6 ms·
X Bans and Then Unbans Journalists and Podcasters in Latest Free Speech Massacre
- paulpauper 3y agoMusk's mistake, as others mention, was positioning himself as a free speech absolutist, which was a promise he could not possibly keep, nor did he really want to. He's following the same sort of approach as other tech CEOs.
- consumer451 3y agoSure, but most people are self-aware, or just aware, enough not to claim to be one. edit: the parent comment has been edited since my reply, it used to make a bit more sense.
- zzzeek 3y agothere is of course a model for making completely outrageous, easily disproven assertions and running with them without ever having to walk them back, and it's called Donald Trump. Musk keeps trying to use the same playbook but lacks the skills.
- consumer451 3y agoThe idea of the firehose of falsehood predates Trump. > The Russian "Firehose of Falsehood" Propaganda Model > Why It Might Work and Options to Counter It https://www.rand.org/pubs/perspectives/PE198.html https://www.rand.org/pubs/perspectives/PE198.html
- Nas808 3y agoHe seems to spout a lot of things about free speech, and about how Twitter is the only place to get your voice heard without censorship, etc. But if a journalist crosses him or pens an article that paints one of his companies in a negative light... they're gone.
- logicchains 3y ago>but who is The guy who runs GAB, pretty much everything that's not pornography is allowed there.
- threatofrain 3y agoHow can people still be on the free speech narrative? PG and a lot of other famous people got punished just for the mere mention of 3rd-tier chat platforms. Imagine you're setting a standard on free speech and you draw the line at the mention of Mastodon.
- consumer451 3y agoI have a related question. What are some plausible explanations as to why community notes still exist? The most charitable explanation is that Musk believes in the concept, even though it is often used against him and his online friends. A less charitable explanation would be that some regulation requires it. Maybe the consent decree? Would anyone who is better informed on the matter care to share an opinion?
- numpad0 3y agoMaybe it's just not bad at all for impressions and engagement metrics?
- bigyikes 3y agoHaving listened to Musk speak on the topic: he seems to believe in community notes as an effective way to suss out truth in a less biased way. He sounds like a fan.
- dist-epoch 3y agoBut when he got Community Noted he called it state sponsored action: > Interesting. This Note is being gamed by state actors. Will be helpful in figuring who they are. Thanks for jumping in the honey pot, guys lmao! https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1733882978781053383 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1733882978781053383
- consumer451 3y agoI was just about to post this. And am I reading the situation correctly, did the note that he was complaining about get removed? I don't see one on the parent post.
- throw310822 3y agoIt's plausible that state actors would try to game community notes somehow. It's hard but no system is perfect and there are very refined actors out there.
- throwup238 3y ago"Free speech massacre"? The hyperbole has gotten out of hand but I for one can't wait for the first article title that starts with "C-C-C-C-COMBO BREAKER"
- smoothjazz 3y agoOn one hand, yes. On the other, there is a literal massacre of humans happening right now and this censorship is definitely related. So it is very dangerous in a real and urgent way.
- snapplebobapple 3y agoWhich one are you referring to there are too many ongoing for me to be certain and I don't want to think poorly of you for calling the military action in Gaza a massacre if you are referring to something else
- smoothjazz 3y agoYes, I'm speaking about the Israeli massacre of Palestinian civilians in Gaza and the West Bank.
- candiddevmike 3y agoA hyperbole about restricting free speech on a platform owned by a "free speech absolutist" will never get old.
- thegrim33 3y agoThey forgot to throw in a "surging"; that's their favorite hyperbole in recent years: "bans of journalists SURGING on X".
- skywhopper 3y ago[flagged]
- orand 3y ago
- im3w1l 3y ago[flagged]
- nickthegreek 3y agoYou consider it a good thing that the CEO has to get involved in mundane things like this? I would consider a failing. Ideally the CEO would fix the system, not just resolve it for the few powerful enough to get his attention.
- gjsman-1000 3y ago"Free Speech Massacre" I thought Gizmodo was on the team ranting against X having "free speech." But now that something went wrong with it, they are on the pro "free speech" side? We need a stronger word than hypocrite. Though, I shouldn't be surprised - G/O Media (who owns Gizmodo, Jezebel, Kotaku) is well known for being peddlers of poppycock.
- wredue 3y agoYou are confusing absolute free speech and free speech. Musk asserts that he subscribes to absolute free speech, but continuously shows that he most definitely does not, usually through being a thin skinned snowflake.
- brandonagr2 3y agoThat is not what Musk asserts, while it's an aspirational goal, he has always said twitter is limited by laws of the government they operate in.
- wredue 3y agoDude. lol. There are numerous tweets and clips of musk himself stating he is a free speech absolutist. This whole “within the confines of the law” only came out after he bought twitter and after advertisers left the platform out of fear of absolutist free speech.
