10 ms·
Samsung extends Android and security updates to 7 years
- Derbasti 3y agoThis is the new EU law, so every handset sold in the EU will be required to do this. This is just Samsung following the law.
- rekoil 3y agoOh shit I must have missed that one, which one is that? The EU are fucking killing it these days actually. So happy to see it. We had a scare there with Chat Control 2.0 but thankfully it was shot down, besides that we've gotten GDPR, USB-C charging ports, the Digital Markets Act, eIDAS is coming which looks like it could be pretty great, digital drivers licenses, etc. A lot of good stuff. What did I miss?
- wkat4242 3y agoI agree they are going good things with GDPR and DMA/DSA. But the fact that they even proposed ChatControl and it really had to be fought to be defeated, doesn't instill a lot of confidence in continued progress and vision towards privacy. It feels like the winds could turn just like that.
- phpisthebest 3y agoIt is very said that people are celebrating digital drivers licenses of all things, how far we have fallen in the battle for privacy and freedom from government intrusion in our lives that we are now celebrating massive authoritarian policies and control as "wins" because they have made our lives more convenient... The devils deal of convenience over freedom...
- krab 3y agoWhat's the difference from the previous state? You had to carry a driving license but the government had all the info anyway. If you didn't have the license on you, they'd find you in the DB anyway. Possibly you get a €10 fine. The electronic driving license is just a simplification to me. You don't have to carry anything.
- rekoil 3y agoMany people hear digitised and they think big brother is watching, I honestly don't know where they get it from because as you say the data we're talking about is already data the government keeps by necessity, that it's now in your phone doesn't automatically make it nefarious. That said, there are things in the category of surveillance that having it in an app do enable. For this reason I would personally like to require that the implementation of these apps is open source, unfortunately I know there was some resistance on that front with regards to eIDAS...
- krab 3y agoWhile removing the driving license carriage requirement is a strict removal of a hassle, I understand where people don't trust the electronic ID card. Unlike the driving license, you still need to carry it, either in plastic or as an app in your phone. And it's becoming a bit complicated. It's not a self-contained QR code with an electronic signature. It's a whole system that allows you to share only part of the info to someone (e.g. only age in the pub). It also remembers who asked for that info. Experience from CZ and very fresh. The electronic ID app for instance is still only a few days old.
- rekoil 3y ago> I understand where people don't trust the electronic ID card. Me too, the reason I trust it is that I understand the (really cool) cryptography behind it, and most don't.
- dotnet00 3y agoThe records were already digitized given the police's ability to look up the license for you if you provided name and date of birth. So digital licenses are just taking away the physical abstraction. There's a concern over what happens if the systems or networks go down, but presumably physical ID isn't completely outlawed yet.
- rekoil 3y agoFrom what I've heard about things like eIDAS there is considerable technical competence behind the specifications for these laws, I would expect there to be mechanisms for cryptographically secure offline validation.
- krab 3y agoAs I understand it the validation happens online to avoid tracking. Nowadays banks and telcos share a lot of information on their clients. So instead of giving out the unchanging personal ID number (containing the date of birth), you're supposed to give out the number of your ID card that changes every five or ten years. Or, in the online world, the bank gets a unique token. I don't think it will fulfill that purpose in practice. The name plus date of birth is a very good tracking identifier and people will be still giving DOB to these companies.
- rekoil 3y agoThere are even cooler ways of doing this, look up eIDAS and/or Zero-Knowledge Proofs. Basically, with the right cryptography, my app can prove my license is valid without revealing any PII. Or in the case of eIDAS, binary questions like "is rekoil 18 years or older?".
- geor9e 3y agoIn September 2022, the Samsung S10 went over 150 days without a security patch being available. That caused my work to kick my phone off it's network. Samsung promised quarterly updates before that. So I have been burned by their broken promises. Hopefully they keep them this time.
- lopis 3y agoYour work network can tell which phones got security patches? And that's a requirement for being in the network?
- namibj 3y agoReplace phone (instance) with phone (model), and it quickly makes sense.
- rekoil 3y agoTo be fair there are endpoint protection solutions that provide phone (instance) information that can be used to decide if the particular device is secure enough to be allowed on the network.
- vel0city 3y agoThere are a number of MDMs out there that will report patch level of mobile devices. If I was buying an MDM for an enterprise, I wouldn't buy one that lacked this. Ensuring devices are up to date is a pretty critical part of a good security posture.
- yukIttEft 3y agoI mean, do they even have to do more than run "make image" after rebasing to a new (minor) kernel update ?
- kramerger 3y agoEven if its just a one-liner, they need to redo all testing and possible certification including those mandated by local carriers.
- kramerger 3y agoThis is good news (and honestly not a huge surprise given the current trajectory) But what is with all the negative comments here? People are complaining about completely irrelevant things just so don't have to say anything positive about Samsung?
