5 ms·
Kaspersky Lab: Apple is '10 years behind Microsoft' on security
- mrb 15y agoAs someone who works in the IT security industry, I absolutely agree with this statement. I could give dozen of examples showing Apple does not prioritize security as much as, say, Microsoft. For example, when an open source software project bundled with Mac OS X releases a security update (LDAP, Apache, Java, etc), it sometimes take Apple months to merely test it and ship it out. OS X was also very late, compared to Windows, in implementing in-depth defense mechanisms such as address space layout randomization, stack protection, etc. And last August, it was discovered that LDAP auth on OS X blindly accepted any password! Apple's code review and testing processes must be very immature to let such a glaring vulnerability ship to customers http://forums.macrumors.com/showthread.php?t=1197379 http://forums.macrumors.com/showthread.php?t=1197379 But I think Apple is slowly and finally understanding the importance of security in their software ecosystem...
- epistasis 15y ago>OS X was also very late, compared to Windows, in implementing in-depth defense mechanisms such as address space layout randomization, stack protection, etc. These are not areas where Apple is even close to 10 years behind Microsoft. The statement here is absolutely indefensible, In 2002 OS X was way ahead of Microsoft on the security front, and OS X has not gone backwards since then.
- sontek 15y agoI don't believe OSX has ever been ahead of Microsoft in security, it just didn't have enough popularity for anyone to really care about attacking it. That has changed.
- epistasis 15y agoIn 2002 Microsoft shipped with all sorts of unnecessary daemons on and listening by default. OS X did not have that problem.
- boyter 15y agoWhich is 10 years ago which the article states.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- taligent 15y agoOSX has always been ahead of Microsoft in the user experience aspect of security. The way it handled privilege escalation has always been far superior to Vista and Windows 7. Also OSX has been leading the charge towards developer signed binaries much more forcefully than Microsoft.
- nirvana 15y ago> As someone who works in the IT security industry, I absolutely agree with this statement. The former claim is impeached by the latter. > it sometimes take Apple months to merely test it and ship it out. This is a dishonest characterization. I'd rather Apple continue to ship a robust and secure operating system, than to simply patch it every time someone releases an update that passes its regression tests, with the subsequent breakage of other packages and new security holes, none of which are caught by regression tests. >OS X was also very late, compared to Windows, in implementing in-depth defense mechanisms I really don't think 2001-2002 counts as "very late". >Apple's code review and testing processes must be very immature to let such a glaring vulnerability ship to customers Please explain to me why there are known security holes in windows that have existed for 15 years? >But I think Apple is slowly and finally understanding the importance of security in their software ecosystem... Damning with faint praise. Apple has taken this issue seriously since 1987. Microsoft makes too much money from being vulnerable to take it seriously. This is just more nonsense from apple bashers based on characterization... Great for clicks but it impeaches you as an engineer.
- sliverstorm 15y ago> I'd rather Apple continue to ship a robust and secure operating system That's the thing, how is it robust and secure if Apple takes months to release security updates for said open-source software? > I really don't think 2001-2002 counts as "very late". You misread his comment. He is saying OS X was not released with in-depth defense mechanisms. Thus its release date is of no consequence. > Apple has taken this issue seriously since 1987. Forgive me for my skepticism, but what security concerns, exactly, did Apple face in 1987? 1987 was in the middle of the emergence of word processors.
- nirvana 15y ago>You misread his comment. He is saying OS X was not released with in-depth defense mechanisms. Thus its release date is of no consequence. Really? 2001-2002 is when OS X got in depth defense mechanisms, thus the date is relevant-- it proves shows how full of it he is. So, I didn't misread the comment, I rebutted it by citing the date. >Forgive me for my skepticism, but what security concerns, exactly, did Apple face in 1987? 1987 was in the middle of the emergence of word processors. And the emergence of viruses. Where were a real problem on the Mac from 1987-1990. >That's the thing, how is it robust and secure if Apple takes months to release security updates for said open-source software? Because just shipping patches without testing them produces a brittle OS and opens them up to having security holes. I'm tired of these argument-from-ignorance claims that seem to be common on hacker news. If you're going to disagree with me, at least please take the time to read what I wrote and comprehend it and disagree with what I'm saying. Don't just dash off some response based on your lack of knowledge of history, and what I'm arguing.
- taligent 15y agoWhat you wrote contradicts itself. You criticise Apple for taking too long to test and ship out security updates. And then criticise Apple for not testing enough. Which is it ?
- steve918 15y agoThese things aren't mutually exclusive. Apple takes to long to put out security updates for the same reason they are not testing enough. They don't dedicate a lot of resources to doing so.
