6 ms·
'Cozy' relationship between Boeing and U.S. draws scrutiny amid 737 MAX 9 mess
- blibble 3y agoat this point I'm surprised the rest of the world still trusts the FAA's objectivity
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lolinder 3y agoThe rest of the world doesn't trust the FAA—51 other countries had already grounded the 737 Max 8 before the FAA did [0]. [0] https://www.latimes.com/opinion/editorials/la-ed-trump-faa-737-max-grounded-20190314-story.html https://www.latimes.com/opinion/editorials/la-ed-trump-faa-7...
- nativeit 3y agoI wonder why the FAA is held to such a higher standard than other regulatory agencies like the SEC, FTC, USDA, and FDA who arguably have far less objectivity, and whose failures are so much more frequent and have wrought so much more damage on the lives of the public?
- blibble 3y agoEurope certainly doesn't trust the USDA or FDA, at all, in any way regulatory capture of the others don't cause a significant problem outside the US when the sides start poping out of FAA approved airliners maybe trust of that agency should be re-evaluated
- lolinder 3y agoThis is classic whataboutism. The FAA isn't held to a higher standard, that's the entire point of this article and the discussion around it. We can and should oppose corruption in all government agencies, and if the FAA is where we can get enough will to start then so be it!
- anthomtb 3y agoCommercial airline failures often lead to sudden and large-scale loss-of-life. I don't know that you can say the same for products and services regulated by the other agencies you mentioned. I also don't know that I agree with your assertions. Do you have further evidence about FAA is held to such a higher standard than other regulatory agencies and how those other agencies failures are so much more frequent and have wrought so much more damage on the lives of the public?
- p_l 3y agoFAA involves international cooperation whereas most of the rest handle only internal US matters. Things that could be passed over in traditional wheeling & dealing of US politicians corruption won't fly (pun intended) because failures will get international consequences and scrutiny and tend to involve big medially visible tragedies (and not white collar crime or slow and unmarketable deaths of poor aka nobody important). Noticeably, two times that president pushed a deregulation policy on FAA, the result was deadly accidents - DC-10 cargo door issues (Nixon) and 737 MAXX development (policy pushed under Bush Jr). Additionally, FAA and related orgs elsewhere tend to take "regulations are written in blood" even more than regular pilots, and thus there's a drive to self correct even in face of problematic political reality.
- water9 3y agoSpirit aero systems makes the fuselage. I’ve made so much money over people panic selling after each 737 Max incident. It is truly a marvel how reliable air travel is especially when you compare it how it used to be in the 1970s when planes would crash almost monthly.
- FredPret 3y agoBoeing puts their name on the finished product; therefore Boeing made it via Spirit Aero Systems.
- Everdred2dx 3y agoSpirit also contracts with Airbus. Did Boeing just get unlucky?
- p_l 3y agoBoeing squeezes Spirit to last cent and didn't care about QA. Airbus apparently takes way more "partnership" approach to contractors.
- water9 3y agoYes people try to get the best price from their suppliers. Should I remind you how Apple iPhones are made?
- p_l 3y agoIf the quality drops because of that hard enough to endanger human lives...
- water9 3y agoYou act like it’s possible to be perfect and that accidents don’t happen in this world. why don’t you hold car makers to the same expectation just because they only go in two dimensions instead of three? Every company has bad workers that do bad jobs even mission critical jobs that endanger lives
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago[dupe] More discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39066737 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39066737
- MilStdJunkie 3y agoDuring the aughts, DERs (14 CFR section 183, employees of the company but "FAA Avatars") - were given relatively godlike powers compared to their role even in as recently as the 1990s. From what I understand that trend only intensified in the decades since. With my own eyes, I've seen activities rescheduled for a "friendly" DER's shift, and I have seen those "Pet DERs" go back and forth to the government offices, because those are the ones the manufacturer trusts to hire back from government service. Supposedly, the FAA offices around Puget Sound are thoroughly infiltrated with Boeing or Boeing-Subcon rotating door staff like this, but take that with a grain of salt. I think it's this sort of abuse that's primarily coming under the microscope, but if I'm being honest, the whole DER scheme needs to be reset to something viable. I mean, cmon. If I am employed by X, but I am an FAA DER, who do you think I am going to side with? The guy who pays my mortgage, or the guy who gives me a fancy shingle to hang on the office? That's a role that should have sharply defined boundaries.
