7 ms·
> I don't understand why Cloudflare can't just be honest and say the reason she got laid off, instead of making up some garbage about her performance. In the v
by Aurornis 3y ago
> I don't understand why Cloudflare can't just be honest and say the reason she got laid off, instead of making up some garbage about her performance.
In the video she says she was hired August 25th, or 4.5 months ago.
She also says she hasn't "closed anything officially", or in other words zero sales.
I understand this is an emotionally charged topic, but the unfortunate reality is that being past your ramp-up period with zero sales is not a good place to be when a company is downsizing. I feel very sorry for her, but I also don't think it's entirely fair to conclude that performance wasn't a factor.
It's also not really fair to conclude that Cloudflare was withholding information when the call starts at 0:26 and she cut's them off with "I'm going to stop you right there" at 0:47 (21 seconds later). They offer to schedule a followup call to go over the details, but she was in such a rush to talk over them and start lodging accusations before they had a chance to talk that I can't blame them for trying to de-escalate on the call.
- aestetix 3y agoIf that's the case, then they should just say that.
- Aurornis 3y agoThey did. They said it was for performance reasons and offered to book a longer, second call to talk about it. Did you watch the video? She cuts them off several seconds into the call and doesn't let them even speak before she starts talking about her situation (hire date, no sales closed). They didn't even have a chance to say anything. Once someone reaches this level of intensity (cutting people off, not allowing them to speak, cursing, making accusations before the other party has even spoken) it's better to slow down and reschedule a follow-up meeting after some time to cool off. I know this is a difficult topic for HN, but this video is a good example of a TikTok performance designed to maximize engagement and outrage. I'm surprised to see TikTok outrage videos working their way into HN comments and that people are taking the situation as presented without stopping to listen to the facts.
- aestetix 3y agoThat's not entirely true. She did cut them off when they were giving out corporate speak. She asked for details, and they didn't have any details for her. I would have expected them to have a list of specific reasons, possibly prepared by her manager, and if she wanted to challenge them, then schedule a follow up meeting. But the "follow up meeting" is often just a way to make the complaint go away, rather than addressing it.
- Aurornis 3y ago> She did cut them off when they were giving out corporate speak. She cut them off after 21 seconds and then went into a heated complaint, including calling what they're doing "bullshit" > She asked for details, and they didn't have any details for her. Once someone becomes this heated, the only real option is to reschedule a followup call after the person has had time to cool down. Nothing good would have come from delving into details of her performance, even though she already admitted and acknowledged that she hadn't closed any sales. I don't think anything will make HN commenters happy, but what would you actually have wanted to hear? If they had instead said "We're cutting you for no good reason" the comments section would be complaining about that instead.
- aestetix 3y agoA few things. First, if they are doing layoffs, shouldn't they expect people to be pissed off, and be prepared to handle that? I don't think the call was heated at all, but maybe it's a cultural difference. It could be that American corporate drones in general are less tolerant of conflict. Second, why not include someone she knew on the call, instead of two people she had never met before? It's a total power move. If they had her direct boss included, or started out with a reason why it was just the two of them, that probably would have helped. Third, the fact that others were getting laid off besides just her tells me that it was not solely a performance issue. It was a corporate level cost saving measure, combined with a performance issue. Had they admitted to that, instead of laying the blame on her, it would have been fine for me. She probably would not have been happy, but I personally would not agree with her posting a video where they said that. Finally, I'm not sure what this stereotypical "HN commenter" is, but if you bring it up again, I may have to consider that you're not actually trying to engage with my arguments and instead dismissing me as a sockpuppet or something.
- BlackjackCF 3y agoI don’t know how tech sales work so I’m speaking from an uneducated place here - but is 4.5 months enough time to close any sales? I imagine that at least a month of that 4.5 months is spent onboarding and shadowing someone else to see how the company handles sales. I also imagine that any tech sales right now are difficult to close given the shrinking customer base due to the number of startups that are folding. And just from my experience being a customer in these engagements - sometimes these sales do take a while to close, since there’s a trial period and figuring out if the product is actually a good fit for the company before the sale goes through. You factor in the time it takes for companies to do the legal/compliance review… it probably takes minimum a quarter to close some of these deals. Anyway, just trying to get at the fact that her not closing anything isn’t necessarily indicative of poor performance given the context.
- PeterCorless 3y agoIt depends on the average deal size for B2B Software-as-a-Service (SaaS) products like Cloudflare. Depending on whether a deal is <$5k, which is expected to close in ~1.3 months, to >$100k, which may take ~5.5 months or more. Source: https://blog.salesflare.com/saas-sales https://blog.salesflare.com/saas-sales From my own experience working adjacent to sales for much of my career: Depending on what customer type and industry she is selling to — say, banking or Federal government sales, or sales of ARR >$1m — some sales cycles could even be superannual. Note that many deals at Cloudflare are >$100k. Source c. 2020: https://www.saastr.com/5-interesting-learnings-from-cloudflare-at-500000000-in-arr/ https://www.saastr.com/5-interesting-learnings-from-cloudfla... Yet starter packages of Cloudflare can be as low as $20 to $200 / month ($240 to $2400 annually), though those lower tiers are likely all self-service to begin with; she likely wouldn't even be involved except to qualify them for a bigger follow-on deal size. Source: https://www.cloudflare.com/plans/ https://www.cloudflare.com/plans/
- taylodl 3y agoDevs don't typically appreciate the lead time required for sales. There's a huge latency up-front where you have to get a lot of irons in the fire. Then about six months down the road they start to pay off. 4.5 months? You're not doing that. What really sucks is she's getting laid-off and someone else is going to get her commission.
- rcarmo 3y agoI didn’t read it that way. She merely waved away their attempt at defusing things by postponing any details (which they didn’t have). Also, she points out that Thanksgiving and Christmas were a factor—Nobody closes sales during those unless you’re in the retail business.
- jkmcf 3y ago> In the video she says she was hired August 25th, or 4.5 months ago. She was on a 3mo training stint and only started truly "working" in December. Unsure if she was expected to make sales during training or not.
- valval 3y agoFrankly, none of this matters. Cloudflare decides what the adequate results would have been, not HN users.