16 ms·
The biggest losers: Metabolic damage or constrained energy?
- paulpauper 3y agoBut most contestants regained a lot of weight and metabolisms slowed relative to bodyweight and stayed slow long after regaining weight. The adaptation explains why they regained weight so fast. It's incontrovertible that the show was a failure for the majority of the contestants. this also agrees with the high failure rates of diets overall and why formerly fat people regain so fast . Biology screws you over and has the final say. This is why it took so long to develop GLP-1 weight loss drugs and why they are such a big deal, by at last giving people a leg-up in this often losing battle against the body.
- SV_BubbleTime 3y agoI don’t understand how this needs anything beyond surface level complexity… you have fat people who for show reasons were tightly controlled on exercise and food intake - which works for well understood reasons - then they took that away and left the people to their lifelong established habits. Of course they regain the weight. These people didn’t magically create mass from nothing. They ate too much for their activity. Done. Stop doing that if you don’t want to gain weight. Obviously easier said than done. But I’m sick of the idea that these poor souls are visited at night by globs of mass that force their way inside. All these magic drugs are going to do is incentive bad food and bad habits. This isn’t good news.
- belltaco 3y ago> These people didn’t magically create mass from nothing. They ate too much for their activity. Done. Stop doing that if you don’t want to gain weight Not true. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/science-reveals-why-calorie-counts-are-all-wrong/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/science-reveals-w... https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5082693/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5082693/ > discovered that certain Russian populations had large intestines that were about 57 centimeters longer on average than those of certain Polish populations. Because the final stages of nutrient absorption occur in the large intestine, a Russian eating the same amount of food as a Pole is likely to get more calories from it. People also vary in the particular enzymes they produce. By some measures, most adults do not produce the enzyme lactase, which is necessary to break down lactose sugars in milk. As a result, one man's high-calorie latte is another's low-calorie case of the runs. > Call out: Germ-free mice can eat more and gain less weight than conventional mice
- netr0ute 3y agoThe problem is, it still boils down to CICO due to thermodynamics. That means they're still eating too much given a certain amount of physical activity.
- chiefalchemist 3y ago> "certain Russian populations" Yes, of course. There are always outliers. But 50+% of the American population doesn't fall into this bucket, do they? Nor did they suddenly become that after they were born (i.e., obesity is a relatively new problem and not so much driven by DNA else why didn't it exist so much even just 50 yrs ago?). We keep looking for all kinds of "answers" to obesity but we already have the one that works for most people most of the time: Take in more calories than you burn, and those extra calories will become added weight. That's it. It is *that* simple. But people refuse to change their diet and/or lifestyle. In fact they're being told it's not their fault, as if someone else is responsible for what goes in their mouth and their sedentary lifestyles.
- SirMaster 3y agoBut what if consuming as low amount of calories as needed to be equal to or less than energy expended leaves you constantly feeling tired and with headaches and such from eating so little? Is this not something that actually happens? It seems like a spiral of doom. Eat less, so now I have even less energy for activity and thus now I am burning less energy, so I need to eat even less...
- chiefalchemist 3y agoSure. That sucks. But so does diabetes, strokes, heart attacks, and premature death. The ultimate solution is prevention. But bring that up and you're accessed of being insensitive, fat shaming, etc. We've normalized the abnormal, and too few what to see that reversed.
- awfulneutral 3y agoIt might be that simple from a high level conceptual standpoint, but when the amount of calories you burn passively adjusts up or down as your body fights to maintain its weight, it is much more complex.
- paulpauper 3y agoFor those contestants, weight loss was a full time job, and they had trainers and dieticians. How is that supposed to work for average people who have jobs and families or do not have a lot of willpower? Weight loss drugs can make it easier, which I am all for. Availing oneself of medical technology is not cheating; it's why the technology exists in the first place.
- jay_kyburz 3y agoI agree that people should accept help if they need it, and should not feel ashamed for doing it, but having a strong willpower is a superpower that will help people in all aspects of their lives. I wonder if there are ways you can improve your willpower.
