7 ms·
HP's CEO spells it out: You're a 'bad investment' if you don't buy HP supplies
- kstrauser 3y agoI'm not your investment, ace. You're mine. Well, you would be, if it weren't for a thousand cuts like this in the past.
- bell-cot 3y ago> "Every time a customer buys a printer, it's an investment for us. We are investing in that customer, and if that customer doesn't print enough or doesn't use our supplies, it's a bad investment." - HP CEO "No HP product could possibly be a good investment for me" - Any & Every Sane Customer
- Spartan-S63 3y agoFurthermore, if this were a sane analogy, HP would be paying us for the printer hardware and we would be returning the “investment” via paper and ink cartridges/toner.
- anamexis 3y agoWell, they aren't paying us, but the printers are most likely sold at a loss. So that part holds.
- RobRivera 3y agoThe xbox was sold at a loss, that was an investment. Convince me they sell those printers at a loss.
- vineyardmike 3y agoTo be fair, Microsoft is also pretty heavy handed that only content which pays a licensing fee to MSFT can be run on the Xbox.
- RobRivera 3y agoThey ensured their investment had low risk
- Almondsetat 3y agoSure: find me someone who indeoendently built a printer. The technology behind them is insane for most of them costing less than $100
- ldoughty 3y agoMaybe they shouldn't sell printers under cost and ink at a 98% profit per sale... I would buy ink cartridges from the vendors if they were not twice as expensive and utilizing sleezy tactics like lying about being empty.
- a_wild_dandan 3y agoThe first time my consumer HP printer refused to print my black-and-white document unless I refilled its magenta or whatever, I tossed it in the dumpster and bought an $80 Brother laser printer. Zero print problems, ever, since the switch. And the original toner cartridge lasted damn near forever, with cheap replacements. You couldn’t pay me to use an HP printer anymore.
- willcipriano 3y ago> refused to print my black-and-white document unless I refilled its magenta or whatever Can't have you printing anonymously https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Machine_Identification_Code https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Machine_Identification_Code
- DougN7 3y agoI did the same thing. Love my Epson ECO Tank.
- Sohcahtoa82 3y agoBlame the short-sighted customers that are going printer shopping and see the $50 HP printer and the $150 $OTHER_BRAND printer and buy the HP without looking at the cost of supplies.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoNo. I blame the corporations that engage in illegal price dumping schemes and the US government which refuses to enforce antitrust regulations.
- BizarroLand 3y ago
- jqpabc123 3y agoI'm looking out for HP by not buying their product and preventing them from making a bad investment in me. If enough other people do the same, they'll be rich, right?
- barbazoo 3y agoThis reminds me of tipping culture. Provide a service, charge for it, and then complain when people don't voluntarily give more money than they have to.
- BLKNSLVR 3y agoIf my investments' success were dependent upon a bunch of people who don't have any personal interest in my investments being successful, then there's a high chance my investments won't be successful. Seems an excellent justification for the board to fire the CEO for fiscal irresponsibility.
- msandford 3y agoThat's weird, I thought I was a customer not an investment. In general of course, with HP the shenanigans have been obvious for a while. It's nice to see people saying what they actually believe out loud. Refreshing.
- rickreynoldssf 3y agoAre personal printers really still a thing? I can count on 1 finger how many times I needed to print something in the past few years and FedEx Kinkos is perfect for that. I'd rather pay like $5 rather than have some bulky ugly thing taking up space on my desk.
- choilive 3y agoDepends on your day to day I guess. My partner is a med student and goes through about a ream or two of paper per semester.
- jawns 3y agoThere are plenty of people who have frequent printing needs, even if they're not using it for work. For instance, my wife homeschools, so she prints a lot of worksheets and such. My son plays piano, and he likes to print out sheet music. And I find myself, more often than I'd like, having to print out forms and sign them, because the company or organization hasn't figured out electronic signatures yet. But perhaps the bigger feedback I'd offer in response to your comment is that just because something doesn't apply to you or your situation doesn't mean that it's not relevant to other people.
