6 ms·
Bad stuff going down at the American Sociological Association
- geerlingguy 3y ago> Universities and academic societies faking statistics, rewarding plagiarism and other scientific misconduct, restricting data, and otherwise mucking up the process of scholarly inquiry . . . that barely registers on the scale of institutionalized evil. I'd lump it in the same category as the other things mentioned earlier: being hypocrites. Like religion preaching one thing, practicing another. Or politicians being for the people, yet willing to enact policies or stir up wars resulting in the death of their people. Academia is supposed to be about learning, knowledge, and growth, but locking down research and not calling out cheating and plagiarism speaks to the same rot; many at the top are just as selfish and negligent as the worst politicians and religious leaders. But they sit at the top of their ivory towers and since we assign sacrosanct status to academic institutions (at least for the most part), they are never accountable.
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoSo then using this logic, as long as an organization doesn’t claim to have any ethical standards then there’s no need to hold them accountable to any ethical standard?
- infamouscow 3y agoThat's the point of having laws. They're held accountable to the law.
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoLaws =/= ethics
- infamouscow 3y agoThe point of having laws is to resolve the problem: not everyone in society has ethics, let alone the same ethics, or ethics that are compatible with each other.
- AndrewKemendo 3y ago> The point of having laws is to resolve the problem This statement is normative and has no relation to how laws are actually created. Can you name a framework of laws that was implemented by a sovereign, explicitly developed to resolve the problem of heterogeneous goal vectors for a defined political population? I’m unaware of one. All foundational “constitutions” I’m aware of were written - not as treaties that were negotiated as partners during peace that have explicit and well defined ethical principles that need to be accommodated for - rather each side claim discrete and finite sovereignty and only at the point that one group shows overwhelming violent dominance is imminent do groups grudgingly carve out their own territory. So no, there is no coherent process for lawmaking that does anything other than encode the desires of the dominant political arm into the structures of its own making.
- infamouscow 3y agoI encourage you to read Murray Rothbard's Anatomy of the State. https://cdn.mises.org/Anatomy%20of%20the%20State_3.pdf https://cdn.mises.org/Anatomy%20of%20the%20State_3.pdf
- ebertucc 3y agoWasn't this the whole point of the Bill of Rights? Without it, some states wouldn't have ratified the Constitution. This was a concession (a weakening of federal power) made for a non-dominant political arm that nevertheless needed to be brought into the fold. That seems to me like it was "explicitly developed to resolve the problem of heterogenous goal vectors for a defined political population." More broadly, "resolve etc." in the above quote sounds like a mathy expansion of "compromise", which happens in almost every legislative body every day. Although maybe that's done implicitly and not explicitly.
- SubiculumCode 3y agoIn any case your framing is off point AND uneccesarily caustic. This is a business. They are worried about their revenue. They make a specious argument in an effort to save that revenue. I've never seen this so called Ivory Tower of academia, but that is besides the point.
- omgJustTest 3y agoAttribution of systematic failures to individuals typically overlooks the power of incentives. Academics need funding, funding allows them to keep going. Institutions that academics work for have bloated overheads typically going to admins who are tiered in such a way that there is just a single admin at every level. As the overheads go up, the pressure to publish and win awards does too. Most awards for public research say you can take up to 7% of the award as unobligated funds. The result is that institutions want higher operating costs, to push the bottom line and increase their 7% share.
- omgJustTest 3y ago(The point i am making is that the overall context looks more like a snake eating its own tail than evil-empire ivory tower dwellers)
- readthenotes1 3y ago"Bad stuff going down..." Possibly, but given the organization, I'm not sure it could be replicated
- cfr2023 3y agoIt is fun to take a hard line on soft "sciences" but hey, human beings are live product that can't ethically be tampered with for useful experimentation.
- readthenotes1 3y agoTo be fair, it's all science that's affected by our humanity (advancing by gravestones...).
