4 ms·
I know this is going to be voted down. I’m always scared of how things get done here in India -- not only because they are careless or trying to reduce cost --
by Brajeshwar 3y ago
I know this is going to be voted down. I’m always scared of how things get done here in India -- not only because they are careless or trying to reduce cost -- but because of the utter lack of importance given to human lives. Unfortunately, with an overwhelmed legal system, most of us, especially ordinary people, cannot even pursue legal action when an accident happens.
I’ve seen, heard, and experienced people doing their job just barely enough to reach a stage of “it works,” popularly known in the colloquial term as, “Chalta Hain.” This is more prominent in works such as the ad-hoc stage creation, pop-up kitchens, and the like.
This incident is sad, and I hope people learn from it and will prevent the other 100 such accidents.
My Condolences.
- shri_krishna 3y agoThis is true. Also equivalent to "Chalta hain" is "Jugaad". We really need to stop doing this. These short cuts/hacks are okay for when you don't have the means/resources available. Not when you have abundance. Doesn't make any sense whatsoever!
- jpgvm 3y agoIt's very hard to switch the mindset though. It becomes ingrained such that even when abundance is the new state of affairs scarcity still dominates the mind.
- disqard 3y agoCan confirm. I grew up in India and now live in the US. I regularly regress into a scarcity-oriented mindset (e.g. preventing all food wastage, avoiding spending on "nice-but-not-strictly-necessary" things, etc.). Even though this mindset is incongruous and inefficient for my present circumstances -- and I'm aware of it -- overcoming childhood programming about it is difficult. Old habits die hard, I guess.
- kumarvvr 3y agoI think the issue is more about greed. A qualified technician, to handle the rig, would cost X. A stage help would cost 0.1 X Indians are cheap and many in job roles are not qualified or care about their job. I am 100% sure that this sort of accident happens all the time, and some temporary workaround is used to repair the issue. Also, no one has any idea about anything close to a "safety margin". If I were on the job, as an engineer, I would make sure that the ropes and slings are atleast 100% more than calculated values.
- spaceman_2020 3y agoIncome differences in India are staggering. A trained bus driver carrying school kids in Jaipur, a state capital city of over 6M, gets paid $200/month. A security guard in the same school would get paid $125/month. The income for a mid career middle management professional in a good job would be 30-60x higher. Imagine getting paid 50x higher than your maid or bus driver or grocery store worker. Now imagine how that would rot your social structure
- beebeepka 3y agocaste system comes to mind. now let's imagine what might happen when genetic engineering comes into play. how can you argue about equality when there would be none, not biologically. i find insects fascinating but I don't want humans to mimic the caste thing. we are though. and we will. Confused by the downvotes. Are you in favour of caste systems?
- cjbprime 3y ago(You're aware that the 60x higher is $144k/year? That's common for a "mid career middle management professional in a good job" in Jaipur?)
- subtra3t 3y agoNo mid career middle management professional is earning a quarter of that anywhere in India. The most charitable take would be to assume a typo.
- walrus01 3y ago> I know this is going to be voted down. I’m always scared of how things get done here in India -- not because they are careless or trying to reduce cost -- but because of the utter lack of importance given to human lives My experience in seeing how electrical and gas lines are handled casually in Pakistan is the same. For instance, there was a huge transformer enclosure with no doors on it and bare bus bars anyone could easily reach in and grab, a transformer for high-voltage AC to low voltage step down, serving a 300 unit apartment building, with children playing football in the parking area right next to it. It's not really an India specific problem but really more widespread throughout many south asian developing nations.
- milleramp 3y agoThere was a documentary covering electrical theft and the guys doing it for a living. It's crazy the risks they take. https://www.pbs.org/independentlens/documentaries/powerless/ https://www.pbs.org/independentlens/documentaries/powerless/
- jacquesm 3y agoI've seen something not quite that dangerous but still pretty bad in downtown Toronto and I was quite amazed. One of those partially in-ground transformer boxes with the lids removed. What really got me about it is that it seemed that I was the only person that thought that this was kind of dangerous, everybody else thought it was just fine. And those things are old and in a crappy state of maintenance, enough so that they blow up with alarming regularity and when they do they spout flaming oil around them. You wouldn't get me to go near one.
- spaceman_2020 3y agoWhat’s bizarre is how little professionals care about their safety. In cities like Delhi, good electricians, plumbers, welders can make $1k+ a month - most of it tax free since they usually work in cash. Yet, they will never buy any safety equipment for themselves. I’ve seen welders use cheap $5 sunglasses instead of buying protective visors. There are new apartments coming up in my area, each of which is priced north of $500,000. Yet the laborers working on them don’t have even good quality plastic buckets or wheelbarrows to haul stuff around - they make do with burlap sacks and weave baskets.