- chankstein38 3y agoThey just asked the question. How would we know that something is relevant to others if we don't ask? As another person in the same boat, it shocks me people even care about printers at this point. I do the same, just run to FedEx if I need to print. That said, thanks to the parent commenter asking the question, I now know. Not sure why you feel the need to lecture.
- jawns 3y agoWhile I admit it's possible to misread tone, I perceived the tone as dismissive, like "This doesn't matter to me, so I'm shocked that it matters to anyone else." That's a form of egocentric bias, which is not to imply that the commenter has an overinflated ego, but merely that it can lead us to make inaccurate assessments.
- AshamedCaptain 3y ago> HP has long banged the drum about the potential for malware to be introduced via print cartridges, and in 2022, its bug bounty program confirmed that third-party cartridges with reprogrammable chips could deliver malware into printers. How to convince the larger masses that this is actually a reflection of HP's plain gross incompetence (and likely intentional), rather than "the inevitable natural order of things" as the HP lackeys want to imply?
- brianwawok 3y agoNot possible. The average tech consumer doesn't know an app vs a webpage.
- jandrese 3y agoThe funny thing is that if this ever happened, it would be on official HP cartridges that were the subject of a supply chain attack or insider threat. And yes, the even better part is that there is zero technical reason why this needs to be the case, the cartridges themselves should be dumb except for possibly a toner level sensor that is just a simple analog device. The threat vector only exists because HP is trying to squeeze the customer.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoGood. Thanks for letting me know. I want to be a bad investment to these scummy corporations. In fact I don't want my value to be merely low, I want it to be negative, they should lose money. It gives me peace of mind that I helped hasten their bankruptcy.
- jjulius 3y agoI can't think of many other ways for a CEO to make it really, really easy for potential customers to just completely disregard their company as an option. Bravo!
- jawns 3y agoI got a notification today that my HP Instant Ink subscription, which rose from $3/mo to $4/mo last year, is rising to $5/mo. this year. My subscription covers 50 pages a month, so that's 10 cents per page. This is making me more inclined to switch to a (non-HP) color laser printer, but I'm finding it challenging to find reputable information about total cost of ownership. Would love some suggestions!
- mewse-hn 3y agoAny laser printer will be significantly more reliable because toner doesn't dry out. People are very happy with Brother laser printers, but I deal with HP enterprise laser printers at work and they basically Just Work vs the nightmare consumer grade inkjets that are always clogging and breaking down
- crandycodes 3y ago+1 for Brother. Had the same one (MFC-L3750CDW) for years now. Just works. No weird subscription push. No weird apps to manage it. Actually integrates with 3rd party software easily. Everything I need and nothing I don't.
- ianceicys 3y agoI canceled my Instant Ink subscription last month $5/month at $60 a year is worth going to costco and picking up a Cannon Laser printer for $200.
- kstrauser 3y agoThere's a Brother HL-3170CDW behind me. I bought a $48 5-pack of toner (1 each of the colors, 2 blacks) in October. The last such back I bought got me about 2000 pages. For toner, then, my ongoing expense is about $0.024 per page.
- DrNosferatu 3y agoReally cool printer feature search / database: https://www.druckerchannel.de/ https://www.druckerchannel.de/ (google translate, or a equivalent, might be handy)
- wolpoli 3y ago> "We have seen that you can embed viruses into cartridges, through the cartridge go to the printer, from the printer go to the network, so it can create many more problems for customers." If this is true, HP's CEO just publically admitted that their printers have some serious security issue.
- jjulius 3y agoThe article goes on to say that it is, in fact, true. >HP has long banged the drum [PDF] about the potential for malware to be introduced via print cartridges, and in 2022, its bug bounty program confirmed that third-party cartridges with reprogrammable chips could deliver malware into printers.
- twobitshifter 3y agoIt seems that they had no incentive to prevent malware, as its existence could be used to make customers buy their ink instead. I wonder if they fixed this bug at all after the exploit was found.
- surfingdino 3y agoHas anyone suggested not spiking cartridges with chips in the first place?
- cocacola1 3y agoInterestingly, HP supplies are also bad investments.