- jauntywundrkind 3y agoIt's great to see vendors doing the right thing. Still, my main ask is upstreamed support. Users should be able to maintain their own devices if they want to. From the start of ownership to beyond the products end of life. That means I should be able to build my own kernel and send them to the device, and I shouldn't need some vendor fork that will someday rot out to do it.
- wmf 3y agoQualcomm is doing a lot of work on upstreaming for the latest Snapdragon which should be used in the S24.
- wkat4242 3y agoOnly if you're in the Us, China or Korea unfortunately. The S23 had Snapdragon everywhere. The S24 only in those three markets sadly.
- TillE 3y agoGoogle could have built a system like that from the start, where Google-certified Android means you have a vanilla base image, plus (openly available) drivers, plus whatever crap the manufacturer wants to layer on top. Basically not unlike Windows. Unfortunately they didn't do that, so it's still a mess.
- dns_snek 3y agoNot only is Google not making it more open, since 2020 they've been actively working to close the ecosystem down with hardware-backed SafetyNet attestations. https://groups.google.com/g/safetynet-api-clients/c/lpDXBNeV7Fg/m/Ov2H6ZvhBQAJ https://groups.google.com/g/safetynet-api-clients/c/lpDXBNeV... You may be able to build your own OS, but as soon as you unlock that bootloader to install it, all of your banking apps will stop working and there will be no workarounds once hw-backed attestation is mandated.
- I_Am_Nous 3y agoThis is excellent news, especially since processors have been powerful enough for a while that we can easily expect most phones should be usable for much longer.
- jwells89 3y agoA good first step. The next one I’d like to see is a one-tap toggle that disables the bulk of Samsung OS customizations and “me too” apps/ecosystem cruft, as some other vendors have. Yes it can be removed manually, but with one of Android’s chief selling points being the choice it affords users, I shouldn’t need to do that, particularly on expensive flagship devices.
- diffeomorphism 3y agoNo, the whole point of the "me too" apps is that Google forbids choice. The device has to have the Google apps pre installed and the only way vendors can attack this monopoly is by putting their apps in addition ("instead" is forbidden). Sure, the vendor apps often suck, but that is no reason to support monopolies.
- kosmozaut 3y agoNot exactly what you asked for, but there is https://github.com/0x192/universal-android-debloater https://github.com/0x192/universal-android-debloater
- amadeuspagel 3y ago> A good first step. The next one I’d like to see is a one-tap toggle that disables the bulk of Samsung OS customizations and “me too” apps/ecosystem cruft, as some other vendors have. What other vendors have that? The fundamental problem in the android world is that OEMs have no market power, and that makes it impossible for them to do longterm investments like research and security updates. What you see here is that using these "me too" apps, Samsung managed to acquire some market power, and so is able to do some of these longterm investments now.
- rchaud 3y agoSeems like you just want a Pixel phone with all-Google apps. Samsung's built in apps are not "cruft" by any means. The Notes app has pen support for sketching and PDF import/annotate, which lets me use a printable calendar digitally. The Browser app has dark mode and adblock; good luck with that on Google Chrome. The Music app doesn't try to upsell me to a YouTube Music plan. I also use Bixby routines to quickly set custom timers for exercise, cooking etc.
- CrypticShift 3y agoIt seems this is only for the new S24 series. I hope this gradually extends to lower ranges. Personally, I find a 2023 phone at 1/8th of the price [1] to be sufficient for my use (spec-wise) Now a removable battery and Less "freezing" [2] please. [1] https://www.gsmarena.com/compare.php3?idPhone1=12583&idPhone2=12773#diff- https://www.gsmarena.com/compare.php3?idPhone1=12583&idPhone... [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38995719 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38995719
- NathanCollins 3y agoGreat point! I have a "cheap" Samsung M32 that I bought for about $170. One reason I chose this Samsung phone over a similarly priced phone from a competitor was that I wrongly believed that Samsung provided several years more OS and security updates. After buying the phone I realized that longer support only applied to flagship models :/
- kramerger 3y agoSo the SAMsung tiers are like this: S: flagship A: mid range M: mostly garbage I can absolutely use an A as my daily driver, but M I will not touch. And you paid way too much for an M series phone, I would say they are worth $80-100. Based on that, I can see why they can't give you 7 years of support. Besides, most M series use some unknown Chinese CPU that will never receive any kernel updates after release.
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoDevil's advocate question: How did you expect Samsung could fund SW dev costs to support 7 years of updates on the margins of a $170 phone while still turning a profit? Not sure how much you were expecting at $170 but you might have been penny wise and pound foolish here trying to scrape the bottom of the barrel as nobody else gives you more than 2 years of updates at those rock bottom prices. Sometimes it pays to spend a bit more and get something worthwile. Samsung's other budget phones from last year in the ~300 Euro range, like the A54 have 5 years of guaranteed support. Maybe the mid rangers of 2024 will also get 7 years of updates which would be killer value.
