his wife left him during his proceedings, and then died of cancer before his name was cleared. And I was inspired by his optimistic attitude in the face of so much injustice. If you want a summary, you're free to copy-paste and ask ChatGPT for one. ChatGPT can't expand a summary into a moving work of investigative journalism while maintaining authenticity.
- preommr 3y agoAbsolutely insane that his brother went and hired an expensive defense attorney and they somehow didn't bring up the results of the DNA test that would've exonerated him. It should've been his job to get the results or do something with it as the judge reviewing this case noted. The cops are also to blame, but that's in their nature. A person's defense is their strongest shield. It's scary to think how this could happen to anyone.
- dotnet00 3y agoThis trial was 1990, the first case to use DNA evidence in the US was in 1987, it'd be pretty close to assume that they'd be relying on DNA tests heavily enough by then. Anyway, this case didn't really involve DNA that could be collected. A creep flashed a girl and then sped off, she later recognized the car and followed it, it stopped at an address the accused had lived at several years ago, but cops just figured it was him. There's also a rape mentioned, which happened in 1987, so similar issue.
- Cacti 3y agowell that’s arbitrary.
- klipt 3y ago> It's scary to think how this could happen to anyone. Maybe, although I wonder if the guy having the surname "Jaile" contributed to unconscious bias. People do like the idea of nominative determinism...
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThis is a pretty good argument for having criminal jurors submit their verdict in the form of vote by secret ballot and then just having the court count the ballots and see if they were unanimous.
- munchler 3y agoThe whole point of jury deliberations is to discuss and debate the case. It would be counterproductive to keep one’s position secret during the process. Multiple votes, including informal straw polls, are often necessary.
- eru 3y agoIt would perhaps be useful to run some experiments to see whether having a jury of 12 discuss is more accurate than having 12 independent jurors that don't communicate. (Or only communicate in very formally prescribed ways, but never meet.) You could run those experiments by constructing cases, or re-constructing known cases.
- skissane 3y agoThe problem with measuring the accuracy of juries, is what do you measure them against? Whether the person is really guilty? In the general case, you can't actually know that. Even for people who are wrongfully convicted, we can't always say the jury made the wrong call. In many of those cases, the conviction is overturned due to new evidence being discovered, or because the police or prosecution wrongly hid exculpatory evidence from the jury, or because the defendant's lawyer was grossly incompetent – in those cases, it is entirely possible the jury made the right call given the evidence actually presented to them, even if it turned out ultimately to be the wrong one.
- devmor 3y agoFor this hypothetical comparison process, I imagine that real cases could be used and re-presented with actors in place of the defendants and witnesses?
- thomasfromcdnjs 3y ago> But as soon as she walked into the jury room, she realized she was in the minority. It was easy for her to write “not guilty” on a piece of paper but much harder to discuss the case confidently as the two white men aggressively advocated for guilt. Each to their own, but she was under no obligation to vote guilty. I'm not sure why the article purports that "two white men" (I'm not white) were the "problem" here, and not that the problem was her inability to stand by her convictions. I often disagree with what I consider dramatised recounts of history, as if it's always some good vs bad, David vs Goliath tale. This was the 1970's in America, if she knew something that others didn't she should have had held her ground. As most people would have given that you are holding someones life in your hands. You can blame external factors all you want, but it is your still your reckoning. And great, that this person eventually helped them rectify this injustice. But what a silly way to tell the story.
- puchatek 3y agoUltimately it was her responsibility, yes. But I've seen loud, big and aggressive people get their say too many times to not think that they are part of the problem. At least ethically.
- silisili 3y agoWas wondering the same. This wasn't like the Jim Crow south or something similar, El Paso has been Hispanic majority for a long time. 69% in 1990, according to Wikipedia. Maybe they existed as outlined, but the focus on it felt like a way of alleviating her(and others) of their wrongdoing.