- Gys 3y agoSo I guess they sell printers at or below cost? In which case one could argue HP is dumping its products. Illegal in some countries.
- 6R1M0R4CL3 3y agoHP is a shadow of how great it was. HP was an engineer company, producing products for engineers. Their measure tools were top notch. Now, it's all gone to Digilent. Their line of reverse polish notation HP series of calculators... long gone. While the HP Prime is somewhat OK, it's a POS compared to the HP48 quality level (I dont care that you integrated Erable-like inside). HP will be gone, like Digital is.
- bpye 3y agoMy understanding was that those bits of HP ended up becoming Agilent, and more recently Keysight.
- therealmarv 3y agoNever thought about it actively but I will never ever consider a HP product again. I think the minimum a company should do is to show some kind of minimum respect to a potential customer.
- willio58 3y agoIt's kind of refreshing in a weird way when a CEO says something like this. Like we put soooo much value in the voice of CEOs globally, yet every now and then you actually tune into the words uttered by them and you realize they're just people. Like they have horrible ideas that they think are profound, just like everyone. So while it's somewhat scary for anyone working for HP and I've personally avoided HP products for over a decade, it just goes to show CEOs don't run their companies. They're a figure head in most cases the actual value comes from... us. The workers. Makes me hopeful that one day all workers will realize who produces the value in their companies and start to restructure in a way that puts their voices more near the top. Unions are obviously great for this, but we just need more of that honestly.
- bigbillheck 3y ago> the actual value comes from... us. The workers. All value is created by labor.
- tempestn 3y agoOf course CEOs are just people who make mistakes. In fact, a CEO is simply a specialized worker whose role is making high-level strategic decisions for the company. (And sometimes more tactical ones, depending on the company's scale.) Some are going to be better at that than others. The leverage of that decision-making allows a CEO to add significant value if they make good decisions, or subtract value if they make poor ones. Personally I agree that the best CEOs listen to feedback from other employees (as well as from customers and other stakeholders) and try to achieve a degree of consensus, but I would argue that that too is a skill that adds value.
- troupe 3y ago> they have horrible ideas that they think are profound I'm not so sure this is a horrible idea from the standpoint of their business. Other businesses could operate differently and if people preferred that, they wouldn't buy HP. Case in point, I haven't heard anyone recommend an HP printer recently.
- anothernewdude 3y agoI mean, they created the malware vector so they could scaremonger. There's no reason a printer cartridge requires any electronics at all.
- tomphoolery 3y agoPeople: "HP is a bad investment" HP: "no u" (j/k of course...i actually rather like their enterprise blade offering if you're making your own cloud)
- JohnFen 3y ago> i actually rather like their enterprise blade offering Just be careful. HP has said loud and clear what they think of you and all their other customers, and their thinking is actively against you.
- JohnFen 3y agoHP's CEO spells it out to me: never buy any HP products ever again.
- ProfessorLayton 3y agoI'll admit I could just be out of touch, but who's buying these inkjet printers? Laser printers are dirt cheap to run (Brother) and they exist in color too. Photos cost like 50¢ each at my local walgreens and they look great.
- Wowfunhappy 3y agoAre there any (color) laser printers that are small? That's my major problem with them, they're all huge and I don't have the space!
- freeopinion 3y agoIs https://www.brother-usa.com/products/hll3280cdw https://www.brother-usa.com/products/hll3280cdw too big? I wouldn't call it huge, but color lasers do require more physical space. Still, this seems to be in the range of most inkjets...
- bombcar 3y agoThese are really good (we buy them and give them away after conferences because it's cheaper than renting a printer from the hotel) - but be aware, they are not photo printers. Color laser printers shine when doing documents and office-style graphics with charts, etc, not photos.
- Wowfunhappy 3y agoI'd say that's too big, yes. You can get some much smaller inkjets, for example: https://www.bestbuy.com/site/canon-pixma-tr150-wireless-inkjet-printer-black/6407491.p?skuId=6407491 https://www.bestbuy.com/site/canon-pixma-tr150-wireless-inkj...
