3 ms·
There is nothing wrong with buying and liquidating a company. Piling up debt is just one of many ways to do it. I don't have much sympathy for banks speculatin
by s1artibartfast 3y ago
There is nothing wrong with buying and liquidating a company. Piling up debt is just one of many ways to do it.
I don't have much sympathy for banks speculating on companies and ending up loaning more than the collateral is worth.
Hopefully this won't be the next bailout
- mtsr 3y agoOperating under the assumption that companies provide no value to society, maybe. Otherwise this is extracting value from companies and then leaving society worse off. These PEs are the locusts of the financial world.
- anovikov 3y agoThat's what we need to assume: companies usually are a detriment to society. I am more and more starting to see life as "you harm the world when you make the money; you benefit the world when you spend it". Hard to see opposite examples. They seem to be more like exceptions than happen when things didn't go according to plan for the companies.
- yterdy 3y agoIt's almost as if the coming-together-to-complete-a-mission that is a business has a raison d'etre other than profit (and, particularly, returning profit to investors), or something.
- konschubert 3y agoProfit is a great incentive. All sides can profit. Life is positive-sum.
- yterdy 3y agoClearly not. This is wishful-thinking.
- bhelkey 3y agoChevrolet harms the world when they make bolts? Starbucks harms the world as they sell coffee? Plumbers harm the world when they fix clogged drains?
- bee_rider 3y agoFor the first two the answer is clearly yes, but the things are useful/enjoyable. Fixing a clogged, depends on how they do it I guess.
- JeffSnazz 3y ago> companies usually are a detriment to society Companies are all we have for a society in this country; decades of liberalization, mobile work forces, and commodification-as-identification have ensured that.
- mjjjjjjj 3y agoProfit is value extracted from society. Sometimes it is used to create further value in other ways, sometimes it is used to extract further value.
- refurb 3y ago> Operating under the assumption that companies provide no value to society, maybe. If the company is going under, it's value to society is questionable.
- wolverine876 3y ago> There is nothing wrong with buying and liquidating a company. Sometimes no, but sometimes yes. What about employees, services the company provides to people, etc.? For example, is it no problem if a PE buys and runs into the ground businesses like nursing homes, hospitals, rental apartments and homes? What about in smaller communities where there is no substitute? Nothing we do is in a vacuum, the domain where economic theories operate. We live in a community, economy, society, and all need to think about how we affect them. If not us, there's nobody else to do it. No person - or fictional corporate entity - is an island.
- konschubert 3y agoYou can declare these good public goods and then publicly own and fund them. That works well for some things and not so well for others. If you want a nursing home in a poor, remote community, you probably need to use public money for that. You cannot tell a private owner of a privately-owned nursing home that they should keep losing money year over year. Considering that there are other, profitable nursing homes, maybe there is a systemic problem with this nursing home that cannot be fixed (for example too expensive real estate, bad company culture, ...). I this case, liquidating it and then re-using the assets (employees, buildings, ... ) in other economic endeavours is the right choice for the individual and also for society at large.
- wolverine876 3y ago> You can declare these good public goods and then publicly own and fund them. That's the theory (or one theory among many), but it doesn't always work that easily in practice. If you own any for-profit business, you have obligations beyond making money. If you own a nursing home, you have obligations to the residents, their families, the community, etc. > You cannot tell a private owner of a privately-owned nursing home that they should keep losing money year over year. Nobody tells them that. First, the choice isn't follow the (stereotyped) PE route or lose money. Second, your job as a business owner is to make money no matter what the conditions. If as a business owner you accept excuses from yourself (or others) about circumstances, you won't last a month - there are always reasons it can't be done. Your job is to balance and solve all those problems, and make money.
- yterdy 3y ago>There is nothing wrong with buying and liquidating a company. Beyond the perversity of using a company's own full faith and credit to eat it dead from the inside out (essentially admitting that the PE firms themselves are not respectable enough to be granted the credit directly), we have multiple instances of the government preempting the purchase and liquidation (and presumably the accompanying halt or even dissolution of production within) of certain companies for antitrust or even national security reasons.
- JeffSnazz 3y ago> There is nothing wrong with buying and liquidating a company. Um, I disagree—there's a lot wrong with that mindset.