4 ms·
A lot of medical terms have been hijacked by influencers, including some influencer doctors. “Dopamine” is the other big offender. So many social media doctors
by Aurornis 3y ago
A lot of medical terms have been hijacked by influencers, including some influencer doctors.
“Dopamine” is the other big offender. So many social media doctors and influencers building huge podcast followings with “dopamine” babble. Huberman is one of the worst offenders, but he seems to slip past a lot of people’s filters because he’s a doctor and he mixes actual studies into his extremely long podcasts so that people assume everything he’s saying is accurate.
- sebmellen 3y agoI don't understand this comment at all. Huberman, to me, has provided the most nuanced understanding of dopamine and dopaminergic effects accessible to the broader public. There's a lot of clickbait around him, and no doubt many "influencer doctors" who make a bad name for themselves, but this is a very clear take on dopamine: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QmOF0crdyRU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QmOF0crdyRU. I wouldn't call it babble. (Huberman is also not a physician, but a PhD, which is an important distinction.)
- pydry 3y agoI hear people talk shit about him much more than I hear reasoned criticism of what he says. The worst thing ive seen him do is cite studies with low p values while mentioning it. The horror.
- dandy23 3y agoWhy cite a useless study? Because it serves his purpose maybe?
- pydry 3y agoI don't know about anybody else but if $lowcostbehavior has a small chance of leading to $goodoutcome I still wouldn't mind hearing about it. I've tried multiple things he mentioned which haven't worked which also didn't cost me anything.
- coldtea 3y ago>I don't know about anybody else but if $lowcostbehavior has a small chance of leading to $goodoutcome I still wouldn't mind hearing about it This has traditionally been the excuse of quacks >I've tried multiple things he mentioned which haven't worked which also didn't cost me anything. And this is "throw things on a wall and see what sticks". It's ok if you're doing research (even there though it should be tamed as an approach) but it's not OK when giving medical and health lifestyle advice.
- pydry 3y ago>This has traditionally been the excuse of quacks Not really. Quacks usually try to sell you profitable remedies that have no chance of working and only cite scientific research in order to be misleading.
- coalteddy 3y agoThis made me realize: What if you listening to his talks/podcasts/videos is the thing he's selling you? What if his product/remedie is just the "content" he produces. Not much different to a quack then.
- pydry 3y agoHe seems to get paid for promoting stuff like blood tests and some supplement company. I tend to ignore that stuff as I ignore all adverts but I would be reluctant to assume that he's selling quack medicine this way. Some people do seem to assume that since he's getting paid to promote supplements, that those supplements are basically another herbalife. I haven't seen anybody give any evidence for this though.
- coldtea 3y agoThat's exactly the thing he's selling.
- coldtea 3y agoThat's their regular selling tactic. But their excuse when they're called for selling snakeoil and bullshit health regimens. Then it's: "it works for some", "doesn't hurt to try", "better that not taking anything", "at least it gives people hope". In this case he doesn't sell snakeoil directly: he sells talking about remedies and regimens for YT eyeballs and popularity (which can be turned into money indirectly).
- JeffSnazz 3y agoBoy you fellas sure know how to talk a guy up!
- zo1 3y agoHis long-form podcasts and interviews get hijacked into little snippets and "motivational" youtube videos. There is a huge industry of "recycling" channels that only do that, even more so now with shorts. So his 2h+ talk about morning routine studies or whatever gets turned into a video called "Neuro Expert's 21-step Morning Routine to live into your 90's". It becomes 4minutes, has peppy music in the background, can be distilled into a 30s short with effort. His channel gets points or money or whatever for you watching it, the recycling channel gets money for making it, and you as the viewer get stuck with the shit-end of the stick. That's not even mentioning the "rebuttal" industry that'll create content criticising or rebutting his content, which gets recycled the same way. It's elephants all the way down, and our attention is sucked up by it. I couldn't block and ignore these channels quickly enough, and no matter what I did YT kept recommending them. So glad I'm off YT.
- gspetr 3y agoWould love to watch/read any sources to better educate myself about things you believe Huberman gets wrong.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- aaronbrethorst 3y agoBlah blah blah Protocol blah blah blah Athletic Greens blah blah
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- j4yav 3y agoAnd for some reason apple cider vinegar is always the cure-all
- darkclouds 3y ago[dead]
- lynx23 3y agoI have pity for those who fall for Huberman. Listening to him for 30 minutes was enough to unsub him again. Low signal noise ratio, and a lot of excited talk about almost nothing. What a shill!
- getlawgdon 3y agoWhat podcasts / sites / sources do you enjoy?
- coalteddy 3y agoHijacking this comment to ask about Bryan Johnson. Anyone have any good criticism of his blueprint. The amount of supplements he takes seem really extreme. Talking about this btw: https://protocol.bryanjohnson.com/ https://protocol.bryanjohnson.com/
- seattle_spring 3y agoAh Bryan Johnson, the guy who claims his body is clinically 18 while having the outward appearance of his actual age (46). When you Google "Bryan Johnson" it autocorrects to "Bryan Johnson creepy".
- mns 3y agoThe issue with the Huberman Lab is, like others mentioned below, his content gets digested and then repackaged by a lot of micro-influencers all ofer the place, with short summaries that present bits and pieces of his podcast as solutions to everything. I started listening to his episodes from the first one, and it crazy to see what he actually discusses and how he presents things and then see what the internet makes of it. My girlfriend told me some weeks ago about that "Doberman" guy that I listen to, from a reel she saw somewhere about how he takes cold showers in the morning, and it's funny because in his podcast he clearly said he doesn't like or do cold showers, and he only presented that as an option based on some studies. He seems very down to earth and never promises things or presents solutions, you can see his academic background, but what the internet has done with his podcast and remixing his content is insane.
- darkclouds 3y ago[dead]
- sph 3y ago"I love doing ** because it gives me a dopamine hit!" — so annoying. Here's what dopamine does, in very simplistic words, from a dopamine connoisseur (i.e. ADHD person): it tells your brain "hey, this is important, carry on!". It's not responsible for the pleasure, it's just motivates you to continue doing a thing. Dopamine is when you're hungry, and tremble in excitement before your first bite of a hot pizza. Dopamine is the thrill of the chase.
- nullindividual 3y ago> excitement before your first bite of a hot pizza. What chemical is responsible for the inevitable disappointment?
- butlike 3y agoMost likely a lack of seretonin response. I'm ignoring the "pizza mouth" aspect, since that is your pain nerve receptors, but the "yes, this is good" neurotransmitter is Serotonin.
- arghwhat 3y agoUsually oil in case of a sad, wet pizza...
- sph 3y agoGluten. As in, I tremble with excitement just to rediscover that, after all, I'm still sensitive to gluten and in a few hours I'm going to need a bathroom. The best part of pizza is everything before that first bite and the crushing realization that I should've gone for a steak instead.
- avgcorrection 3y agoI’m very tired of people using clinical-sounding terms to describe their felt, first-person, lived experiences when it adds no preciseness—which should be the whole point of using such terminology.