- wvenable 3y agoThere's a big upfront cost difference between inkjet and laser printers. I finally wised up many years ago and bought a Brother laser printer after wasting far too much money on inkjets. At the time it was a bigger cost but it's more than paid for itself now compared to an inkjet.
- jzb 3y agoI tell anybody who asks, if you need a printer, then 1) avoid inkjet printers and 2) I recommend Brother laser printers. I've owned 4 Brother printers since the 90s. The first one lasted more than a decade, and I put it through the wringer. The next one lasted about the same, including a stint as EIC of a magazine which meant I printed a ton of proofs on that poor thing. They all worked easily with Linux, to boot. I currently own two, one color and one multi-function B&W. They don't actually get a ton of usage but <knocks wood> they work when I need them to and I'm not constantly buying toner for the things. (I'm sure other folks have horror stories because somebody always does no matter what product, but they've served me well enough - and certainly Brother doesn't seem to be as customer hostile as HP.)
- jmisavage 3y agoNewer Brothers printers are starting to do the same tricks. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31860131 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31860131
- renewiltord 3y agoOh thanks for that. Looks like I should keep all revisions of firmware on oldest possible. I print through CUPS, so it should be quite safe to do since printer cannot require upgrade unless it's time-limited already.
- JohnFen 3y agoSo if Brother is out, which printer is still reasonable to buy? Are there any?
- pkaye 3y agoAnyone have thoughts on Canon laser printer? My Brother laser printer keeps on having lines and dots despite changing the toner and fuser. I've kind of given up on them. Canon seems much lower price for a similar feature set so I'm wondering what is the catch.
- 3y ago
- jdietrich 3y agoMeanwhile, Epson will sell you a printer that just takes ink. Not cartridges, just ink. From a bottle. They aren't particularly cheap, but that's the deal. https://epson.com/ecotank-ink-tank-printers https://epson.com/ecotank-ink-tank-printers
- Joeri 3y agoBe careful to print enough. I have one and it dried out due to lack of use. There’s a deep clean that unclogs it, but you can only do it a few times before the non-replaceable ink sponges fill up.
- troupe 3y agoThe ink is extremely cheap compared to what you pay for ink in a print cartridge on a traditional inkjet printer.
- lolc 3y agoFunny how HP also has a tank printer.
- FpUser 3y agoCongrats HP. You went long road from a premium proud company making insane range of high quality products down to printer extortionist. No need to worry about "investing" in me. I saw where it is all going and have switched to Brother long time ago.
- twobitshifter 3y agohow did hp dethrone dell’s position on business laptops?
- jedberg 3y agoI have an HP printer and a subscription. It's the best print setup I've had, because it works for my use case. We print a few pages a month, but sometimes we print a big stack. We had injects before, but they would gum up because we didn't use them enough. So we switched to laser. Those lasted forever, but they don't work for any heat transfer or other "special" print jobs that we do. Now we have the subscription. Once in a while new ink shows up, right before we run out. It's kind of magical. I realize this won't work for everyone, but I can see it working for most people who still need a printer.
- hedora 3y agoThey're charging you about $0.10 per page. That's an insane markup, especially if it doesn't include the paper. What happens when the heads dry out, the printer stops working, or they decide to drop windows device driver support? Do they mail you replacement hardware? I've had at least one of those things happen every year or two with 100% of the inkjets I've owned, regardless of brand, but especially with HPs.
- foobarian 3y agoOne great advantage of modern inkjet systems is that heads are included in the cartridges. I am cheap so I got an Epson Ecotank and the heads (which are build into the printer) are clogging months after purchase.
- hedora 3y agoSay I sign up for the $0.99 / month plan (max 10 pages per month), and use it to file my taxes once a year. That means I pay $12 per year, and the heads are clogged 100% of the time I try to use the printer. They could send me a cartridge every few months, but I don't think the postage will work out in their favor if they do that.
