3 ms·
I am skeptical about reports of people who don't seem to gain much weight despite reading a lot of food. Most of those reports are merely anecdotes, or at best
by nradov 3y ago
I am skeptical about reports of people who don't seem to gain much weight despite reading a lot of food. Most of those reports are merely anecdotes, or at best observational studies, and we know that most people are terrible at accurately tracking their caloric intake. More rigorous studies that involved putting subjects into locked environments and carefully measuring their intake have consistently found that the CICO model is accurate.
However, as a practical matter for people who want to lose adipose tissue there are likely more effective approaches than CICO.
- notfed 3y agoAnecdote: throughout my life, on many occasions, I've gone on multi-month binges of over-consuming massive quantities (1500+ cals) of desserts on a daily basis, while retaining a sedentary lifestyle. I always seem to weigh the same weight (skinny). I realized I've been doing this over the past month. I weighed myself yesterday. Same weight. Clearly something is different about my body, at least when it comes to sugar calories. It just doesn't seem to readily convert it to fat. Is it really that hard to believe that some people's bodies actually behave a little more rationally than most?
- nradov 3y agoIt really is that hard to believe. Have you ever had a resting metabolic rate test? Have you ever gone several weeks carefully tracking everything you consume using an accurate food scale? I am skeptical that even during binge periods you were really taking in as many calories as you claim. That said, there are limits to what the human digestive system can absorb from a single meal. Binge eaters do sometimes exceed that limit and just poop out the excess without storing it as fat.
- psd1 3y agoLol. We exist. I got the taste for raspberry ripple ice cream in my mid-20s, and ate 10 litres a week - that's 2000+ kcal a day just in dessert. That's not binging. I put that on top of 500g dry weight of pasta with cheese and sauce, and kept it up for months. Plus breakfast, lunch, and several beers. And packets of chocolate biscuits. I was covering 10km a week or less, no marathons. No tapeworms, either. You may be right that I was shitting a lot of it out; the horrible shits are what turned me off the ice cream habit. Nonetheless, I ate well over 4000 kcal every day, for years, and never put on weight. 6000 was typical. And most of that was potatoes and wheat, which are very bio-available carbs. I've always been a black hole for food. I suspect I radiate it as heat. Exes have told me I'm hot - in a caloric sense. I feel the cold more, now that I eat less. To the overweight, if it helps at all, know that I have other struggles.
- hombre_fatal 3y agoYou need more than vibes to know how many calories you're eating. Unless you have Cronometer / calorie tracker receipts, I would dismiss your calorie estimations and so should you.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- soulbadguy 3y agoThey have been some studies where they showed that NEAT (Non-exercise activity thermogenesis) varies widely acros individual and even with the same individual at different time. I think variation as wide as 1500 have been observed. Enough to explain the people who eat a lot but don't gain weight .
- psd1 3y agoThat's me, and I have yet to discover any upper limit - I eat less now because I'm bored of chewing.
- paulpauper 3y agoThere is one individual Michael Rae who is able to do just this. He stays at 115 pounds despite eating 1,900 calories/day with a BMI of 15.6, which is insane. Most men would probably need to eat 1000-1500/day to get to that lean, as the infamous Minnesota starvation study showed, and even then many of those participants did not get that thin. Here is a profile of him, among other individuals who are part of his dieting cult/group https://nymag.com/news/features/23169/ https://nymag.com/news/features/23169/ Michael’s regimen of 1,913 calories a day is exactly that: 1,913 calories every single day, 30 percent of them derived from fat, 30 percent from protein, and 40 percent from carbohydrates. Cooking for him is the same elaborate exercise in dietary Sudoku it is for all CR die-hards, only more so. There is no evolutionary justification to have such an wasteful metabolism (for all of history until now it's a a disadvantage), so people like him are rare, but they exist. Another is Roy Walford who got to a similar weight during Biosphere2 on a similar 1900/day diet when the artificial habitat began running out of food.
- sudosysgen 3y agoThat's not insane at all. At ~183cm, his BMR at 135lb would be 1600 cal/day using a standard formula, so he would only need to expend 300 calories through activity in order to breakeven, which is something many people do with just their daily routine walking around. There's nothing even slightly unusual here. The key is that very small changes in calorie intake, over a long time, have a large impact on equilibrium weight, and that height factors a lot more into BMR than people think.
- paulpauper 3y agoA BMI of 16 is very rare. It's unlikely it was always that low for him. Assuming someone starts with a BMI of 22-24 and then diets to get it to 16, this would likely would req. fewer than 1900 even if the calculator says so, due to metabolic adaption and the breakdown of the calculations at extremes .
- sudosysgen 3y agoOf course it would take less than 1900 to get there. But it would take around 1900 to stay there, according to our models of basal metabolic rates. And it turns out that this person stays there at 1900, so our conclusion is that the BMR model we're using fits this data point. It's possible that for some people at such extremes commonly available models would break down, but clearly for this person, they haven't. And while BMIs of 16 are relatively rare, so are 6 foot tall males that eat an average of 1900 calories for years. Ultimately if you're trying to use this case to show that the models are inaccurate, that's not what this case does, it's actually remarkably close to what is predicted and if anything would be better used as evidence in their favour.