- perfectstorm 3y agoI agree with this. As someone who grew up in India and now live in the U.S, i'm very scared whenever i visit India. Human lives have very little value in India. i can think of two aircraft accidents in the past 15yrs that could have been avoided (at least the second one if they learned from the first incident and if safety was a priority). I'm talking about the Mangalore airport accident in 2010 and the Calicut airport accident in 2020. Both have tabletop runways and i believe both planes skidded off the runway under poor weather conditions. if they learned something from the first accident, they would have deployed countermeasures (something like an arresting mechanism to stop the planes from skidding off. i forgot the technical term for it). when i was a kid, i remember hearing about rickshaw accidents frequently. most of the time, these rickshaws pack 10-15 children when 5 kids could barely sit comfortably. i'm sure i can think of many more examples showing lack of value for human life.
- cjbprime 3y ago> (something like an arresting mechanism to stop the planes from skidding off. i forgot the technical term for it) I don't think arresting mechanisms are common, and they require extra space to install them. The crew having the training and authority to divert to an alternate airport when it is wet and they are overweight is probably a better focus. > most of the time, these rickshaws pack 10-15 children when 5 kids could barely sit comfortably. Of course, it's also important to avoid criticizing poor people for being poor. What were the alternatives? It would be much safer for each kid to be in their own family SUV, as is common in the US, but this increase in child safety is due to increased wealth, not increased virtue.
- TaylorAlexander 3y agoThe SUV would decrease the safety for pedestrians in the area, so not really the ideal suggestion. It sounds like they needed more rickshaws, or trains.
- vr46 3y agoI was taught by my advanced riding instructor that riding/driving safely was about making sure that everyone inside and outside the vehicle was safe, not just the vehicle occupants. Protection and safety are different concepts in this regard. Everyone has a right to be safe, so "don't ride like a twat" in this case.
- ssivark 3y agoI acknowledge your concern, but also wish to point out that the emphasis/tone is slightly misdirected [fn] India certainly has a long way to go on this front. It feels very reminiscent of the US circa the gilded age roughly a century ago (Eg: look up worker safety in manufacturing, or fire safety scandals in NYC from back then). I’m sure Europe had a similar story. A society that is experiencing real and somewhat sustained growth for the first time is going to learn some hard lessons through the process, and then be forced into improvements to prevent the ugly side-effects. But the growth engine must first get going, before what seems like “overheads” can be paid from the surplus — and it likely will take a few decades. But you’d be surprised at the extent to which culture can change in a couple of generations (and how many bedrock cultural behaviors are relatively young). [fn] This is crucial for learning the right lessons, and inspiring the right response. It is certainly a solvable problem, it’s important to look at history to understand how other societies solved the problem after similar growth pangs.
- sillysaurusx 3y agoI’m not so sure. This argument reduces to "sacrifices are required in order to industrialize." You would perhaps feel differently if you were the sacrifice. Or your spouse. Or child. I might even agree with that argument, if it was true. I’m not above saying that it’s worthwhile for a society to sacrifice slaves in order to grow. Empirically, that was an effective strategy. But I wouldn’t want to live in a society with slaves. And that’s the level at which this argument must be reduced to, because someone who dies with no recourse due to their society’s goals is little more than a slave. The question is, are you absolutely certain that the suffering you’re referring to is a requirement of industrialization? I’m not qualified to answer that, but it would be interesting to hear whether you feel it’s true.
