4 ms·
It inherently has to damage our present conception of IP, unless we plan to cripple the AI revolution in the crib. If you have smart robots in the home, much l
by adventured 3y ago
It inherently has to damage our present conception of IP, unless we plan to cripple the AI revolution in the crib.
If you have smart robots in the home, much less AGI, what's the plan on restricting them? Sorry robot, you may only learn this limited set of skills, you're not allowed to create, because you've seen too much and might be too good at learning and producing.
They'll be incredibly metered if they're not allowed to learn and produce at a high capability.
And if we're talking about AGI, you can never realistically reach it if you put it in the straightjacket required to protect IP as things are today. Sorry all-knowing AGI god, you may not make images that look too much like XYZ. In fact, you're not allowed to even see any of it because of your capabilities. In fact, Disney has decided through the copyright act of 2042 that you're not even allowed access to the Internet (or magazines, or radio, or music, or TV).
It can't be AGI if it can't create. Forget about trained on ('just do not train it on material with copyright'), it'll self-train, and then what? Well then you can't even let it self-train, ie no AGI is possible.
It's going to be either or. Either the IP laws get changed, or you get no AGI. The only thing possible would be extremely boxed off, narrow, high capability AI.
- jprete 3y agoWhy do you think AGI is desirable?
- foobiekr 3y agoHumans are too stupid to collectively govern themselves. Just look at the US election cycle that is starting. There is a genuine messianistic cult at work.
- tatrajim 3y agoAll hail the wisdom of the cold circuits. We hear and obey.
- johnnyanmac 3y agoIsn't this the premise of like, half of all cyberpunk works?
- noitpmeder 3y agoI, for one, do not want to live in your new world. Further, I doubt that preventing AIs from literally stealing protected information will halt the rise of smarter AI. There is plenty of free use information out there that is LEGAL TO USE. Just curate your dataset to prevent the ILLEGAL use of other material.