5 ms·
U.S. moves to increase minimum legal size of commercial lobster
- Whatarethese 3y agoBetter get it done before this most recent Supreme Court case gets overruled and biased courts will set the laws when they aren't subject matter experts.
- themaninthedark 3y agoThe (US) courts rule on the legality of the laws with respect to the constitution and then rule if the prosecution/enforcement of the law is correct within the legal framework. The law is set by the legislators.
- roamerz 3y agoIf SCOTUS overturns the Chevron Doctrine it probably wouldn't matter much when this gets ruled on as it would likely be challenged after the fact. >>biased courts Yeah I totally am with you there. Courts should be about laws not any sort of bias. “A Government of Laws and Not of Men” -John Adams
- agensaequivocum 3y agoAh yes because unelected bureaucrats are unbiased.
- tonyedgecombe 3y agoI wonder whether lobsters will respond by evolving to be smaller adults.
- throwaway5752 3y agohttps://phys.org/news/2022-11-overfished-lobster-bigger-areas.html https://phys.org/news/2022-11-overfished-lobster-bigger-area...
- ijhuygft776 3y agoThey grow bigger because they get to live longer?
- ojbyrne 3y agoI don’t think these policies last long enough to show up on an evolutionary timescale.
- mista2nith 3y ago[dead]
- hansvm 3y agoI know the practice of de-clawing crabs led to small claws as a dominant characteristic till it was abandoned, and similarly the illegality of harvesting molting variants of hard-shelled crabs resulted in local populations of permanently quasi-soft-shell crabs. Admittedly that took decades rather than the few years we might see for a lobster size ban, but minor evolutionary tweaks when those phenotypes already exist in the wild don't take long to establish themselves under heavy fishing pressure.
- rcpt 3y agoLots of focus on the fishing industry I'm that article and not on the fact that sea life populations are collapsing.
- candiddevmike 3y agoMaybe an AI overlord can solve the tragedy of the commons
- nefarious_ends 3y agoI for one would welcome a benevolent AI dictator.
- arnaudsm 3y agoWe already have that in Europe, it's called "strong government regulation" and it's great at certain tasks
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoAmericans would rather have AI overlords than strong government regulations. /s(?)
- anthomtb 3y agoI think the US is doing the right thing here. Lobster populations are going down so regulations are being enacted to limit harvesting. Lobster isn't exactly a staple food anyways. I have it maybe twice a year in a sushi roll or sandwich, which is probably more often than your average North American.
- dubcanada 3y agoIt's not exactly a staple food for you, is what you mean. I know plenty of people in fishing communities that eat lobster at the same rate you may eat hamburgers or pasta. One of my close friends growing up had a lobster fisherman father, and they ate it once a day. That and deer/moose meat was the staple food. Edit: The goal of this comment was not to say that this is incorrect, I am for this change. My goal was just to say I feel there are places where it is staple. That's it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- voisin 3y agoOk, but this has to be a pretty small minority, right? What percentage (or absolute numbers) of people do you think eat lobster daily, or even weekly?
- dubcanada 3y agoI guess the real question is how many people matter. Is it 1 million that we care about? 50k? 10k? Lobster is a food item, just because it is now treated as a special food item on special occasions does not mean everyone does.
- beambot 3y agoIn the context of sustainable lobster populations, total consumption is the only metric that matters -- not distribution of consumption frequency.
- csdreamer7 3y agoFor those who want to eat sea food despite declining population numbers. Gordon Ramsay did a piece on how global warming was causing king crab to move north into former colder waters where they destroyed the ecosystem by reducing fish stocks and caused their numbers to balloon. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p6ff-ShY5Bw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p6ff-ShY5Bw
- dumbo-octopus 3y agoThe takeaway being we should eat more king crab? That's the kind of activism I can get behind!
- colordrops 3y agoNo, the takeaway is that we are abusing the ocean causing ecosystem collapse.
- dumbo-octopus 3y agoA takeaway needs to be actionable. That's kinda the whole point. If there are too many king crabs, we can action on that by making their removal economically favorable. I'd be curious to hear what the people downvoting my comments think the author was implying in their comment, which so far as I can tell is saying the exact same as mine just less bluntly.
