5 ms·
I'm guessing a lot of the purchase orders were placed well before the MCAS incidents occurred. These purchases tend to be contract based, and not something you
by dylan604 3y ago
I'm guessing a lot of the purchase orders were placed well before the MCAS incidents occurred. These purchases tend to be contract based, and not something you can just leave with the cashier when you suddenly decide not to purchase them. So you're contractually obligated to spend the money, so might as well get a plane out of it and hope for the best
- largepeepee 3y agoExactly, the 737 was the highest-selling commercial aircraft before the incident, and the MAX was promised to be a simple but efficient upgrade to that popular series that many already had.
- ta8645 3y agoLawyers for the airlines should have made their orders conditional on a continued high safety record.
- dylan604 3y agoYou're also looking over the fact that the purchasers really Really REALLY wanted this plane, and Boeing knew this. The fact that it was being sold as an in kind upgrade so no new training was required was a H. U. G. E. part of the decision to purchase. There was a helluva sales pitch with that fact on top of the fuel savings. I'm guessing there's a lot of bar lowering that the airlines would have been willing to accept to even contemplate a safety record clause
- ta8645 3y agoRegardless, it would seem prudent to give yourself flexibility to react to such a compromised safety record. You can always still go through with the purchase if it makes sense. It just seems to me the airline lawyers failed to protect their interests, when agreeing to these purchase contracts.
- bobthepanda 3y agoNeither Boeing nor Airbus would actually sign such a thing, and above all else the reason the airlines are buying planes is because they need one. The older models are also now out of production.
- AdrianB1 3y agoPlanes have a limited life and a shelf life. If you are an airliner and your planes are either aging or becoming not competitive due to fuel consumption (this is the biggest change from a generation to another), you are forced to buy anything you can find. Waiting lists are 5 to 10 years long, depending how big pockets you have. There is no competition, it is a duopol, so many times you are forced to buy.
- throwup238 3y agoThe list of orders and deliveries is public: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Boeing_737_MAX_orders_and_deliveries https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Boeing_737_MAX_orders_... Most orders were before the accidents but the vast majority haven't been canceled. Boeing has only delivered a fraction of them; they have another 3,000 to deliver before they get to the orders placed after the accidents (~1400).
- Beldin 3y agoIf you cancel, you'll have to place an order elsewhere and end up at the back of their log. Since there isn't that much competition, this means Airbus. Moreover: this also means introducing another brand of aircraft into your fleet. That is a far greater maintenance headache than "merely" various types by the same company. Basically: Switching cost are stratospheric.
- smokefoot 3y agoMost carriers operate both Airbus and Boeing. Low cost carriers have less diversity and operate either 737s or A300s. Southwest is the only airline I can think of that would have their hand forced in this way.
- selectodude 3y agoSouthwest and Ryanair were the airlines that demanded a 737 and said if Boeing didn't make one, they were going to switch to Airbus. It's just all kind of a clusterfuck.
- SkyMarshal 3y ago> That is a far greater maintenance headache than "merely" various types by the same company. You would think so, but it’s actually not. I used to work at an airline in IT, and asked that question of the Ops folks when the airline was evaluating switching fleets to Airbus. They said switching fleets or operating a mixed fleet is not cost prohibitive. This was midsize regional airline fwiw.
- Aeolun 3y agoI’d imagine the plane you are primed to buy dropping out of the sky due to engineering malpractice to be a reason to re-evaluate, if not automatically cancel those contracts. Unless you are a sociopath and only care about your balance sheet I suppose.
- dylan604 3y ago> Unless you are a sociopath and only care about your balance sheet I suppose well, there you go