7 ms·
Haier Europe Eases Off on Legal Threat and Seeks Dialogue
- jacquesm 3y agoSuing your best customers is never a good idea. This is one of the reasons why having only outside corporate counsel is sometimes useful: it stops you from having to keep your lawyers busy.
- Hamuko 3y agoI thought that the best IoT customers are those that install the company's own IoT app?
- sam_lowry_ 3y agoThese are the worst customers. They generate the most support tickets, increasing costs.
- blagie 3y agoThose are the most complex customers. They directly cost more than they bring in. However, they're also: 1) Thought leaders / influencers. How you treat them translates directly into blog / forum / etc. posts. 2) Innovators / bounds-pushers. This can impact future products, market research, etc. 3) Ecosystem builders. Network effects! It's a complex conversation. Apple courted education for much of its early history, not for direct profits, but so people entering the workforce would be trained on Apple. Balmer said "Developers, developers, developers!" even though developers cost money.
- sumtechguy 3y agoI worked one IoT system. Several hundred thousand devices. Our traffic was bonkers. Until we looked into it. It was one customer causing us like 80% of our traffic. Now this customer was one of those 'you really do not want to make them mad as they will make full page ads kinda companies'. But the fun part it was not even all of their devices (which had a flaw) it was like 10 locations where they had the devices (out of their huge fleet) that was causing us 80% of our traffic. Their device would setup a call squirt the data and hangup. These devices were doing that 20k times per hour. Most other devices we supported were maybe 10-15 per day. Being the 'big co' they were they blamed us. Being another 'big co' though we were like if you do not fix this we will walk on your account. That worked because this thing was a big deal for them. It could have easily gone the other way and damaged our whole product line. The solve was to properly moderate their calls and batch the data. Also it is dead easy to get this sort of thing wrong. From a programmers PoV send data. Under all of that could be a queue (hopefully), some sort of ppp connection and all sorts of interesting machinations. Yet the programmer PoV it is just a tcp setup, send, and close out cycle. Then there are things like 'do you really need to send all of that data?' 'does it really need to be human readable json?' 'have you tried this in your target environment and not some developers desktop yet?'
- rprospero 3y agoSupport tickets don't increase costs. Whether you have one support ticket or a trillion, the one guy responsible for clearing those tickets gets paid the same salary.
- dns_snek 3y agoWhy is this being downvoted? It's clearly, obviously, true. If the company saw it any other way, they wouldn't be sending frivolous legal threats to those trying to bypass their app.
- blagie 3y agoOutside counsel has one desire: Maximize billable hours. There is literally no incentive to have customers do well. I've seen a ton of frivolous litigation due to having legal strategy defined by outside counsel. Internal counsel, charitably, at least, has employment and gets to slack off if there's less work. Outside counsel wants those hours. There's a complex story about: 1) IANAL disclaimers and why it's often important to consult a lawyer rather than assuming you know the law 2) What NOT to trust lawyers on. This is much more than whether or not to sue; no lawyer ever got in trouble for being too conservative. Business decisions like this one should not be made by lawyers at all. Lawyers, inside or outside, should explain what the law is, but the decision should be made by someone who can do math on things like risk and ROI, and who understands brand value / impact on the above of any action.
- Angostura 3y ago> Maximize billable hours. Thw chances of this is not naximised if you are fired. I imagine the person who sent the original letter isn't exactly viewed as 'trusted counsel' at the moment.
- nirui 3y agoThe mindset of Chinese companies is different. The consumer laws in China don't work the same way compare to (say) the one in the US. Chinese user often only permitted to use the product as-is, if you developed and/or published a tool that could change how the product function, and the company produced the product deems the change undesirable (say, it hurts their profit), the company then has all the rights granted by laws to force you to take your tool down, as well as ask you for compensation and/or even escalate it to criminal charges. Company might (likely, actually) choose not to do that, but if they really wants to, they can pursue it to that end. That's maybe why Haier claimed that the project in question "harms their business model", which is a legal ground often used in lawsuit against Chinese developers. This case is a little bit more trickier since the project calls Haier's private API, because of that, according to Chinese laws, the violation could ranging from copyright infringement all the way to cyber attack (thus Haier claimed "violate copyright laws").
- kmeisthax 3y agoWait, "federal contempt of business model" is an actual tort in Chinese law?
- yorwba 3y agoNot literally in those terms, but the Anti-Unfair Competition Law 反不正当竞争法 (English text: https://wipolex-res.wipo.int/edocs/lexdocs/laws/en/cn/cn409en.pdf https://wipolex-res.wipo.int/edocs/lexdocs/laws/en/cn/cn409e... ) seems to often get used to accuse business model-threatening third parties of doing something illegal. E.g. Haier could claim that the API is a trade secret that the HA integration is using illegally, or that by accessing the API, Haier's domain name is being used without authorization (though I think this is intended to combat impersonation where someone registers a domain with their competitor's name) etc. etc. Funnily enough, it also outlaws "causing, in bad faith, incompatibility with an internet product or service lawfully provided by another business entity".
