6 ms·
IBM scraps rewards program for staff inventions, wipes away cash points
- kwanbix 3y agoI worked for IBM 15 years. It is so sad seeing what it is today.
- Woshiwuja 3y agocorrect me if im wrong but it looks like they just acquire new companies and their software but they either let it die or never continue improving on it. Just check IBM's products page. Its a mess. They literally have thousands of softwares some of which arent even being sold to customers
- twisteriffic 3y agoThey can make a lot more consulting dollars on marginal software than for something that was sanely designed and worked well.
- Woshiwuja 3y agoThats my experience with them and qradar. Its literally littered with bugs and instead of fixing them they just made a new version with literally 0 things shared with the old one, naming it qradar+ (nice naming btw, next time it call it qradar 2)
- skeeter2020 3y agoA friend's startup competes with Maximo, and IBM's "in-place version upgrade" has not yet been completed for a client with less than a year-long consultant engagement to fix changes that are both forwards AND backwards incompatible. Might as well be a new system.
- Woshiwuja 3y agoWe use maximo to track changes, its terrible.
- zeroclicks 3y agoWhat time frame did you work there? I enjoy reading about the Mercury missions and the work IBM did in that era. There must have been a lot of smart people there then. There's also a (recent?) book about IBM's work with the Nazis during WWII that has gotten some press lately. Has anyone read it?
- astura 3y agoWhen? Recently or back in it's heyday? My cousin worked there from like 1999-2016 or so as an accountant. I've never seen someone so overworked.
- anthomtb 3y agoMy FIL worked for IBM for 15 years (1980-1995, IIRC). He says that when he was hired he wondered why on earth a company like IBM would need a Civil Engineer. And wondered the same thing every day up until being laid off. I think its been a long, long time since IBM was a shining star of American business.
- Workaccount2 3y agoIf I am understanding this correctly; you could file 3 "high value" patents, which would result in 12 points awarded, which you could convert to a...$1,200 payout? I guess it is better than nothing, but $1,200 is like is like gold sticker level for people in those tiers (at least I hope so).
- hashtag-til 3y ago$1,200 is really lower than any company that want to incentive patents would pay.
- readyplayernull 3y agoBug bounty programs are the next iteration for these companies to avoid hard and expensive research.
- richbell 3y agoIBM conveniently does not seem to offer bug bounties. Granted, it's possible that they have a private program. https://hackerone.com/ibm https://hackerone.com/ibm
- jjoonathan 3y agoMaybe the program is dominated by a few people who got really, uhh, efficient at cranking out patents and the new prices reflect the hourly rate of keeping the hustle going rather than attracting new prospective inventors with fresh ideas.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- blacksmith_tb 3y agoSeems like the fix for that problem is a cap for annual payouts instead of torpedoing the whole program? Though I would think for a lot of people who might be able to contribute to only one or two per year (and still do their dayjob) the $1200 would be pretty underwhelming.
- bediger4000 3y agoCorporations famously are unable to take advantage of potential internal innovations. Sun Microsystems couldn't do dedicated network storage, leading to Auspex. Auspex couldn't do cheapo storage, leading to NetApp. And then there's the Fairchildren.
- fnordpiglet 3y agoThe typical business reason to do this is to erect patent walls around areas of innovation or investment happening parallel to the patents to prevent others from either competing directly or suing to enforce their own parents through a mutually assured destruction argument. Rarely is it a patent is the genesis of invention at these companies but as a result of other activity.
- CoastalCoder 3y ago> And then there's the Fairchildren. Is that referring to companies that originated from Fairchild in some way?
- bequanna 3y ago> And for each plateau achieved, IBM would pay its inventors $1,200 in recognition of their efforts. After taxes, this is a pretty small amount. With paltry rewards like that, I wonder if employees even cared much about this program.
- robertlagrant 3y agoI wonder if they set up agreements whereby people would add each other to patents, like a webring. So you only had to really do 1 in 5 of your named patents and you'd all get $10k+.
