6 ms·
Ford's new 48-inch digital dashboard is a lot of Android for one car
- whycome 3y agoScreen failure and you lose everything?
- vidanay 3y agoIncluding all the money in your bank account to pay for the repair.
- doodlebugging 3y agoI agree with this. It will be expensive. Reminds me of my sister's Ford F150 oil pan leak issue. The oil pan is plastic (for weight control, certainly not durability). After a while they leak. There are thousands of F150s with leaking oil pans and there are no aftermarket oil pans that one can buy to replace the OEM pan. Her truck is on its 3rd or 4th oil pan. They must replace the pan when it develops a leak. It isn't as simple as replacing a gasket or squeezing some sealant on the old pan and torquing the bolts. You must replace the pan. This means logistically that you are trapped in a supply chain problem when you buy the vehicle since the new pans need to exist before you can use them to replace a leaky pan. When you take your truck to the dealership they may have it for weeks waiting on parts. Once they get the pan you can relax since it will be installed by trained Ford techs with approved Ford parts. Well not really. Turns out that Ford's bulletin goes into detail about the procedure and in the end reminds the tech that any deviation from their bulletin procedure will result in a leak which will require replacement of the replacement pan since it is now an unreliable, used part. Vehicle cost a lot of money. Hers has been out of service for this single issue several times for a total of more than a month of lost time. Somehow I am supposed to trust that a company that produces a vehicle with a plastic oil pan which is not a part that anyone familiar with automobiles would ever consider to be a wear part, can reliably produce a digital display that can remain in service, working perfectly for at least a decade and that once it fails it can easily and cheaply be replaced by the owner if the owner chooses to keep the vehicle. This is not rocket science people. While scanning wrecking yards looking for parts for a couple of my older, but still well-maintained vehicles, I have found cars and trucks in great condition that are in the wrecking yard because the owner thought they couldn't afford the repair. For one of my vehicles the repair part that the junk donor needed was widely available at any auto parts store for under $100 and could be installed by anyone who had a phillips screwdriver and a metric socket set that included a 10mm socket. I can't imagine that a digital gauge display will be user-replaceable or inexpensive.
- vel0city 3y ago> can reliably produce a digital display Ford doesn't make displays. The people making the displays are vastly different people from the people making the oil pan. This is a pretty key part you're ignoring here.
- doodlebugging 3y agoI wasn't ignoring that. Ford is likely to be the single source for any replacement displays especially if each vehicle model uses a different dashboard layout. Even if they standardize displays across their entire product line they would likely still be the only ones selling or stocking replacements. This makes it expensive to replace when the vehicle "owner" has a critical problem with the unit installed at the factory and needs a replacement. As far as the oil pan, the design of the pan probably makes it too complex to manufacture at scale in a material that is more durable. It is not a simple cake-pan style reservoir. It has mating surfaces and ports that would be difficult to reproduce in metal. Here is the TSB that Ford techs need to follow to accomplish this temporary repair.[0] [0]https://static.nhtsa.gov/odi/tsbs/2019/MC-10164470-0001.pdf https://static.nhtsa.gov/odi/tsbs/2019/MC-10164470-0001.pdf
- vel0city 3y ago> Somehow I am supposed to trust that a company that produces a vehicle with a plastic oil pan which is not a part that anyone familiar with automobiles would ever consider to be a wear part, can reliably produce a digital display that can remain in service, working perfectly for at least a decade and that once it fails it can easily and cheaply be replaced by the owner if the owner chooses to keep the vehicle. Here you're absolutely equating their failure at making a reliable oil pan as a reason to question them producing a digital display. Ford isn't producing the display. Their failure to make a reliable oil pan is pretty disconnected to them buying screens from an automotive supplier. Ford isn't producing any displays, so questioning their ability to source a display given their failure at making a good oil pan on one generation of one vehicle is pretty moot. As a counter point to displays being unreliable that, I've had Ford vehicles with displays that have lasted well over a decade so far, and to my knowledge still work. I've never had an automotive part have the display just fail on its own, personally. As for them deciding to stop supplying them, eventually they'll also stop supplying the "analog" gauges as well, so its once again a moot point. That "analog" display can still fail requiring replacement. You're not avoiding that problem having needles instead of an LCD.
- jimnotgym 3y agoDear Ford, I will stick with real gauges even if it means driving a 20 year old car
- bluGill 3y agoYour 20 year old car had digital gauges too. They just moved a mechanical needle so they looked mechanical, but it was all digital to the cluster. Now they are just replacing the cluster with a LCD.
