3 ms·
> I’ve heard a few good arguments in this direction before, things like how engineering trains you to have a very black-and-white right-or-wrong view of the wor
by Aurornis 3y ago
> I’ve heard a few good arguments in this direction before, things like how engineering trains you to have a very black-and-white right-or-wrong view of the world based on a few simple formulae,
Whenever the rationalist writers start talking about engineering, programming, or machine learning in technical terms I have a sudden Gell-Mann Amnesia realization that these people's primary domain is writing and pontificating, with little to no actual experience with engineering, programming, or machine learning.
I don't know any engineers who would characterize the world as being simply defined by "a few simple formulae"
Meanwhile, the rationalist community has an abnormally large reverence for engineers, programmers, and machine learning experts as if they were superhuman:
> But to these I’d add that a sufficiently smart engineer has never been burned by arguments above his skill level before,
Really? Sufficiently smart engineers have never encountered arguments above their skill level? Are we to assume that engineers are at the peak of logic and reasoning and skill? Is this an attempt to pander to an engineering audience? Or an actual belief that engineers have superhuman levels of logic?
Finally, I'm growing tired of the way rationalist writings go out of their way to self-congratulate rationalists while placing the rest of the population into the unenlightened normie category that we're all supposed to look down upon:
> The people I know who are best at taking ideas seriously are those who are smartest and most rational
- pixl97 3y agoI call this the "Rationals spend a whole lot of time and effort ignoring their irrational parts"
- SkyBelow 3y agoTo further expand on the "a few simple formulae", many of those experienced in these fields will note that complexity can emerge from simplicity. Conway's Game of Life is my go to example. Following some of about the simplest rules you can have, you can create a fully Turing complete system able to emulate itself.
- EduardLev 3y agoThanks for finding the exact words for how I also feel about the rationalist community. Source: sufficiently smart chemical engineer
- KineticLensman 3y agoYes, I think that an engineer who can navigate (to some extent) human and organisational minefields will be much more effective than one who is merely super-smart
- naasking 3y ago> I don't know any engineers who would characterize the world as being simply defined by "a few simple formulae" I'm an electrical engineer. The Standard Model of particle physics governs literally all of existence, minus gravity, and it can fit on a single page [1]. Gravity is another few equations that can also squeeze onto that same page. This is a set of fairly simple formulae compared to the unbelievable complexity of existence. A universal Turing machine can compute any computable function and it's description is even shorter. In other words, unimaginable complexity can follow from "a few simple formulae". I don't know many engineers that would dispute this. Your problem is that you have some conception of "simple" that does not match what rationalists mean. [1] https://www.symmetrymagazine.org/sites/default/files/images/standard/sml.png https://www.symmetrymagazine.org/sites/default/files/images/...
- mistermann 3y ago> The Standard Model of particle physics governs literally all of existence, minus gravity, and it can fit on a single page [1]. Gravity is another few equations that can also squeeze onto that same page. This is a set of fairly simple formulae compared to the unbelievable complexity of existence. Can this model explain why we have yet another war in the middle east (which is part of existence), and also why education in certain fields seems to decrease one's curiosity in the cause of such events and whether they can be reduced or eliminated? Maybe gravity isn't the only thing missing from the model... If there was something else missing, is there anything contained within the model that would allow one to detect such a situation, or at least think about the possibility?