7 ms·
It doesn't matter how Apple markets it to consumers. The law was written in a certain technical way, and what's relevant here is whether it counts as 1 or 5 st
by crazygringo 3y ago
It doesn't matter how Apple markets it to consumers.
The law was written in a certain technical way, and what's relevant here is whether it counts as 1 or 5 stores according to the law.
It's the same way you could claim Amazon is 1 store, or 58 stores (1 for each country) or 2.5 million stores (for each third-party seller).
They're all correct for different purposes, and none of them have anything to do with whatever Amazon writes in marketing material.
Likewise, it's perfectly valid for Apple to argue that the law considers the size of an app store per operating system, since an app for one OS doesn't necessarily run on another.
The argument might succeed or it might not. But it doesn't have anything to do with marketing copy.
- ajross 3y agoThe DMA is an antitrust statute. While sure, you can argue that Apple operates different stores as a matter of implementation, it strains reason to claim that they somehow compete with each other. No, this argument is silly. Silly arguments aren't illegal, but it's hard to imaging this swaying any judges who aren't just looking for an excuse to find in one direction (which happens! which is why lawyers sometimes construct silly arguments to act as excuses).
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoBoth sides have to be consistent. If they lump all the app stores together to make an argument just about phones, for example, that won’t fly with judges.
- crazygringo 3y agoBut that's not what anybody is claiming. This is a simple bar the DMA set up that an app store has to be a particular minimum size for the law to apply. That has nothing to do with whether the app stores compete against each other. They don't have to. That's not the purpose here. There's nothing silly about Apple's argument. It's no different as to whether Microsoft has one app store for Windows and one for Xbox. It's not silly to say they're separate. Same thing for Apple Watch and Apple TV.
- smoldesu 3y ago> whether Microsoft has one app store for Windows and one for Xbox. It's not silly to say they're separate. At the same time... https://www.xbox.com/en-US/games/xbox-play-anywhere https://www.xbox.com/en-US/games/xbox-play-anywhere
- arghwhat 3y agoWhen dealing with antitrust, the general assumption is that you cannot trust the company (heh). It is rather obvious that a company will do their best to interpret themselves in a way where legislation is less applicable. In this particular case, the argument is silly: The users are presented with one storefront under one name, where apps can have different degrees of support, and apps can be installed on platforms they were not made for (e.g., iPhone apps on iPad or macOS) despite that they claim those are served by different "stores". If this argument was valid, you could also say that the Google Play store is not one store, but a gajillion stores for each individual Android device series - e.g., a Google Pixel phone store, a Google Pixel tablet store, a Google TV store, a Samsung phone store, a Samsung tablet store, a... It is incredibly silly, and serves only to avoid applying the legislation to e.g. Apple TV so they can keep avoiding sideloading and forcing subscription cuts there.
- crazygringo 3y agoIt is also rather obvious that companies are allowed to defend themselves. "Trust" is irrelevant here -- this is a court case about facts. And your Google Play example isn't analogous, because this isn't about "device series", it's about operating systems. Samsung and Pixel phones have the same OS and generally share the same set of installable apps. I'm not saying Apple's argument is necessarily going to win. I'm just saying that it's not "silly" -- we shouldn't dismiss it like that. Because this isn't about some "common sense" idea of what constitutes a store in consumer's eyes, it's about how this particular law defines a store, for the purposes of this law only, in technical terms.
- stale2002 3y ago> Because this isn't about some "common sense" idea of what constitutes a store in consumer's eyes You misunderstand the law. Common sense is bedrock defining feature of the law. There are all sorts of laws that have words and interpretations which could be argued either way. And the way that we choose between those interpretations is often through things like juries. IE, an every day layman's "common sense". > it's about how this particular law defines a store, And how that law defines a store, and could be interpreted between competing definitions is through common sense. It's through a human, a person, using their common sense to understand the law, and ultimately decide if that is how a store is defined.