- droithomme 15y agoAs has been discussed here, FileVault decryption passwords are stored in plain text in RAM that is easily found by a scanner attached to the firewire port. Fixing this is not difficult, it's simply a matter of NOT storing encryption passwords in plaintext in RAM, but in a register instead. This is just one of countless numbers of critical vulnerabilities in the system that are known and completely ignored as "works per spec" when reported. This is definitely by design, for many government agencies use automated hacking devices that take advantage of these vulnerabilities to gain access to machines, such as when passing through customs, or when stopped by police. The vulnerabilities are desired and doing what they are supposed to - providing a false sense of security.
- ceph_ 15y agoSecure virtual memory has been an option since pre leopard. In lion it's enabled by default and they removed the menu option to disable it.
- replax 15y agoAs you said, secure VIRTUAL memory refers to swapped memory. Meaning it is encrypted when it is written to disk. Seeing as the password is probably in near constant use, it will never be written to disk and therefore stays UNENCRYPTED in ram...
- nirvana 15y agoFalse, and has been false for at least 4 years. This vulnerability was unexpected and resolved in the next release of the OS, which allowed this memory to be kept encrypted.
- werrett 15y agoNot false I'm afraid. I use this issue to grab FileVault passwords from OSX boxes on a monthly basis. In combination with DMA access from the Firewire port it can be quite fun[1]. Although with Lion, you can't use DMA when the machine is locked. "Secure Virtual Memory" only does just that -- Encrypts the memory that is being swapped out to your disk. I've never done a memory dump and found the FileVault password has been swapped out. Probably because it is being used all the time to secure disk read/writes. The latest OSX really is behind the latest Windows on the security front. Windows has just been the focus of intense hammering on that front over many many years and they've been force to improve their game. And I say this as a mac user, as 99% of my pentester colleagues are. [1]: http://www.breaknenter.org/projects/inception/ http://www.breaknenter.org/projects/inception/
- mindstab 15y agoSome people seem to wonder how Apple could be 10 years behind. How about this, lets look at application programming language. Apple uses objC, Microsfot increasingly uses C#. What does this one metric get us? I believe it was Paul Graham himself who 10 years ago mentioned that to scale a company you should have your top developers just develop the tools the rest use. This was also around the time Microsoft was at the height of the buffer over flow bugs. Slowly they transitioned much of their code to the memory managed language of C# that their best developers made. Their entire development process, developer allocation and development language changed in part in order to meet security needs. Mean while Apple still develops everything in un memmory managed objC. That's just one example of how long Microsoft has been transitioning the entire company to new more security focused practices. The point is, to be really good at security, you have to be really focused on it, at all levels, in an all encompassing way. Microsoft has been transitioning to that for a long time and it's paid off. Apple hasn't even started. And that kind of massive corporate change in companies this big doesn't happen over night. And look how much public shaming it took to kick it off for Microsoft. I think we can look forward to a new golden age of Mac insecurity over the next few years before the process even kicks off. And this is probably how Kaspersky Lab came to say that Apple is 10 years behind Microsoft on security.
- shadesandcolour 15y agoTo be fair, Mac OS X is transitioning to Automatic Reference Counting in the next version 10.8 and iOS has had ARC and Garbage Collection for a version or two now. Apple does exactly what Paul Graham said in a different way. Their top developers make the tools that everyone else uses. Just because they haven't transitioned to a different memory management scheme doesn't mean they aren't doing it. We also might want to take a statement on the security of a platform by a company that makes their money securing people's computers with a grain of salt or two
- DrJokepu 15y agoThis is nitpicking but OS X 10.7 already ships with full ARC (and it works on 10.6 too in a somewhat limited manner). However, garbage collection was never enabled on iOS.
- nirvana 15y agoMicrosoft has real security problems- rampant viruses and trojans, and a major business on that platform is selling after market security products (probably why Microsoft has never closed these holes.) Apple killed the virus problem of the late 1980s dead, with only the most robust viruses surviving in the early 1990s, but none since. Apple has had an automatic updating program for at least 15 years, long before Microsoft, including monthly (if needed) security updates patching holes as they are found. Microsoft makes a lot of money from the security holes its own products, many of which were put there deliberately as "marketing features" that later turned out to be security vulnerabilities that apparently Microsoft finds it unprofitable to close. I've seen the source code for both Windows and OS X. Windows is very poorly engineered in general, with a great deal of cruft (leading to inadvertent security holes) while OS X is generally well engineered, benefits from being open source and pulling from open source BSD and from being fostered by a company that does not make any money from shipping security holes. However, Apple's superior quality for the past 2 decades has resulted in a great deal of growth in profits and prominence for Apple, and this means that you can always get a lot of attention by claiming Apple has security holes. In fact, people have been making these claims for the past 15 years, in articles like this. And yet there aren't massive botnets of Macs (the one trojan that got any traction has been eliminated) while there are millions upon millions of infected windows boxes out there to this day. The idea that Microsoft is ahead of Apple on security is a joke to anyone who knows their history or knows their engineering. Ok, You got me. This is obviously a troll, and I responded.... and of course the people commenting here seem to have no real knowledge of the matter, but anyone not bashing Apple is getting down voted. This is the kind of crap that makes "Hacker" news suck.
