6 ms·

Same thing here in German military where instead of saying "zwei" because it might sound like "drei", you say "zwo". It's quite useful even though its a small

Same thing here in German military where instead of saying "zwei" because it might sound like "drei", you say "zwo". It's quite useful even though its a small problem compared to all those problems which happen because of the way you read numbers above 20. "Twenty one" becomes "one and twenty". It's not as bad as French but still a pain and I've seen Germans mixing it up also.

lqet 3y ago
When I was in 4th grade in Germany in the 90ies, the teacher once asked a classmate of mine to come to the blackboard. She asked her to write thirty-one ("einunddreißig", or "one and thirty"). She wrote "13", and the whole classroom exploded with laughter. I guess this is how you instill math phobia in children.
- rawbert 3y ago
  I was born in Poland and we moved to Germany when I was a kid. As a child I learned it quite easily (and fortunately I was on a school full of migrant children - today you would call it "Problemschule" here in Germany, I guess - so nobody laughed at me), but my parents still don't get used to it after more than 30 years and struggle with it on a daily basis.
  - hnbad 3y ago
    I'm a native German speaker and I have very strong feelings about this because it still trips me up when transcribing number groups by ear. If you ask me to write something down, spell out every digit individually so I don't have to pause every time to find out if you are going to say e.g. "drei", "dreißig" or "dreiundzwanzig". And for the love of god don't say "und" (and) before the final group either. But then again, even three digit groups pose problems (especially when the final group has fewer digits) - is the pause in "einhundert ... dreiundzwanzig" because it's two numbers or because you hesitated?
    - SushiHippie 3y ago
      https://zwanzigeins.jetzt/ https://zwanzigeins.jetzt/
- ethbr1 3y ago
  As an American South(east)ern kid, I was convinced either my ears were broken or I was dumb, because I couldn't understand how to count syllables in a word. I understood the method the teacher explained... ... but I would always come up with the wrong number when listening in testing. I finally asked my mother, who informed me that it's just the southern accent throwing me off, and the word 'that' shouldn't actually be pronounced the way my teacher was ('tha-yat'). So I feel childish academic bewilderment through no fault of their own. :(
  - thimkerbell 3y ago
    I still remember confidently explaining to our teacher that the grammatical choice was always the one that sounded right, and being taken aback when she said other kids grew up where that rule of thumb wouldn't work.
  - freeopinion 3y ago
    In recent years I have seen a number of arguments break out in a game that requires single syllable answers. It is fascinating to see the disagreement over words like "orange" and several others I never would have imagined.
- kergonath 3y ago
  Learning German as a foreign language, that was one of the painful aspects. Also, who thought it was a good idea to have /dreißig/ sound so much like /dreizehn/? Anyway…
  - madcaptenor 3y ago
    I mean, who thought it was a good idea that "fifty" and "fifteen" should sound so similar?
    - kergonath 3y ago
      Yes indeed. This tripped me up occasionally when I was learning English as a foreign language as well!
    - scarby2 3y ago
      We should just stop the whole teen thing and say it like we do everything else. Maybe onety five.
nihzm 3y ago
A tangentially related interesting note is that in German zwo also meant two, and so did zween. In old German some numbers were gendered and zwo is the feminine form. The only form that is used today "zwei" is the netuer form. Some languages still have this feature, for example in Russian "two" are два (m+n) and две (f). So this change is (technically) grammatically correct. English also had something similar (cf. twain).
- phyrex 3y ago
  I’m German and I never knew this! Thanks!
- dkarl 3y ago
  Zwo is still common today, because it's the word for two in some German dialects. The military adopting zwo would be similar to the American military adopting "y'all," a word that's commonly used and universally understood.
  - nihzm 3y ago
    You're right, in southern Germany, Switzerland and Austria (?) it is still widely used in everyday life. It's interesting how northern dialects "choose" zwei while the southern ones preferred zwo. Also, IIRC in some regions the (few) elderly still use all three with their original grammatical rules.
    - lxgr 3y ago
      It's definitely not common in Austria, and I also haven't heard it in Germany (outside of a "clarity of communications" context on the phone). Bavarian (which is close to many Austrian German variants) would use "zwoa", which sounds quite different too.
      - fnordian_slip 3y ago
        In Franconia, we use "zwo", "zwä" and "zwei", but it might just be very local to the small towns in my area.
JackFr 3y ago
I believe that's why in some contexts you'll hear "niner" rather than "nine" ti differentiate it from "five". Also why ships use "port" to mean the left side. It was formerly "larboard" which sounds an awful lot like "starboard",
hnbad 3y ago
Similarly, the names of the months June and July sound similar in German (Juni and Juli), both ending in an ee sound, so when talking over the phone (or radio) the latter is often pronounced with an aye sound instead. German also has a "phonetic alphabet" (i.e. nouns and proper names used to spell out letters over the radio) similar to the NATO phonetic alphabet. There are actually multiple because they differ between Germany, Austria and Switzerland. Germany also has two separate standards (of course): https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buchstabiertafel#Deutscher_Sprachraum https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buchstabiertafel#Deutscher_Spr... Most Germans know some of the postal alphabet (or an impromptu variation on it) because it's the older of the two. It's also worth mentioning that the postal alphabet was revised by the Nazis to eliminate "Jewish" (i.e. Biblical) names like Samuel, Zacharias and Nathan. Some of them were restored but that's how we ended up with Samuel/Siegfried, Zacharias/Zeppelin and Nathan/Nordpol. I'd say there's an 90% chance when spelling out a word or name over phone the other person will understand the postal alphabet and a 10% chance they'll be confused what you're doing.
isolli 3y ago
In French banks, to avoid costly confusion, traders use the words "septante", "octante", and "nonante" in use in the French-speaking part of Belgium instead of "soixante-dix", "quatre-vingt", and "quatre-vingt-dix" (sixty-ten, four-twenty, and four-twenty-ten).
- williamdclt 3y ago
  I don't know about French banks, but belgians don't say "octante", seems to be a common misconception! They say "quatre vingt", like the French. Swiss don't either, it's either "quatre vingt" or "huitante"
  - isolli 3y ago
    Indeed, I stand corrected! I still think that "octante" was used on the trading floor, but it was more than 10 years ago, and I was not trading myself...
    - paulgerhardt 3y ago
      There are a couple of papers comparing language in children’s numerical ability and performance (particularly speed and accuracy). [1] The theory espoused was simpler and quicker languages like Chinese (well at least the Chinese number system with quick mono-syllabic base ten based counting) resulted in faster computing ability with fewer errors than English with specialized words like eleven and eighteen rather than “tenty-eight”. The more exemptions to simple logic the slower and more error prone computing was for humans. French on this metric was at the bottom of the pile with polysyllabic non-simple words like quatre-vingt-dix. I like the idea of Walloon or Fribourg French counting being a sort of high frequency trading hack for people of the 19th century with shorthand like “ûtante.” [1] While not the paper I was looking for, this one + it’s reference section gets the point across: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2018.02731/full https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2018.0273...
      - isolli 3y ago
miki123211 3y ago
I've seen English radio comms use "niner", presumably to make "nine" and "five" easier to distinguish on a noisy channel.
hammock 3y ago
In English the military can say "niner" instead of nine esp on the radio to avoid confusion with "five"
- me_me_me 3y ago
  I heard it was due to NATO and coincidentally german military. Where nine sounds like nein, so they change it to niner to avoid any potential confusions in case nato units need close cooperation.
deleted 3y ago
[deleted]

