6 ms·
The Dark Forest hypothesis is absurd
- justrealist 3y agoCrazy that people fixate on the Dark Forest part of the books. I had nightmares for weeks about the dual-vector foil.
- anonymouskimmer 3y agoMy issue was his having unilateral decisions which screw the entire population okay because of "democratic choice".
- digging 3y agoInteresting beginning of an article, but it's paywalled after part 1.
- gary_0 3y agoI just added substack.com##.post:has(.paywall) noahpinion.blog##.post:has(.paywall) to my uBlock filters so I don't waste my time in the future.
- cmrdporcupine 3y agoWe don't need a Dark Forest hypothesis to explain Why No Aliens... because the reality is, the distance between solar systems is so incredibly massive, and the impossibility of FTL so real, it doesn't even matter. They'll never make it here, and we'll never make it there, even if we somehow were to communicate. We will be alone in this system forever, get used to it. Maybe a machine or two of ours might make it out someday, but we'll be gone by then anyways.
- readthenotes1 3y agoYou're assuming that they are no more capable than we are now it seems
- cmrdporcupine 3y agoThe capability is not possible.
- megaman821 3y agoThey wouldn't have to be that much more capable. If every 10,000 years humans could reach a habitable planet and start a society there, in a few billion years humans would be everywhere.
- qayxc 3y agoAnd if actual history and real biology are anything to go by, you'd end up with a zoo of civilisations (and remnants thereof) that don't resemble humanity in the slightest and might as well be aliens.
- stcredzero 3y agothe distance between solar systems is so incredibly massive, and the impossibility of FTL so real, it doesn't even matter That also doesn't matter. Another star is going to come close enough to any given star, often enough, that the entire galaxy could be colonized without ever having to travel that far that fast. (Look up Issac Arthur's "Crawlenizing the Galaxy" idea.) we'll be gone by then anyways It's the combination of distance AND civilization longevity that does it. Considering that we are in an exponential process of change, it doesn't seem like we'll be around long enough in our current form as a civilization.
- awb 3y agoCommunication is still a problem. A colony 5 light years away means 10 years before you get a response. For all intents and purposes most colonies will be independent and unable to act efficiently in unison with other colonies towards a strategic objective. Similar to how humans migrated out of Africa and then discovered each other again after they had created different cultures, belief systems and ways of living.
- stcredzero 3y agoCommunication is still a problem. Not for carpeting a galaxy with descendants of humans.
- awb 3y agoRight, but how could colonies over such great distances have any meaningful commonality or purpose? Homo Sapiens evolved ~300k years ago. The Milky Way is ~100k light years across. It’s possible you’d have different species colonizing different sectors of the galaxy. And those species might be just as likely to compete with each other rather than cooperate.
- digging 3y agoYour assertion is wrong (because you're 100% confident about something not knowable), but what's worse, it doesn't even address the question of "Why no aliens?". If alien intelligences were abundant but just "really far away", we'd still expect to have seen them by now.
- skywhopper 3y agoThe book posits that FTL travel exists, so it does matter.
- 1970-01-01 3y agoShips powered by pulse fusion reactors can certainly reach other worlds. Robust AI systems could tell us what's going on and be back in time for the year 2100. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_pulse_propulsion#Project_Daedalus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_pulse_propulsion#Proje...
- KineticLensman 3y ago> the distance between solar systems is so incredibly massive, and the impossibility of FTL so real Those things, and the likely temporal separation of civilizations - where they miss because one peaked one million years before its nearby neighbours. E.g. Proxima Centauri, our nearest star, which per Wikipedia, is 200 million years older than the sun, so a civilization there which matured at the same speed as ours, would likely be long gone.
- dwaltrip 3y agoTraveling at 0.1% the speed of light, one could traverse the galaxy over 40 times since it was formed.
- qayxc 3y agoNot really. Unless you assume a couple of things: indestructible, perfect technology and methods to either suspend or prolong lifespans to geological time scales. Even system hopping would have at the very least the requirement of a basically unchanging (both biologically and in terms of politics/society) civilisation. If either of those aren't practically achievable, the idea falls apart quickly.
- dwaltrip 3y agoMy main point is that the distance between stars is not physically impossible to overcome, as the original comment suggested.