- someone13 15y ago> Microsoft makes a lot of money from the security holes its own products, many of which were put there deliberately as "marketing features" that later turned out to be security vulnerabilities that apparently Microsoft finds it unprofitable to close. [citation needed], please. I'm not being snarky - in fact, if you have a citation, I'd love to be able to use this in my discussions with others.
- cooldeal 15y ago
- nirvana 15y agoMicrosoft has real security problems- rampant viruses and trojans, and a major business on that platform is selling after market security products (probably why Microsoft has never closed these holes.) Apple killed the virus problem of the late 1980s dead, with only the most robust viruses surviving in the early 1990s, but none since. Apple has had an automatic updating program for at least 15 years, long before Microsoft, including monthly (if needed) security updates patching holes as they are found. Microsoft makes a lot of money from the security holes its own products, many of which were put there deliberately as "marketing features" that later turned out to be security vulnerabilities that apparently Microsoft finds it unprofitable to close. I've seen the source code for both Windows and OS X. Windows is very poorly engineered in general, with a great deal of cruft (leading to inadvertent security holes) while OS X is generally well engineered, benefits from being open source and pulling from open source BSD and from being fostered by a company that does not make any money from shipping security holes. However, Apple's superior quality for the past 2 decades has resulted in a great deal of growth in profits and prominence for Apple, and this means that you can always get a lot of attention by claiming Apple has security holes. In fact, people have been making these claims for the past 15 years, in articles like this. And yet there aren't massive botnets of Macs (the one trojan that got any traction has been eliminated) while there are millions upon millions of infected windows boxes out there to this day. The idea that Microsoft is ahead of Apple on security is a joke to anyone who knows their history or knows their engineering. Its just fodder to bash Apple from Apple haters (which is why, naturally, this is on the first page of "Hacker" News.)
- shadesandcolour 15y agoTo put it bluntly, Apple is 10 years behind Microsoft on security because up until now they could afford to be. We had a few trojans and such but for the most part, security updates weren't critical because people just weren't messing with the system. The important part of all of these outbreaks of flashback means that Apple realizes that it's time to get going on security. Apple doesn't ship the patches that Oracle or other third parties ship as quickly because this is how they work. They want to make sure that everything results in the best experience for the user. "But wait!" you'll cry. "Getting a virus because of a slow update isn't the best experience!" Well neither is shipping a patch that causes more issues than it fixes. Hopefully, the outcry of the users that they are getting viruses will up Apple's security efforts. In the next version they've already signaled that they think security is important because they're shipping Gatekeeper. I'd also like to point out that many, not all, but many of the bugs that are being used as exploits are in third party software (probably with the exception of Safari which has some serious issues).
- nirvana 15y agoThe Mac had viruses in the late 1980s. I know they existed as early as 1987, and as late as 1989, from first hand experience. Do you think that the Mac was a major force in the 1980s, but has been safe in obscurity since then? Apple has been serious about security for 22 years, at least, and measurably better than Microsoft for 18 years. It is absolutely absurd to ignore that history and pretend that nobody was interested in messing with the mac, when they were interested in messing with it in the 1980s. But what else can you do when you are an apologist for microsoft? Admit that they make billions from their security holes?
- el_presidente 15y agoDo you think that the horse carriage was a major force in the 1800s, but has been safe in obscurity since then? It is absolutely absurd to ignore that history and pretend that nobody was interested in messing with the horse carriage, when they were interested in messing with it in the 1800s.
- Jayasimhan 15y agoRead as "Apple is 10 years behind Microsoft in our revenue growth chart."
- pslam 15y agoI would be worried about Kaspersky's CEO if this wasn't just off-the-cuff hyperbole. Was he around in the tech industry 10 years ago? Because if he was, he would realize just how ridiculous it is to compare anything from today with the state of Microsoft software in 2002. For starters, people were still running Windows '95 (or worse). A fresh install of Windows would be infected just by connecting it to the internet - and within 15 minutes depending on where you were. All web browsers had multiple vulnerabilities, and by far the worst was Internet Explorer. Everyone ran everything as root/administrator. Yes, today is just like Microsoft from 2002.
- replax 15y agoAs I used Win in 2002 I was wondering why you consider IE the worst browser at that time. Is there a reason for that? What were the better alternatives? At that time, I found IE to be superior, actually. Also, do you have more information on the infected-within-15min claim? I'd like to know more about it...
- r00fus 15y agoPhoenix/firefox hit 0.2 in fall 2002 and was already faster and more usable for me than IE