- itishappy 3y agoA takeway just needs to be memorable. Actionable is nice, but not a requirement. "We can't do anything useful in this situation" can be a valid takeaway, as can "we do not know enough at this point." In this situation, my takeaway is that we do not know enough, and that's what I understood the parent's post to be saying. Removing the surplus crabs might help, it might set off another chain of poorly understood events.
- hammock 3y agoThe smaller lobsters are tastier (little known secret). I typically go for 1lb or 1 1/4 lb when everyone gets google-eyed at the 1 1/2 lb or bigger ones. But most lobster gets processed, and is not consumed whole. In that case I am all in favor of supporting the lobster fishery like this
- ojbyrne 3y agoIt’s a fairly well known secret in areas that produce lobsters (I lived in Nova Scotia for a long time).
- sneak 3y agoSame with shrimp, and perhaps tomatoes. It’s like flavor is constant regardless of volume, as size goes up, flavor density decreases.
- asquabventured 3y agoFor lobster at least, the sweetness of the meat decreases as a lobster gets bigger though it's more than just the same level of flavor compounds being spread across a smaller amount of total mass.
- asadotzler 3y agoThis is true of virtually all animals we eat. When I fished, the 1 lb bass was a keeper and the 4 lb bass was a throw-back.
- sandworm101 3y agoWhen I was in Massachusetts I went to a museum with an exhibit on the history of the fishing industry. At first they hunted whales near the surface, until there where no more whales in the Atlantic. There was actually a map diagraming how each year the whaling fleet needed to travel further and further south. Then it was cod. Then halibut. And now lobster. Overt two centuries, the industry systematically cleaned out species in order from sea surface to sea bottom.
- melagonster 3y agowe had finished blue tuna in Atlantic and Pacific Ocean, too
- rightbyte 3y agoIt feels so strange that lobster are cheap in the US. There is this place at the Alpine Rd. in Portala Valley with the name "Lobster shack" that sells fast food lobsters. I mean, it was nice, but felt like a waste on the lobsters ...
- explaininjs 3y agoFor much of history lobsters were considered "sea bugs" and reserved for the poorest of the poor to eat, much as one might treat a cockroach. The idea that they are valuable is a rather recent invention.
- traeregan 3y agoHere's some further reading on this and other interesting lobster lore, by the MIT Sea Grant Program: https://seagrant.mit.edu/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/Lobster_Lore_Print.pdf https://seagrant.mit.edu/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/Lobster_...
- pc86 3y agoWhere are these cheap lobster?
- opwieurposiu 3y agoLobsters in the gulf of Maine are fed A LOT of herring as bait. Like 70,000 tons a year. Hard to say what the overall result of this is. More lobsters? Less Herring? Some lobstermen joke that they feel more like ranchers then fishermen. https://www.wellsreserve.org/writable/files/Goldstein-Shields-2018_Ovigerous-lobsters-and-bait-diets.pdf https://www.wellsreserve.org/writable/files/Goldstein-Shield...
- TriangleEdge 3y agoI hear some farmers pump water into chickens to increase the weight so it sells for more. I also hear the same thing about bean moisture content since it's sold by weight (I think the Smarter Every Day has a video about granaries that shows this?). Will this put pressure for farmed lobsters to be full of growth hormones?
- dubcanada 3y agohttps://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2493311/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2493311/ Not sure if it's practiced a lot, but it's possible.
- hansvm 3y agoIf you happen to know, I've been curious about the water weight of various foods. In particular, I've bought dried or canned beans or tuna or other such things, and attempting to correct for the water weight I normalized on total labeled protein mass (or some other relevant macronutrient) rather than total mass. However, water content still varied dramatically for on-paper identical goods. Do you happen to know if that's a quirk of US food labeling laws (e.g., they can report a certain number of grams of protein per gram of food so long as water is within a 40% margin), or if there's some other factor at play that would allow macronutrients to actually be similar in qualitatively different products?
- traeregan 3y agoSuggested title update: include species context, which is the American or Maine Lobster (officially "Homarus americanus"). That species is quite different from the myriad species of spiny lobster that are common throughout much of the world (notably that the American Lobster has claws).
- nothercastle 3y agoWhy not maximum size? Larger lobsters produce significantly more eggs than small ones. A big one might be worth 2-5 times a small one and it’s a proven survivor