- paulpauper 3y agoI wonder if there are ways you can improve your willpower. stimulants
- louwrentius 3y agoSure, blame the people. Fat shame all you want. Problem solved. Done. It's so easy, just stop eating so much. As if fat people haven't heard that one a bilion times over. As if fat people havent tried time and time again. Personal responsibility! you put that stuff in your mouth, rah! rah! Personally I'm actually sick of people having no eye for the bigger picture, for many systemic reasons and larger society, and just blame stuff like this on individuals.
- goostavos 3y agoBut... Not eating works, though? How are statements about reality fat shaming?
- louwrentius 3y agoWhy don’t poor people just work hard and become rich?
- goostavos 3y agoAlas, the laws of thermodynamics remain despite irrelevant comments.
- wexomania 3y agoWell, it is easy to hold people accountable for what they themselves put in their mouths no? That being said, there is some issues with the prevelance of hyperprocessed unhealthy foods. The fact that the most unhealthy options also tend to be the cheapest and easies, really do not help.
- Dagger2 3y agoEasy, yes, but not exactly correct and certainly not helpful in the slightest.
- rustcleaner 3y agoToo bad bootstrappers can't be barred from welfare. They can never dogfood their own philosophy when on the wrong side of it!
- thaanpaa 3y agoIt requires that complexity because a metric shit ton of scientific research shows that it is more complicated than that. Permanent weight loss of more than ten pounds is nearly impossible from a scientific standpoint. The success rate after 5 years of weight loss is somewhere around 0.1%. You'd think that if it was as easy as everyone claims, more people would succeed. Heck, many people who have had gastric bypass surgery regain a significant amount of weight, even if their stomachs have been reduced to the size of a ping pong ball.
- paulpauper 3y agoyup, the stomach gradually expands and the weight returns. Really hard to beat the body.
- bodiekane 3y agoMy weight floats in a range that's 40-50 pounds lighter today than I was a decade ago. It's because I eat less and move more. Physically, weight-loss is utterly trivial. Literally everything that people say works, does. Eat less calories, eat less sugar, cut out snacking, cut out liquid calories, cut out processed food, reduce carbs, literally any and all of those work, choose whichever is most appealing to the individual. The challenge to weight and diet in America is mental and cultural. Obese people remain obese because they have unhealthy relationships with food and eat addictively or emotionally, using food to soothe anxiety, depression, loneliness, disappointment, etc and because cultural norms and advertising have normalized obesity-causing diets. Eat food. Not too much. Mostly plants.
- vkazanov 3y agoFully agree. The science of body metabolism is hard. But the rules for weight loss are simple: move more, eat less. For some people it's just "Move more, eat the same". "Eat less" means "less calories", volume can be the same - really helps. PS chips are a crime against humanity
- thefz 3y agoNot even that, if you change what you eat, you can have a dramatic effect as well. Try cutting out carbs and sugar as much as possible, results in two weeks. Changing when you eat is a factor too.
- bluescrn 3y agoThe bad food habits are only going to get worse as meat+dairy is forcibly taken away from us by the powers that be. Fewer options for an appealing 'proper meal', more temptation to eat sugar-laden junk.
- thomasfromcdnjs 3y agoI agree 100%. (though I don't think there are any particular "powers" at play) The sentiment still stands though, all the cogs in play seem to spin to make real food inaccessible and expensive. (by real I mean animal products and good produce) (raw milk is straight up illegal in Australia, most of the world would laugh at that) ==== Side note: Judging health questions off a game show is ridiculous
- frankus 3y agoDo you have first-hand experience with being overweight and/or losing a significant amount of weight? I think you're vastly overestimating how much of this (particularly "calories out") is under voluntary control. We're discussing an article that showed that extra active calories burned tend to lead to a compensatory reduction in resting metabolism. And there are some very strong psychological/physiological drives that influence "calories in" (read up on the Minnesota Starvation Experiment for examples).
- paulpauper 3y agoyup. many of these people who are on weight loss drugs already tried dieting and it did not work.
- SV_BubbleTime 3y ago“It did not work”… interesting choice of words.
