5 ms·
The Case for Nuclear Cargo Ships
- ZeroGravitas 3y agoIt quotes someone saying we need nuclear ships because we don't have enough clean fuels. Then much later quotes someone making the every obvious counterpoint, that we could install the nuclear on land and use that clean electrical power to manufacture the clean fuels. Now just replace those land based nuclear plants with a cheaper source of clean electricity and we have a solution that looks more feasible.
- cornholio 3y agoE-fuels are so inefficient that you need to bump carbon taxes to absurd levels before they become lucrative; it's cheaper to not ship most goods than to power ships with e-fuel. It's a niche solution for niche markets - say, racecars, supercars or piston aviation - not a green transport solution. One efficient solution for marine transportation would be Hydrogen storage as Ammonia, but it requires a new engine and it's a technology that is still in its infancy. Nuclear ships and submarines exist for decades and are a workable technology. The economics might still be off, especially considering the full maintenance and decommissioning. But if there is a place to try small modular reactors that get cheaper and more reliable as they are produced in series, this is it.
- pfdietz 3y agoOn the historical experience curve, electricity from PV could get so cheap that, per unit energy, it will be cheaper than thermal energy from burning natural gas. So don't presume e-fuels will stay expensive.
- goodSteveramos 3y agoYes. The cool thing about efuel is that it replaces the need for both battery electric vehicles and grid storage which are incredibly expensive too. People try to compare efuel to battery electric vehicles alone but that’s not accurate.
- Almondsetat 3y agoWhich efuel? Surely not hydrogen since its risk of exolosion is terrifying
- pfdietz 3y agoAmmonia is talked about as a fuel for ocean going ships. It's derived from hydrogen.
- goodSteveramos 3y agoI think efuel refers only to synthetic hydrocarbons like gasoline not hydrogen gas or ammonia.
- pfdietz 3y agoNo.
- goodSteveramos 3y agoFrom Wikipedia: Electrofuels, also known as e-fuels, a class of synthetic fuels, are a type of drop-in replacement fuel. So no, neither Hydrogen gas nor amonia are drop-in replacements for gasoline or diesel fuel.
- pfdietz 3y agoIt doesn't say what they're a replacement for in that definition. In this review article, hydrogen and ammonia are classed as e-fuels. https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/9837910 https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/9837910 > Another example is transforming electricity into e-fuels (like hydrogen) > hydrogen can be further converted to synthetic electricity-based fuels (e-fuels) as chemically bound RE and such as e-methane [27], [28], Fischer-Tropsch fuels [29], [30], e-ammonia [31], [32], and e-methanol [33], [34]. (that last paragraph doesn't say hydrogen is not an e-fuel, it says it's not a "synthetic" e-fuel, as hydrogen is as feedstock for synthesis here.)
- vlovich123 3y agoYou’re suggesting powering large tankers using PV cells? I think it’s less about cost and more that there’s insufficient power density to power a tanker. Hydrogen fuel is probably the only way to do that and you’d probably need a nuclear plant close to ports generating it on demand because hydrogen is energy intensive to create and supremely difficult to store (+ storage would still be a problem on ships and massive explosions would be a real risk)
- aaronblohowiak 3y agoPV cells on land overproducing leading to 0 or negative electricity prices, upturning the economics of using electricity for hydrolysis -based fuels, iiuc
- epistasis 3y agoThe suggestion is that electricity from PV could be so cheap that generating fuels with electricity could be cheaper, even with the massive inefficiency of it. It won't be hydrogen, because hydrogen is volumetrically not dense enough, it would likely be something like methanol or methane or maybe, with the right tech breakthrough, longer chains of carbon. You definitely don't want a nuclear plant generating this, because nuclear is way too expensive. Today, right now, solar energy stored in batteries is cheaper than new nuclear. And every year that price falls further. And most of the energy would never even have to be stored in batteries, and PV is cheaper than operating already-paid-for natural gas generators in most markets right now, (and getting cheaper). The energy world is being disrupted, but the incumbents aren't paying attention, and most of the US media is devoted to covering it up and discrediting cheaper energy, to benefit incumbent fossil fuel energy companies, the ones buying lots of advertisements.
- pfdietz 3y agoCarbon-containing fuels have the problem of either requiring CO2 to be retained on the ship for regeneration, or capture of CO2 from air to close the cycle. I wonder if metal e-fuels like, say, magnesium could be used. These might be more compatible with direct conversion of chemical energy to electrical energy. Oxidized magnesium could be directly released into the ocean to help reduce its pH. More aggressively: sodium?