- ironlake 3y agoIn the books, each civilization can have a hiding gene and/or an exterminating gene. At the beginning of the story, humanity has neither. The idea is that civilizations without the hiding gene won't last long. So it's not rational for a civilization to become "Space Hitler", there are other options, they can hide. I found the hypothesis to be convincing in the story. By the time you figure out if a civilization is friendly, they may have advanced to the point where they could destroy you. Everyone has to hide. Not everyone has to exterminate. Clearly, having discovered no other civilizations in the universe, we don't have enough information, so it's all guesswork and fantasy.
- anonymouskimmer 3y agoPrisoner's dilemma, or even better than that. Cooperation is ignored despite having significant advantages laid out in the likes of Star Trek and Babylon 5.
- SnazzyJeff 3y ago> Prisoner's dilemma This falls apart pretty rapidly when you move beyond one person—groups of people don't tend to act collectively rationally. Hell, the entire reason "capitalism" is a thing at all is it provides some consensus in the face of byzantine faults even if it fails to represent our collective needs with any accuracy.
- anonymouskimmer 3y agoI'm pretty sure capitalism is a thing because it provides a means of legal ownership and the growth of one's exercise of power through the exploitation of that ownership. Consensus would exist due to the power of the state regardless of the economic system.
- SnazzyJeff 3y ago> Consensus would exist due to the power of the state regardless of the economic system. What does this mean? Genuinely confused what you think a state is in the modern age if not the infrastructure necessary to support a market.
- anonymouskimmer 3y ago> So if Liu’s hypothesis is right, it makes sense for the galaxy’s top civilizations to just look at every star, see if there’s a civilization there, and wipe it out if so. If resource are scarce, destroying stars and planets seems counterproductive. Why not just colonize as the Trisolarans made steps to do to Earth?
- wintorez 3y agoAre resources really scarce? Other than stars and planets, there are plenty of resources in the astroids and gas giants, and interstellar space. We can argue that the most scarce resource is organic matter. In universal scale, wood is exponentially more scarce than gold.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoAre you sure? The estimate for gold in the universe is 50B tons. There's 550B tons of organic matter on earth - I'm assuming most of that being plant mass. And that's if you're certain Earth is the only planet in the entire universe that has organic life.
- macspoofing 3y ago>The estimate for gold in the universe is 50B tons. That is a wild underestimate. Our galaxy alone has around 100 million Earths worth of gold [1]. [1] https://www.discovermagazine.com/the-sciences/astronomers-tally-all-the-gold-in-our-galaxy https://www.discovermagazine.com/the-sciences/astronomers-ta...
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoInteresting - this was the first thing that popped up on Google: https://www.zmescience.com/feature-post/natural-sciences/chemistry-articles/periodic-table/how-gold-is-made-science-064654/ https://www.zmescience.com/feature-post/natural-sciences/che... But I see there's an estimate that there's more gold than that just in our Sun.
- SnazzyJeff 3y agoI can't be the only person who absolutely doesn't care about intelligent life. Either it makes its relevance clear or it doesn't. I see no particular reason why "intelligence" is noteworthy enough to look for in the first place.... maybe that's just a quirk of self-organization rather than a common route to it.
- stcredzero 3y agoI can't be the only person who absolutely doesn't care about intelligent life. Do you care about yourself and consider yourself intelligent?
- SnazzyJeff 3y agoDo you have a point? Humans are self-evidently self-interested. You don't need to justify it.
- stcredzero 3y agoDo you have a point? Yes. I'm showing that the commenter does care about one example intelligent life!
- digging 3y agoYou seriously don't understand the difference between finding alien microbes vs finding aliens that can build guns and point them at us? Or for that matter, aliens that can actively teach us new things. I just... no, I don't think you're the only one who has this position, but it's the kind of wanton ignorance that doesn't need to be shared.
- SnazzyJeff 3y agoI mean, I'd also like to find elves. I don't see any reason to suspect either exists. There's an assumption that intelligence is a natural progression for evolution of life, which seems irrational. Why is intelligence so special compared to other mechanisms of self-organization?
- 1970-01-01 3y agoNot absurd if you consider enslavement. Anyone worried about AI alignment will be in the dark forest camp. You simply can't trust the universe to care about you any more than it already does.