- jklinger410 3y ago> They ate too much for their activity. Done. Stop doing that if you don’t want to gain weight. So much science out here to disprove this kind of statement, yet you still make it.
- thefz 3y agoWelcome to weight loss discussion on HN, where any rational point like "eat less" or "calories in, calories out" gets downvoted and discussed to death. Apparently for this crowd taking medicines is better than stopping stuffing yourself, because you know, if you take a medicine you can keep stuffing yourself. Oh, and also "it's more complicated than that" is always a nice escape from the harsh reality of thermodynamics.
- Dagger2 3y agoIt gets downvoted because it's stupid and unhelpful. If your body has the wrong idea of how much fat it should store, it'll do its best to force you to eat more to get that fat, even if it makes you unhealthily overweight. Medication can fix the body's idea of how much fat it should have. Taking that medication doesn't mean you can keep stuffing yourself, it means you can finally _stop_ stuffing yourself, without your body incorrectly reporting that it's starving. The point of the medication is to make it possible to do the right thing.
- petesergeant 3y ago> if you take a medicine you can keep stuffing yourself That’s not at all how these new medicines work. You can’t (well, don’t) keep stuffing yourself on Wegovy (Ozempic) and Zepbound (Mounjaro), because you no longer spend all your time wanting to. These drugs work by switching off your desire to stuff yourself, not by allowing you to stuff yourself without weight gain. When you eat a big meal on these medicines, you feel satisfied and over-full, rather than like an addict who just got a partial hit and wants to ride it. I take an immensely helpful SSRI for GAD, that no amount of mindfulness, therapy, or healthy living seemed to touch. I take a GLP-1 agonist for a food compulsion I’ve had for 25 years and couldn’t shake. I never got properly fat, but fighting a desire to EAT ALL THE FOOD no longer occupies 50% of my mental energy. Have you ever come off nicotine? If so, you’ll know the little voice in your head that is continually telling you that you should have a cigarette for the first few days. You can’t shut it up. Hey, have a cigarette. You know what’s be good right now? A cigarette. Oh you just woke up? Have a cigarette. It fades eventually for nicotine. In my experience, and, in that of many/most fat people, you have that constantly for food, that food noise. GLP-1 agonists turn the food noise off.
- rustcleaner 3y agoAh, moralism.
- SV_BubbleTime 3y agoAs opposed to the immoralism that has been making us fatter and fatter?
- arjie 3y agoFYI the show was not an incontrovertible failure for most contestants > Six years after the competition, median weight loss in 14 of "The Biggest Loser" participants was 13%... That means at least 7 of them lost 13%. That's pretty significant. On Ozempic, average weight loss is 11% after six months. The show worked for the majority, and the difference between the people who it worked for and the people for whom it did not work is Physical Activity not Energy Intake. This is covered in the OP link and also in https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29086499/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29086499/
- paulddraper 3y agoTbf they were massively obsese so they "should" have lost like 30% of their body weight. But yes, 13% is significant.
- waterheater 3y agoBased on a Mayo Clinic article [1], it's possible that Ozempic affects ghrelin uptake [2]. [1] https://diet.mayoclinic.org/us/blog/2024/how-does-ozempic-affect-hormones/ https://diet.mayoclinic.org/us/blog/2024/how-does-ozempic-af... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghrelin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghrelin
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- CooCooCaCha 3y agoMetabolic damage is mostly a myth. Fat, muscle, and activity burn calories. If you lose weight you’re probably burning fewer calories unless you replace it with muscle. Activity levels also vary over our lives. We tend to be more active when we’re younger.
- paulpauper 3y agoan extra 10 pounds of muscle, which is average for someone who has never trained, maybe burns only 100 extra calories. The problem also is that muscle hypertrophy also entails gaining some fat too.
- CooCooCaCha 3y agoDepends on how you bulk. You’ll gain some fat sure, but you can limit this by eating healthier and not too much over your caloric needs. But my point is, if someone loses a bunch of fat their bmr is going to take a hit. Could be pretty significant on the order of hundreds of calories a day.
