3 ms·
There is one individual Michael Rae who is able to do just this. He stays at 115 pounds despite eating 1,900 calories/day with a BMI of 15.6, which is insane.
by paulpauper 3y ago
There is one individual Michael Rae who is able to do just this. He stays at 115 pounds despite eating 1,900 calories/day with a BMI of 15.6, which is insane. Most men would probably need to eat 1000-1500/day to get to that lean, as the infamous Minnesota starvation study showed, and even then many of those participants did not get that thin.
Here is a profile of him, among other individuals who are part of his dieting cult/group https://nymag.com/news/features/23169/ https://nymag.com/news/features/23169/
Michael’s regimen of 1,913 calories a day is exactly that: 1,913 calories every single day, 30 percent of them derived from fat, 30 percent from protein, and 40 percent from carbohydrates. Cooking for him is the same elaborate exercise in dietary Sudoku it is for all CR die-hards, only more so.
There is no evolutionary justification to have such an wasteful metabolism (for all of history until now it's a a disadvantage), so people like him are rare, but they exist.
Another is Roy Walford who got to a similar weight during Biosphere2 on a similar 1900/day diet when the artificial habitat began running out of food.
- sudosysgen 3y agoThat's not insane at all. At ~183cm, his BMR at 135lb would be 1600 cal/day using a standard formula, so he would only need to expend 300 calories through activity in order to breakeven, which is something many people do with just their daily routine walking around. There's nothing even slightly unusual here. The key is that very small changes in calorie intake, over a long time, have a large impact on equilibrium weight, and that height factors a lot more into BMR than people think.
- paulpauper 3y agoA BMI of 16 is very rare. It's unlikely it was always that low for him. Assuming someone starts with a BMI of 22-24 and then diets to get it to 16, this would likely would req. fewer than 1900 even if the calculator says so, due to metabolic adaption and the breakdown of the calculations at extremes .
- sudosysgen 3y agoOf course it would take less than 1900 to get there. But it would take around 1900 to stay there, according to our models of basal metabolic rates. And it turns out that this person stays there at 1900, so our conclusion is that the BMR model we're using fits this data point. It's possible that for some people at such extremes commonly available models would break down, but clearly for this person, they haven't. And while BMIs of 16 are relatively rare, so are 6 foot tall males that eat an average of 1900 calories for years. Ultimately if you're trying to use this case to show that the models are inaccurate, that's not what this case does, it's actually remarkably close to what is predicted and if anything would be better used as evidence in their favour.
- paulpauper 3y agono, Rae is truly exceptional. Other calorie-restrictors eat far less and weigh more ,even controlling for height https://www.webmd.com/diet/features/restrict-calories-revive-your-life https://www.webmd.com/diet/features/restrict-calories-revive... "I eat the same thing twice a day, seven days a week, 365 days a year," says Pomerleau, of his diet of 1,200 calories a day. "It's a lot of veggies with olive oil-based salad dressing, a lot of mixed fruits, almonds and hazelnuts, and flaxseed oil for omega-3 fatty acids." https://archive.is/e345S#selection-4235.216-4239.443 https://archive.is/e345S#selection-4235.216-4239.443 .Bob Cavanaugh, a 54-year-old landscaper from Morehead, N.C., has trimmed his intake to two meals a day, totaling 1,500 calories. Breakfast consists of one cup of quick oats, two tablespoons of toasted wheat germ, one cup of skim milk and blueberries. For dinner, he eats vegetables, fruit and a small portion of fish. "I'm hoping to see my great, great grandchildren," he says. Mr. Cavanaugh's diet may sound extreme, particularly since at 5-feet 9-inches tall and 158 pounds, he isn't overweight. But over the next several years, if the monkey results hold up, they could represent a major shift in how we view food and nutrition. The U.S. Department of Agriculture says the average sedentary woman should eat 1,600 calories a day and the average man 2,200 -- benchmarks already significantly overshot by most Americans. and a third guy https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EW8oScgXsAAVqeg.jpg https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EW8oScgXsAAVqeg.jpg A bmi of 21, nowhere close to 16 despite eating fewer calories (1700)
- nradov 3y agoThere's no evidence that Michael Rae has an unusual or wasteful metabolism. 1900 kcal/day really isn't very much. With his size and input level (CI), a moderate activity level (CO) would keep him in energy balance. Note that there is no reliable evidence that caloric restriction to the point of having an underweight BMI will actually extend human lifespans. The experiments have all been done on smaller lab animals living in safe little cages where they are protected from injuries and infectious diseases. Under nourished humans are at severe risk of sarcopenia as they age. https://peterattiamd.com/outlive/ https://peterattiamd.com/outlive/
- paulpauper 3y agoThe Minnesota starvation study showed that the formulas fail when extreme weight loss occurs. So if someone starts with a BMI of 22-24 or so and then tries to get to 15.6, will burn way fewer calories than predicted by the calculators/formulas. 1900 is not much but a BMI of 15.6 is pretty low. He did not start that low, so I wonder how much he was eating before he embarked on this experiment. As for extending lifespan, agree, that the data is iffy on that.