- skissane 3y agoIt is a psychological thing. Some people find it really hard to assert themselves when faced with dominant personalities. Differences in culture, gender, etc, can be a factor. The article mentions that at the time her English skills were still developing, and that may have also played a role. That's not to say any of this entirely excuses what she did, but it helps put it in perspective. It was also the fault of other members of the jury, who were more concerned with obtaining superficial agreement than convinced agreement.
- devmor 3y agoThe way this article frames the titular juror really rubs me the wrong way. As if her forgetting about her negligence, then finally going back to do the right thing was heroic. It was better than nothing, but a lot worse than what she should have done to begin with.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- renewiltord 3y agoWell, 11 others did all the wrong things and didn't do the one right thing. In general, I think people like to reward this thing to allow people to know that if they fucked up, forgiveness is forthcoming if they try to right the wrong. Overall, that's my view. I try to reward what I want to see more of. And there's sufficient suffering and shame from knowing you put someone innocent away that I think I'm fine with promoting anyone who fights that. It really sucks that she fucked it up the first time, going along with other more strident people. But good on her for what she did.
- devmor 3y agoOh don’t get me wrong, I’m not admonishing her for eventually doing the right thing. I’m glad her conscience took hold and that poor man could live out his twilight years in peace. It’s the author of the article I’m more bothered by. I’ve seen less heaped on praise and weepiness for people who died stopping mass shooters.
- locallost 3y agoSo basically it confirms again that the role of the police and the justice system is not to find the guilty, but to find someone to make everyone feel comfortable with the system working. A type of a sacrificial lamb for the civilized world. Of course we know who the predominantly white police force will consider for the role. Puts into perspective why there are over 2 million black Americans in prison. Quote: I asked Carlos who he thought bore the brunt of the blame for DNA evidence not showing up in his trial: the police, the DA, or his own attorney, Gibson. “Straight-up crooked cops,” he said. “That’s all it was. Plain and simple.”
- armada651 3y agoThe jury system was never about truth and fact finding, it was always about community justice. If the community feels safer with the accused behind bars the accused is sent to jail, evidence is only there to inform the jury in their decision. It's a terrible system that should've been relegated to the past.
- cqqxo4zV46cp 3y agoIt’s just a reflection of how society works. Are you suggesting an even more concentrated arbiter of truth?
- armada651 3y agoQuality over quantity, for trails of this severity you have multiple judges decide the case. I am not convinced that having a random selection of people with no experience in law results in more accurate verdicts, in fact there is plenty of evidence of the opposite.
- bryanrasmussen 3y agoI'm supposing then as part of this restructuring of society that will never happen there will also be a restructuring of how judges get to be judges in America which will also not be happening so that this "quality" will be achieved.
- Gunax 3y agoI am getting increasingly skeptical of juries. For one, I just don't think we are very rational. And I am including myself in that. And, like this case, the personalities reflect exactly what happens when you gether a dozen individuals. One or two are loud-mouth bravados, a few don't speak, and some are just apathetic. It's nice to think that I would be that disagreeable person who would stand my ground, but I am not sure. Sometimes I wonder what we would do if the courts were designed today. I am pretty sure we would not come up with a system where we gather 12 random people. I don't know what we would decide on, but almost certainly not this. But like many things, it varies on because no one has an obviously better way.
- trilbyglens 3y agoWatch a few lower court cases on YouTube, and your opinion of judges might drop so low you'd be happy with juries again hah.
- rrr_oh_man 3y agoThis. Every judge I know has their mind made up before the trial even starts.
- armada651 3y agoJust because you let trials be decided by judges does not mean it always has to be a single judge deciding a case. Based on the severity of the crime you can have multiple judges decide the case. Also you can keep a right to trial by jury for the defendant. If the defendant decides they'd rather by judged by their peers they can choose a trial by jury. It's their constitutional right in the US after all.
- Ekaros 3y agoJudges are crap, prosecutors are crap, juries are crap... And sometimes the defence is crap... It seems extremely expensive, inefficient and broken system overall.