- vel0city 3y agoYea, my 2000 Honda Accord's instrument cluster just had a digital wiring harness to drive it. Even an older somewhat cheap 2002 motorcycle I owned had a completely digital instrument cluster.
- SoftTalker 3y agoThose gauges are still working after 20 years though. Will that be the case for the LCD?
- vel0city 3y agoI've had to replace instrument clusters due to the gauges failing. In fact I've had two different vehicles that needed to have work done to repair/replace physical gauges. Generally speaking, moving parts will fail more often than solid state things.
- doodlebugging 3y ago>moving parts will fail more often than solid state things. And when the solid state things fail they are probably more expensive to replace. I too have replaced instrument clusters (in a Ford) that failed due to age. Two things failed - a couple of capacitors that allow the unit to process the velocity information it gets from the VSS that tells the cluster how fast the vehicle is moving, and the LCD display (liquid crystal) that tracks the accumulated mileage. Both were >25 years old and I fixed the problem by buying a used gauge cluster from a similar vehicle at a wrecking yard. The mileage on the two vehicles was vastly different (300k miles on mine versus only 120k on the donor) and the vehicle age was the same. On a different vehicle (Nissan) we had a gauge cluster issue where the instrument lights would fail at night or would be ON/OFF randomly as you drove. My wife took the vehicle to the dealership and had them diagnose the issue. $1500 to replace the malfunctioning gauge cluster was their verdict. Fortunately she did not let them do anything to the vehicle and instead decided to just drive it like it was. For a long time we used a small flashlight to illuminate the dash as we drove at night. I bought a replacement for it from a wrecking yard but didn't install it since I wanted to use it as a known-good example in determining the problem with the original cluster. Eventually I found some free time and decided to investigate the issue since it seemed like it could be something simple, like a broken trace on the circuit board. I removed a clip-in piece of trim and the six screws holding it in the dash and unplugged the three connectors. I was intending to use the oven and do a solder reflow but before I got started on that I used my loupe and walked every trace on the board, they were nice and fat and easy to follow. There were no issues anywhere that I could find. It didn't feel like it needed a reflow. I had removed all the bulbs that are used to light the gauges and idiot lights so that I could follow the traces and as I picked them up to begin putting them back in place I noticed that some of them had carbon flashing inside the bulb. With that information, I carefully separated the ones with the carbon flashing from those without and examined each separately. All of the ones with the carbon had filaments that could be seen to be broken, disconnected etc so those bulbs were effectively burnt out. Turns out that they were in the critical locations used to illuminate the speedometer, tachometer, and oil, fuel, battery, and coolant lights. Those that were still good were down in the group of lights that illuminated only at startup or rarely when there was an issue. Each bulb, there were half a dozen of them, cost $2 at the dealership. I did some investigating and found that we were not the only ones to have this identical problem and that quite a few people had been suckered into replacing the cluster which cost $520 brand new from the dealership. I guess the rest of our quote was labor to remove the old one and install the new one. Seems excessive to me but maybe some people are okay with paying that kind of money for someone to spend less than 30 minutes removing the cluster, replacing a few bulbs, and reinstalling the cluster. I found some LED replacement bulbs online and used some of the money that I saved investigating the issue to replace all the bulbs in the gauge cluster and haven't had a problem since. That is more than 10 years ago and the vehicle currently is a daily driver with 265k miles on it. Personally, I will not be buying anything that requires me to use a touch screen to control it. I guarantee that the dealerships will be no help at all in diagnosing issues with them and will happily roll in the cash they can generate replacing things that shouldn't exist to begin with.
- jbverschoor 3y agoI'd love to have a strip of 6" tall array of lcd screens like that in the back of my desk. A large version of the touchbar :-)
- from-nibly 3y agoYou can pry my late 90's early 2000's cars from my cold dead hands. I have a mechanic and I'm going to go find the fountain of youth so I can keep him alive forever.
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoThis is the move Analog Knobs and buttons No spyware You can even do gas to electric conversion cheap and easily if you’re not about that petro life There’s more than enough usable vehicles in the world some just need more maintenance than others. The last thing we need is more cars to be produced.
- sufficer 3y agoNo no no. Need to keep producing! Capitalism baby!
- dmichulke 3y agoYou mean consumerism, I don't think anyone would produce if it wouldn't be bought.
- PaulHoule 3y agoChina is practicing a very different form of "capitalism" where huge amounts of capital are invested into maglev and such. (Something you can't do here because people have property rights and getting the right of way is almost impossible.)
- geodel 3y agoSo what people will do after saving time by fast travel using maglev. I would've guessed spending time on leisure, food, shopping, entertainment. But since it is China all saved time will go towards spiritual fulfillment not consumerism.