- roywiggins 3y agoHe doesn't seem to be exactly eager to comply with various European laws: https://www.pbs.org/newshour/world/eu-investigates-x-over-potential-violations-of-social-media-law https://www.pbs.org/newshour/world/eu-investigates-x-over-po...
- themaninthedark 3y agoI thought the argument by those for censorship was in this order: 1. You have no right to hate speak. 2. Companies don't have to give you a platform. 3. It's not censorship unless the government is doing it! 4. Muh freez peach I guess we are now trying to walk back our previous declarations by saying that "Free Speech" and "Absolute Free Speech" are distinct things. How about instead we learn that if we censor and silence critics that the same tactics will be used by the other side, and a civilized society this does not make.
- throwaway4good 3y agoHow does accounts with 500.000 followers get mistakenly closed by a spambot? This is obviously related to the cancel-thy-neighbour over Israel/Palestine that is going on at the moment. Mr. Musk is just too shy to admit it.
- aerodog 3y agoElon isn't above lying
- IntelMiner 3y agoThe twitter meme of putting replies to ELO's "Mr Blue Sky" for every lie Elon has told would probably make the song go on for hours
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- taeric 3y agoThere is a decent related question for how many of those followers are legitimate? I think it is somewhat likely that any account with a lot of followers has a lot of bot followers. I could easily see any "clean up the bots" script being wrong on taking down some legitimate posters that are in the neighborhood of a lot of bots.
- threeseed 3y agoTwitter's bot system is fundamentally broken right now. If you look here you can see OpenAI being used en-masse across the platform all blue-ticked indicating that they will not be flagged as spam. And showing exactly what Musk said would not happen when he changed what blue-tick meant. https://www.threads.net/@parkermolloy/post/C14qS_CJp8q https://www.threads.net/@parkermolloy/post/C14qS_CJp8q
- darkwater 3y agoChatGPT bots are one of the worse problem of Twitter, but I really don't get how the math can work for them. Between the blue tick and the OpenAI API costs, how can they make actually some profit with subpar-quality tweets that leech from big accounts and basically redescribe the original post? What am I missing?
- mulligan 3y agoUseful to consider how many accounts that are not high profile were deleted and if these high profile accounts were a casualty ofa much more aggressive attempt to silence a segment of voices then then next question is, what is the criteria being used?
- runjake 3y agoThe subtitle of the article is "Elon Musk's "free speech" social media platform banned a number of accounts recently critical of Israel." Wasn't Elon widely deemed an antisemite last month? Edit: I wasn't being tongue-in-cheek. Perhaps we should not attribute to malice what we can attribute to incompetence -- especially in Elon's case.
- Stranger43 3y agoyes and this is likely twitter overcompensating after that fallout. Basically what this show is that firing your entire moderation team leads to inconsistent moderation as modern automation simply isn't up to the task of dealing with high-emotion topics.
- aredox 3y agoHe visited Israel a month ago. This man has the ideological orientation of a windvane.
- asylteltine 3y agoHe visited because he was called out for openly supporting complete psychos like Louis farakan. His advertisers increasingly wanted to disassociate with people like that so he was doing damage control.
- CamperBob2 3y agoHe's a puzzle. He's more than smart enough to understand that for someone in his position, the only winning move is to STFU. Yet his rational side always seems to lose these battles.
- aredox 3y agoHe's an idiot's idea of a smart person.
- IntelMiner 3y ago"He's more than smart enough to understand" Are you sure about that? Historical accounts of his actions and thoughts would disagree He famously wanted to move Paypal to Windows NT because "UNIX is for old junk mainframes!"
- jeffwask 3y agoDead platform continues to flail, news at 11.
- renewiltord 3y agoBSD is dead! Netcraft confirms!
- dylan604 3y agoUndead platform continues to flail, news at 11. Zombies have feelings too!
- pengaru 3y agoYet another headline reminding those who forgot that Twitter/X still exists...
- asylteltine 3y ago[flagged]
- throw310822 3y agoIf the accounts were suspended and almost immediately restored after Musk's intervention, couldn't the explanation be that some actors managed to trick the system into getting them banned (for example through a flood of reporting) rather than something initiated in Twitter itself?
- imchillyb 3y agoAn attack with immediate moderation seems the most plausible explanation, without further data.
- greenie_beans 3y agofirst discussed then flagged here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38927699 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38927699
- infamouscow 3y agoI don't really understand why the legacy media keeps reporting on X. Not only were they COMPLETELY wrong about X being days away from shuttering, these idiots are paying Elon for corporate subscription to keep using his platform. These are unserious people and should be regarded as nothing more than clowns. That's all they are. I can see why the talentless scumbags of Gizmodo are so terrified of ChatGPT taking their job, especially when the most broken ChatGPT results are more congruent with reality than the likes of their self-proclaimed journalists.