- liamwire 3y ago100 kcal is ~0.5 kg of fat per month, or 6 kg per year. Read that again. Six kilograms, per year. Every year. Given a person consuming near their total daily energy expenditure, that’s the difference between losing almost 20 kg since the start of COVID, and gaining 20 kg. Small changes over time compound in unintuitive ways, which is all the more reason not to dismiss them so flippantly.
- paulpauper 3y agoBut bodybuilders gain a lot of fat offseason even despite having lots of muscle mass.
- agos 3y agobodybuilders are playing a completely different game from the person with 10 pound of muscle
- belltaco 3y ago> In 2016, Pontzer and colleagues published a study putting forward the constrained energy model: Energy expenditure does increase with more activity, but only to a point. Once physical activity gets really high, the body will adjust other components of the metabolism to keep your daily energy expenditure within a narrow range How do people who constantly repeat the mantra of thermodynamics in such threads explain this? How is the body burning the same calories with increased physical activity? Not to mention that people can extract more or less calories from the exact same food and quantity consumed.
- n4te 3y agoThe only thing that makes sense to me is that the body gets more efficient.
- jay_kyburz 3y agoThat what I imagined as I was reading, the act of breathing and pushing blood around the body just becomes easier when you are fit. (requires less energy)
- Workaccount2 3y agoYour nervous system also becomes more efficient at zapping the right muscles at the right time. The effect of this can be pretty dramatic too. Even a slightly out of sync orchestra just sounds wrong.
- pi-e-sigma 3y agoThe only plausible explanation is that it's at a cost of other functions that are vital long-term but can be turned down temporarily? Such as reduced creation of new blood cells etc.
- awfulneutral 3y agoCouldn't your body burn more or fewer calories passively and release the energy as heat? Or you could make more or fewer micro movements throughout the day, in a way that adds up to whatever your body thinks energy expenditure should be?
- TylerE 3y agoOT, but is anyone else's HN homepage like, super stale? Most of the posts are from 12+ hours ago, some from more than a day. Edit: 5/30 less than 12 hours old, 16/30 more than 20 hours old.
- zilti 3y agoI suppose they still have some issues, HN was down for a few hours today.
- TylerE 3y agoIronically, I didn't notice that because MY internet was down, due to heavy winds/rain from the big storm yesterday.
- SketchySeaBeast 3y agoMine as well. They had some outages today, I wonder if there's trouble afoot.
- dang 3y agoYes, it's related. Sorry. If you guys suggest (or submit!) some good submissions and let me know what they are, I can put them in the second-chance pool, which will accelerate the refreshing of the front page.
- hristov 3y agoIt looks to me like HN has been in a massive censorship mode in order to remove ongoing stories about the Bitcoin ETF, the SEC and the Twitter/X hack of the SEC's account. That story was on the top by far yesterday and then it suspiciously disappeared, after the comments took a very decidedly (and very deservingly, in my opinion) anti-Muskian bent. Since then there has been no story about the bitcoin ETF on the front page of HN even though it is a very important time for bitcoin (the deadline for bitcoin etf inclusion is today) and HN loves talking about bitcoin. So there is your answer.
- 3y ago
- chiefalchemist 3y agoIn the last few months I read two books on this topic, and both (if I recalled correctly) mentioned The Biggest Loser (or similar). Exercised - Daniel E Lieberman https://www.npr.org/2021/01/05/953249677/exercised-explains-why-it-can-be-hard-to-commit-to-working-out-and-why-we-should https://www.npr.org/2021/01/05/953249677/exercised-explains-... Burn - Herman Pontzer (who I believe was a student of Lieberman's) https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/new-human-metabolism-research-upends-conventional-wisdom-about-how-we-burn-calories/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/new-human-metabol... Both a fairly dry and academic, but do get into the weeds if that's your thing. A third book that's related but is an easier more entertaining read is "The Comfort Crisis" but Michael Easter. https://eastermichael.com/book/ https://eastermichael.com/book/ Easter actually interviews / quotes Lieberman. The gist of all three...from an evolutionary perspective, the human body is designed for lean caloric times. When there is more calories than there is activity to burn it, those calories will be stored as fat (in preparation for leaner times). There's no ceiling on that so you'll keep adding weight. In modern times, our evolutionary advantages become disadvantages. The best way to lose weight, is to not gain it in the first place.