- axiomdata316 3y agoNow for a phone that has a battery that will last that long. That would really be news. I find that I don't replace a phone because it can't function or is no longer secure. I replace it because it can't hold a charge long enough for regular daily use.
- wmf 3y agoFor a flagship phone it's definitely cheaper to replace the battery.
- andrewia 3y agoThat's an inherent limitation of modern lithium batteries with a smartphone's constraints of density, size, packaging, charge current, and a bunch of other requirements. Replacing a battery every 18-24 months costs ~$75 (or 1 hour and $35 if you're comfortable with DIY), which is a reasonable maintenance cost considering smartphones cost $300-$1300. Many car owners don't sell/scrap their car until repairs exceed the value of the car, we should apply the same philosophy to smartphones.
- gtirloni 3y agoI've replaced the batteries on several phones (at authorized places) and, while I like the idea, they all started displaying weird behavior. I guess they are glued so hard that the heating needed to open them up must cause some tiny damage. Just a guess.
- andrewia 3y agoI haven't had any issues with a Samsung S7, Samsung S9 (although I broke HDMI output), and Sony Xperia 5 Mark II (very pleasant to repair). iPhones have been much more troublesome for me, as I have destroyed three during repair attempts. All the issues were from damage to ribbon cables, as they are fragile and easily damaged from being bent. So I'd advise avoiding devices with tight tolerances like iPhones, and minimizing interaction with ribbon cables.
- user_7832 3y ago
- ortusdux 3y agosee also https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39032041 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39032041
- stjohnswarts 3y agothis could definitely open me back up to android. I got tired of my device becoming hacker friendly and went over to iphone after my perfectly useful android device was outside of feature/security updates. I didn't want to install another OS android or root my device, I just want to use it and stick it back in my pocket. I will definitely look at samsung again with my next mobile "era" when my iphone dies/is too slow.
- seanwilson 3y agoWhat budget phones right now have a decent number of years for security updates and run stock Android? I tried to get this info a couple of years ago and it took some serious digging to find when each phone was released and how long updates are meant to last as there's no central place to find this. Maybe there's a good resource for this now? Nokia phones are meant to be nearly stock Android I think with 3 years of updates but longer would be nice.
- Moldoteck 3y agofairphone? The last one will have 8y + it's repairable. In terms of performance/camera quality it's far from apple/top snapdragon but still
- elabajaba 3y agoFor anyone looking at budget android phones, probably the most important thing is to look at the CPU on gsmarena (or elsewhere) and make sure it has at least 2 a7N cores (the higher the N, the better, eg. a72<a78<a720), because android OEMs are still selling phones with 8 a53 (or a55) cores which are unusably slow (8x a53 cpus were terrible a decade ago, and they're even worse now). For qualcomm cpus you might have to check the wikipedia article [1] to figure out what the kryo cores actually correspond to. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kryo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kryo
- esalman 3y agoI have a hard time figuring this out too. I have resorted to looking at benchmark scores for comparing mobile CPUs.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 01nate 3y agoI know this isn't exactly the answer to your question, but it's sorta adjacent and might be useful. Pixel devices can run a number of Roms that go much longer than Google's support period (DivestOS, PostMarketOS, Lineage, etc). Older models can probably be found on sale from Google for ~$200 occasionally or even cheaper used, and with Lineage offer a really long support period on an OS that resembles AOSP with or without G Services.
- jvanderbot 3y agoHow much of this is good faith, how much public backlash, and how much just not pushing out revolutionary new hardware every year due to the long awaited death of Moore's law.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 38 3y agowhat we really need is a way to disable forced updates. how people are not more upset by that is beyond me. every time I say that people scream "BUT MUH SECURITY", as if thats the only thing that matters and nothing else should even be considered. I am an adult. if I want to disable updates, I should be able to do so. give me multiple, loud warnings before doing so, fine, but dont stop people outright. otherwise its no longer an operating system, but a toy for babies.
- hacketthfk 3y agoYou're an adult. Stop buying toys for babies. Even better, start a company creating real phones for adults. That's what adults do when they face a problem - they solve it and maybe even make money.
- 38 3y agogreat idea. every single time I have an annoyance in life, I will just start a company to fix it. that is certainly scalable!
- hurrdurr57 3y agoYou could always root your phone and install an open source OS.
- aceazzameen 3y ago7 years of updates for what? The S24 models and up? Or all phones up to 7 years ago? It doesn't specify, and the cynic in me makes me think it's only on 2024 models as a selling point.
