5 ms·
"Millennium Camera" to take a 1k-year long-exposure photo
- Reubend 3y agoI think they should have started with a more achievable goal to make it to 10 years, and then re-evaluate afterwards. Maybe 100 is achievable to some extent? 1000 seems like pure fantasy to me.
- was_a_dev 3y agoOr a series of cameras. With one being opened every 10 years or so.
- kilroy123 3y agoI thought the same. I wonder if they did already? If so I would love to see the picture(s).
- kibwen 3y agoIt's an art project whose purpose is to get people in the present to consider the passage of time, rather than a project whose purpose is to produce a photograph. To spark discussions like this about its feasibility in the face of the uncertainty of the future is as much a part of the project as the camera itself.
- mihaic 3y agoSaying something is art is really not an excuse to not put in extra effort. Proof of engineering makes a statement in itself.
- karaterobot 3y ago> To spark discussions like this about its feasibility in the face of the uncertainty of the future is as much a part of the project as the camera itself. Nobody's talking about the future of the world as a result of this project, they're mostly talking about the future of the project itself, and how it'll end up a wet fart because of poor planning. If the goal is to get people slapping their foreheads then it's a smashing success. Beyond that, I'm not sure what the effect will be. All press may be good press, but not all press amounts to art.
- kurthr 3y agoYeah, it seems purpose built as an untestable thought project. Might as well have had some kids put hand prints in concrete at the base. Imagine what the time value of the money spent on this will be for this in 1000 years. A market investment of $1000 that could return 2% over inflation over that time period would be equivalent to $400B in today's dollars.
- CPLX 3y agoProblem is that’ll get you a medium Diet Coke in 3024.
- kurthr 3y agoNote that I said beat inflation, but hey maybe 2024 Diet Coke cans will be the last remaining currency in 3024.
- plasticchris 3y agoIf dollars are even still a thing
- CoastalCoder 3y agoMore likely a 12 oz. Slurm.
- thsksbd 3y agoBeating inflation by 2% over 1000 years? Physically impossible
- kurthr 3y agoWell, I agree $ is unlikely to be a thing by then, but the broad stock market has beaten inflation by 6% (almost 7%) over the last 150 years. That's already over 1000x. So, no more impossible than having a random stick take a photograph for 1000 years. Perhaps, they'll sell 0.0000001% of the stock of a corporation that owns the photograph for $4, or it will contain the last unburnt bitcoin.
- isoprophlex 3y agoI took a photo like that with a ~ 1 year exposure time. The patterns the sun makes are really cool, you can make out the moments with and without sunshine throughout the days. My gut feeling of doing this for one year: 1000 years is just plain impossible. Not with something made out of metal with an actual hole in it. Maybe some glass capped ceramic to avoid water ingress and corrosion... but after one year, my camera was already full of weird goop. https://files.rombouts.email/IMG_6500.jpeg https://files.rombouts.email/IMG_6500.jpeg
- bluenose69 3y agoThat's a great image. Thanks for sharing.
- Toutouxc 3y agoNeat idea, what kind of camera did you use?
- BizarreByte 3y agoStick a piece of photo sensitive paper in a pinhole camera and you're good to go. People typically make them out of black film canisters and such. Google "solargraph"
- isoprophlex 3y agoI got one pre-made[1], but as another commenter said, it's "just" a box with a tiny hole and some photo sensitive paper, a pinhole camera [1] https://solarcan.co.uk/ https://solarcan.co.uk/
- hairywalt 3y agoMy attempt was a 6-month exposure from a winter to a summer solstice using a Solarcan pinhole camera (https://solarcan.co.uk/ https://solarcan.co.uk/) Fairly pleased with the result, would definitely recommend having a go: https://stickyhat.com/a-6-month-pinhole-camera-exposure/ https://stickyhat.com/a-6-month-pinhole-camera-exposure/
- mkl 3y ago
- izzydata 3y agoHow does the sensor work for capturing light for that long? Wouldn't it produce a solid white image after a single day? Is there any difference between taking a 1000 year exposure and taking a photo every day for 1000 years and laying them ontop of eachother?