- ZeroGravitas 3y agoBig names in shipping (shipbuilders, shipping, big customers) have already committed to efuels like green methanol. The ships are rolling off the production line now, the big task is a massive (massive!) ramp up of production of fuels to fill them. Carbon and other pollution fees are part of the solution to kick the market off, but again they're already in place (and would help nuclear powered ships equally)
- IshKebab 3y agoI think you're right but I got curious about the numbers: > 48% of renewable electricity used to convert e-fuels into liquid is lost along the process, while up to 70% of the fuel's energy is lost upon combustion. Not as bad as I thought tbh.
- electricships 3y agowe need all of the above deploy existingg tech, work on the remaining problems if there are angels here for deep sea clean shipping, kindly DM me pros: global moat, feasible tech, price parity at $80/barrel , massive upside cons: very early, capex heavy, long timelines
- DrNosferatu 3y agoI’m sure those Somali pirates would pay no attention to them!
- wkat4242 3y agoConsidering the shipping industry right now uses the absolute worst, most polluting terrible fuels they can find as soon as they're in international waters, we have absolutely zero chance they will handle the risks of nuclear responsibly.
- ericpauley 3y agoA factor that is often ignored is that bunker fuel is an inevitability of the refining process. It’s not like you can stop making it without stopping other fuel production. So it’s either going to get burned or disposed of some other way.
- Ographer 3y agoOil is naturally occurring and just because it exists doesn't mean we need to burn every component of it, releasing it into the atmosphere. Bunker fuel could hypothetically be re-injected into depleted reservoirs, much like brine water which is a useless byproduct of production. This would increase production costs of other components but at the benefit of the world's climate.
- wcoenen 3y ago> the shipping industry right now uses the absolute worst, most polluting terrible fuels they can find as soon as they're in international waters This was the case before 2020, but I think it has now been addressed by IMO 2020. https://www.imo.org/en/MediaCentre/PressBriefings/pages/34-IMO-2020-sulphur-limit-.aspx https://www.imo.org/en/MediaCentre/PressBriefings/pages/34-I...
- joeconway 3y agoIt is still used exactly as much as it was before, and sadly won’t change as a result of IMO for quite some time.
- Centigonal 3y agoIf it's still used just as much, then why are atmospheric SOx levels falling, especially over the oceans? [1] I'm not saying there's 100% adherence, but you're saying this isn't related at all? [1] https://twitter.com/LeonSimons8/status/1669667629844267008 https://twitter.com/LeonSimons8/status/1669667629844267008
- r0ckarong 3y agoSo what other ships are ran on nuclear power? I can only think of military vessels who have basically unlimited budget, personnel and oversight and tons and tons of extrinsic factors to not want to have a failure. How would you translate this to one of the most competitive, cost cutting industries with a notorious history of accidents and poor labor conditions?
- zrail 3y agoCompletely sealed power plant packs. Refueling requires swapping the entire power plant and sending it back to the manufacturer for recycling.
- r0ckarong 3y agoDoesn't cover lost or abandoned vessels. Who pays for the recovery when one of these sink? The insolvent carrier company? Who is accountable if the maintenance isn't done properly and one of these has some sort of serious malfunction that releases radiation? So many scenarios that are covered by government in a military scenario that can be circumvented in a billion ways in the private sector. The amount of legislation it would need to make this somewhat isotope tight is unfathomable and there would be a lot more money behind poking holes in it than to make it truly safe.
- moffkalast 3y agoSubmarines, aircraft carriers, some cruisers, icebreakers, and the one cargo ship Sevmorput. Safety's probably not as much of a prohibitive factor as raw cost.
- ViewTrick1002 3y agoAll designed for the least price sensitive customers globally. Nuclear powers' navies.
- moffkalast 3y agoPlus they conveniently already have a nuclear programme to source fuel and engineers from.
- RandomLensman 3y agoLet's see if those SMRs ever get to the price points, reliability etc. In the early days of nuclear power people had great hopes about progress, too, and, yet, here we are.
- bunabhucan 3y agoWe lose ~31 cargo ships per year, has "nuclear reactor shipwreck cleanup" been factored into the insurance costs to operate these in industrial ports? https://www.statista.com/statistics/236250/looses-of-ships-worldwide/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/236250/looses-of-ships-w...