- DistractionRect 3y agoIt's likely going to be recent devices. Older devices Android was tightly coupled to kernel version, didn't have a good hardware abstraction layer for drivers, etc. Basically android has been working on restructing itself under the hood over the years to be more maintainable. Further, older devices will be on LTS kernels which will already be outside their support window, so there's a ton work to be done updating the device tree to upgrade to a newer LTS kernel. Short windows made sense simply because it was a lot of work to maintain old devices. Now that there's a more solid separation of concerns, longer support windows make sense.
- captn3m0 3y agoI maintain https://endoflife.date/samsung-mobile https://endoflife.date/samsung-mobile and this is extremely frustrating. Google was clear when they bumped the support that it only applied to Pixel 8 and above. Why can't Samsung clearly publish a press release.
- neilv 3y agoGoogle Pixel end-of-support info: https://support.google.com/pixelphone/answer/4457705?hl=en https://support.google.com/pixelphone/answer/4457705?hl=en GrapheneOS end-of-support info (for Google Pixels): https://grapheneos.org/faq#device-support https://grapheneos.org/faq#device-support
- kramerger 3y agoMan, that page is gold. Thanks for creating it
- kjellsbells 3y agoWhere can one go to verify these claims straight from the source? the Internet is full of "mobile news" sites that claim Samsung are doing this or Google are doing that, but they are impossible to verify. I would hope that Samsung would at least put out a press release, or there'd be a link to some release note, or _something_, but nothing. Where do other HN readers go to verify these types of stories?
- wmf 3y agoFirst result for Galaxy S24 press release: https://news.samsung.com/global/enter-the-new-era-of-mobile-ai-with-samsung-galaxy-s24-series https://news.samsung.com/global/enter-the-new-era-of-mobile-... "The latest flagship continues Samsung’s commitment to extending the product lifecycle, offering seven generations of OS upgrades and seven years of security updates..."
- kjellsbells 3y agoAh, but that sentence is footnoted, and the footnote simply says, "Availability and timing of Android OS upgrades and security updates may vary by device model and market." Which doesnt tell me, for example, whether a reader with an arbitrary Samsung phone is in- or outside the tent. And is therefore something of a nothingburger.
- Endurancee 3y agoSeems like these only applies to S24 series, will be nice if they do these for S23 series also or at least flagships. Although I'm thinking as the next gen leaps are getting diminished year by year and smartphone like Pixel 8 are already more pricy than it should have been, companies can just jack their prices with even less innovation saying 7 years security updates but how long does an average user keeps phone anyway and will batteries are going to last that long.
- geodel 3y agoPhone hardware most likely would've turned to crap in 3-4 years. But if one does keep it up and running despite all odds for 7 years they can keep it secure. I guess its great.
- gorbypark 3y agoI'm still using an iPhone 11 Pro that I bought used, it's now almost 5 years old and still very, very usable. I did have the battery replaced about a year ago, but unless I break it/loose it, but I can see myself using it until Apple stops making OS updates for it. Even then, they seem decent at pushing out security fixes for old phones (I believe the 6s got a patch recently even though it's 2 versions behind the latest version).
- 01nate 3y agoNow if they only allowed you to unlock the bootloader. Samsung makes great hardware* but it's disappointing see locked down and bloated devices that only gets security updates for a few years IF you pay full price when they come out. Long support periods are great, with that fixed it probably brings Samsung phones to Apple levels of quality, but I've enjoyed using my phone like a real computer instead of a locked down smart device that's disposable after a few (or 5-7) years. Maybe I'm not the target audience of these manufacturers, but man has having a phone that let's me use it like a tiny ARM desktop (pixel) been really nice. * At least they did, no experience with recent hardware. Last time I bought a Samsung device was a tablet in 2016. It's still a great device, but I don't use it a lot given it ran out of support ages ago despite still being a great priece of hardware.
- realusername 3y agoSamsung devices aren't locked? You are just going to lose Knox in the process but it's not like it has much value, I don't use it even when I can.
- 01nate 3y agoOh, cool, for some reason I thought they didn't let you unlock the bootloader. Did they stop you from doing it for a while and then re-enable it at some point or am I just misremembering? Either way, always good to be wrong about something when I'm complaining about the state of tech.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- valeg 3y agoThis is a very positive trend. I'm glad we are moving away from "2,5 years of updates" e-waste. I might even pick Samsung as my next smartphone (curious about DeX).
- donor20 3y agoThe proof will be in the pudding. The headline does not restrict this to specific models. I’ll be impressed if they actually update old models. If it’s another go forward promise - I’ll be a bit skeptical until they actually deliver for a bit. Apple historically (with no big announcements I’m aware of) has an actual history of pushing updates - iPhone 6s from like 9 years ago still getting updates