- MadnessASAP 3y agoIt's a pinhole camera, a tiny hole creates a faint projection of the scene on the inside of the "camera". You can make one yourself with a suitable cardboard box, a bit of foil, a needle and a sheet of photographic film. Exposure time ranges from a few seconds to a minute or two. In this case the artist used a layer of paint instead of a more traditional photosensitive material. The projected light will cause the paint to fade and change over time causing an image to appear over the course of centuries instead of minutes.
- brutus1213 3y agoI've wanted to make a pin hole cameras since I was a kid. I didn't realize the photographic film part .. now that makes sense! Where do you source that in North America these days? How do you handle it? I recall loading film into cameras as a kid .. that was exposed to light but then you moved over that part of the film? Presumably the part exposed to light is junk?
- MadnessASAP 3y agoIt's not film, it's the paper would project the negative onto to make a picture using an enlarger. It's not as readily available in this digital age but you should still be able to find it at a "good" camera store. I'd look for maybe single owner dedicated to craft type places vs chain dedicated to tech. You'll be wanting the B&W stuff, easier to develop and you can work with it under red lights instead total darkness. You'll also need 2 chemicals called "developer" and "fixer" suitable to the paper and distilled water to bath it in. Pinhole cameras are fun because you can build them in less then an hour for nearly free and it gets you hands on with the underlying principles of photography.
- master_crab 3y agoThat steel pole definitely looks like it will last 1000 years. /s As another posted stated, they should have started small: 1 yr, 10yrs, then maybe a 1000. Iterating each time with a better design. Also, dump the steel. You need something more inert.
- IshKebab 3y agoIt's art. Doesn't really need to work. But yeah I would be more impressive art if it at least appeared like it could work.
- nuccy 3y agoArt may be useful (or at least usable and realistic), e.g. imagine providing instructions how to get the photo from that camera for (hopefully) people in 1000 years, or even describe what that cilinder on a pole is in the first place. Science experiments demonstrating discoveries of the past centuries (magnetism, electricity, radio) are a kind long-term useful art.
- yreg 3y agoI'm not sure I like this kind of pretend art. Surely many people will believe that it is a serious project that's intended to work. I visited Expo once and it was full of this "pretend stuff" and it was unsettling how it mislead many people. But, it's ok, I'm certainly not saying it's bad art just because I'm on fence about it.
- peterangular 3y agoArt is subjective so everyone's entitled to their takes on it. Personally, I don't like when art makes me contemplate the delta between _intended ideals_ vs. actual execution. Especially for this piece... it's just fake. "We made a camera that's going to take a 1,000 year exposure!" - and it's like... maaaan. No, no you didn't - and it's unethical to market that you did.
- thsksbd 3y agoSteel can work. Just not that steel.
- jrockway 3y agoI would have expected a hole drilled into a cave or something like that. A piece of steel attached to a deck probably won't survive 100 years, simply because someone will want to make the deck bigger or better in the intervening time and then the camera will move. That said, that whole pitch drop experiment is going pretty well. It's not quite at 100 years, but it's getting very close. (2027). So that's 1/10th of a millenium. (I will note that the pitch drop experiment has been moved before. It's not nearly as sensitive to movement as a camera.)
- Jerry2 3y agoWhat it some bug lays a nest there? Or some dust flies into it? There's so many ways to disable this even without discussing the types of materials used.
- CPLX 3y ago> an experimental philosopher at the University of Arizona Clearly I am in the wrong line of work.
- neom 3y agoJonathon Keats work - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jonathon_Keats https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jonathon_Keats
- HPsquared 3y agoHow does this fit into data protection law? If a person stands in front of it for a moment, (a tiny shadow of) their likeness will be preserved in the image. What if that want that removed?
- dist-epoch 3y agoYou have a programmers view about how the law works. Such a claim would be dismissed immediately as frivolous.