- dylan604 3y ago>I don't really understand Really? They have a massive pipeline built on generating content for their sites 100% dependent on mining Twit...er,X. It's really easy to understand if you're being honest about the situation. Just because you don't like the content doesn't mean the masses of sheeple feel the same way
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nashashmi 3y agoJournalists need to fine tune their words to smaller nets. Free speech does not mean any more what it used to mean. Change headline to "... in latest assault on political journalism." Or Pro-Palestinian journalism.
- numbers_guy 3y agoElon Musk on Lex Fridman, very soon after the latest violence started, made comments that appeared pro-Palestine, something along the lines of "Israel should safeguard Palestinian civilians and draw them away from Hamas with kindness." Soon after, they tried cancelling him, there was the infamous "go fuck yourselves" during that interview, and he visited Israel. Hard to say where he stands and who is pulling the strings, but it's interesting to follow.
- numpad0 3y agoOh, so Twitter ban-wave is a thing in the English world too? That has been a problem since long before the takeover, and I think it's also one of reasons why rather few aside from spammers use human names and sign up for paid plans. Twitter the system bans prominent accounts in frequency and amount for no discernible reasons(it's "Twitter Rules"). That had completely normalized ban evasions to the point even its support personnel sometimes suggested it in the past. Users won't pay to get banned[1]. Businesses can't rely on ID provider that unexist hard earned customers. People flee to competitors when the platform does this and require social graph reconstructions. It's not a new phenomenon, it's a plague somewhere within the system that needs to be fixed by a major re-architecture. 1: Anecdotally, but in fact I've seen users signing up for the paid Blue program when it was first introduced, hoping for preferential treatment for paid accounts with regard to bans, only to report back in disappointment - and I've seen it precisely because those users had promptly gone through the ban and evasion process and came back in the buzz.
- drak0n1c 3y agoIt's a private platform. Freedom of speech doesn't mean freedom from consequences. [XKCD showing affected pundits the door] https://xkcd.com/1357/ https://xkcd.com/1357/
- krapp 3y agoYou may be trying sarcasm here, but the "free speech absolutists" this argument was originally deployed against insisted such a right should not exist, and that freedom of speech meant the government should privatize social media and force platforms to publish content against their will, and make content moderation illegal. However no one here is claiming Musk doesn't or shouldn't have the right to run Twitter (I still refuse to call it X and will die on this hill) however he likes, rather people are just pointing out that he's a hypocrite and an asshole.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y ago> I have made posts critical of Israel’s targeting of civilians and journalists But they aren't targeting those groups.
- hermitcrab 3y agoLets let a petulant man-child control one of the most important media companies in the world. What could possibly go wrong?
- tourmalinetaco 3y ago“Important” is not what I would use to describe one of the most toxic and uninteresting cesspools to come out of the Internet.
- greenie_beans 3y agounfortunately that's why it's important. it's like a cesspool being upstream of a city's water source being an "important" problem.
- tourmalinetaco 3y agoIs it really upstream of the water source, or is it its own lake that sometimes, but not often, runs off into the water supply? The mainstream idea is that Twitter is important, but I haven’t seen much reason to agree. Most apps that rely on it could be served with an RSS feed. Most people I’ve met don’t use Twitter to any measurable degree. The amount of real world change the service has brought is rather low given how often it appears in mainstream media. In fact I see TikTok do more to influence and promote.
- greenie_beans 3y agoi don't think you realize how much culture moves on twitter. regardless of your personal opinion and your selection bias of nobody in your friend group using it. so much happens on twitter, still, even after elon musk has driven folks off of it.
- JoeAltmaier 3y agoFor people who give two F*s about Twitter. The rest of the world keeps revolving.
- incomingpain 3y agoFree speech massacre = antispam system? Gizmodo you can do better... I gave reddit another try during xmas break. I would copy and paste a sutta and reply on r/buddhism. A mod would come along and called me an idiot and wrong. I never really said anything myself lol, you cant really disagree with me. Literally a major violation of right speech, but they are a mod so they decide. I then go on my province subreddit and 11% of people have gotten the new covid booster. But if you have a viewpoint anything other pro-vaccine, you're not going to be allowed to speak. I was then on some major subreddit and I linked a recent vibrations kill cancer cells thing. I said 'cure to cancer?' and got banned for medical misinformation. Then I was on a vaguely trans subreddit, im trans. The person posted asking for help. They mentioned they have a feminine parts, they have an obgyn, etc. They never said their gender. I posted trying to help, and I accidentally misgendered them. They were upset greatly. Reddit admins gave me a warning for harassing/abusing them. Dont worry reddit admins, i'll ban myself from the tremendously toxic website. Meanwhile on X. I never have any problems at all. I actually have free speech. Amazing.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- iteratethis 3y agoIf you know enough about Musk, doing thoughtless, stupid, risky stuff that backfires is his play. Or not even a play, a default state of mind. He enjoys all this drama. We all believe we're punishing him by massively dunking on him, but we effectively reward him. The media too loves Musk, in the same way that they love Trump.