- steeve 3y agoThis is exactly the plot of 12 Angry Men (1957): https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0050083/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0050083/ Great movie about what it entails to be the only voice calling for reasonable doubt.
- fastball 3y agoNot really exactly the plot, as [spoiler alert] in 12 Angry Men it goes the other way, and the initial holdout therefore doesn't feel guilt for decades.
- pama 3y agoI understand that the state does not want to pay $2M, yet I wonder why it is so difficult to prove the person innocent of the crime they were convicted for. The mismatch of the DNA evidence from the rape scene is bullet proof as far as arguments go. All the other supporting evidence, including the strong alibi help for sure, but DNA is a detailed signature and there is no way to get an accidental mismatch?!
- armada651 3y agoYou can't have one without the other. If he overturns his conviction and proves his innocence he would be entitled to compensation for damages inflicted.
- bryanrasmussen 3y agohttps://www.findlaw.com/criminal/criminal-procedure/how-dna-evidence-works.html https://www.findlaw.com/criminal/criminal-procedure/how-dna-... "Although estimates vary, forensic DNA analysis is roughly 95% accurate." I remember however an article I can't find now from about 20 years ago so probably things have improved since then that found only about 2/3rds accuracy - and that accuracy could be affected by stating the result you wanted. It was in Time, or New Republic or some major news magazine. My thoughts could be colored by this, but given history of forensic abuse in the U.S I would tend to undervalue evidence that found someone guilty. I am however a cynic. I would also think that this 95% accurate claim seems weird, since it is effected by all sorts of things, basically if DNA evidence gets admitted it is treated as bulletproof but it may still have a lower than 95% chance of being correct at that point - but when admitted the battle is pretty much lost.
- pama 3y agoI don’t think that a clearly mismatching DNA has anywhere above a one in a billion chance of belonging to the same person. So either the sample is wrong, which is near impossible with a rape case nowadays, or some technical mishandling (switch of samples?) that can of course happen but this is not likely leading to a 5% error rate. Maybe in the early days people used erratic methods for reading pieces of the DNA but it’s hard to imagine a 5% error rate even then. I guess the other way around could work, ie a match may be a twin sibling or something.
- the_absurdist 3y agoIf I don't do anything about this, I am the problem. Government is us. Our responsibility to design, implement, and hold accountable. Talking about what happened isn't enough. Carlos Jaile lost his entire adult life because of systemic failures in the justice system. This needs to be fixed not only for Carlos but for everyone. What needs to be changed and how?
- friend_and_foe 3y agoThe first thing that I think needs to be changed, is your mind: the government convincing us that it represents our will is one of the biggest cons in history. The government is just an evolution of the strongest gang winning in an anarchy. That's what we live in, an anarchy where the strongest group has already taken power. They only consider our desires and needs as much as they have to to preserve their power. The truth is that collectively we are stronger than them, but if they can convince us that they are equivalent to our collective will they can pick on us in small groups or individually, because if we identify that they are not our collective will then we might enact our true will, and they can't stand to that. So what to do about this? Acknowledge that the machine doesn't represent you, that it's not your fault, and take legitimacy from a system that abuses you by withdrawing your faith in it.
- kergonath 3y agoThis is horrifying. Ignoring evidence and ruining someone’s life just to make a point in a political race or for the self gratification of hurting someone is reckless at best, and should be criminal. Considering how the system works, I don’t think it is acceptable for people to have to prove their innocence in that context. The state harmed them, it is the state that should make its case. And ideally impeach or sue officials for gross misconduct and breach of ethics.
- rado 3y agoClint Eastwood's upcoming last film, Juror #2, has an interesting premise where a juror realises he might be the perpetrator.
- apricot13 3y agodid they find who actually committed the crimes? I can't help but feel for the victims who believed they were getting justice who now have to deal with the reality they they weren't safe all these years. that their attacker was still out there the whole time. Finding this out is almost another attack. If they do find the real culprit what reason do they have to believe this time.