- csours 3y agoHungry Brain by Guyenet is huge recommend from me, and I second the recommendation for Burn
- chiefalchemist 3y agoI'll check that out. Thanks. Speaking of the brain, I've often wondered if less focus and thinking is also contributing to weight gain. The brain is responsible for ~20% of resting metabolic rate. If the brain consumes just a bit less calories per day, that's also going to add up.
- Angostura 3y agoThe calorific difference between an active and resting brain in negligible
- slothtrop 3y agoThe more frequent the dieting and steeper the caloric deficit, the worse metabolic adaptation gets, and the longer it takes to return to normal. As I understand it that's the result discerned from more than just one paper. Layne Norton explores this at length in his book Fat Loss Forever and yt channel. The interesting thing in this link was the impact of change in exercise regimen. We know that exercise in itself can mitigate metabolic adaptation and leads to better outcomes, so maybe that should not be surprising (when they quit). The outsized impact is interesting. I wonder if those who sustained higher levels of exercise were actually in a steeper caloric deficit. It's possible to lose weight sustainably even without exercise, so perhaps it's fair to say that if you're going to exercise, you best sustain it. "damaged metabolism" was always kind of a semantic misnomer.
- cbsmith 3y agoWait. What this analysis seems to suggest is that the exercise (as long as it is a significant increase) actually encourages metabolic adaption.
- slothtrop 3y agoYeah I saw. But you'll see that the Biggest Loser contestants chased weight-loss on a very aggressive timeline. They have a steep deficit, and relatively high intensity exercise regimen. Which could just further exacerbate the effects of a steep deficit. At any rate, all of them had lastingly bad metabolic adaptation, even if those who exercised more had it worse. In other studies (alluded to here as those where participants don't undergo anything so extreme), exercise is both a strong predictor of long-term weight-loss success, and can dampen metabolic adaptation (since more muscle and good cardiovascular shape boosts metabolism, usually). I'm not sure what the lesson is yet, but I would hazard that, in the long-term, it's more important to sustain tracking energy balance (sustainability of your diet is #1). Moderate exercise can probably help, but perhaps it should also be sustainable, and in that capacity there are rapidly diminishing returns to intensity of exercise (and perhaps going hard and then quitting is a risk factor for weight regain).
- 3y ago
- waterheater 3y agoA shift in understanding the metabolism has been gradually occurring since the 1990s with the isolation of leptin. What is leptin? Discovered in 1994, leptin is a hormone that signals the availability of energy reserves in the body. "High leptin levels are interpreted by the brain that energy reserves are high, whereas low leptin levels indicate that energy reserves are low", the latter causing the body to enter a resource-minimizing starvation mode [1]. More recently, leptin has also been shown to regulate "neuroendocrine and immune function and [play] a role in development" [2]. Why is leptin so important to obesity? "Most obesity occurs in the presence of increased leptin levels", which suggests a form of "leptin resistance" in obese individuals [2]. Leptin changes our understanding of body fat, also called adipose tissue. We generally think of body fat as simply stored energy reserves, so fat can be burned by decreasing our caloric intake (diet) and increasing our energy usage (exercise), forcing our body to dip into its reserves. This approach is generally referred to the calorie-in/calorie-out (CICO) model. While true to an extent, this perspective is too simplistic, given one key fact: leptin is primarily produced in adipose tissue [1]. This fact means body fat is actually an endocrine system organ. Consider this: an obese individual has elevated leptin levels. A decrease in adipose tissue causes a decrease in their leptin production. Due to leptin resistance, low leptin levels causes the body to enter starvation mode, and hardcore dieting causes leptin levels to drop further, which makes weight loss even more difficult. What they mean by "metabolic adaptation" may be understood as "leptin adaptation", though I'm just speculating there. It's strange that so many articles talk about weight loss and "metabolism adaptation" without mentioning the hormone signalling energy availability. With leptin, we clearly see the body has an energy availability feedback loop, and fighting the intrinsic dynamics of a feedback loop rarely leads to good outcomes. On this vein, I want to highlight slothtrap's comments: >The more frequent the dieting and steeper the caloric deficit, the worse metabolic adaptation gets, and the longer it takes to return to normal. >I wonder if those who sustained higher levels of exercise were actually in a