- pixl97 3y ago
- FredPret 3y agoGood news: - There are physical buttons (not many) - It still supports CarPlay (somehow), and - > The car will recognize the driver and adjust the settings accordingly. And the interior displays can be configured to as much — or as little — information as desired. However, the speedometer and other critical info will also be driven by this Android system. Hope it doesn’t “crash”
- GenerWork 3y agoI believe that it's able to support Carplay because Android is just the UI dev layer. It's not an all or nothing scenario.
- FredPret 3y agoI suppose Carplay would go on the central main screen only - I was wondering if it would go on the 48” strip screen.
- droopyEyelids 3y agoThe latest version of CarPlay does support something like that. https://www.macrumors.com/2023/10/23/all-new-carplay-late-2023/ https://www.macrumors.com/2023/10/23/all-new-carplay-late-20...
- WorldMaker 3y agoYeah this is a funny situation where Google's brand naming strategy does them no favors: Android Auto (their CarPlay equivalent) != Android Automotive (their Car OS) and Android Automotive supports both Android Auto and Apple's CarPlay, except when turned off (as GM is doing for reasons that escape everyone except presumably GM executives).
- jwells89 3y agoYeah, I’m not averse to things like critical information being on a screen, but the software powering that screen needs to be ridiculously stable and well-built, which is unfortunately unlikely as long as big car companies continue to contract out dash/infotainment software rather than develop it in-house.
- alwa 3y agoDoes anyone prefer the digital gauges to real ones? I’m rabidly allergic to the screen-based car controls, and I feel like I see a lot of that in the comments here and in conversation with friends and relatives. Where is the pro-digital-control constituency hiding out? Surely the manufacturers wouldn’t be going so hard this way if market research bore out quite that degree of resistance.
- andy99 3y agoI think it's a kind if lock-in. Digital stuff isn't repairable and requires the dealer to fix it, plus they force you into a digital ecosystem they control so they can upsell, show ads, harvest information etc. I think it's all driven by what they want to force on people rather than what people want. What's the point of regulatory capture if you don't use it, right?
- bluGill 3y agoGauges have been digital for decades now. Even in the 1990s many of them were digital not analog. Sure there was a needle so they looked analog, but the data came in digitally and them the computer on the display decided how to move the needle to whatever digital position. (I can think of 3 different ways to implement this and I'm not an electrical engineers - who I would expect to know more than me about what works)
- Kon-Peki 3y agoYeah, people need to understand that their cars have been rolling computers for a really long time. If you live in a wealthy country, the chance that any car you are still driving isn't highly computerized is very low. For the past few years, we've started to see major UX changes (buttons & mechanical gauges going away) and huge amounts of new infotainment that are now possible because we've stopped hiding the digital nature of everything. Lots of us hate that, but it does no good to focus the hate on the wrong thing ;)
- bee_rider 3y agoI think they are talking about the UI, so a pointy-needle that is controlled by a computer would not be considered digital. The details inside the engine are less relevant to the user, the point I think is that the display is fixed-function.
- lemonberry 3y agoI'll be driving my little Mazda hatchback for longer than I expected. It's a manual transmission. Automatics are much better than they used to be, but I still love the feel of shifting gears. My next vehicle will be a used something. Does the definition of Luddite change with each generation's shift in technology?
- doodlebugging 3y agoSame here. 2015 Mazda3, manual transmission. Very good car. It does have a touchscreen in the center display but it also has dedicated buttons to navigate near the drivers hand on the center console. Our touchscreen has glitched on us and evidently we missed the free replacement period. In addition, two of the corners have developed cracking like shattered glass due to age. All things considered this is a great fuel efficient car. I definitely would not buy a vehicle with a full-screen digital display like the one in this article. The Mazda3 is our newest vehicle. My other daily drivers range in age from 32 years to 16 years.
- ciconia 3y agoI find those new car screens a total turn-off. When driving I don't want a giant screen just in the periphery of my view to take my attention off the road. The passengers anyway don't need it - they each have their screens, so what's the point? Just give me a good electric car with good range and the usual accessories and features, minus the screen.
- SoftTalker 3y agoThe passengers also upgrade their screens every few years. How will that work in a car? These are just gratuitous technology, that will live in a very harsh environment (many people have to park outside in winter cold or summer sun). It is nothing more than a 1,000 new possible points of failure, yet it will only be repairable as a total system replacement. And after five years, forget it -- the parts will no longer be available. Car makers brag about their manufacturing being "zero landfill" and are trying for "zero carbon" but how does that square with adding all this unnecessary crap?