- jedberg 3y ago> They're charging you about $0.10 per page. That's an insane markup, especially if it doesn't include the paper. Most people get the more economical 6 cents per page plan. > What happens when the heads dry out, the printer stops working, or they decide to drop windows device driver support? The same thing that happens when you own the printer -- it stops working and you have to get it fixed or replaced. I'm not sure what your point is here. Inkjets break unless they get regular use. If you're going to use it regularly, the ink subscription isn't a bad way to go.
- rchaud 3y agoHP paid $11b for a fraudulent analytics company in 2011, wrote that down, then paid $100m to settle a shareholder lawsuit related to that acquisition. They know better than most what makes a bad investment.
- DueDilligence 3y ago[dead]
- Ahmedb 3y agoNever ever ever buy anything from HP. They will brick it with a software update. If you need a lightweight printer go with Epson. You can refill them.
- onyxringer 3y agoWhy is no competitor just buying all their printers and throwing them to trash?
- Havoc 3y ago>"I think for us it is important for us to protect our IP. There is a lot of IP that we've built in the inks of the printers, in the printers themselves. And what we are doing is when we identify cartridges that are violating our IP, we stop the printers from work[ing]." That's barely coherent... >"We have seen that you can embed viruses into cartridges, through the cartridge go to the printer, from the printer go to the network, so it can create many more problems for customers." Remind me whos idea was it to have any sort of electronics in cartridges? Ah yes the printer industry trying to coerce their victims eh clients into reduced choice and monopoly control of supplies. What a sleezy industry
- sys_64738 3y agoI'm proud to say I've never bought any HP product and never will. You can often pick up a laser printer for 75 bucks and use it until the toner runs out. Then chuck it and buy another, which is what I've done for years.
- bambax 3y ago> "We have seen that you can embed viruses into cartridges, through the cartridge go to the printer, from the printer go to the network, so it can create many more problems for customers." That's a bit rich. The reason cartridges have chips in the first place is so printer manufacturers can monitor their use and try and prevent customers from using off-brand ones.
- qwerty456127 3y agoDear HP CEO, please just sell me a rock-durable/repairable, PS/PCL-compatible, easily-refillable printer (I know you can, you used to make these when I was a kid) for whatever a price which satisfies you and leave me alone with it forever. I'm not an investment, I'm a deal, a good old "right here right now" kind. Or wait... actually I am also an investment because, if satisfied, I will convince almost every client and friend of mine to buy one or more printers of the same model (now I do so for Brother but there's room to compete in quality). Or maybe go the Lexmark way - sell dirt-cheap printers to up-sell expensive ink cartridges. This also is a fair deal some will be happy to choose because the printer itself is so cheap. As long as the carriage head is replaceable and won't clog to death when not used often enough. But in whatever a case - no cloud/app bullshit please, just plain drivers.
- imglorp 3y agoSomething changed in the last few years. Maybe someone has a word for this? One revenue stream is not enough now, for anyone. You can't sell a widget. It seems shareholders now demand you maximize: * original sale of hardware, sometimes loss leader * subscription for cloud service * subscription for supplies/refills * advertising to end user eyeballs, direct psyops * exfiltrate and sell end user data * require phone app which includes more surveillance, location, etc Some of the new toothbrushes are like this: hardware, cloud subscription, refill subscription, app, data: 5 points?
- qwerty456127 3y agoObviously. But I will avoid these at all cost. I mean it - all cost. I hope some investor's minds will click at this and offer me an expensive bullshit-free widget. Apparently I'm not alone wanting it. I have little idea of the market potential but I believe there is some. Apparently there are at least some investors and makers who believe the same. For example this is how they market Matic[1] (a cloud-free smart vacuum robot). Which I'm probably going to buy (unless I discover it's not bullshit-free enough) although it's expensive. I still have no robot vacuum just because every not-horribly-dumb model depends on a cloud (even though they don't have to - some are possible to uncloud but I have no time for this). The same applies to social networks etc - they try to reach every person in the world by offering free service at a cost of the user being made a product. Let me pay money but respect me as a customer, not a zombie. [1] https://maticrobots.com/ https://maticrobots.com/
- renewiltord 3y agoHow come printers don't have cheap Chinese device duplicates? The fundamental laser patents are from the 80s and 90s. Surely a reimplementation of these exist somewhere. I would gladly AliExpress one of these and just USB to print.
