4 ms·
The least we can do is agree that money is a societal construct, and if money grows all by itself then the gains should be fully taxed and given back to society
by amelius 3y ago
The least we can do is agree that money is a societal construct, and if money grows all by itself then the gains should be fully taxed and given back to society.
- boringuser2 3y agoThis is an incredibly pointless statement. Nobody thinks that money isn't a contract. Calling everything a "social construct" -- or, rather, calling anything a social construct is meaningless. Everything is a social construct, even "I" as a concept.
- gamepsys 3y agoIs hydrogen a social construct? Is pi a social construct? Is the sun a social construct? I'm not completely sure about the answer to those questions, but they all derive meaning in a different way than money does. I think calling money a social construct just highlights that as far as mutually agreed upon meaning being focused on an abstract concept goes, money is pretty high on the list of having lots of meaning and being very abstract.
- boringuser2 3y agoYes, they are. Even something as minute as considering a collection of atoms an "element", i.e. organizing things into discrete clusters, is a social construct. The human brain has a CPU limit so it has to cluster things to interact meaningfully with material reality. Glimpsing beyond this is nearly impossible because it goes outside the bounds of our abilities, but you can scrape at it if you abstract it enough like I'm doing here.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- quickthrower2 3y agoI agree. I mean why else is someone doing a load of work for me just because I tapped a bit of plastic on a device?
- feedforward 3y agoIt's not pointless. Social constructs are social constructs. The aristocracy twists language to reify into things what are social constructs. For example the adjective rich. Which means people with money. Rich people being rich due to their relationship with pieces of paper is fetishism. They are people in a scheme of relations of production with others, namely, workers.
- ethbr1 3y agoWhat does "money growing all by itself" mean?
- amelius 3y agoThat you did not perform significant work for it, and did not take a significant risk.
- ethbr1 3y agoSo significant work and/or significant risk are required to justify returns. What if these things are offloaded to a secondary party, in exchange for a portion of the returns?
- rangerelf 3y agoThen the secondary party would have lower tax level.
- brigadier132 3y agoSomeone did perform work for it. Those shares were sold by the original creator and employees of the company in order to raise money for the company or to fund their own living expenses. The person that purchased those shares only did so with the expectation that they could later sell them for a higher price. By taxing those earnings you reduce the demand for the shares which then reduces the amount of money the original workers can raise by selling shares. The secondary market provides incentive to invest in companies. Why is it that people of certain political persuasions always seem incapable of thinking through second and third order effects?
- wewtyflakes 3y agoHow about thinking of the first order effects? Do you think taxes are fair as they are now? How is that working out for us?
- 3y ago
- FredPret 3y agoSome selected nitpicks with what you have said. > The least we can do is Putting it like that implies that there's a direction we should all be moving in. Presumably you have determined what this direction is and have determined that it is right for humanity. Others may disagree. > agree that money is a societal construct, and Money is a simple technology that has gained wide... currency, but that doesn't mean it's an airy concept that can pop out of existence at any moment. It represents energy, effort, ingenuity, work. > if money grows all by itself You ever done a day's work? You ever start a business, make an investment, borrow or lend money? Nothing related to money happens by itself, except decay. > then the gains should be fully taxed and Again with the direction that you have determined that we should all go towards. Maybe not everybody wants a government with absolute power? > given back to society. Huge leap of faith here to suggest that taxes = giving back to society. The government certainly represent a good chunk of society in the form of numberless bureaucrats (some of whom are needed and useful) employed, and of the voters who are happy with the government. But there's a significant conflict of interest here; not one government has ever distributed its budgets perfectly. There's always the desire to increase headcount, to allocate more power to itself, to further its own goals.
- rstuart4133 3y ago> You ever done a day's work? You ever start a business, make an investment, borrow or lend money? Nothing related to money happens by itself, except decay. Aggressive. The OP would be in a very unusual position if they haven't done most of those things. You don't have to do much to make money grow at about 8% per year on average, if "not much" is defined as something else you can do while maintaining a full time job and raise a family. That's faster than wages grow, so get enough of it you can literally stop working. Granted "not much" is not the same as money growing on it's own, but it's a good enough approximation. > But there's a significant conflict of interest here; not one government has ever distributed its budgets perfectly. I don't think that was the claim. The claim is that governments distribute wealth more evenly that a corporation would, which I consider to be self evident. Also I notice you mentioned government money paying bureaucrats, but didn't mention it spends money building roads, hospitals and running schools. In fact the vast bulk of the money goes to the latter. If a democracy is functioning well, meaning it has an informed electorate and fair voting, the governments are under considerable pressure to deliver as many of those services as they can for the dollar. You do that by shrinking the bureaucracy as much as possible. I suspect you also believe corporations do things more efficiently that governments. In reality study after study has shown government bureaucracies are about as efficient as corporate ones. About the only thing that clearly does better than both is a competitive market (as opposed to a free market). One outstanding example of this comes from comparing the cost of going to a USA hospital versus one in just about every other country on the planet. It's an interesting comparison between hospitals in the USA are invariably run privately, whereas in the rest of the world they are partially funded by governments to varying extents. Turns out in just about all systems where the government has a say in how hospitals are run, they delivery more services for less cost.
- paulddraper 3y agoYes money is a social construct/contract. No it does not grow on its own. It usually shrinks, actually. Non-currency assets can "grow" though