3 ms·
> Today, you pay very little tax on the empty land or parking lot because you’re taxed on that total value of the land and improvements. This discourages buildi
by toast0 3y ago
> Today, you pay very little tax on the empty land or parking lot because you’re taxed on that total value of the land and improvements. This discourages building stuff sometimes. With land value tax, you’d be taxed on what someone would pay you for that land with improvements similar to surrounding, so it’s advantageous to build something there instead of nothing, since you’re paying the same tax as the sky scraper next door.
If you're being taxed on hypothetical improvements and not just the value of the land, why is it called a Land Value Tax, rather than a Hypothetical Best Use Tax? People assume the name means what it says and get confused.
- ok_dad 3y agoI don’t know why they name stuff what they do, but it’s dumb to simply read the name of something and then make assumptions based on no further information about that thing. Maybe you should have read the Wikipedia about it before assuming stuff?
- toast0 3y agoWell, that doesn't really help, because Wikipedia says > A land value tax (LVT) is a levy on the value of land without regard to buildings, personal property and other improvements upon it. In my mind, the value of the land without regard to buildings, etc, is what you would pay for an empty lot. But you said the value is what you would pay for the lot with improvements. Theoretically, real estate property taxes I've paid have been divided into the land value and the improvements value (although it's mostly conjecture; the total value is all that matters and that generally approximates market value of the lot with the improvements, at least in CA and WA, where I've paid property taxes; although CA has Prop 13 that distorts assessments over time). Washington even states the land portion is assessed based on the best use, not the current use, unless it's in some special categories like farm, forestry, and open space. Now I'm even more confused. Which speaks to the GP's confusion. > I have yet to understand why people have made land value tax a thing. If the whole concept is so confusing, starting with the name, it's no wonder advocacy isn't effective.
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoNot everybody does a half-hour of research before every HN comment. Nor should they be expected to. LVT was named (I presume) by the advocates of it. If their name is misleading, don't blame the people reading it who are getting confused.
- ok_dad 3y agoA person can read about it in maybe ten minutes max, and if someone can’t even do half an hour of research, anyways, should they even comment? Do people have the right to a conversation simply because they read the article title yet have not read even at the surface level about that topic?
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoWell, how much research have you done on the quality of discussion board topics, and how much time people should spend on research before they comment in order to produce the optimum discussion? And yet here you are, commenting on it. ;-), but a serious point: You don't actually live that way. Nobody does.
- Dylan16807 3y agoYou're looking at it the wrong way. They're not looking at the hypothetical improvements and charging as if you built them. They're saying "this land could reasonably support a skyscraper, therefore it is very valuable land".
- nostrademons 3y agoOr the other way to look at it is "This land has lots of valuable community improvements like nearby restaurants, shops, parks, good schools, walkability. Therefore, the land itself is worth more. It is more economically efficient if more people get to benefit from the positive externalities of a good location, and so we should incentivize development in the locations that are most valuable." Most areas can support a skyscraper, but it doesn't really make sense to build one in the middle of nowhere. Conversely it doesn't make sense to keep prime real estate next to shops & public transit a surface parking lot. LVT incentivizes developing the parcels that are in good locations into high-density, high-value uses. A traditional improvement-based property tax reverses those incentives: if you develop your parking lot into a skyscraper, you pay much more in taxes, which may be unaffordable for smaller non-corporate owners, which gives them an incentive to hold onto them and keep them as marginal low-productivity uses.
- toast0 3y agoOn the other hand, I would say, "this land has very high taxes compared to its price; therefore it's not very valuable land." If you implement a land value tax, as I understand it, the parking lot and the skyscraper next to it should be taxed the same if they have the same footprint. All things being equal, that means a very large tax burden for the parking lot owner, and that certainly is an incentive to transfer it to someone who will do something with it, which is what you're advocating for. But at the same time, it makes the price you can get for the parking lot much lower. And I'm having a hard time not equating sales price and value. And once I've seen that under a LVT, the parking lot has no or little value, because it can't be sold for much money, it's more confusing --- if the value is low, and the tax rate is based on value, why are the taxes so high?
- Dylan16807 3y ago