- bitanarch 3y agoEnslavement only matters if your level of productivity is still on roughly the same order of magnitude (as in, up to minus a few) of your masters. e.g. you are a cow, a jug of your cow milk is still worth a few dollars in human markets. That means it's still worth it to keep you around. If you're a mosquito OTOH... even enslavement is not worth it. It's eradication.
- tbrownaw 3y agoAn individual bee isn't that productive, at least for the kind of bees that are kept commercially. Or an individual yeast.
- galkk 3y agoI tried to read the books in Russian, in English but they just don't click for me. Also I just cannot accept any analogy of dark forest with empty and dead place. Anyone who've been to the forest or even seen any documentary knows/hears/sees that it's also full of life
- josefresco 3y ago> Anyone who've been to the forest or even seen any documentary knows/hears/sees that it's also full of life All books I've read about the Amazon rainforest describe it as an extremely harsh place almost devoid of easily spotted pray or food. Anything that falls to the forest floor is consumed very quickly. There's a ton of life there, it's just ruthlessly competitive and therefore beyond easy sight. I think the Dark Forest concept fits perfectly here. We see "empty" space wherein fact life could be just behind the curtains of "self preservation".
- me_me_me 3y ago> Also I just cannot accept any analogy of dark forest with empty and dead place. Huh? I don't even know what you are talking about. First of all dark forest is not about empty and dead place. Its about being able to blend in with the forest so no one can discover you. Once spotted you become dead, once you spot someone else in your best interest is to destroy them if you can do it without being spotted. In the books there are several civilizations, and hits that there were plenty more living in higher dimensions.
- infradig 3y agoI always considered it a political metaphor really.
- Andrews54757 3y agoAfter reading the books, I thought that there was some sort of underlying political meaning with the way Liu incorporates both philosophy, religion, and real world events (ie, the Cultural Revolution). Then I read the afterword and author interview transcripts where the author explicitly says that there is no such meaning. > “As a science fiction writer who began as a fan, I do not use my fiction as a disguised way to criticize the reality of the present.” Given that the author lives under an authoritarian government, I'm not sure if Liu's words should be taken at face value. But officially, a political interpretation of the book wouldn't be the authors intention.
- sdwr 3y agoWas looking for this, had to scroll a long way to find it. The "dark forest" is a metaphor for growing up in an authoritarian regime. Paranoia and zero trust, because crimes against the state are absolute, and you never know who is reporting on you. Then it mixes that with the US - China relationship mirroring first contact with the aliens. Not everything lines up 1 to 1, but all the themes are there. Amazing how many people take it at face value instead of looking for context.
- romanhn 3y agoJust a PSA that 3 Body Problem is coming in March as a Netflix series. I was pleasantly surprised to see a trailer come out recently.
- axiom92 3y agoLooks pretty cool https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mogSbMD6EcY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mogSbMD6EcY Although, it seems it's only going to cover the first book (which makes sense, given how difficult the other two would be to film). The real magic for me was in book 3. It was inspiring to see someone think so far out, so boldly.
- anonymouskimmer 3y ago> It was inspiring to see someone think so far out, so boldly. It's not that unusual in SciFi (and even some Fantasy). I didn't like the way this series did it. I personally prefer Asimov's take in The Last Question. It's all well and good to ask the elderly to commit mutual suicide for the sake of the yet-to-be-born, but assuredly there would have been newborn young species (not to mention the youth of old species) even in an old universe. Sorry youngins, to Moloch you go!
- Kluggy 3y agoAmazon prime has https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three-Body https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three-Body available, dubbed in English. I enjoyed it.
- awb 3y agoIf we look at human history through the lense of a Dark Forest hypothesis and resource scarcity, you’d expect to see a variety of behaviors: aggression, defensive isolation, cooperation, etc. And as on Earth, in Space, distance may help keep the peace.
- me_me_me 3y ago> distance may help keep the peace Its the opposite actually, distance increases the information latency. The higher latency the more uncertainty (and paranoia about what other side will do). You will notice your neighbor slowly changing their attitudes and ideas because you can see it happen. You can intervene or prepare for whats happening, but At space distances by the time you see those changes, their relativistic weapons were already fired. And even if there was some cultural shit and they regretted firing it, its already too late to do anything
- myth_drannon 3y agoThe Dark Forest theory being popular right now is more a reflection of our society and our fears. Stanislaw Lem has a good take on the subject of biological systems evolution in his "Summa Technologae". Carl Sagan and Shklovsky also wrote a lot on the topic ("Intelligent Life in the Universe" for example). But they also represent a different time, the Cold War.