- bombcar 3y agoChina can't make them cheaper than HP and Brother dump them for, I suspect. They could probably make knockoff LaserJet IIIs, but nobody wants enough to fire up an entire line.
- hedora 3y agoI checked this too. Alibaba is too busy selling newer, but related, technologies (laser cutters, t-shirt printers, 3d printers, medical devices, etc, etc) at what look like reasonable margins. I'm sure the same factories could make zero-margin laser or inkjet printers, but why target a shrinking, obsolete market when you could use the same employee expertise to build things for growing, high margin markets? I'm guessing buggy whip and carriage bolt manufacturers charged crazy markups for 10-20 years after the Model T came out. I think we're witnessing something similar (especially for inkjets that target document sized printouts).
- bombcar 3y agoCorrect - most things on the 'baba are either 1. Parts 2. Various cheap items without brands 3. Obvious "overruns" of a branded factory smuggled out the back door 4. Additional runs of a factory that is no longer making whatever it was for the original manufacturer 5. Supplies You find some printer stuff in 1 and 5, and I saw a few that might be 3 or 4. Nobody in China is bringing up ancient equipment lines (and it would likely be way more expensive). At most, you might be able to find someone somewhere (if you have the right connections) that can get you a default firmware for some known printer that is OEM'd to everyone. I know these have been found for things like smart bulbs and other firmware'd devices.
- hedora 3y agoOut of curiosity, I looked at Alibaba to see if I could get a cheap non-terrible Chinese brand laser printer. They aren't cheap, and they mostly don't target paper, but the variety is astounding. They have laser cutters, t-shirt thingies, hair removers, UV 3D printers, etc, etc. How is HP still in business again? The rest of the market is at least 20 years ahead of HPs offerings, and apparently commanding healthy margins.
- neilv 3y agoIs the situation that selling good printers isn't a sustainable business (given price competition from loss-leaders and lower-quality devices)? Or is the situation that HP is trying to increase profits beyond that (and the way is to force subscriptions)? On subscriptions, are there two angles? I'm thinking maybe (1) consumer has to get consumables from HP rather than competitors, no DRM circumvention tricks, so HP gets the revenue and fixes the price; and (2) consumer is forced to provide regularly recurring revenue, has little flexibility, and overall paying more than they would purchasing refills on-demand.
- 8jef 3y agoThe world is ripe for an open source printer hardware project, maybe something we could 3d print, with some raspberry pi as a controller. Please, take my money and do that. At first, I'd be content with a manually fed dual axis flat tracer, or anything able to transpose a pdf to paper. Really, the printer companies cartel need some opposition here.
- RecycledEle 3y agoI wonder what that Management Class person thinks of me? I buy very old HP LaserJet printers surplus, and max the RAM, then feed them Genuine HP supplies I get in eBay for 5% to 10% of the retail price. Also, I tend to connect them with USB-to-parallel adapters because every old printer is exploitable.
- jauntywundrkind 3y agoThankfully there are some folks making nice good cost-effective printers too. Way higher tier item, but... Epson's EcoTank 8550 has gotten pretty glowing reviews. Very very low per-page count. Too early to tell about long term reliability, but looking ok so far! A randomly selected review: https://www.imaging-resource.com/news/2022/10/12/epson-ecotank-et-8550-printer-review https://www.imaging-resource.com/news/2022/10/12/epson-ecota... I'd been interested in getting something big & expensive like a Canon Pro-1000 but knowing the per page price was also going to be considerable, even more so if you aren't using it constantly (it periodically cleans itself)... It was hard to justify. I haven't bought the ET-8550 yet but the idea has stayed on my mind.
- grishka 3y agoAt this point I'm really curious why is there no open-hardware printer project. There seems to be a huge market for one. Or at least not an entire printer, but something where you would buy some popular printer model and replace its motherboard.
- gliiics 3y agoWith all due respect (which is zero) HP can go fuck themselves, right next to Ubisoft
- rony989 3y ago[dead]