- teaearlgraycold 3y agoWhen I've promoted the idea of nuclear cargo ships it's in conjunction with the US military running a fleet of them as a federal service. So these aren't just cargo ships, they're a navy presence around the world. Hopefully better funded, better ran, and better defended. What's nice about this is you get both the American "left" (environmentally conscious) and "right" (pro military) with one new initiative.
- vlovich123 3y agoIs that economically sustainable or would the US have to be subsidizing this significantly? Or would the reduced shrink rate / easier inspections make up the cost difference?
- ok_dad 3y agoDo you realize how much it costs to do nuclear on a ship? It’s not financially viable. The US Navy only uses it because they don’t want to have to fuel carriers.
- teaearlgraycold 3y agoDoes it need to be financially viable if you’ve got the military budget at your disposal?
- jrockway 3y agoI don't know if we need any more military scope creep. The military already has to deal with Russia v. Ukraine, Israel v. Gaza, pirates blowing up ships in the Suez canal, North Korea rattling its sabers, and an almost-inevitable invasion of Taiwan.
- gfsghfds 3y agoBe real. Cargo ships are easy targets. You would need massive security to prevent hijacking, radioactive exfiltration, etc.
- systems_glitch 3y agoAnother point to consider: many all-water routes are currently planned with excursions to allow picking up cheap bunker oil en route. Remove fueling concerns and you can run more direct routes.
- photochemsyn 3y agoRenewable methanol (ultimately via atmospheric CO2 + hydrogen from water) looks a lot more plausible as the long-term option, and is being deployed already. Much cheaper and no unusual risk profile, see Maersk and JP Morgan: https://www.fastcompany.com/90923816/maersk-first-cargo-ship-green-methanol-food-waste https://www.fastcompany.com/90923816/maersk-first-cargo-ship... https://www.offshore-energy.biz/jp-morgan-confirms-deal-for-methanol-powered-chemical-tankers/ https://www.offshore-energy.biz/jp-morgan-confirms-deal-for-... > "The utilization of green methanol on vessels is capable of eradicating SOx and Particulate Matter (PM) pollutants, while delivering a 60% reduction in NOx emissions. Furthermore, when measured on a tank-to-wake basis, it achieves nearly 100% reduction in CO2 emissions when compared to conventional marine fuels." As far as nuclear, I can't imagine many port operators are going to take the risk of irradiating the entire port for decades due to a catastrophic accident or deliberate attack that lightly. Countries might be more willing to accept stationary floating nuclear power plants as they'd have tighter control over them (although putting a floating nuclear power plant in SF Bay or similar locations also seems unlikely).
- credit_guy 3y agoThis is silly. If we ever get the capability to manufacture thousands of SMRs, then we are better off placing them on land, with the resulting decrease in emissions coming from land-based sources. A ton of CO2 is a ton of CO2. If we ever get to eliminate all the land based emissions, then we are well into net negative territory.
- JumpinJack_Cash 3y agoI believe the better idea is to put a regular nuclear reactor on a regular ship some 20 miles off the coast and then find a way to make an high voltage transmission line to land, to deliver electricity. At the first signs of trouble the ship can power up its regular diesel engines and go in the middle of the ocean so if a meltdown happens it's a solved problem already, in the worse case scenario you sink the ship and that would be the end of it considering how water is the best radiation shield and the ocean is immense It could be a nice option to finally convince people to give nuclear a try, the fear of meltdown is engrained in their minds so no matter how many reassurances and design models you give them they'd always be in panic mode, so the answer might be to just say 'okay if meltdown happens it's going to be 1500 miles away from the coast, in the middle of the ocean and we can immediately bury the whole thing under 6 miles of water.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- keepamovin 3y agoIran is gonna love nuclear cargo ships. Now they won't just fund Yemeni Houthis to interdict the ships, but to weaponize and cannibalize their nuclear power source! Fast track the Iranian nuclear program and maybe kickstart one in Yemen. Awesome.
- andy99 3y agoA lot of comments I see are assuming that the worst, least trustworthy shippers are going to be using these irresponsibly. Presumably we won't just be handing out nuclear engines. There would have to be a pretty robust regulatory regime that manages the whole lifecycle, and whatever random ship is not going to qualify for a nuclear fit-up. The required regulation may render the whole thing infeasible, I don't know, but any realistic solution will be heavily regulated making most concerns about misuse unrealistic.
- mjlee 3y agoOne flaw glossed over in the article is that having a nuclear reactor means your ship will be unable to visit many ports such as those unequipped to deal with, say, a fire on a nuclear powered vessel. That's not even to mention general nuclear opposition such as New Zealand's outright ban on nuclear powered vessels.