- madcaptenor 3y agoMy employer pays a patent bonus (I forget the exact number). They'll pay $X per inventor for up to three inventors but only $3X/n for n inventors if n > 3.
- oldpersonintx 3y agoI filed some patents under this system and made $10k removing this system basically just reduces the number of garbage patents issued, which is a net gain for society even if some employees miss out on some money
- pm90 3y agoGood. We will see a lot less dumb patent filings from them. Getting patents was a requirement for career advancement when I worked there, so a lot of people end up “collaborating” on patents that they didn’t really contribute much to.
- astura 3y agoThey seem like they are just replacing the program with another similar program with an incompatible payout scheme and this is just an excuse to not pay people. >IBM canceled the program at the end of 2023 and replaced it with a new one that uses a different, incompatible point system called BluePoints. >"The previous Invention Achievement Award Plan will be sunset at midnight (eastern time) on December 31st, 2023," company FAQs explain. "Since Plateau awards are one of the items being sunset, plateau levels must be obtained on or before December 31, 2023 to be eligible for the award. Any existing plateau points that have not been applied will not be converted to BluePoints."
- duxup 3y agoI don't think they file patents because of their incentive program.
- indymike 3y agoTaking away already earned compensation is wrong. And probably illegal. Even if it is just points that convert into cash.
- _ea1k 3y agoPossibly an indication that the value of patents has declined? It'd be a good thing if that is the case.
- AlbertCory 3y agoI had a lot of experience with patent rewards programs like this; both starting one (Packeteer) and helping administer one (Google). People who are named as inventors sometimes actually contributed to it. The legal definition is "they conceived of at least one element in one claim." In practice, the claims change as the prosecution proceeds, usually removing things rather than adding, and the inventor list should shrink. It rarely does. That's if the company is following the rules. Often the manager just puts himself or herself on as an "inventor." As for the monetary value: occasionally a patent is worth a lot to the company, and often it's zero. Google acquired a number of IBM patents, so in that case you could put an exact value on it!
- CharlesW 3y agoI was so proud of my first patent, and also heartbroken that several other non-contributors were somehow listed as inventors.
- AlbertCory 3y agoIf you really wanted to be career-limiting, you could notify the PTO that the other "inventors" didn't really qualify. I've never heard of anyone doing this, so it would be maximum fun to watch what happens.
- sys_64738 3y agoWhy would the patent office believe you?
- AlbertCory 3y agoWe're dealing in hypotheticals here, so that's why I said it would be career-limiting fun. I can only speculate on what would happen.
- temporallobe 3y agoThey would be required to investigate that during prosecution.
- pcurve 3y agoThey're not getting rid of the program. It's just being replaced by another program, but for some reason they are not transferring the points. Very dumb and easily fixable.
- astura 3y ago>for some reason It's for cost cutting.
- skeeter2020 3y agoOh really? and just WHAT is the conversion rate between a PatentPoint and a BluePoint? </s>
- CoastalCoder 3y agoI hope in the next few years, someone can be bothered to see if/how this event correlates with IBM's yearly patent-filing numbers.
- StreetChief 3y agoDo you think they planned the changes in the award program, company financing, marketing, and policy, but missed transferring points, just happening to change a $x liability into a $0 dollar liability by accident?
- jacquesm 3y agoOne sided clawback of deferred compensation? I certainly hope someone sues them.
- astura 3y agoI don't, because it would be a massive waste of time. Labor laws vary by jurisdiction, but it's extremely unlikely that "points" like this that have to be accumulated before being cashed out is considered "deferred compensation" in the vast majority of locations IBM operates out of. Employers have an unbelievable amount of latitude in the administration of these sorts of fringe benefits.
- ska 3y ago> "deferred compensation" Usually such programs are structured intentionally to avoid such designation.