lqet 3y ago

When I was in 4th grade in Germany in the 90ies, the teacher once asked a classmate of mine to come to the blackboard. She asked her to write thirty-one ("einunddreißig", or "one and thirty"). She wrote "13", and the whole classroom exploded with laughter. I guess this is how you instill math phobia in children.

rawbert 3y ago
I was born in Poland and we moved to Germany when I was a kid. As a child I learned it quite easily (and fortunately I was on a school full of migrant children - today you would call it "Problemschule" here in Germany, I guess - so nobody laughed at me), but my parents still don't get used to it after more than 30 years and struggle with it on a daily basis.
- hnbad 3y ago
  I'm a native German speaker and I have very strong feelings about this because it still trips me up when transcribing number groups by ear. If you ask me to write something down, spell out every digit individually so I don't have to pause every time to find out if you are going to say e.g. "drei", "dreißig" or "dreiundzwanzig". And for the love of god don't say "und" (and) before the final group either. But then again, even three digit groups pose problems (especially when the final group has fewer digits) - is the pause in "einhundert ... dreiundzwanzig" because it's two numbers or because you hesitated?
  - SushiHippie 3y ago
    https://zwanzigeins.jetzt/ https://zwanzigeins.jetzt/
ethbr1 3y ago
As an American South(east)ern kid, I was convinced either my ears were broken or I was dumb, because I couldn't understand how to count syllables in a word. I understood the method the teacher explained... ... but I would always come up with the wrong number when listening in testing. I finally asked my mother, who informed me that it's just the southern accent throwing me off, and the word 'that' shouldn't actually be pronounced the way my teacher was ('tha-yat'). So I feel childish academic bewilderment through no fault of their own. :(
- thimkerbell 3y ago
  I still remember confidently explaining to our teacher that the grammatical choice was always the one that sounded right, and being taken aback when she said other kids grew up where that rule of thumb wouldn't work.
- freeopinion 3y ago
  In recent years I have seen a number of arguments break out in a game that requires single syllable answers. It is fascinating to see the disagreement over words like "orange" and several others I never would have imagined.
kergonath 3y ago
Learning German as a foreign language, that was one of the painful aspects. Also, who thought it was a good idea to have /dreißig/ sound so much like /dreizehn/? Anyway…
- madcaptenor 3y ago
  I mean, who thought it was a good idea that "fifty" and "fifteen" should sound so similar?
  - kergonath 3y ago
    Yes indeed. This tripped me up occasionally when I was learning English as a foreign language as well!
  - scarby2 3y ago
    We should just stop the whole teen thing and say it like we do everything else. Maybe onety five.