steeper caloric deficit. >perhaps it's fair to say that if you're going to exercise, you best sustain it. These comments align with present understanding of leptin dynamics. A steep caloric deficit pushes the obese body into starvation mode, so net energy expenditure from high levels of exercise will be decreased. Weight loss will be maintained once the body adjusts its leptin production and usage, which, as of now, can only be accomplished with habit. It's also worth mentioning here the hormone ghrelin, which was identified in 1999 and is nicknamed the "hunger hormone" [3]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leptin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leptin [2] DOI: 10.1146/annurev.physiol.62.1.413 [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghrelin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghrelin
- aantix 3y agoThoughts on Adenoviruses as being a root cause of obesity? https://www.geneticlifehacks.com/weight-loss-genetics-obesity-virus-adenovirus/ https://www.geneticlifehacks.com/weight-loss-genetics-obesit... "Interestingly, animal studies show that the gain in fat mass is not due to eating more or moving less… Animals ate the same amount of chow, but those infected with adenovirus 36 increased fat tissue by 60-80%." https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17135605/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17135605/ "A 2004 twin study showed that the Ad-36 antibody-positive twins were “significantly heavier and fatter as compared with their antibody-negative counterparts”. This was a groundbreaking study indicating that the Ad-36 virus was likely causing obesity."
- waterheater 3y agoIt may be a contributing factor in some cases. The study published in Obesity you link says the adenovirus affects insulin, leptin, and corticosterone. An important note about the third item: "In many species, including amphibians, reptiles, rodents and birds, corticosterone is a main glucocorticoid, involved in regulation of energy, immune reactions, and stress responses. However, in humans, cortisol is the primary glucocorticoid..." [1]. Note that the adenovirus itself wasn't definitively causing obesity, but obesity is caused by the adenovirus' effects on certain hormones. I highlight this because obesity is increasingly being reestablished as a hormonal problem. See my post and replies for more information about this change: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38942521 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38942521 [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corticosterone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corticosterone
- InSteady 3y agoA lot of viral infections impact cortisol in humans. Infection tends to ramp up cortisol levels, but prolonged or chronic infection can both deplete cortisol (so called adrenal fatigue) and/or make the body more resistant to the effects of cortisol. This is seen in the extreme in the case of HIV. I assume cortisol resistance is analogous to insulin resistance in prediabetics. Apparently chronic stress can have similar effects. And chronic stress may be associated with chronic viral reactivation. [1] Great comment! Interestingly, depleted cortisol levels from chronic stress may be associated with the development of long covid. [2] I wonder if down the road we will see that people who have had long covid are at increased risk of developing or exacerbating obesity. [1] - https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8470332/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8470332/ [2] - https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9519365/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9519365/
- anothernewdude 3y agoI like how it's being positioned as "damage". It's the body working more efficiently with less fuel. That's not damage, it's adaptation and homeostasis.
- tlow 3y agoI'm a participant in runner groups. I was surprised to meet several exceptional runners with stories of moving from very unhealthy/overweight to their current level of marathoner+. Several of them had success not just with intermittent fasting, but prolonged fasting. Humans can run when they feel like you have no energy. It's hard to believe that this isn't a psychological and behavioral issue: >A 30 percent reduction in caloric intake results in a 30 percent decrease in caloric expenditure. Often times I find it difficult to run or exercise, a lot of times I don't feel like I have the energy. Especially when fasting. I've fasted 7 days and run 3+ miles every day until I had no glucose left in my body. I've never met anybody doing prolonged fasting, distance running and a 100% commitment who couldn't transform their bodies. There may be some rare cases out there of individuals with severe disease/diagnosed health disorders, that's between someone and their doctor. For the rest, are they 100% committed? If you feel like this is you, please reach out, would love to talk and connect with you.
