3 ms·
The term "serverless" is so confusing if to me. I had settled on "scale to zero" as my chosen definition for it, because it was the only definition that truly
by simonw 3y ago
The term "serverless" is so confusing if to me.
I had settled on "scale to zero" as my chosen definition for it, because it was the only definition that truly made sense to me and that I very strongly valued.
Apparently AWS don't think it means that.
I guess it just means "you'll never have to SSH in and upgrade anything"?
The other thing that surprises me here is that one of AWS's biggest selling points is how rarely they break existing apps by turning off services developers depend on.
- throwboatyface 3y agoServerless is a paradigm where you pay for capacity, not for a specific number of instances. It's extending "cattle, not pets" beyond VMs to databases. In theory it provides better incentives for both parties: Customers don't have to pick instance size, etc. to try and accomodate their workload. They can buy throughput, etc. in fractions of an actual instance. They can look at their quota usage to determine whether to "scale up" or "scale down". Service providers are incentivized to optimize their software. If you sell instances + a service on top, there's a perverse incentive not to make your code too fast or people will buy fewer instances. In serverless, providers are incentivized to reduce their costs and optimize the entire stack. Scale to zero isn't necessarily a property of serverless - a service provider can agree to keep your data on ice for free, but that's a business decision.
- sspiff 3y agoI mean, the inverse incentive to hobble performance is still there for all the serverless stuff that bills by time spent.
- Freeaqingme 3y agoAlso, it's a way for AWS to reuse very old hardware where customers don't think about the specifications of the underlying hardware.
- Hamuko 3y agoI still consider "serverless" to mean something that does in fact scale to zero. You also don't necessarily need to SSH in and upgrade stuff with a managed service either but RDS isn't exactly serverless even though you don't really need to service the database server yourself.
- wnolens 3y agoIt typically means the unit of management (and billing) are not physical constructs (or abstractions over them). So no servers/instances/nodes etc. You manage purely logical containers like databases and tables, the serverless service takes care of the logical to physical mapping. This lets them get better density, manage patching scaling, and a ton of other things
- joshstrange 3y ago> I guess it just means "you'll never have to SSH in and upgrade anything"? To me that is just "managed". I agree, serverless means scale to 0 (compute and costs). I'm so glad I left AWS Aurora Serverless after how much I disliked v1 and never considered v2. If I was still stuck on them my costs would double or more for my dev/qa environments (which I had scale to 0).
- jamessb 3y agoYou may be interested in this article in Communications of the ACM: Serverless Computing: What It Is, and What It Is Not? https://dl.acm.org/doi/pdf/10.1145/3587249 https://dl.acm.org/doi/pdf/10.1145/3587249 (pdf)
- marcosdumay 3y ago> "you'll never have to SSH in and upgrade anything" We have "managed" for that. But if you manage to get a meaning for "serverless", I would love to know it too.
- anotherhue 3y ago"Serverless": We don't bill you if you forget to turn it off.
- marcosdumay 3y agoThat's a synonym for the GP's "it scales into 0", that is evidently a bad meaning to attach to the word. Somebody answered the GP with "it's SaaS, not IaaS". The more I think about it, the more I think this actually represent what people mean when they say it.