- tedivm 3y agoI don't understand why people keep bringing up China when this is a european company run by people in Europe. Every email that came to the dev seems to have come from a white european dude. None of this has anything to do with China.
- supergeek133 3y agoHow do you know these are Haier's best customers? By definition, they are using MORE platform/API traffic than the average user and not paying more.
- janwillemb 3y agoContext: German developer Andre Basche has created plugins to connect Haier devices to Home Assistant, apparently via the Haier API. Haier thinks/thought this harms their business model. From https://www.redpacketsecurity.com/haier-hits-home-assistant-plugin-dev-with-takedown-notice/ https://www.redpacketsecurity.com/haier-hits-home-assistant-...: > The plugins offered in the GitHub repositories enable users to control Haier, Candy, and Hoover air conditioners, purifiers, dishwashers, induction hobs, ovens, fridges, washing machines, and dryers through Home Assistant. > According to a notice published by the repository owner, Haier claims these plugins cause the firm significant financial damage and violate copyright laws, requiring the developer to take them down to avoid further legal action.
- nirui 3y agoHaier was a state controlled/ran company founded by the Chinese gov. Someone/team in their organization certainly still remember the days of being an untouchable. I'm glad that they regretted their wrong decisions and trying to hide it by walking away from it. But, I suspect that this whole event might go differently if the community response was slightly weaker. I'd rather thank the community, not Haier. Haier should probably start handing out real money to those independent devs who's still willing to work on their appliances after this.
- janice1999 3y agoThere was a now detailed comment in the GitHub thread reminding people that Haier "Europe" has an increasingly large manufacturing presence in Russia. Probably another good reason to avoid them.
- lionkor 3y agoThe west of Russia is part of Europe, whether you like that or not - A lot of people in western Russia consider themselves europeans, and visiting it feels like any eastern european country for the most part. As for why manufacturing in Russia would be a bad thing, I'm not sure, but I'm assuming you're referring to sanctions.
- meepmorp 3y ago> The west of Russia is part of Europe, whether you like that or not Literally nobody has a problem with that. What many people don't like is Russia's government and the way it's behaved towards everyone around them, for a few centuries at this point.
- beeboobaa 3y agoSure and I believe I'm a temporarily embarrassed millionaire. Doesn't make it true. Go shill somewhere else, troll.
- justinclift 3y agoOn that note: https://leave-russia.org/haier https://leave-russia.org/haier
- jeroenhd 3y agoIt's a bit disappointing to see Haier's very reasonable response (an extra high AWS load is expensive, because AWS is just expensive by design) but only after internet wide outrage. Had Haier reached out and asked the dev to optimise their HTTP calls, or perhaps adviced him on what kind of call pattern their cloud servers were optimised for so that costs could be kept low, Haier wouldn't have received all this bad press. Like many reverse engineered APIs, the HACS plugin probably does a whole bunch of inefficient API calls because there's no way of knowing what API calls are cheap and what calls are expensive. Haier could've gone further, and set up a dialogue to include a Haier component into Home Assistant directly, and slap a "works with home assistant" logo on their products' website. I'm no market analyst, but I'd be surprised if Haier wouldn't turn a profit on implementing official Home Assistant support.
- toyg 3y agoEuropean management culture is very business-first. Chances are that things went more or less like this: - Management sees cost spike, asks Sysadmins - Sysadmins investigate and say "not our fault, it's them pesky commie devs" - Management rings up legal, shenanigans ensue Now they've been publicly bitch-slapped, it's likely that management will do a bit of a sing and dance and then let engineers talk to engineers, while they piss off to some expensive restaurant at the company's expense.
- MilaM 3y ago> It's a bit disappointing to see Haier's very reasonable response (an extra high AWS load is expensive, because AWS is just expensive by design) but only after internet wide outrage. If this is the real reason, how long can you expect Haier to support the API free of charge for existing customers? Not very long I bet. The only sane solution are applicances that can be controled locally without an internet connection.
- EvanAnderson 3y agoIt would be great if "smart" devices requiring access to Internet-based servers had a monthly subscription fee. That would serve to both insure that the servers remained up by making them economically viable for the vendor and preserve the utility of the devices, and drive manufacturers to make locally-controllable devices to appeal to price-sensitive consumers. It would be great if we could go further and demand that manufacturers release the specs for their communications protocols if they exceed a threshold of unit sales, since they're effectively making a bunch of devices landfill fodder when they turn off the servers within the viable lifetime of the dependent devices. There's cool stuff out there I'd love to buy but once I see it requires an Internet connection it's a no-sale for me. (Even being locally controllable isn't a win if that comes with the requirement of running a closed source native "app". I'm still sad about some 32-bit iOS apps that Apple says I can't run on newer devices. I don't want to keep nursing an iPhone 3 along to be able to control a home appliance because the manufacturer figured out they can tie their product lifecycle to Apple's user-hostile backwards compatibility policies.) Sometime in the last 20 years the tech industry became a game of tempting me with cool features and then snatching them away, versus the exciting progress I remember from the 80s and 90s. I'm sure getting older is part of it, but I can't imagine shaping my habits around technology that can be taken away from me at any time would appeal to me at a younger age either.