- tcbawo 3y agoIsn’t it in both the FAA and Boeing’s interest to produce safe and reliable airplanes? It seems like the regulatory picture is not effectively fulfilling its duties, but the ultimate responsibility is with Boeing’s leadership structure for promulgating a culture where design lapses can persist and human error can be compounded.
- ponector 3y agoDon't mess interest of organizations in general and particular individuals. I'm sure many people in Boeing really care only about how to get required signoffs with as little effort as possible.
- acdha 3y agoYes, but it’s always a question of timeframe and personal distance. One of the insidious problems behind the modern MBAs’ veneration of Jack Welch is that GE always made its numbers, irregardless of the long-term cost to the company. If you’re in a position where your personal compensation depends on something going on a particular schedule, such as a huge sale of airplanes once a new model is approved, it’s going to be very easy to tell yourself that it’s “just”government red-tape delaying your cabin cruiser and the “safety Nazis” are just over-concerned. The odds are good that nothing will happen for years so you might not even be there when it happens, and complex failures usually mean there will be some complicating factors so the guys who made bad calls might be telling themselves that everything would have been fine if it wasn’t for someone else’s actions.
- psynister 3y agoBoeing's relationship with government agencies is beyond alarming. There needs to be better oversight and accountability for the sake of both passengers as well as workers in the aviation industry. People's lives are more important than profit. I can't believe this is a controversial position in our society.
- alexsereno 3y agoEffectively all of the aerospace and defense industries are like this. I’m not even sure it’s controversial, it’s just so normalized
- kevmo 3y ago"New Spin on a Revolving Door: Pentagon Officials Turned Venture Capitalists" - https://dnyuz.com/2023/12/30/new-spin-on-a-revolving-door-pentagon-officials-turned-venture-capitalists/ https://dnyuz.com/2023/12/30/new-spin-on-a-revolving-door-pe...
- tgv 3y agoI don’t think it is controversial, but rather overlooked whenever it’s convenient. Yes, that would speak ill of the people involved.
- bendergarcia 3y agoBeoings relationship with the U.S. only barely starts at commercial planes. They support the U.S. mission militarily. It is and should be alarming but also not surprising. The gov cozies up with any corporation that can further its interest
- golergka 3y agoIf that's how they cut corners in civilian aviation, which is used by the public all the time, how can they cut corners when they deliver obscure military hardware that just sits in the warehouse waiting for WW3?
- throwaway4good 3y agoShouldn't the "scrutiny" have been there years ago following the 737 MAX 8 crashes killing hundreds in Indonesia and Ethiopia?
- deathanatos 3y ago> But the longstanding special relationship between the U.S. government and Boeing has come under growing scrutiny, particularly after two crashes involving Boeing's 737 Max 8 plane, in 2018 and 2019.
- Jtsummers 3y agoA lot of these same issues came to light at the time of the MAX 8 crashes and their followup as well.
- midasuni 3y agoHundreds of Americans?
- iamsanteri 3y agoMy only question at this point: How has Airbus managed to avoid such problems so far? I really have begun admiring Airbus for this. It looks almost like Boeing is losing the grip on its core business and slowly decaying into some half-assed bureaucratic mess.
- bbojan 3y agoAirbus was an underdog, and it's always easier being the underdog? If Airbus becomes dominant for decades like Boeing was, it's likely that it could start experiencing the same problems.
- posix86 3y agoIs it? Airbuse gross income: 50 bln, boejing: 60 bln. Net income: 5bln vs -6 bln.
- erokar 3y agoPart of the answer could be that Airbus is European and regulated by different authorities.
