7 ms·
If Carpenters Were Hired Like Programmers
- Elainewallace 3y ago[dead]
- Sunspark 3y agoReading this is enraging because it reminds me of an interview I had.. they kept asking me repeatedly over and over if I ever had specific experience with this very specific individual setup and circumstance that was particular to them only. Later I complained to the Director about this interview experience and he was good enough to meet with me to talk about it. He explained that they had no choice, that the VP had already decided they wanted to hire a specific person, so the only way they could have hired me or anyone else above the wishes of the VP would be to not only prove that I had domain-specific knowledge, but also exceed it. I.e. Have already been working inside the team. I did get hired to that team a few years later and the repetitive question wasn't relevant anymore. Positions posted are not always available positions.
- CoastalCoder 3y agoIt was good of the Director to be honest with you at that point. He may have been risking his own job by doing so.
- booleandilemma 3y agoI'll never forget the time I was in an interview and I was asked about paging data in a sql query and I laughed and said I'd have to google the syntax and the interviewer gave me this horrified stare like I had just said I wanted to eat his children.
- u32480932048 3y agoMaybe he didn't know what Google was?
- im_down_w_otp 3y agoTo be fair, the cannibal that ate his children looked up how to do it on Google.
- jacknews 3y agoThis seems like only 1 aspect of what's broken now. Interviewer: First, congratulations, out of the 13000 applications we received, our AI selected yours for further consideration. Now please take this test on the chemistry of lignin, and it's reactions. If you don't hear back with your results, it's because we decided not to persue a relationship at this time... After the test, we will ask you to build a mock tudor house from rosewood. It should take no longer than a few days. Again, if you don't hear back... Then you will have an email interview with a junior from our Department of Talent, where we'll grill you on any blemishes in your record. Following that, assuming you hear back from us, there will be a psuedo-scientific psychology and personality test. By this point, some weeks or even months later, we may well have already hired internally, or just dropped the hiring requirement (even if it actually existed), but assuming we still need someone, you will then have a brief video call with whoever happens to be free in the department, to discuss wood and possibly carpentry, and houses and such ... There will be 3 such interviews, and, assuming you hear back, you will then move to the next round, where we will ask you to build a ship's hull, and carve a medieval gargoyle ... ... Thank you for your application to the role of 'nailgun operator'. Here at L'Arborious, we are passionate about hiring the top 0.01% of talent!
- 1over137 3y agoGood lord, where are interviews like that? Is it a FAANG thing?
- el_oni 3y agoI had a series of interviews at a big pharma company that was like this. Multiple stages, conversations with team members,tech tests, psychology and aptitude tests. The only reason I turned the offer down is because they took several months to get me a contract and I didn't stop interviewing in that time
- gymbeaux 3y agoIf only this were hyperbole. I once interviewed with a startup whose process was: 1. Pass TripleByte (already puts you in top whatever percentage of SWEs) 2. Meet with 4 members of the company for an hour each, and if they all like you: 3. Create a 15 minute presentation on some code you worked on. It can be code from a current or past job, but that will probably reflect poorly on you, so go build something so you can create a 15 minute presentation on it. 4. Deliver the presentation during lunch to anyone at the company who joins the meeting. Also, join the meeting via some pseudo video game in the browser that you’ve never heard of and probably won’t exist in 2 years (about 8 people joined the meeting, most of which I never met). 5. Meet with the cofounder for an hour, and if they like you enough: 6. You have the privilege of working for them for a week “trial” to make sure it’s really a good fit. You can still be rejected at this point, though if I made it this far only to be rejected, I’d have killed myself, so the fact that I’m writing this now should tell you I did not make it past #4. For those curious, #4, my presentation was about how I reverse engineered the Robinhood API, spoofed requests to get around their “security”, and used two levels of caching (Redis and a typical relational DB) to subvert rate limiting/IP blacklisting. I don’t know anybody who has done something as remarkable, especially in their spare time, for fun. BUT, I apparently said or did something they didn’t like so all that is moot. If carpenters had to go through what we go through… Jesus Christ himself could come back to Earth, apply at the Google of construction firms, and be rejected because of the gap on his resume. Ooo, sorry, that gap is a huge red flag. What’s that, you were murdered by Romans and it’s not your fault? Ehhh…. I don’t want to risk making a bad hire. Thank you so much for your interest though, we will surely keep you in mind for future opportunities.
