4 ms·
What does "money growing all by itself" mean?
by ethbr1 3y ago
What does "money growing all by itself" mean?
- amelius 3y agoThat you did not perform significant work for it, and did not take a significant risk.
- ethbr1 3y agoSo significant work and/or significant risk are required to justify returns. What if these things are offloaded to a secondary party, in exchange for a portion of the returns?
- rangerelf 3y agoThen the secondary party would have lower tax level.
- brigadier132 3y agoSomeone did perform work for it. Those shares were sold by the original creator and employees of the company in order to raise money for the company or to fund their own living expenses. The person that purchased those shares only did so with the expectation that they could later sell them for a higher price. By taxing those earnings you reduce the demand for the shares which then reduces the amount of money the original workers can raise by selling shares. The secondary market provides incentive to invest in companies. Why is it that people of certain political persuasions always seem incapable of thinking through second and third order effects?
- wewtyflakes 3y agoHow about thinking of the first order effects? Do you think taxes are fair as they are now? How is that working out for us?
- brigadier132 3y agoTax revenues are so obscenely misallocated that I am not convinced that raising them further will fix anything. We spend more on education than any other country and have worse outcomes. If I had any reasonable confidence that if taxes went up every city will be made beautiful, the homeless would stop doing drugs and go live in government provided housing, and high speed rail would be built between all major metros I'd be first on board. As it stands, a third of my taxes would be used to pay off interest on debt and another third would be used to blow something up.
- ehnto 3y agoIt's unlikely the OP is referencing your tax income, but rather corporations and billionaires. I am certain spending could be better allocated, but should corporations and billionaires be getting a free ride when they are gaining so so much from society? What are the downsides to taxing them more?
- brigadier132 3y agoThey aren't getting a free ride and as a shareholder of many corporations while also not being a billionaire, by increasing taxes on corporations you are increasing taxes on me. Billionaires and corporations are a misdirection, the actual policy that they will push is to raise taxes on people making upper middle class salaries.
- datadrivenangel 3y agoCapital -- Money -- represents assets that can be used for things. Sometimes this is physical, like manufacturing machines that can be used to produce material goods that people want. Sometimes it is virtual, like the monopoly on force that forces people to pay taxes.
- quickthrower2 3y agoI am going to do the HN thing and respond to the strongest possible interpretation. And that is for me - there are people who inherit fortunes, who by virtue of having fortunes, and who invest in anything sensible, even an index, will never need to work and contribute, and are virtual kings. This is a hard kink to iron out in capitalism. In addition those who have fortunes and decide to work hard may direct that work into getting more unfair advantages (lobbying, for example, to ban better mousetraps) rather than doing stuff for the greater good (making better mousetraps). I think this too is a problem. Capitalism + government intervention + free speech/debate might be as good as it can be for now, until abundance.
- Alpha3031 3y agoThe (classical) liberals believed in inheritance taxes but that would probably get you called a pinko commie by today's standards, even by the supposedly classical liberal parties.
- anymouse123456 3y agoIs this problem better or worse in alternative solutions (that have been instantiated with humans)? Capitalism is the worst economic system, except for all the others.
- ethbr1 3y agoCapitalism itself is a gradient though, from e.g. Nordic models (strong worker rights and social distribution of profits) to Singapore (free markets in many areas, with government involvement via ownership stake).
- barbazoo 3y agoDividends maybe.
- bllguo 3y agothe established terms for these concepts are rents and rentier capitalism.