5 ms·
My New Apartment's Most Aggravating Feature
- kjandersen 3y agoIncluding the fact that the smartlock _also_ has a keypad, and that the code is just 7 digits the author claims not to be able to memorize seems like a really easy way to undermine an otherwise solid story about dystopian crapware apps locking tenants out of their rented property.
- HomeDeLaPot 3y agoYeah, I would have memorized the two 7-digit codes. And being able to re-key locks without having to physically send someone to the property seems like a legitimate innovation. I'm personally a little more weirded out by the pictures and activity being sent to the landlord and who knows where else.
- avidiax 3y agoThere are purely mechanical methods to make rekeying easy. https://www.kwikset.com/smartkey-security https://www.kwikset.com/smartkey-security Combine that with a protected keyway and you can have the tenant rekey themself.
- lvspiff 3y agoI rented an apt that was integrated with latch and it was crazy frustrating. The app only worked half the time, the door pad was in a circle and recognized numbers wrong half the time as they were not physical buttons, and which made it difficult to get in the building even at times if you were carrying anything. Half the time people left doors propped open cause it only was like a 5 second unlock. We begged for a key card which they finally relented to giving us after 3 months which was a bit more tolerable but still annoying to not just have a key. Technology has improved to a degree but it’s definitely not fully baked
- jbburt 3y agomy apartment building in Boston (part of AvalonBay Communities) installed Latch last year, and I can't agree more with this article. sure, one 7 digit code isn't difficult to memorize, and I obviously memorized the code for the door to my unit. but in my building alone, there's one door to the main lobby; a first-floor main entrance; another first-floor entryway that requires opening two distinct doors sequentially; and, in the adjacent building where the gym is, there are at least three doors to enter the building from outside, plus a second door to the gym itself; and EVERY DOOR HAS A DIFFERENT CODE. it's an absolutely terrible system
- nine_zeros 3y agoLATCH is absolute garbage. Their Bluetooth often doesn't even work. And yeah, now without a phone, I am homeless.
- lozenge 3y agoIf every door has NFC why don't they just make physical cards like employee access cards or hotel key cards? They can still be logged, revoked, etc, the only "feature" lost is the Face ID/mobile phone passcode.
- pfranz 3y agoTheir website says keycards /can/ be offered, just like physical keys (mentioned in the article). Apartment complexes opt not to support those things.
- gumby 3y agoThat’s stupid: these locks should support multiple codes so everybody just enters their house code to get in. And a way to issue a temp code for visitors that isn’t anyone’s apartment code.
- riscy 3y agoThen all it takes is one person with a guessable passcode for their apartment and strangers can get in and steal packages, etc.
- RetroTechie 3y agoThis just sounds unreasonable. How about: 1) Hire locksmith. 2) Have them replace app-supported lock with regular metal key one. 3) Profit (in time & annoyance saved). 4) While you're living there, if landlord threathens legal proceedings: hire lawyer & "see you in court". 5) When you leave: hire locksmith to revert lock to app-supported one. If landlord requests so. Sure there's ownership. But for all intents & purposes, while paying rent you are owner of said apartment, right? If doorlock isn't working, fix it.
- Sohcahtoa82 3y agoDo you even need a locksmith? I was always under impression that all you needed to replace a lock in a door was a screwdriver and a new lock from Home Depot.
- bsder 3y agoYou can probably do that on your personal door but doing that on a shared access front door will very much get you in hot water.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y ago> But for all intents & purposes, while paying rent you are owner of said apartment, right? Wrong. You don't own that place, the owner owns it. And they have the right of entry in emergency situations, or typically with 48 hours notice. They will bill/sue/evict you for tampering with the entry locks, for sure.
- c22 3y agoThe notice is so you can make a plan to let them in.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoI don't know about you, but my landlord keeps a cabinet of keys for every unit on the property. When they come to make even a routine maintenance call, they have already obtained my permission to enter, and if I don't answer the door, then they key right in. Check your lease; YMMV; most people aren't actually allowed to tamper with their door locks. Shocker, I know, right? When the Constable comes to evict you, your landlord/owner's going to have the keys to let him in.
- mikestew 3y agoSounds like Latch is just garbage. Our August locks consist of me talking to the watch (or phone, if that's your thing): "hey dingus, unlock the front door". I can do that after a run when I'm still 50 feet away, or whenever is convenient for me to do so. Of course, leaving the house is just the opposite, me shouting at HomePod on the way out the door: "hey dingus, lock the front door". And before I'm out the front gate, I hear the chime confirming that the door locked. Latch sounds like they just turned your phone into a really shitty physical key without the convenience of an actual twist-it-in-the-hole key physical key.
- bsder 3y agoALL BLE phone app access control thingies are garbage. It doesn't matter whether it's Latch, OpenPath, whoever. These kinds of things want BLE to scan all the time. Your phone OS wants BLE to scan never. The app will always lose this battle. All of these services work with an RFID fob or keycard. I suspect it will take a couple of "equal opportunity" lawsuits to force landlords to cough them up.