- scp3125 3y ago[TW: SPOILERS] I don't understand how something like this can be critical, but 'conveniently' ignore fundamental conceits of the narrative that led the characters to the formation of the Dark Forest Hypothesis, such as the technological explosion capacity of advanced galactic civilizations, which was a huge talking point in the trilogy. It was literally the reason why the Trisolarans utilized the Sophons /to halt technological progress of human research past a certain boundary/ by having the Sophons manipulate the results of any microscopic-scale particle experiments of scientists across the globe. (You know, the thing that causes a bunch of scientists to kill themselves and spur the plot of the first book into action) Also disclaimer: didn't read past the paywall because lol paywall
- izzydata 3y agoAs the author of this article says at the top it makes for a fun science fiction, but doesn't necessarily make a lot of sense in reality. So why do people fixate so much on how not realistic this particular science fiction concept is? Writing science fiction isn't about making realistic theories of how reality is. It's about writing interesting things that are only loosely related to actual science. It's also worth noting that this hypothesis is not an original idea of Liu's it just wasn't called a Dark Forest previously.
- KineticLensman 3y ago> It's also worth noting that this hypothesis is not an original idea of Liu's Yes, Greg Bear explores the concept in Forge of God (1987) and Anvil of Stars (1992), twenty years before Liu. David Brin also covered it. Anvil of Stars really explores the moral quandary from the perspectives of a civilisation that can take revenge in such an environment.
- red-iron-pine 3y ago> Writing science fiction isn't about making realistic theories of how reality is it's called "science" fiction because there is an attempt to extract scientific theory and thought, and it's implications. Otherwise it's fantasy, space opera, or just plain ole magical fiction.
- komodus 3y agoIt is not absurd. It depends on the type of beings at play. Plants don't kill each other, but animals do on a daily basis, from whales to mosquitoes, they're all part of a macabre annihilation dance where strength, intelligence and mimetism play important roles. Through different eras, men have traveled long distances to kill, subjugate, enslave other people, and to consume everything that can be consumed, we won't change if we start going to the outer space. Being the most advanced species on earth doesn't make us different, as spiders, fish, birds, wolves, anything that moves is determined to kill or be killed, so it's not only a human trait. Is it a dark forest? We don't know, it may just be an open battleground where intelligence is the final conqueror and that's exactly what rides on top of the arrow of evolution.
- awb 3y agoCooperation and symbiotic relationships exist in nature as well. The trajectory of history suggests that it’s easier to trade than to steal and easier to ally than to fight.
- rf15 3y ago> Plants don't kill each other They absolutely do. From simple concepts like resource competition in which trees deplete the ground or outcompete each other for sunlight (e.g. any forest floor is usually not covered in grass) to parasitism and strangulating vines and whatnot, these guys are hostile and deadly to one another. They just don't run around much. > through different eras, men have traveled long distances to kill, subjugate, enslave other people I know lichens are considered "symbiotic" but I'm not sure what you would call a fungus that breeds algae cells and consumes them for nourishment. In that vein we're also symbiotic with pigs, which I find an inappropriate term. Either way, my point is: Animals aren't remotely as unique as many people think.
- calimoro78 3y agoImportantly, Liu’s books basically abandon the very same idea in the second and third books of the series (aliens that very actively battle across the galaxy and have many many opportunities to interact, which kind of undermines the premises of the dark forest argument)
- nope96 3y agoIf "the singularity" is a real thing that can happen, it seems like there is an incentive for species that fear "the singularity" to preemptively wipe out any civilizations they find which seem close to achieving AGI
- stcredzero 3y agoIf "the singularity" is a real thing that can happen The way you're talking about it, the only way to win is to become "the singularity" yourself. However, as it's used in mathematics and in the context of exponential growth and accelerating change, it's not a real thing. In math, it's where the math breaks down. In this context, it just describes the point at which standard Homo sapiens can't predict or deal with the speed of change.
- _nalply 3y agoAnother hypothesis about why humans don't find traces of aliens in the universe: The universe is quite young. We are just first in our local sector! https://grabbyaliens.com/ https://grabbyaliens.com/ > Advanced aliens really are out there, and we have enough data to say roughly where they are in space and time, and when we will see or meet them.