- intothemild 3y agoOh my, they nailed this!
- throwawaaarrgh 3y agoThe irony here is carpenters aren't generic. You don't hire "a carpenter", you hire a cabinetmaker, a framer, a fine woodworker, a cooper. It would be ridiculous to hire a framer for cooperage. Most people doing tech hiring are idiots. But most people getting hired are also idiots. So I think it all shakes out about even. If the results actually mattered, we would have some kind of industry wide standards, people would need to understand the tools they use or computer science, etc. That's not really the case anymore. You can hire any monkey who's gone through a boot camp and they'll fake like they know what they're doing pretty well. The work will be shit, but you can sell shitty work as long as it looks good to the customer.
- Turing_Machine 3y ago> Most people doing tech hiring are idiots. Didn't Guido van Rossum once get rejected for a Python job for having insufficient experience? When the hiring team demands X+5 years of experience for a technology that only came out X years ago, it's no surprise when the applicants start faking experience.
- AlotOfReading 3y agoLike all analogies, it's not perfect if you analyze it too literally. Hiring companies absolutely do ask about the "species of wood" though. I got some questions this week about how much I've worked with a specific product line of generic ARM CPUs, as if that matters.
- lumost 3y agoUnfortunately, this is the type of interview you get when you don’t do the god awful LC kind. I personally like the untimed take home + a conversation about the job. It’s not difficult to come up with a take home which can’t be “cheated” easily, and as a candidate I can look at the take home and decide at some point I don’t want the job that much.
- fallingknife 3y agoI'll do a take home when you pay me my consulting rate to do it. Not interested in any company that isn't even going to take an hour of engineering time to give me a technical screen.
- lumost 3y agoThat's fair, the company spending real engineering time to interview you indicates that it is actually a real job and not a fake job. On the other side, I find live coding interviews terrifying. I only got over it in the last year or so after having done enough of them to know that I'll get the answer most of the time - and the times I don't ... I just don't sweat. When you're early in your career, it can be tough to know what you'll be asked and whether you are actually prepared enough - this leads to a lot of wasted effort/fear.
- gymbeaux 3y agoAt least with leetcode there’s a standard, there’s consistency. You judge my ability to code by how well I know Djikstra? Fine, at least there’s only one Djikstra’s Algo, and I only have to learn it once.
- _ea1k 3y agoI worked at a place where we'd sometimes give take homes, but only for roles where we were hiring outside of their experience. Oh, you think you can learn tech XYZ even though it isn't on your resume? Ok, take a test that a novice in that area could pass fairly easily. You don't even have to pass, just explain what you tried and what your reasoning was. A few syntax errors and a directionally correct attempt are fine. We got a few good candidates that way, and I think we also filtered out some bad ones. Probably filtered out a few good ones too, though, tbh.
- ktsakas 3y agoReminds me of this YouTube sketch: https://youtu.be/BKorP55Aqvg?si=NxCQht1PqO0hfPfH https://youtu.be/BKorP55Aqvg?si=NxCQht1PqO0hfPfH
- heads 3y agoThis probably rings true for junior carpenters. As you progress in your career you are much more likely to land gigs based on your network. Carpenters work on projects together and want to keep working with other good carpenters. They don’t reach out to employers to apply for jobs — the employer reaches out to them!