- kotaKat 3y agoBut I don't want to have to rely on Google Assistant as the default voice controls in the vehicle and then rely on that requiring a connection to the Internet to use. And I still don't want to sign in with a Google Account to my vehicle. What happens in those horseshit "my Google account got yeeted by someone in Mountain View with no warning" situations we see every now and then? Then I just... can't use parts of my car I paid for because another company says so?
- jfim 3y agoIt's an interesting design direction considering the current model year has a physical button to turn the infotainment screen off; it's the button between the volume knob and the source button in this interior shot https://carbuzz.com/cars/lincoln/nautilus/photos-interior#5 https://carbuzz.com/cars/lincoln/nautilus/photos-interior#5
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoNot surprised to see the "give me my analog buttons!" comments that come out ad nauseum whenever articles about vehicle touch screens are posted. That said, while in many ways I agree with that sentiment, I have seen vehicle touch screens done well when they are appropriately augmented by physical controls. For example, my car is mostly touch screen but there is a physical spinner in the central console for volume, plus a switch on the steering wheel for volume as well as forward, back and pause buttons. That is, the controls I'm most likely going to want to touch while driving are physical, but controls that I'm likely to use while setting up stuff beforehand (like searching for and selecting a playlist) are on the touchscreen. The biggest screw up in this car is that the buttons for opening/closing the garage door are virtual and behind a menu that autohides after a while, which makes no sense given that 99.9% of the time you're going to be pressing this button twice. Main point being that car manufacturers definitly screwed up when they followed Tesla's lead of "everything is a touchscreen!", but I don't think pulling everything back to no-touchscreen is the right solution either.
- ninkendo 3y agoTo me it’s not about physical vs touchscreen, it’s about being able to do common controls without having to browse through contextual menus. I should be able to pause the music with a dedicated button (I don’t care much if it’s physical, but it’s very rare for touch screens to have “dedicated” buttons because it’s a waste of touch screen space.) It’s important while driving that I’m not required to read what’s on the screen to perform common actions. Having to browse to the music app just to pause means I’m spending several seconds not looking at the road. Just taking a typical infotainment UI and adding a jog dial doesn’t help me at all here.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoI mean, it sounds like we completely agree? > It’s important while driving that I’m not required to read what’s on the screen to perform common actions. Having to browse to the music app just to pause means I’m spending several seconds not looking at the road. Exactly, which is why I love that on my car I can just press a physical button with my thumb on the steering wheel to pause the music.
- nightski 3y agoI know it will severely limit my options in the future, but the last thing in the world I want is android/google in my car. I specifically do not buy an android phone.
- nvahalik 3y agoDrove a rental Mustang Convertible a couple of weeks ago. It had a fully touch-screen UI. All of the analog buttons were on the steering wheel, which wasn't necessarily bad, but trying to adjust all of the little things like seat heaters and volume, was a HUGE pain. Especially with gloves on in the cold weather. We have a 2019 Mustang Convertible and it has buttons for everything. It's trivial to adjust volume, seat heating and climate without having to waiting for feedback.
- NoPedantsThanks 3y ago'96 Cobra here. The only touchscreen in it is on my phone, for which I built a dock. Nothing else was or is needed. https://imgur.com/a/VnXFA3d https://imgur.com/a/VnXFA3d
- nvahalik 3y agoYou put a lot of trust in that 30-pin connector. (: That's pretty awesome, though!
- NoPedantsThanks 3y agoThanks! I don't rely on just the connector, though; that curved piece of plastic against the back of the phone supports most of its weight. I have to swap the 30-pin cord out for a Lightning connector. I have Apple's 30-pin-to-Lightning adapter, which is the only decent solution to their idiotic removal of the headphone jack because it restores the audio line out and power in at the same time. It's academic at the moment because I have to pull the engine out of the car to replace the heads; a bunch of Ford engines had a defect where they blow spark plugs out, destroying the hole in the cylinder head.
- genman 3y agoIf you think that the car designers can't go any more stupid then this is the proof that for sure they can. Anything that forces the driver to take the eyes of the surroundings is bad. Now there is more than meter of it. Some of it so far from the driver that for some of them getting any usable information would take considerable amount of focusing. Why? Do they want to get people killed?
- jacknews 3y agoWoah, what's the replacement cost for that panel - probably not far off the entire car. And I'll bet you can't operate the car at all without it. Modern electronics and 'smart' features etc are just a way to obsolete products that much quicker.
- sklargh 3y ago“Ultimately, the goal is to keep drivers from looking at their phones by giving them enough information and functionality in the infotainment screen.“ Perhaps simply less information and greater focus on operating a moving vehicle is appropriate.