- ssivark 3y agoFirstly, it’s an enormous human tragedy, and I’m not justifying it. I’m trying to understand why the problem seems so widespread. > "sacrifices are required in order to industrialize." No, I’m making a different point. I’m not saying it ought to be that way (to industrialize) — only why it’s so naturally, and therefore what changes are needed to improve. Safety margins in construction, and proper regulation/inspection are “overheads” which can only be paid once you have surplus (economic productivity). In some cases, the extra cost is minimal (just preventing corruption/carelessness in an already sufficient process/design), but in other cases it requires being willing to pay extra “for safety”, so it becomes a question of affordability & access eg: traveling in a well built car rather than an auto rickshaw, or discarding food past the "sell by" date. To use another example from a sibling comment: a dozen children being crammed into an auto rickshaw on school commutes. Suppose the society starts enforcing a law mandating that no more than 3 humans (incl children) can travel in an auto rickshaw at once. The consequence is that the cost of commute has now increased manifold — does that take it beyond the regime of affordability for some fraction of the population — Will the kids now have to walk/cycle to school instead? What tradeoffs would those kids/families prefer? So investing in safety requires not just that the business under consideration be profitable, but also that all customers have enough economic productivity which manifests in their willingness to spend larger amounts and demand safety and/or raise the floor forbidding unsafe products. Reasoning in analogy with a minimum wage — if you raise the level too high, you just rule out a whole bunch of low-surplus economic activity. To make the trade off worthwhile, and not forbid essential economic activity, the wage floor can only be raised in tandem with economic productivity. Consumer goods at least segment markets with price discrimination, so richer people can buy Eg. larger+safer cars. But they might have to drive on the same roads as everyone else (potholes and all), or use the same cable cars (to borrow an example from a sibling comment), or use the same medication — because "infrastructure" that needs to serve a larger population can only match the average (cumulative, in some cases) productivity. It’s an example where inequality hurts — however rich a single consumer might be, they only have access to are what the rest of the market is willing to buy (made viable with economies of scale). Finally, what I'm trying to point out is that these are not "sacrifices in order to grow" (i.e. investments) to some rosy future -- these are tradeoffs necessary for functioning today. Growth is a separate story -- if and when it does happen, the prosperity helps bootstrap the system into safer operating modes, for which we may be thankful.
- throwaway892238 3y agoThe US, among other industrializing nations at the turn of the 19th century, had a pretty poor record for reliability, safety, etc. Over the years, local groups gathered together and lobbied for changes, usually to protect or defend a particular trade. Towards the late 19th century, more organizations were popping up to push for professional standards, licensing requirements, codes of ethics, public safety and social responsibility. For the better part of two centuries, this country (and others) have been very slowly yet incrementally improving how engineering is done. Developing nations like India need their own time to move through similar processes. There still needs to be people lobbying, doing the work of organizing, and changing the way things work. But it's going to take decades, and maybe even centuries, like it did for other nations.
- resolutebat 3y agoI once took a cable car in Haridwar, which had a large poster outside assuring riders that they were fully insured and in the event of death, their relatives would be compensated by the grand sum of Rs. 10,000. Even at the time, it was less than US$500, and I'm sure that even getting that amount would involve an epic decades-long battle with bureaucracy.
- ssivark 3y agoHow much economic surplus do you think that cable car generates? How much of that could/should be spent on insurance premiums? What payoffs would those premiums entail? What is the right balance between spending on better safety tech (structural integrity, etc) vs premiums? There definitely needs to be a culture change wrt safety, but a massive increase in economic productivity is necessary to drive investment in safety.
- tuwtuwtuwtuw 3y agoI think you completely missed his point.
- CommanderData 3y agoI was told by an Indian work colleague that it's a matter of culture and stems from something along the analogy he gave of 'bare minimum', 'if I can get away with it'. It probably explains why I've seen offshore teams verbally abused and oppressively micro-managed by their managers, to extents that treatment would be illegal in the West. I'd feel anxious if any life critical sector or even piece of software was developed from any of the large Indian consultancies I've had the displeasure of working with. As this attitude manifests itself almost every time sometime is delivered. There's a shrew of threads on HN about poor, contaminated pharmaceuticals from India e.g. eye drops. The UK governments website on drug recalls have a large number of Indian manufactured products.
- tock 3y agoI say this all the time: the large Indian consultancies pay their new grads ~$4500 YEARLY. I know plenty of people who used to work there. They were all treated like livestock. Please do not expect them to care about quality when treated like shit and paid like shit. The good engineers in India work for much much higher wages and they do produce world class work.
- CommanderData 3y agoI have 3 South Asians in my team and completely agree with you about class work or talent. It's taken the best part of 5 years to curate the best from offshore to eventually offering onshore jobs. We now all complain about the same issues; lack of care, pride of work or worksmanship. They now manage offshore and treat them with alot more humanity. Sometimes will resort to 'ill speech' because they say 'it's how things work there as a boss otherwise they climb ontop of your head' which always makes me laugh when they say it.
- sirsinsalot 3y agoMy experience in software in the UK has consistently been that Indian workers also have this mentality. It seems to be a cultural approach to engineering. Things become a botch job constantly, backed my false promise. It appears more important to look competent than to be so. I'm not saying this is universal and of course everyone gets the bias free opportunity to execute on their own merit, but this has been my observation.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- silisili 3y agoThe lack of importance given to human life is one of the most jarring things to me having been born in the US. My wife is from a similar area and tells me childhood stories that make -me- feel traumatized, as if it's just another day. The last one I remember was about a 'careless boy' who was in the road too much on the way to school being run over and killed by a bus, like it's his fault. And they just threw his body out of the road and went to school like it's a normal Tuesday! I have no idea to reconcile that as a whole, and generally understand how lucky I am. But it just feels like things will never get better when the most basic (to me) of values is missing.