nihzm 3y ago

A tangentially related interesting note is that in German zwo also meant two, and so did zween. In old German some numbers were gendered and zwo is the feminine form. The only form that is used today "zwei" is the netuer form. Some languages still have this feature, for example in Russian "two" are два (m+n) and две (f). So this change is (technically) grammatically correct. English also had something similar (cf. twain).

phyrex 3y ago
I’m German and I never knew this! Thanks!
dkarl 3y ago
Zwo is still common today, because it's the word for two in some German dialects. The military adopting zwo would be similar to the American military adopting "y'all," a word that's commonly used and universally understood.
- nihzm 3y ago
  You're right, in southern Germany, Switzerland and Austria (?) it is still widely used in everyday life. It's interesting how northern dialects "choose" zwei while the southern ones preferred zwo. Also, IIRC in some regions the (few) elderly still use all three with their original grammatical rules.
  - lxgr 3y ago
    It's definitely not common in Austria, and I also haven't heard it in Germany (outside of a "clarity of communications" context on the phone). Bavarian (which is close to many Austrian German variants) would use "zwoa", which sounds quite different too.
    - fnordian_slip 3y ago
      In Franconia, we use "zwo", "zwä" and "zwei", but it might just be very local to the small towns in my area.

JackFr 3y ago

I believe that's why in some contexts you'll hear "niner" rather than "nine" ti differentiate it from "five". Also why ships use "port" to mean the left side. It was formerly "larboard" which sounds an awful lot like "starboard",

hnbad 3y ago

Similarly, the names of the months June and July sound similar in German (Juni and Juli), both ending in an ee sound, so when talking over the phone (or radio) the latter is often pronounced with an aye sound instead. German also has a "phonetic alphabet" (i.e. nouns and proper names used to spell out letters over the radio) similar to the NATO phonetic alphabet. There are actually multiple because they differ between Germany, Austria and Switzerland. Germany also has two separate standards (of course): https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buchstabiertafel#Deutscher_Sprachraum https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buchstabiertafel#Deutscher_Spr... Most Germans know some of the postal alphabet (or an impromptu variation on it) because it's the older of the two. It's also worth mentioning that the postal alphabet was revised by the Nazis to eliminate "Jewish" (i.e. Biblical) names like Samuel, Zacharias and Nathan. Some of them were restored but that's how we ended up with Samuel/Siegfried, Zacharias/Zeppelin and Nathan/Nordpol. I'd say there's an 90% chance when spelling out a word or name over phone the other person will understand the postal alphabet and a 10% chance they'll be confused what you're doing.

isolli 3y ago

In French banks, to avoid costly confusion, traders use the words "septante", "octante", and "nonante" in use in the French-speaking part of Belgium instead of "soixante-dix", "quatre-vingt", and "quatre-vingt-dix" (sixty-ten, four-twenty, and four-twenty-ten).

williamdclt 3y ago
I don't know about French banks, but belgians don't say "octante", seems to be a common misconception! They say "quatre vingt", like the French. Swiss don't either, it's either "quatre vingt" or "huitante"
- isolli 3y ago
  Indeed, I stand corrected! I still think that "octante" was used on the trading floor, but it was more than 10 years ago, and I was not trading myself...
  - paulgerhardt 3y ago
    There are a couple of papers comparing language in children’s numerical ability and performance (particularly speed and accuracy). [1] The theory espoused was simpler and quicker languages like Chinese (well at least the Chinese number system with quick mono-syllabic base ten based counting) resulted in faster computing ability with fewer errors than English with specialized words like eleven and eighteen rather than “tenty-eight”. The more exemptions to simple logic the slower and more error prone computing was for humans. French on this metric was at the bottom of the pile with polysyllabic non-simple words like quatre-vingt-dix. I like the idea of Walloon or Fribourg French counting being a sort of high frequency trading hack for people of the 19th century with shorthand like “ûtante.” [1] While not the paper I was looking for, this one + it’s reference section gets the point across: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2018.02731/full https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2018.0273...
    - isolli 3y ago

miki123211 3y ago

I've seen English radio comms use "niner", presumably to make "nine" and "five" easier to distinguish on a noisy channel.

hammock 3y ago

In English the military can say "niner" instead of nine esp on the radio to avoid confusion with "five"

me_me_me 3y ago
I heard it was due to NATO and coincidentally german military. Where nine sounds like nein, so they change it to niner to avoid any potential confusions in case nato units need close cooperation.

deleted 3y ago

[deleted]