- asdajksah2123 3y ago> The law was written in a certain technical way That's not how the law works. That's why all those Sovereign Citizens don't get to make their own laws up, even if they may have found a technical out. The spirit of the law also matters, beyond just the technical wording of the law.
- Kilenaitor 3y agoCourts are the ones that interpret them. That's why Apple's argument is made to an EU court, not legislature.
- EPWN3D 3y agoIt's not that cut and dry -- "the spirit of the law" is not a get-out-of-jail-free card for poorly-drafted legislation. That's why we have courts. They'll weigh the text of the law versus the drafted text versus the equities of imposing this level of regulation on Apple.
- mschuster91 3y ago> The law was written in a certain technical way, and what's relevant here is whether it counts as 1 or 5 stores according to the law. European judges don't really look favourable on defendants attempting to circumvent laws on technicialities - they also take the reasoning behind a law into account. This crucial difference is what many American companies learn the hard way when they try to bulldoze their way through European laws.
- yxhuvud 3y agoUh, that sort of depends on what part of EU you are speaking of. The Romance countries does not have the same legal traditions as as the ones based on the English way (even if uk is gone, there are others that share tradition with them), and the Scandinavian countries are different to both.
- seabass-labrax 3y agoThe court relevant to this case is the General Court of the European Union. Each member state can put forward up to two judges each. Given the current composition of the EU, that seems to me to be broadly equal between the Germanic and Romance traditions (although I am quite aware of the limitations of such an academic division).
- ryandrake 3y ago> The law was written in a certain technical way, and what's relevant here is whether it counts as 1 or 5 stores according to the law. It's the same way you could claim Amazon is 1 store, or 58 stores (1 for each country) or 2.5 million stores (for each third-party seller). IMO this culture of "Rules Lawyering" and being technically correct is one of the reasons why everything is so shitty and why companies always seem to get away with bad behavior in the US. This is the corporate version of a six year old waving his hands 2 millimeters in front of his sister's face saying "I'm not touching you! I'm not touching you!" Yes, the marketing material is totally irrelevant and should be considered fiction, but I would hope that a judge would look at the actual end-user experience is in totality, rather than accepting some silliness like "look, it's 5 different IP addresses, so ackshually it's 5 different stores!" or whatever the technicality-driven argument will be.
- kristjansson 3y agoThere's nothing _but_ 'rules lawyering'. All good intentions that hope to have an impact on the real world have to be reified as policy, which has to be implemented as law, which usually delegates specifics to rules-making. We can be disappointed that ultimate product of that process often falls well short of the original intention, but laws and rules are wildly preferable implementation of policy than judgement alone.
- linkgoron 3y agoThat's just not true. A lot of judicial systems give leeway for judges to rule using the spirit of the law and not just the letter of the law. Especially for obviously fake arguments, or when laws need updating to newer norms or unforeseen technologies.
- kristjansson 3y agoJudicial interpretation is essential. Half the artifice of western civilization is built on the word 'reasonable' and its interpretations in caselaw. However judgement cannot be the primary definition of a policy. 'I know it when I see it' couldn't even be the definition of obscenity - the court repaired it 10 years later with a more clearly delineated test in Miller. The definition of 'platform' or 'monopoly' or w/e in the context of TFA is necessarily going to be technical and detailed, and encourage the entities it regulates to drive right up to the lines it draws. The job of the policymaker is to draw lines that accomplish her intentions.
- libertine 3y agoThen they falsely advertise their Appstore, claiming it's one unified system when in reality it's not. And after that's settled, then it's just a matter of taking this case and breaking it into the number of stores they have, because they still have the monopoly of each system. Hopefully, the EU courts can see past this silliness and just steamroll over it - as an EU citizen, I do hope we've passed the point of having massive corporations dodge their responsibilities due to legal technicalities.
- heisenbit 3y agoThe beauty of being a regulator is that you have a lot of leeway when it comes to interpreting your rules. Apples disrespectful approach is certainly not going down well and even if it is intended play for time will cost them more than they gain.