- Llamamoe 3y ago> For the rest, are they 100% committed? In poor health, willpower often fails long before physical performance, and there are many different possible barriers, like struggle to eat properly, poor nasal breathing, general fatigue, poor posture and running form, etc. Personally, I can run for a longer time, but between having to push through mental fatigue and very poor nasal breathing, it's an extremely unpleasant, aversive experience. Even when I can do it, it's really harsh on me.
- crdrost 3y agoIt's kind of shouting into the void but I always wanted to try to teach high school physics starting from energies rather than forces/velocities/other vectors... And the easiest places where people run into energies are light bulb wattages and nutrition facts, and the latter always seemed more interesting than the former, so the idea was “The Biophysics of Weight Loss” as a first physics course. As an example of how this looks a bit different to a physicist, most people go to an online calculator to get their TDEE or RMR, some measure of how much energy per day passes out of their body. If you're a physicist, you can't help but measure this at two different weights, current and target. So that gives you a slope, a delta: kilocalories per day per kilogram of fat lost. Except there is also a rough measure of how many kilocalories to lose to lose a kg of fat, so in dimensional analysis terms, this is really just a time constant. I forget the exact amount but it works out to something like nine months or a year or so. And then you realize that that's a half life. You choose a lifestyle, you start living as if your weight were W, then after a year you will get halfway there, after another year you'll get halfway closer, and so on, and so on. But that's not how anybody thinks on a diet. They are thinking, I'm going to intervene, get my life under control, then I can return to the lifestyle I had before but without the weight. But what you are describing is a severe lifestyle shift, “I became a marathon runner and my friends are all marathon runners and that is our new lifestyle.” Polar opposite of intervention. But it's also, there's a selection bias. If the actual cause is depression related, and marathoning worked because it gave a new sense of purpose and self, how would you notice? You spend all this time on caloric output, that's trying to treat it like a linear system. When the circuit has transistors and op amps, that's not how you analyze it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- siliconc0w 3y agoAnother factor not mentioned is when you exercise you get better at it over time. So even though you're doing the same amount, same perceived effort each day, you're actually burning much more.
- at_compile_time 3y agoI can't remember the source, but I remember hearing that the two demographics in society who average at a healthy BMI were endurance athletes and vegans. I struggled through my 20s to keep my weight under 200 lbs at 6ft tall. Then I went vegan 4 years ago, and started running during the pandemic. Nothing crazy, just 5-8 km once or twice per week when it's nice out, and lots of beans and tofu in place of meat and dairy. I haven't weighed in over 185 since, and that's without fasting or counting calories. I'm sure that viruses and environmental toxins and whatever else contribute some amount at the margin, but I'm convinced that it's diet and exercise, in that order, that are primarily to blame.
- mrmlz 3y agoThat is really shocking - that a diet change that resulted in less calories and an increase in physical exercise led to weight loss! :)
- ramino 3y agoSame experience here. I‘m also vegan, but I would say cutting back on sugar and highly processed wheat products helped me the most to stay at a healthy weight.
- chestertn 3y agoCould it be muscle loss?
- at_compile_time 3y agoI look lean, not wasted away. "Protein-deficient vegans" is a joke among omnivores, who assume that anyone not eating meat must be malnourished, and among vegans, who find ignorance of that magnitude hilarious.
- karmarepellent 3y agoI think BMI is a little confusing when it is applied to some categories of healthy individuals like endurance athletes and others. When I ran (a lot) in my early to mid-twenties my BMI was always "underweight". Yet I have never felt better. The same probably goes for climbers. Some of the climbers I know are inredibly lean and their BMI is certainly not in the "normal weight" range. Yet they are able to push their bodies to incredible feats. All that is to say, I suppose BMI stops to be useful at some point while, at the same time, it may be a good instrument to measure your progress during weight loss. It can be both useful and not, depending on who you apply it to.