- yieldcrv 3y agoI’ve also heard a lot of stories from people in/from India where the wrong lesson was learned from my perspective like whatever you predict the moral of the story would be, its the opposite toxic thing
- CastawayData 3y agoIn China, the attitude is known as “Chabuduo” or “close enough.” It’s wild I went this long thinking there was something inherent to Chinese culture that gave rise to this. I don’t think it’s Indian, Chinese or Asian culture. I think this is what happens when people aren’t paid enough to care.
- Aeolun 3y agoI’m not sure. I can imagine a lot of people in the Netherlands not being paid enough to care, but I have a really hard time imagining any of them not caring enough about safety critical equipment. Then there’s Japan, where caring too much even though you are paid too little is kind of a cultural thing.
- maxglute 3y ago>this is what happens when people aren’t paid enough to care. This is what happens when economic development selects quantity over quality. And IMO it's the right choice, especially for large countries. Nevermind not being able to pay for for quality in the first place (lack of qualified skill), when you're at the bottom of the ladder it's long term better to trade safety/lives for more/faster progress. The aggregate societal and human gains that can be afforded from growing income almost always trumps loss from chabuduo. Especially for large countries like India and PRC with so much (bluntly) disposable bodies, you want to throw everyone into the mixer because with that many bodies, it's important to seperate wheat from chaff in terms of human capita as soon as possible and harness them - otherwise potential gets squandered on massive scale. It's not just construction. It's important to manufacture lots of things because even if you make lots of shit, you'll also discover the great makers who makes things that are internationally competitive. Or spam lots of academic papers, because even if most of is hack fraud, it's also maximizing for gems that raise ceiling on top end. Countries grow by learning and improving via doing a lot, even if most of it is not good.
- mlrtime 3y agoI'm a US citizen and I've been to India ~ 10 times. Mostly always Mumbai/Pune. The first few times I was optimistically surprised at how less expensive services and food were "I could live like a king here". However I realized that while things were cheaper, the quality of the services were much much lower than the same service in the US. I started to search for the best services for things I needed (and cared about) and the cost ended up being the same or sometimes more than the equilvilant in the states. This is just a small observation that I remember and I wonder if it what you are talking about.
- nelblu 3y agoIt's absolutely true - the lack of respect for human lives. Remember all those incidences where a film star or a rich kid or politican drinks and drives over a family of poor people sleeping on the streets and you hear nothing about it after it has happened? One of my relative killed 2 girls drunk and driving in a village and got away with it. Every time I think of that, it traumatises me :'(
- Tryanasorus 3y agoEven before reading your comment, I was thinking how empty the "industrial accidents" sections on sites like LiveLeak would be without India and China. I am never ever in my life going to those places. Death lurks in every corner of their infrastructure. And you'll have to pardon me for drawing a connection between the plummeting standards in Western construction and the foreign workers - predominantly Indian - flooding this sector. It's not a coincidence.
- JohnBooty 3y agoNot sure where you live, it's worth noting that India and China combined have 8x the population of the United States, so certainly we'd expect something like 8x the number of "industrial accidents" there. Perhaps more, since we've offshored so much of our industry.
- Tryanasorus 3y agoIt's not so much the frequency as the nature of the accidents. There is an astonishing lack of regulations, safeguards, and standards (especially in Chinese videos) combined with an astonishing lack of situational awareness, foresight, and humility (especially in Indian videos). Of course America has its unique videos too. Every place has its problems, that's what I find interesting about it. I like the unfiltered view into the underlying culture and psychology in these places that only "gore" videos can provide.
- cafard 3y agohttps://www.osha.gov/fatalities#&sort[#incSum]=0-1-1-0&page[#incSum]=1&size[#incSum]=40 https://www.osha.gov/fatalities#&sort[#incSum]=0-1-1-0&page[...
- strikelaserclaw 3y agoThe average indian mentality = say 'yes' to things even if you don't know how to do something and do the bare minimum required to get away with it. It is hard living in India due to the huge amount of people living there and the lack of proper allocation of resources, if you try to live a principled life, you look around you and see 50-60% of the people taking advantage or cheating the system and you get FOMO big time, and eventually most people succumb to corruption of some sort which keeps this loop going, it is a vicious cycle.