4 ms·
Perhaps I just don't understand how this works all that well, but shouldn't it be easy to defeat GPS spoofing when you're 30,000+ feet in the air? Presumably t
by kelnos 3y ago
Perhaps I just don't understand how this works all that well, but shouldn't it be easy to defeat GPS spoofing when you're 30,000+ feet in the air? Presumably the spoofed GPS signals are all coming from the ground, or close to it. I would think it would work to use a semi-directional antenna that is on top of the aircraft, pointing upward. Even an antenna that has a 180-degree field of view should reject fake GPS signals from the ground, no?
Only thing I can think of that would invalidate this is if the fake GPS signals bounce off the atmosphere above the planes and come back down. What else am I missing here?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- chii 3y agothe gps receivers are probably not going to be able to detect the direction a signal comes from.
- mikewarot 3y agoYou're right, a cheap GPS isn't going to do that.. however, it is well within then realm of possibility to design a GPS receiver system that uses beamforming to lock onto satellites and ignore everything else for orders of magnitude better jamming resistance.
- minetest2048 3y agoIts called controlled reception pattern antenna (CRPAs), which unfortunately is an ITAR restricted thing because of insane paperwork required, so no one wants to build it for civilian receivers. Which is stupid because beamforming (or null-steering) algorithms are not that difficult to implement, and so we already have Chinese and Iranian receivers with CRPAs. So PNT National Advisory Board is trying to convince US government to stop putting CRPAs under ITAR: https://www.gps.gov/governance/advisory/meetings/2023-05/murphy.pdf https://www.gps.gov/governance/advisory/meetings/2023-05/mur...
- mikewarot 3y agoI figured there was going to be some ITAR thing if I kept going with the brainstorm.... and you confirmed my hunch. There are so many things these days which are almost trivial to build and somehow fall under ITAR.
- genmud 3y agoRadio goes through and reflects off things, including aircraft. GPS signals are incredibly weak, and even if an aircraft attenuates or reflects 99.9% of the signal, a ground based system will nearly always be able to overpower it. It can be as simple as reflecting off the tail section of the aircraft.
- sokoloff 3y agoIncredibly weak is correct and even bordering on understatement. They are below the noise floor by about 50dB (which is a logarithmic scale, so is a factor of 100,000x).
- somat 3y agoIt still blows my mind that gps even works given how far below the noise floor it is. I am very far from being any sort of expert in radio theory but my layman understanding is that the receiver "knows" exactly what a gps signal should look like and somehow magically uses that to extract the data out of the noise. It is one of those absolutely genius aspects of modern life, and we tend to just take for granted
- sokoloff 3y agoSame. I am pretty comfortable as a programmer and that translates to feeling moderately comfortable at gluing together blocks of digital electronics. Analog electronics are much more of a struggle and RF is entirely black magic. The idea that GPS works at all defies my understanding of what ought to be possible.
- mjevans 3y agoMaybe the GPS hardware (firmware) or software reached the conclusion it shouldn't finish calculating the result for some regulatory reason?
- burnerthrow008 3y ago> Presumably the spoofed GPS signals are all coming from the ground, or close to it. I think that's a good presumption when operating in, say, Iraq or Afghanistan. Maybe less so when operating near Russia (which has its own GNSS system)? > I would think it would work to use a semi-directional antenna that is on top of the aircraft, pointing upward. Even an antenna that has a 180-degree field of view should reject fake GPS signals from the ground, no? GPS receivers already do this to reject ground reflections that could give false position readings (and the GPS signal is circularly-polarized so it can reject odd-ordered reflections off building and the ground). However, any kind of steerable (electronically or otherwise) directional GPS antenna is considered an ITAR no-no. The other problem is that GPS signals are incredibly weak (actually below the thermal noise floor), and rely on processing gain from the CDMA chipping to raise the SNR to something useful. So even an antenna with very very good rejection from the lower hemisphere will easily pass a jamming signal from the ground which is both many times closer and probably of higher power. > Only thing I can think of that would invalidate this is if the fake GPS signals bounce off the atmosphere above the planes and come back down. What else am I missing here? Any country with a space program could transmit the jamming signal from above.