- smashah 3y agoThere is EU law protecting interoperability projects (2009/24/ec) also Haier should be reported for anticompetitive behavior
- tzs 3y agoI have not read 2009/24/ec in great detail, but skimming it plus reading Wikipedia's description of it suggests that it is about copyright. Haier Europe's main complaint was with the Home Assistant plugin's use of APIs running on Haier's servers. That's not a copyright issue, and so appears to be out of scope for 2009/24/ec.
- close04 3y ago> Haier claims these plugins cause the firm significant financial damage and violate copyright laws Haier issued the takedown notice specifically on copyright grounds. Google and Oracle already battled this one out, and it was decided that using an API is fair use. This is probably the rule of thumb now barring exceptional cases.
- tzs 3y ago> Haier issued the takedown notice specifically on copyright grounds From the original letter they sent [1]: >> We are writing to inform you that we have discovered two Home Assistant integration plug-ins developed by you (https://github.com/Andre0512/hon https://github.com/Andre0512/hon and https://github.com/Andre0512/pyhOn https://github.com/Andre0512/pyhOn) that are in violation of our terms of service. Specifically, the plug-ins are using our services in an unauthorized manner which is causing significant economic harm to our Company. From their subsequent correspondence also shown on that page: >> Recently, we've observed a substantial increase in AWS calls attributed to your plugin, prompting the communication you previously received as standard protocol for our company, This is true: > Google and Oracle already battled this one out, and it was decided that using an API is fair use but not really relevant here. It just means that if you copy someone else's API that is not a copyright issue. It does not mean you have permission to call an implementation of that API that is running on their servers. That is out of scope as far as copyright goes. [1] https://github.com/Andre0512/hon/blob/main/takedown_faq.md https://github.com/Andre0512/hon/blob/main/takedown_faq.md
- djaychela 3y agoI emailed them to say I'd never buy any of their products again given their threat of legal action, having seen it on Louis Rossman's channel. I wonder how many other people did - the kind of thing you never know!
- AidenVennis 3y agoThis is another amazing story (after MyQ) to follow where public support is the main driver. I love seeing this support in times where the internet primary existence seems to be monetization lately. I do hope Andre wins this and continues this effort, I would even be pretty sure he could open a successful crowd funding action for legal fees if it needs to come to this.
- Freak_NL 3y agoHackaday links to this brief message on the website of Haier Europe: https://corporate.haier-europe.com/press-release/hon-app-a-message-about-our-iot-and-ecosystem-vision/ https://corporate.haier-europe.com/press-release/hon-app-a-m... It never ceases to amaze me how someone (or more likely some team) can write something like this and consider it an effective, or even just desirable, form of communication. The message is devoid of all signs of actual humans communicating. It's all empty corp-speak. Nothing about the reason this message was posted; no summary of what happened and what they perhaps did wrong. No explanation of how their actions came about. Even just “The API usage spiked; we freaked out and went straight to legal threats. We shouldn't have done that.” would feel less generic.
- 3abiton 3y agoExactly, I can fathom how a corporation tried to scrub an actual useful tool to help its users, and worse tried to sue the developer of this tool.
- marcosdumay 3y agoI really like the cookie warning "we would steal your data, but the Law requires that we tell you" you get before reading an apology. That's a really nice detail.
- j-a-a-p 3y agoIt is easy to overestimate the competence at these regional sales offices. I visited one a few years ago (similar product, Japanese HQ). And it seems Haier HQ dropped the ball by letting these locals roll out their own APIs. Also hilarious the US branch publicly distanced themselves from their EU colleagues.
- WesolyKubeczek 3y agoNo no no no no. You don’t seek a dialogue after, figuratively speaking, putting a gun to someone’s head. Hell no, you don’t say it was a joke when the gun misfires. They seek dialogue today, and tomorrow some beancounter from the legal department will pull this shit again to get their quarterly bonus. Heck, a company may have a written promise to never do stupid shit and then they renege on it because they feel like it. Publish code under a non-revocable license like GPL, then we talk. In the meantime, fuck Haier, fuck their legal department, fuck their PR team, and fuck the air conditioner they rode in on.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 3y agoOn one hand, I agree. On the other hand, many companies act badly without realizing it and genuinely try to better themselves after understanding why what they did was wrong. (This is particularly common with security reports, with a threatening response first then a more reasonable response once someone who knows how to properly handle disclosures talks to management.) There needs to be a balance - if there are no consequences for getting it wrong initially, many companies will try the bad way first and only backtrack when they get caught, but if we apply the standard that there is no possibility of redemption, a company would have no incentive to improve once they screwed up the first time.
- WesolyKubeczek 3y agoHow many misfires like this should happen before a whole generation of managers learns to not do that even once? How should I be sure that the company won’t reverse its course and sue me right back retroactively? There had been cases of the same companies doing several oopsie-daisies in a row. I can only be sure they can and will pull that shit again and again, and having done this once is proof enough. The parable of the frog and the scorpion exists for a reason. The only way a company may do something to prove they mean it is to do something they really cannot back away from by any reasonable means, not without paying a devastating cost. And thus my point above about Haier still stands.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]