4 ms·
Yes trucks slow down slower than cars but that's just physics. You've got the exact same problem with humans driving under say rainy or foggy conditions. If an
by Havoc 3y ago
Yes trucks slow down slower than cars but that's just physics. You've got the exact same problem with humans driving under say rainy or foggy conditions.
If anything driverless helps dramatically on this front. If you can run trucks 24/7 without stopping then you can cut their speed say 33% or whatever and still come out on top.
You can also adjust the cargo to reduce stopping distance - use autonomous truckers for things that are large but not heavy.
Or hell even just add more wheels for more stopping traction. Sure gets you more wear & tear but that's an infinitely easier problem than trying to teach an AI to recognise a kid running into the road in a busy urban steet or navigate construction site or whatever other surprises come up.
Author makes some valid points - stopping distance vs sensor range - but to me the conclusion that trucking on highways is hardest doesn't follow at all.
- foofie 3y ago> If anything driverless helps dramatically on this front. If you can run trucks 24/7 without stopping then you can cut their speed say 33% or whatever and still come out on top. I think that this line of reasoning misses the forest for the trees. If the promise of a silver bullet is a mode of transportation that can safely and reliably work 24/7 day and night with limited to no human interaction and be able to move large volumes of goods, then we already have that: it's called railway.
- fallingknife 3y agoAnd when there is a railroad to every warehouse in the country, it will replace trucks.
- o11c 3y agoThe problem with rail is that most businesses don't want a whole train worth, and removing just a single car from the train is hard.
- wongarsu 3y agoWhy don't containers already solve that problem? You can unload individual containers just fine, even put them on a truck for last-mile delivery. And then there's this American idea of putting entire trailers on flatbed cars, so you can just roll them on and off.
- foofie 3y ago> The problem with rail is that most businesses don't want a whole train worth, and removing just a single car from the train is hard. You don't need to remove cars from trains. The transportation world has been moving around shipping containers for almost a century. Shipping containers, also known as intermodal containers, were designed specifically to simplify the task of moving arbitrary units of cargo between modes of transportation, which includes to/from trains. You just need to drop them off on a flat car, take them from A to B, and then drop them off to handle the last mile.
- jmull 3y ago> …you can cut their speed say 33%… You probably can’t have cars going 70 or faster sharing the road with trucks going a steady 45.
- alemanek 3y agoIn the US there are lots of long 3-4 lane highway stretches where this is perfectly fine. Also we already see this on mountain ascents. Plenty of times I have seen trucks climbing a pass at 30-45mph in the right lane and cars zipping up it at 80mph in the left lane.
- alistairSH 3y agoIsn’t dual speed limits (lower for trailers) fairly normal in Western Europe? Pretty sure that’s true in the UK for caravans/personal trailers, though I don’t recall if that lower limit applies to commercial trucks.
- chefkoch 3y agoIn Germany you share the Autobahn with trucks going 90km/h and some cars going 200 km/h.
- perlgeek 3y ago... and I hate it, it's so much stress (unless you're constantly on the right lane and driving 90km/h). When you cross from the Autobahn to Denmark, where there's a speed limit of at most 130km/h, traffic immediately becomes less stressful.
- lotsoweiners 3y agoSounds like you’re the problem.
- Sayrus 3y agoI can understand where you're coming from but driving on a road where everyone has the same speed on average is less stressful than driving on a road with large differences in speed. The latter requires a good evaluation of the speed of the vehicles behind / in your mirror rather than just checking for whether a vehicle is there. On the former, you can simply match speed with the person in front and you're good to go. Due to this, ADAS is also broken on roads with high speed differences. It won't alert you of a vehicle is coming 100+ kmh than you in your blind spot.
- coryrc 3y agoAdding more wheels does not reduce stopping distance.
- itsoktocry 3y agoDoesn't it though? More rolling resistance and braking surface area?
- ars 3y agoBut then pressure (force) on each tire is lower now, so the friction is also lower. Effective friction is a function of weight and coefficient of friction between the materials. Interestingly the surface area of the contact is not part of the equation. On a flat surface a truck and a car using the same tire compound should have identical stopping distances. The issue comes when you are going downhill.
- lpapez 3y agoThat equation works for friction between idealized solids. Tires are not even close to an idealized solid, they deform as more weight is added to them, so the contact surface area increases as more pressure is added. That is why you see racing cars with big fat tires, because it's more grip and the relationship is not linear.
- ars 3y agoThe equation still holds. As the tire deforms to have more area the pressure on any particular part of the tire is lower. The total friction is unchanged. > That is why you see racing cars with big fat tires If you mean drag racers those tires are glued to the ground, and do not work off of friction. Other than that, what race cars have big fat tires? Tires are usually sized so that the ground pressure of the tire is in the 40 to 100 psi range (which is also the tire inflation pressure). That's simply to keep the ground from deforming and the tire from popping. It does not affect friction. This is also why off-road tires have lower pressure - the sand and mud they work on is not strong enough for a higher pressure. It is NOT for increased friction, it's because the surface they drive on can't handle it, so you spread out the weight, and reduce the pressure.
- lokar 3y agoHumans can often identify the need to slow/stop further out then current AV systems.
- kelnos 3y ago> If you can run trucks 24/7 without stopping then you can cut their speed say 33% or whatever and still come out on top. Well, they should still be driving no slower than the rest of the traffic in the slow lane (modulo what is safe for a larger vehicle under whatever the prevailing road/weather conditions are). I think a bigger benefit to not needing drivers that need to rest/sleep is that you can allow for self-driving software that can't handle all the weather and road conditions that humans can handle. The self-driving software can pull the truck over for a few hours in a snowstorm that a human driver would be able to handle, and still be ahead of a similar human-driver schedule.