3 ms·
> as willfully ignorant of the Vision Pro as those complaints were of the iPad, and later the Apple Watch and the AirPods These are the evidence of the opposit
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
> as willfully ignorant of the Vision Pro as those complaints were of the iPad, and later the Apple Watch and the AirPods
These are the evidence of the opposite.
Apple's hardware from the 70s and 80s, like the original Macintosh, were something special. NeXTSTEP, the Steve Jobs thing that got rebranded as Mac OS X when Apple bought them, was the first modern OS to be simultaneously good and popular. The iPhone changed what a phone is.
The iPad is an iPhone, but bigger. The watch is an iPhone, but smaller. These are not innovations of the same kind. They're the sort of thing you'd expect out of Facebook or Amazon or any other large mature bureaucratic corporation.
If the Apple II was the 70s and the Macintosh was the 80s and NeXTSTEP was the 90s and the iPhone was the 2000s, name the thing of this caliber they did in the 2010s.
- jedberg 3y ago> name the thing of this caliber they did in the 2010s. Well, you had to wait for the 2020s, but Vision Pro. It's an entirely new computer, meant to be your primary device. It's similar to how the Mac came out when PCs already existed, but were just different. Just wait 10 years until the market realizes it.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago>Just wait 10 years until the market realizes it. People said that about Google Glass 10 years ago.
- jedberg 3y agoGoogle glass was ahead of its time. And was creepy with its recording ability and other features it launched with. Also, it was only a display for an attached phone for the most part. It couldn't really do anything. This is a whole computer strapped to your head.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoWhy would you want a computer strapped to your head? Computers generate heat and have weight that you'd rather put in your pocket than have to support with your neck. To make it work you're stuck with a trade off between performance, weight and battery life when none of those is fun to sacrifice in this context.
- hnfong 3y agoYou could have said the same things to laptops 40 years ago, and smartphones 20 years ago. As long as Moore's law limps along, eventually performance/weight/battery will work out.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoMoore's law has been dead for a while now and nobody really knows how much more we can get in terms of performance per watt. But even if it continues to improve, you're implying that what they've got right now is this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compaq_Portable https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compaq_Portable Or maybe worse than that, because the trade off never really goes away. Desktops and servers are still faster than laptops, but portability is a huge advantage, so sacrificing some performance is worth it to have something with you everywhere you go. But how much performance is it worth sacrificing to avoid having a phone in your pocket? Nowhere near as much as it is to avoid lugging a desktop computer around with you. Or to measure it from the other side, lots of people still have a Macbook even though they also have an iPhone.
- hnfong 3y agoThat's why I said Moore's law limping along.. it has slowed significantly, and the original transistor doubling every 18~24 months is definitely dead, but transistor processes are still improving, slowly. The trade off is always there, but more people are using their phones over their desktop computer these days. That said, I do have serious concerns the greater impact to society in general when transistor technology hit a hard roadblock. Probably outside the scope of this discussion though.
- amanj41 3y agoThe Vision Pro is hardly differentiated from the top end Meta VR model. There are a few UX enhancements, and I think they'll take the lead in the space eventually. But I wouldn't say this is a big innovation in the VR space from what I've seen.
- jedberg 3y ago> The Vision Pro is hardly differentiated from the top end Meta VR model. I think their approach is unique. They are branding it as a replacement for your computer. The one and only device you need to be productive. And don't underestimate the value of not needing controllers.
- mjamesaustin 3y agoThe iPhone was hardly different from other touch screen phones at the time, except for the UX enhancements. And it turns out good UX changes the world. Pay attention to how people talk about the experience of using Vision Pro vs other headsets. The eye tracking interface is widely praised and described by third parties (not just Apple) as feeling like magic. I haven't used it yet, but I can imagine what using a computer would be like if I didn't have to actually point my mouse anywhere and instead it could effectively read my mind about where I want to click. IMO this is the interface revolution that will become ubiquitous over the next 5-10 years, and Apple is once again leading the charge.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> name the thing of this caliber they did in the 2010s AirPods. It’s a category-defining product, and in pure Apple tradition, a refinement of an existing one.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoAirPods are earbuds. They're nice earbuds, but it's hardly the next iPhone.
- hatsunearu 3y agoWe went from earbuds looking like one thing, to basically everyone wearing airpods-like things with great noise cancellation and usability. I'd say that's a home run.
- MBCook 3y agoWhy weren’t there tons of earbuds that looked like AirPods before the AirPods came out? Two independent things that weren’t linked with a wire that you could put in a charging case? I seem to remember there was one other similar looking device at the time, I think from Samsung. But it wasn’t as small and got terrible battery life. There was absolutely nothing like them at the time in the category.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> Why weren’t there tons of earbuds that looked like AirPods before the AirPods came out? Two independent things that weren’t linked with a wire that you could put in a charging case? Because making them that way is more expensive. > There was absolutely nothing like them at the time in the category. iPhone: There is now a usable internet-connected general-purpose computer in your pocket. AirPods: We got rid of the piece of wire between your earbuds. It's not the same thing.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> iPhone: There is now a usable internet-connected general-purpose computer in your pocket. AirPods: We got rid of the piece of wire between your earbuds. Most people who have AirPods didn’t have earbuds with the wire. Those who did didn’t wear them like AirPods. The iPhone is a computer in your pocket you interact with through touch. AirPods are computers in your ears you interact with through voice. Especially with LLMs, the latter is a huge step forward. Also, the processing power in an AirPod outclasses Apollo 11’s; if we’re going to go full tech reductionist, it’s still a feat.
- thoughtsimple 3y ago>If the Apple II was the 70s and the Macintosh was the 80s and NeXTSTEP was the 90s and the iPhone was the 2000s, name the thing of this caliber they did in the 2010s. Arguably, the iPod was 2000s and the iPhone was 2010s. The iPhone really didn't get started until the iPhone 3GS in middle-2009 so it started slowly but really defined the 2010s for Apple.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThat's just as true of the others. NeXTSTEP was the 90s but "Mac OS X" wasn't released until 2001. But if you asked someone in 2004 or 2014 if Apple had done anything interesting recently, you'd have been able to name what it was.
- chrisjc 3y ago> If the Apple II was the 70s and the Macintosh was the 80s and NeXTSTEP was the 90s and the iPhone was the 2000s, name the thing of this caliber they did in the 2010s. Apple Silicon?
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoApple Silicon is slower on the same process node than AMD.