- Ekaros 3y agoMultiple governments involved that is at least French, German and Spanish. So capturing all of those at one time is much harder process.
- pg_1234 3y agoEurope puts people before corporations. America puts corporations before people. There are endless articles about how American business is "more competitive" ... and it is, but this is the price.
- everybodyknows 3y ago> When congressional investigators started digging into what caused the crashes, they found a range of problems at Boeing — both with the design of the Max 8's flight control systems, and with pilot training — and they found insufficient oversight by the FAA. And at that layer of the onion the investigation stops, because the underneath is Congress' underfunding of the FAA, forcing the latter to resort to the sham of "self-inspection" by Boeing. Congress does not investigate itself; legislators are never to blame. NPR, as usual, has no clue.
- everybodyknows 3y agoOr, or, NPR management knows exactly what it's doing, and knows well not to bite the hand that feeds. The hand that feeds is extended by, of course, Congress!
- janice1999 3y agoInspectors could have spotted quality issues but I'm not convinced inspections would have found the MCAS issue. Boeing hid the feature, literally renaming it to sound less important, under existing trim control. Boeing emails showed management placed huge pressure internally to ensure no additional pilot training would be mandated. If the company is so willing to hide, obfuscate and outright lie, would external inspectors have helped?
- lopsotronic 3y agoSoftware FAA DERs (boeing staff who "report" to FAA) were a factor in the MCAS-related crashes. There's vanishing few SW DERs these days.
- baybal2 3y ago[dead]
- kurts_mustache 3y agoWhy does it seem like the average American doesn't care at all about exactly how much sway corporate interests hold in our government? Boeing's influence on politicians and regulatory agencies is a glaring example. The safety of passengers should come first, but somehow the 737 MAX keeps ending up getting the necessary approvals to carry passengers even after multiple crashes and now the doors falling off.
- make3 3y ago[flagged]
- bendergarcia 3y agoIt’s not about who voted for Trump or not. There’s democratic politicians who just as likely take beoing money. The crux of it is that more and more education is being eroded and the education we do get is funneled through the lens of what’s profitable. Americans critical thinking ability is being eroded. And we all know the systemic issues that cause this.
- matwood 3y ago> Americans critical thinking ability is being eroded. It's more nuanced than that. The internet has made critical thinking harder than ever. The search for engagement means headlines and half truths are pushed over deep analysis. And, once a person shows any interest in taking a side they are funneled into a bubble that's hard to leave. Even the best critical thinkers are going to have problems as AI takes off.
- dotnet00 3y agoYou're demonstrating an example of the critical thinking ability being eroded that the other poster mentioned.
- make3 3y agoI'm not sure how saying that electing a serial scammer & the actual impersonation of brutal, moral-less capitalism is an example of the culture of, and linked to, corporations capturing politics, is a lack of critical thinking. please show your work. I think you're just one of the people who say "you can't think critically" or "you're biased" to anyone you disagree with, without actual honest structured thought yourself
- ssnistfajen 3y agoSo when is Boeing going to get the ByteDance treatment of being accused of acting as an arm of a nation-state government?
- chefandy 3y ago> The head of the FAA says it's time to reexamine the longtime practice of delegating some of the agency's oversight responsibilities to Boeing employees, raising the possibility of moving some of those duties to a third party. Third party? I’m no expert, but I reckon the FAA should shift the FAA’s responsibility of Federally Administering the Aviation industry to the FAA. It would probably be a real bummer to have all of that sudden accountability and such, and to be fair I’m sure he didn’t assume he’d have that responsibility when he took the helm at that particular critical government regulatory agency. However, ensuring the safety of airplanes and protecting one of the US’s most important industries from the incompetence of grubby-fingered, greedy, executives might be a worthwhile pursuit.
- civilized 3y ago[flagged]
- hulitu 3y ago> 'Cozy' relationship between Boeing and U.S. draws scrutiny amid 737 MAX 9 mess Of course, you can call it lobby, you can call it "'Cozy' relationship", just don't call it corruption. It does not look good. /s