- nonethewiser 3y agoI found it difficult to glean the high-level points of this article without reading the whole thing. So here it my paraphrasing: This is a highly opinionated article against recent ASA opposition to a law that would require them to release taxpayer funded research publications for free immediately. Currently there is a 12 month delay before they need to release which allows them to generate revenue via subscriptions. The ASA says this is bad because it removes the source of funding for peer review so there will be negative effects on academic integrity. The author frames this as opposing open science and they allude to other integrity problems in academia such as plagiarism and cheating. My opinion: Kinda seems like it boils down to a conflict between wanting an open and centralized system. I cant fault the ASA on one hand because this does fundamentally weaken them, but on the other hand maybe the best system doesn't include a central institution responsible for shaping the field. But thats not currently the case, and the ASA exists, so it seems like they're acting rationally.
- lokar 3y agoIt only applies to research funded by US taxpayers
- TheRealPomax 3y agoWhich is pretty much all academic research, there's almost always some public funding component involved.
- lokar 3y agoSure, but if you want to own something and totally control it, don’t take outside cash.
- TheRealPomax 3y agoHold up now, that's mistaking the people who take the outside cash (namely, the folks who actually do the research) for the people who want to "own" something (namely, the ASA wanting limited term exclusive publication right for papers that people submit to them). It's not the ASA taking the public funding. The folks who do the research should make their research results available for free, irrespective of what the ASA wants to do: the value of an ASA or any other similar association is in "being a peer-reviewed publication platform" that publishes vetted research (well, ideally. We all know the problems here). For that, having a publication publishing right where you are the only periodical that gets to release a product consisting of collections of research results does not interfere with any law that says that if you, as researcher(s), take public funding to do research, your research data and results should be freely available.
- SubiculumCode 3y agoI put about 5% of my effort into peer review. The journals have never sent me a dime. I peer review because it is what I do: I am a scientist. My university takes it into account while conducting merit reviews, but whatever extra I earn through merit pay raises, is paid for by my University and NIMH grants. The journals are complaining that my donated labour won't be as valuable to them anymore, even as it becomes more valuable to the scientific community.
- eyeundersand 3y agoThis is what baffled me. The claim that access restrictions are justified because they enable peer reviews is absurd given that peer review is entirely a non-profit exercise.
- red_admiral 3y agoIndeed. It looks to me more like some for-profit journals and other "gatekeepers" are worried that people could run academia just as well without them.
- systems_glitch 3y agomgmt sees their positions threatened.
- lfmunoz4 3y agowhen you review a paper, where does your "review" go? Is your review some sort of written document? Why doesn't arXiv have a place for reviews? I.e, if I trust a reviewer and says paper is good I'm likely to go read it.
- SubiculumCode 3y agoWhen I write a review, I write several paragraphs to pages pointing out strengths and weaknesses, asking for clarification, new approaches, etc. I then send that to the editor who packages all the reviews together in the form of a letter to the authors. The authors in turn respond to that letter point by point in their own letter. Its more like email than a publication. In terms of whether reviews should be public, there are pros and cons to anonymous review. The cons are easy to see. When I read a paper I don't know whether the reviewers asked a question and gotten a response about a concern I have about the paper. Often clarifying results in response to a reviewer's inquiry can be shared in the letter but never make it into the paper. I always ask for a brief sentence describing those additional checks to be put into the paper briefly or in supplemental, but that is me. The pros of anonymous unpublished reviews are slightly more nuanced. Sometimes stupid but innocent mistakes happen, and these can be embarrassing. Part of the value of review is having the chance to have fresh eyes on it, but doing so in public view can push people to get grounded in their position as a matter of reputation. Another issue is that criticizing a paper from a well known research is a bit harder when it will be published, and especially when it isn't anonymous.
- newswasboring 3y agohttps://archive.is/NCAmo https://archive.is/NCAmo (I think the site is hugged to death)
- rahimnathwani 3y agoThe site is behind Cloudflare (at least according to the message on the error page). Why isn't Cloudflare serving a cached version of the page?
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoThis is simply asking for research funded by the American people to not be arbitrarily censored to the benefit of a non democratic cartel How anybody not associated with the cartels could even tacitly support that is mind-boggling
- mdgrech23 3y agoWait till you learn about the research done by the Pentagon that we all pay for that sees the light of day.