- buildsjets 3y agoI do have to say, I have seen some really trash patents approved that were only submitted because the company in question had a patent bounty system. I have a colleague who has racked up about 50 so far and none of them have been used in a product. https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/20782/boeings-been-granted-a-patent-for-turning-the-b-1b-into-a-gunship-bristling-with-cannons https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/20782/boeings-been-gra... pew pew pew
- baq 3y agoThe point isn’t to use the patents in products, the point is to give lawyers ammo to countersue when an infringement suit arrives.
- AlbertCory 3y agoThat very rarely happens, despite what the lawyers tell you. You don't countersue a troll, because they have no assets. You might countersue a rival, except they probably won't sue you. Mutually Assured Destruction is the more common defense among competitors.
- baq 3y agoSo it works as intended! (at least by lawyers)
- AlbertCory 3y agoYou said "give lawyers ammo to countersue" so no. Most infringement suits are from trolls. A countersuit against a rival would need at least some basis in reality, so they'd have to be selling something that infringed your patent (unlikely).
- baq 3y agoYou’re just making my point but somehow disagreeing with me. The are no suits because MAD works. MAD only works if both sides have enough ammo to glass the other. So you need all the patents you can get to have a reasonable chance of finding a few your opponent infringes upon.
- clusterhacks 3y agoWhen I was at IBM, the whole patent/publication process was intensely gamed. Most employees in my division weren't particularly interested but made efforts to patent/publish because it was part of moving up salary bands. A few true sociopaths went totally scorched earth with it - digging up years-old reports generated by other teams, getting them published after minimal "updates", and claiming lots of bonus dollars along the way. It was a very weird experience working at IBM for me . . .
- x86x87 3y agoI mean, it is IBM. From my experience working there you either have really young people that are just at the beginning of their careers or lifers who know and exploit the system inside out
- jitl 3y agoAt Notion Labs Inc, a patent is worth one Cuisinart® Precision Master 5.5 Quart Stand Mixer. I got a patent and the stand mixer to show for it.
- mmastrac 3y agoAt SMART Technologies (the whiteboard company), I got an iPod nano and a glass cube.
- iaw 3y agoThe glass cube sounds like it could be cool.
- toast0 3y agoI swear there's a patent incentive company that's selling into these programs. everybody was doing patent cubes for a while. I've got a patent light (from Facebook), which I'm guessing must have been a thing too. About the only thing my patent was useful for was when a PM came around asking about a new vendor with a creative way of doing something, I could defer with "I have a patent on that, it didn't really work when we tried it"
- Woshiwuja 3y agoi love how accurately you told us the model of the stand mixer
- hipadev23 3y agoThat’s nice but it’s no waffle party awarded to refiner of the quarter.
- notatoad 3y agothey couldn't even spring for the kitchenaid?
- jitl 3y agoI know right? Well, it’s nicer than the other options I could choose from - a “smart” speaker or a duffel bag.
- skeeter2020 3y agoWhen does IBM launch their commercial airline, to accompany the revamped, silly-named points program that invalidates all previously accrued points?
- htrp 3y agoAs far as I can tell, the frequent flier program is the one thing that almost never gets touched even in bankruptcy.
- sys_64738 3y agoYour first patent is like "Ohhhhh!" but subsequent ones are like "meh!" If you take away the financial incentive to do patents then I won't even try filing them. If you don't pay me enough to file one then I won't bother. Filing patents is a hassle and dealing with the lawyers and crawling through legalese is a pain in the bum. Once you have a couple then it's all about the $$$ IMO. iBM must be cutting their throat to save a few bucks. They used to be a massive patent harvesting machine.
- naikrovek 3y ago“We simply have no problem continually cutting employee reward programs, as they allow us to return value to the shareholder, which is our #1 priority.”
- throwawayq3423 3y agoMore and more I see corporate work as a fall back until you stand up your own business. Why would you stay somewhere that takes from the margins of your labor forever ?