- romaniitedomum 3y agoVery off-topic, but there's something very odd on that page. There's these meta tags: <meta data-preact-helmet name="description" content="Dominate The Male Enhancement Niche Today with Aizen Power The following joke was posted to an internal Magenic list. I don't know who actually wrote it, and I'll give credit if someone points out the creator of the joke. It perfectly illustrates what I think developers (especially consultants) have to go through all the time when they're interviewing for the next gig."> <meta data-preact-helmet name="twitter:description" content="Dominate The Male Enhancement Niche Today with Aizen Power The following joke was posted to an internal Magenic list. I don't know who actually wrote it, and I'll give credit if someone points out the creator of the joke. It perfectly illustrates what I think developers (especially consultants) have to go through all the time when they're interviewing for the next gig."> Then, the body contains: <span>Dominate The Male Enhancement Niche Today with </span><strong><a href="https://getaizenpower24.com/start/index.php#aff=aboel3z" rel="nofollow ugc noopener">Aizen Power</a></strong> Looks like a link to a really sleazy ad, but the name of the product is put into metadata seemingly to improve its SEO.
- quickthrower2 3y ago. Edit: might be a one off.
- Yhippa 3y agoDo you know if these ads are injected or if the authors are doing this? This is really gross.
- KTibow 3y agoTo be honest the whole article seems like backlink spam. If you look with your eyes at the rendered article, you'll see a link to the supplement at the top, some links to a book about carpenters when it says "carpenter", and a extended blurb about the supplement at the bottom. (the original was on a personal site: https://web.archive.org/web/20230325234744/http://www.jasonbock.net/JB/News/Item/7c334037-d1a9-437d-9fa6-506e2f35eaac https://web.archive.org/web/20230325234744/http://www.jasonb...)
- irjustin 3y agoI really hope this article only represents a handful of companies and not a material percentage. My true hope is: ------ Interviewer: We brought in some frames, please help me construct a part of a house Carpenter: *bang* *bang* *bang* - *completes* Interviewer: I noticed you did this but didn't true up the corners. Can you walk me through this: Carpenter: While it visually looks more impressive, the long term stresses by forcing it to move the 5" causes it to break and needing replacement/repair within 4-6 years. Keeping it uneven is a better long term solution without sacrificing its load bearing ability. ------ Or, You know... building stuff. (everything above is made up - i have no idea how to frame a house)
- vandyswa 3y agoInsane. I could consistently sit in a room with a candidate for an hour, and at the end describe which positions they could handle, which would be a stretch, and which would be a fiasco. I ended up being a bit of a candidate whisperer. But the truth is simply that if you speak clearly and listen closely, you'll learn more than enough in an hour. All this madness is to avoid developing these important skills. It's sad.
- paiute 3y agoAgreed, i spend a couple minutes verifying their resume through fizz buzz type questions. Then figure out how they react when they don’t know something. Make sure they can collaborate. At this point you get a decent idea of how that person fits, or doesn’t. It really only takes 20 minutes of tech questions and 10 of shooting the shit. Pro-tip for getting hired with most interviewers is to get them to do most of the talking and parrot back what they say they want.
- 000ooo000 3y agoYep, it doesn't take all that much work to size up a candidate and whether you can work together. You can get a good feel for them just by having a chat like normal people. Maximum half hour.
- neilv 3y agoSame here. It's also important to set the tone from the start of the interview, that what's wanted is pretty candid, genuine discussion between colleagues. Otherwise, people so conditioned to the conventional BS interview rituals might do that mode. Which is absolutely not what you'd want from an engineering colleague. And BS mode in interview context makes it harder to see what they'd be like to work with, and raises the question of why they're doing that mode. (IME, most people seem to get the desired tone instantly, or within moments.)
- quickthrower2 3y agoBecause there is no skin in the game. A C# programmer can write Java, but it might take them 3 months to be as fast as an already Java experienced programmer. And a coder can leave at any time. There is no long termism unfortunately. So this is the equivalent of not wanting to hire someone who has only been a waiter as barstaff or vice versa, and not wanting to train them, when people are changing job every 6 months. Google can't afford to be like this, with all their systems no one else uses!
- linker3000 3y agoHappens to (potential) castle designers too. This structure was built as a showpiece. It's about 5 miles from where I live and sits alone atop a tall hill. It's a very atmospheric place. https://www.lovethesouthdowns.org.uk/places/hiorne-tower https://www.lovethesouthdowns.org.uk/places/hiorne-tower