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoPlease tell me about it!
- mrits 3y agoI don't know much about it but I'd be more upset if the Pentagon freely released all their research.
- pdonis 3y agoKeeping research results secret for national security reasons is very different from paywalling it just so journals can make money selling access to something the taxpayers already paid for.
- gigatexal 3y agoPublicly funded research should be publicly available as soon as it’s published. Simple as that. Why should any tax payer have to pay twice for the research when they’ve paid for it already with their taxes?
- micromacrofoot 3y agoMany of these associations exist to perpetuate the profile of a few dozen people at the top. Be wary of any group that's generations old, has ridiculous real estate, and people in the related industry are afraid of disparaging. They're academic pyramid schemes.
- red_admiral 3y agoThe open letter says that "open access" would "[threaten the] financial stability that enables us to support peer review that ensures the quality and integrity of the research enterprise." Fact: peer reviewers are mostly unpaid. Journals might have some paid staff, but the way peer review works is academics are expected to do the actual reviewing work for free. Doing this a lot and being famous in your field gets you a fancy title like "editor", but that doesn't usually come with money attached. Peer review itself would work just as well in an arXiv + easyChair model like some of STEM does it, replicating the value of journals for a much lower cost (and saving some trees in the process). Public access to publicly funded research is long overdue.
- ProllyInfamous 3y ago>Public access to publicly-funded research is long overdue. RIP Aaron Schwarz... he wasn't wrong [in his attempts to share publicly-funded research], just early.
- bumby 3y agoI may not know the particulars of his actions, but I think there may be an important and subtle distinction here. Did Schwartz limit his actions to only releasing publically funded research?
- ProllyInfamous 3y agoIIRC: Schwarz "never got that far," being apprehended quite quickly [while he was still mid-DL on-campus]... because a trap had been set for him after the massive datatransfer was first observed. BUT I personally support lib-gen, so I absolutely do not respect the concept of "Intellectual Property." I have contracted for several opensource projects which still find ways to become profitable (usually by distributing code with hardware). "Privatize profits, subsidize losses" == take taxpayer funds, charge taxpayers for access IMHO
- bumby 3y ago
- moi2388 3y agoScience publications are a business. Most results can’t even be reproduced, are paid by taxpayers yet the researchers or university gets to patent it. This is a joke. Public funding ought to equal public results. Both to the claims, the paper, the raw data and the peer reviews. Having said that; peer reviewers and disproving older papers should earn more money than making claims that cannot be reproduced. Also the practice of ranking scientists and universities by citations is moronic. I could in theory write a paper that claims the earth is square. Now a 1,000 friends and colleagues quote me, explaining I don’t make sense, but somehow both I and my university will RISE in ranking?!
- red_admiral 3y agoIt's a common joke in Mathematics that the way to get lots of citations is to publish a paper with a subtle error - then every "someone was wrong on ~the internet~ _a paper_" type will cite you with suggested corrections.
- voakbasda 3y agoNot just math. The technique is called "nerd sniping": https://xkcd.com/356/ https://xkcd.com/356/ Beware. It's a common trick on forums not entirely unlike this one.
- myself248 3y agoCunningham's Law.
- autonomousErwin 3y agoThere was an opportunity of comical irony here...
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoYeah. Everyone claiming peer-review and publishing is broke, are completely discounting this effect. That people like finding things wrong in other papers.
- phailhaus 3y agoIt seems that everyone is in agreement that these changes would result in less money going to the ASA. That money is used for something. What is it? What would happen if the money stopped flowing? Is there another way that they can recoup the lost income?
- grubbs 3y agoMaybe they'd have to have a smaller holiday party?
- boxed 3y agoLess money short time maybe. But look at the reverse situation when lotteries were legalized and used as funding for schools. Which happened short term, but then not.
- sct202 3y agoAccording to their published annual reports they make like $1.5m in profit from their publications ($2.8m rev - $1.3ish direct exp). That profit looks like it basically pays for their administration and 'governance' line items which total $900k. https://www.asanet.org/about/governance-and-leadership/audited-financial-statements/ https://www.asanet.org/about/governance-and-leadership/audit...