- naikrovek 3y agoBecause starting your own business is usually even more of a soul-crushing activity, with even less pay, for many years, if not forever. Not everyone can start a business and guide it to success. And if they can, it can easily become the corporate work you were attempting to avoid.
- throwawayq3423 3y ago> Because starting your own business is usually even more of a soul-crushing activity, with even less pay, for many years, if not forever. According to the hustle porn version of startups, sure. But if you find a niche market, build a simple product, spread out the work with people you trust, and deliver consistently to your customers, you can own a large chunk of more revenue than you'll ever see renting your time out by the hour. We all know "it doesn't have to be crazy at work", but starting a business doesn't have to be crazy either.
- acuozzo 3y ago> But if you find a niche market Therein lies the rub. If the market you find is too niche¹, then any product you produce for it will likely be unprofitable, so defining exactly what niche means in this context requires bounds. So now it's a game of shopping around for the right niche market. If you're lucky, then you'll find one which aligns with what intrinsically motivates you. If not, then it'll be a grind to become enough of a SME in that niche market segment to produce a product which meets the needs of its participants. I therefore argue that step 1 is to be a normal enough person to have some niche interests, but ones which are not so niche that you only share this interest with— at most —a few thousand other people. [1] The owner of The Laserdisc Database, lddb.com, doesn't make enough solely from this venture to support himself.
- josh_fyi 3y agoWhen I was at IBM around 2010, they offered $250 for filing patent, then $750 when the patent office approved it, usually after 3-8 years -- if you were still at IBM. Then after a few years, they swapped those numbers around, so that if you'd been waiting for your $750 bonus, you'd get $250.
- jjice 3y agoI heard from on Oxide and Friends that Sun had a pretty strong patent incentive program back in the day. I wish I could remember it off the top of my head but I believe Bryan Cantrill mentioned he still had furniture in his home that was paid for by some patents :)
- bcantrill 3y agoHa, this is true! (I know we talked about it recently, but I can't find it either.) I would say that the program at Sun definitely incentivized filing patents, but it was always perverse: when it paid out for invention disclosures, people did a bunch of bad invention disclosures; when it became much more heavily backloaded to reward granted patents, it rewarded people so long after the fact as to be meaningless. (But it did allow us to buy some good Amish furniture that I do indeed still have!) It's clear from the article that IBM went on a similar journey, settling on this goofy innovation frequent flyer system?! All of that said, scrapping the program is probably the right decision: especially with patent law tracking the way it has (namely, making it harder for patent trolls), there has been less of an imperative around patents -- and paying out for patent-related work conflates all innovation with patentability, which is a mistake in my opinion. I have not (and would not) establish an incentive program around patents: it's great to reward innovation, but cash bonuses for patents isn't it -- however well-crafted the resulting furniture may be. ;)
- jll29 3y agoI worked at a large U.S. information company that gave $500 per author for filing a patent application. Once a year, you could submit your patent application for the "Inventor of the Year" award. Given the 60k employees worldwide, it carried some weight, was awarded by the global CTO of the corporation, and the cash prize was $10k. Yet the true main benefit is the line item in your resume, I suppose. I don't know if giving $500 pre-tax is a good idea, because it is so little after taxes. On the other hand, the annual $10k amount is more appropriate unless shrunk by sharing with co-inventors. In contrast, German law has a clause that inventors must be given a share of the profit generated by patents. You cannot sign to opt out of this clause, and the profit must be proportional to your invention's part of the product or service generating said profit. This is interesting in that only value-generating, granted patents are rewarded, not applications. But it's hard to find a fair reward formula for detemining how much a particular patent contributes to a product's profit or revenue stream (if it's not Amazon's "1-Click" button...).
- m463 3y agoI'm reminded of the maxim "Tax what you want less of" what's interesting is that one of IBM's greatest assets has been its patent portfolio, but ... Why would an employee spend the extra time away from core duties (in this layoff environment) to do this? IBM should really want this - it is giving up the long term view for short term .. something?