- FireBeyond 3y agoI bailed on my Level lock after the second occasion where it was chewing through batteries at a fantastic rate on my new home and I got locked out due to battery failure - with no notification on the app. (I ended up installing a Knox Box type device the second time). I ended up going with the Schlage Encode Plus. Works as a dumb NFC, accepts keycards, full HomeKit, Apple Watch, etc., physical key, and keypad.
- notzane 3y agoA few nights ago, I spent 30 minutes standing outside of a rental because the August app wouldn’t connect to my AirBnB account. Eventually the host woke up and sent a backup code for the keypad (with the help of phone support—do they have a pager system?). (If anyone from August is reading please help, it’s error log ID e720cfee2a9e90e5)
- bennyelv 3y agoI just rented an Airbnb that used "Nuki" door looks and they were absolute garbage as well. I never appreciated what an excellent solution a physical lock and key is until I experienced: - The paranoia when my phone was low on battery that I'm not going to be able to get back into the house. - The refusal of the stupid app to connect to the lock, requiring 5 attempts, turning things off and on again. Whilst standing in the street with all my stuff. Several times. Which causes... - Paranoia that the thing is just not going to work. A smart lock needs to match the reliability and convenience of the thing it replaces. The reliability of a physical lock and key is so high that I'd describe it with a 1 rather than 9's.
- NewJazz 3y agoWhat happened to fobs/keycards? Do people not want those?
- JadeNB 3y ago> What happened to fobs/keycards? Do people not want those? Apartment owners prefer not to give them. Don't ask me why.
- dataflow 3y agoThis is just nuts, what happens if your phone is out of battery? You're supposed to stay out for minutes or hours at potentially past midnight before you can go into your own home?
- devsda 3y agoUnless there are power outlets in your apartment complex and there's right power adapter available how are you even supposed to charge your phone in this situation? We need to go to a place where it's possible to charge and while the device charges we can quitely contemplate on all the life choices that led to this situation.
- pfranz 3y agoiPhones have had Power Reserve for a few years now. For up to around 5 hours after your phone turns off due to low battery you can still use things like Find My or Express Card transactions (payment, transit, car home hotel keys, student ids). Unfortunately, Latch doesn't support this. Oh, and Latch automatically locks the door behind you. Don't forget your phone when you take out the trash, get the mail, or pick up dry laundry.
- jryb 3y agoWhen I was apartment hunting, I asked about this at a place that had smart locks, and they said I just had to fill out a "Reasonable Modification" form (or something to that effect) and they'd install a traditional lock.
- ivanjermakov 3y ago> ..I’d have to memorize two separate codes — one for the main entrance and another for my apartment door — which seems unlikely since I lost the ability to memorize any seven-digit numbers when I bought my first cell phone 23 years ago. Since when this became an insurmountable task?
- hattar 3y agoI would guess about 23 years ago for this person
- slackstation 3y agoI was living in a building that converted to "smart" locks (not Latch) in the middle of my lease. It was horrible. It mostly worked but, it added daily frustration and friction. There was almost no benefit for me and it all went to the landlord. There is a record of every time I entered my apt that I'm not in control of. It made it harder for delivery people because the complex already had an intercom system and now I had to give directions to two different systems to successfully deliver. It was one of the main drivers for me to move out. I will never rent an apt with a system like that again. Now I know to ask if they have "smart" locks and will avoid them like the insecure plague they are. They also had some wireless box that communicated with my apt lock that I had to put in my apt, connect it to my wifi, and use my power, all without any compensation.
- msmenardi 3y agoThe purpose of smart locks such as these is never convenience. It's not even to make money. The purpose is to deprive you of the resource they control should you say something they disagree with. In fact, this applies to all smart devices, and IoT gadgets - to spy on you, and to control you if you step out of line. "Oh I'm sorry your dishwasher won't start, should have thought of how much you valued having clean dishes before you started speaking out against the regime" Obviously, that doesn't happen right now. But if the infrastructure is in place, all it'd take is a software patch and suddenly we get a dystopia that nobody could see coming and everyone reached for with arms outstretched.
- mariusor 3y ago> The purpose is to deprive you of the resource they control should you say something they disagree with. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. I think you're showing yourself a little too eager to go down the cybery slope of dystopia.
- tdeck 3y agoI thought this would be about "valet" garbage, or maybe that startup that replaced your onsite package room with a warehouse you had to schedule delivery of your own mail from through an app.
- kazinator 3y agoI would uninstall that shit, put in normal lock, before you can spell the word "blog" out loud.
- JohnFen 3y agoThose smart locks are a clear and obvious Bad Thing for renters all around. I would absolutely not rent any place that uses them, if for no other reason than that they are a strong indication of the attitude of the landlord toward their tenants.