- barelyauser 3y agoDepends. Can you provide your date of exposure and a equivalent exposure of yourself against a neutral background so we can average you out?
- InCityDreams 3y agoThere is no data protection required if you don't give them your data.
- wkat4242 3y agoUnless your stand in front of it for 10 years in the same pose, you will not be recognisable in the least
- aziaziazi 3y agoI wonder if the paint used as exposed layer will see its “printability” property decay with tile. I have experimented pinhole exposures length up to 1 day with and photographic films and the light capture decay drastically with time: what’s happening in the beginning of your scene is much more present than what was present in the end.
- dstroot 3y agoA 1k year-long exposure will result in … a gray blob with no useful information. Now a 1k-year timelapse of one photo per day made into a film would be amazing!
- jp57 3y agoIf the probability of the camera being damaged, destroyed, vandalized, or stolen in any given day is one in a million, then this thing only has a 70% chance of surviving a thousand years. (And I think that's high...)
- wkat4242 3y agoOr moved, which will ruin the photo
- PBondurant 3y agoThe photographer Michael Weseley did a number of long exposures (>12mths iirc) of Berlin during the 1990s as it was being transformed after the fall of the Wall and subsequent reunification. Viewed as huge prints in a gallery they were impressively detailed, as layers of various rebuilding and urban planning projects were revealed in varying degrees of transparency, depending on how long they took and how recent they were: eg https://www.uncubemagazine.com/blog/14374185 https://www.uncubemagazine.com/blog/14374185
- tropdrop 3y agoBeautiful work and great magazine. Thanks for sharing
- deadbabe 3y agoIt would have been better to attach the camera to some ancient historic landmark that has been around for hundreds of years or even thousands of years and will likely still be preserved to be around for a thousand more years. Several exist.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gumby 3y agoI can’t wait to see how the picture comes out!
- crazygringo 3y agoSo after a millenium, how do you remove the film to look at it without it being ruined when it's exposed to light? Does it need to be developed or something? Or does the material stop being photosensitive after a few centuries? (I mean I know this is an art project rather than something genuinely meant to last a thousand years in practice, but it seems like they're trying to make it work at least in theory.)
- Alghranokk 3y agoIt does not seem to be using a material we would normally consider appropriate for photograpic film. The article mentions: "multiple thin layers of an oil paint pigment called rose madder" If i understand the principle correctly, the captured light would simply slowly fade exposed portions of the "film" over centures, eventually resulting in a faint negative of the sum total of the scenes witnessed. Exposing the film to light at that point, one kiloyear from now, would probably do nothing, unless you left it exposed for a couple decades to direct sunlight.
- antonkar 3y agoIf you could’ve taken a 4.5 billion years long-exposure photo on our planet, I believe it would’ve been mostly a water world for most of its existence. So you’ll see a smooth water on the photo. But about the sky I’m not sure: will it be completely white because of the stars?
- mkl 3y agoWith a steel pole that looks like it's already rusting, I can't imagine it lasting 1000 years, and good luck putting it back in the same position if you replace the pole! I don't think many buildings would show up, if any. I once took a 10 second pinhole camera exposure of a busy playground, and there's no sign of the children in the image at all. One kid standing still for one second would be like a building that lasts a century for this image, but they weren't visible because of the other 90% of the time.
- corethree 3y agoA smarter project is to make a video then merge the frames.
- mjaniczek 3y agoI think the approach was chosen partly for its lack of moving/digital/energy-needing parts.
- corethree 3y agoMy approach saves more energy. This one has the camera continuously running and feeding light to the sensor or film. Mine is just taking a picture once per day.
- mjaniczek 3y agoWhat camera - the hole in the paper/...? There's no active electronics here, also no timekeeping ("once per day")
- bitwize 3y agoIt seems a symbolic gesture more than anything, though I can see where it would appeal to the kind of Hackernews who always writes a year with five digits (like 02024).