- tiahura 3y agoWhy don’t science grad students take over the publication industry and run it like they do in law?
- light_hue_1 3y agoAs an academic both the article and the ASA get things wrong. Obviously making science available for everyone is good, and the ASA has no argument. But the article minimizes the fundamental problems in academia. > 2. Academia is more open than much of business, government, and organized religion, so it’s easier for us to see the problems. That's not even remotely true. Academia is more closed, more obscure, more small network, with fewer sunshine laws, than any business, government or organized religion. It's far harder for us to see the real problems. > 3. So much of the enabling of cheating in academia just seems so pointless. It’s not cool when companies pollute, but, hey, you can see the reason$ they’ll want to do so. But what does the American Sociology Association get out of fighting against open science, what does the University of California get out of tolerating research misconduct, what do the American Statistical Association and American Political Science Association get out of giving rewards for plagiarists? Nothing. That’s what so damn pitiful. Cheating in academia has great rewards! The ASA gets money. UC gets prestige, donors, etc. The fundamental mistake the author makes is that academia is not one thing. There are academics as we've always known then and then there is the administration class. The people who do the work mostly want to get to the truth and get things done. The administration is into face-saving, donations, endowments, insanely expensive buildings, adding another VP of something, yet another layer of paperwork for every action, etc. the truth and what's right isn't aligned at all with the administrative class.
- brightball 3y ago> In comparison, universities and academic societies faking statistics, rewarding plagiarism and other scientific misconduct, restricting data, and otherwise mucking up the process of scholarly inquiry . . . that barely registers on the scale of institutionalized evil. Isn't this a significantly bigger issue because of how much these various studies are used to drive public policy that affects everyone?
- denton-scratch 3y agoI don't feel like taking a stand on "sociological research". I'm all for publicly-funded research being publicly available; but I have never regared sociology as a rigorous discipline, so in this case I don't care very much.
- s17n 3y agoI have a friend who works at one of these scientific societies (not the ASA). It's a complete scam - the organization hasn't done anything to advance the field since before any of use were born, and basically just exists to pay the salaries of the people who run it, none of whom are actually scientists. The money comes from a long-ago established monopoly on publishing some books that everybody needs to buy (which are, of course, written by actual scientists, who don't get paid).
- s17n 3y agoSo to be clear, I fully believe that the leadership of the ASA would try to undermine open-access publishing for no other reason than it threatens their own cushy jobs.
- incomingpain 3y agoGreat on Biden for standing firm on this, at least so far. I certainly approve that they need to end this sociology civil war. APA and friends have been in civil war for like 15 years. Certainly not 2019, but yes they oppose open science. Surely it has to come to an end at some point? Really started in 2005 when you must declare your biases. Sociology has never been the same. You can basically ignore any sociology pre-2005, and oh look some classic names like Jung as coming back? But holy crap has the replication crisis slapped sociology in the face. The minor update to the dsm5 and the expected major delay of the dsm6 will be huge. Practically an entire rewrite at this point is needed. I expect there will be a new diagnosis called 'neurodivergent' which will be defined as 'not bad, but different' Autism, ADHD, OCD, chronic pain/ fatigue/ somatic disorders, tics, and bipolar These will all be unified under the same title as they are all the same thing. LGBT, Dyslexia, Dysgraphia, Dyscalculia, Crohns, IBS, Colitis, Rheumatoid, osteoarthritis, Celiac, sjogrens, addisons, guillain-barre, Dental inflammations, Diabetes? Chronic pancreatitis, Herpes or mouth sores All going to show up on the ND spectrum. cPTSD will need to exist but perhaps just be neurodivergent as well. There's going to be a major overhaul of the personality disorders. Trauma informed. etc etc. Then again I expect I'll be flagged for violating the obvious rule: "All truth passes through three stages: First, it is ridiculed. Second, it is violently opposed. Third, it is accepted as self-evident."