4 ms·
From the article: >Debate about whether to adopt the longer recording standard weighs considerations about cost and privacy implications against safety. >The
by gruez 3y ago
From the article:
>Debate about whether to adopt the longer recording standard weighs considerations about cost and privacy implications against safety.
>The U.S. FAA has previously rejected the NTSB's call for mandating the retrofitting aircraft with new cockpit voice recorders, saying the costs would be significant at $741 million versus $196 million under incremental upgrades it proposed.
>Pilots have also opposed the move, with the union representing pilots for air-freight company Atlas Air telling the FAA the longer recordings would be an invasion of worker privacy.
Whether or not a "technical barrier" exists is a non-sequitur. Just because you can get a $10 audio recorder on aliexpress that records 200 hours, doesn't mean it takes $10 to implement this change per plane.
- amelius 3y ago> Whether or not a "technical barrier" exists is a non-sequitur. Just because you can get a $10 audio recorder on aliexpress that records 200 hours, doesn't mean it takes $10 to implement this change per plane. I bet many investigators would be very happy with the aliexpress implementation ...
- rob74 3y agoIn this case the aliexpress implementation would have worked, but not in cases where the aircraft is literally pulverized on impact, like in the 737 MAX crashes of 2018 and 2019 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethiopian_Airlines_Flight_302 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethiopian_Airlines_Flight_302 - "The aircraft impacted the ground at nearly 700 miles per hour (610 kn; 1,100 km/h) [...] Both the cockpit voice recorder and the flight data recorder were recovered from the crash site on 11 March.")
- freeopinion 3y agoYou've constructed a false dichotomy. You can have the current 2-hour system and a cheap 24-hour system at the same time. Then you can gradually harden the new addon. This could be a way to make it all even more expensive.
- hef19898 3y agoI hope you don't design avionic systems, or any other safety critical piece of hard or software...
- striking 3y agoHardware is hard. There are so many more things that can go wrong. If your cheap 24-hour system decides to self-immolate, it might be the cause of the incident rather than just help determine what the cause was.
- LewisVerstappen 3y agoYou can make up 1000 different potential failure modes to try and make yourself feel smart.
- mulmen 3y agoAnd you can ignore those failure modes and kill hundreds of people at a time.
- freeopinion 3y agoDid you conduct the extensive study into all the possible failure modes if we allow pilots to wear smart watches? Or cork-soled shoes? It is appropriate to use caution and care. You are right about that. It is obstructionist to demand every possible mode of failure be used as an excuse to block progress. It is possible to use flaky hardware that will increase risk. But it isn't that hard or expensive to use reasonable care to avoid it while dramatically improving the tech. To pretend that any new tech would automatically lead to hundreds of deaths and should therefore never be considered is ridiculous on its face.
- mulmen 3y agoAirlines have dress codes for pilots. “Reasonable care” is expensive for airline grade hardware. You don’t just add features because they sound good. You don’t throw tech at the wall and see what sticks. You engineer reasonable solutions to real problems. It’s nothing like building a webpage.
- hef19898 3y agoI am fairly certain NTSB flight incident investigators understand fully well the safety implication of integrating an AliExpress recorder in the avionics suite of an aircraft. And wouod hence oppose such an idea quite strongly.
- dclowd9901 3y agoCounterpoint: what price would it have to cost to make it not worth doing? I contend the actual cost will almost invariably be less than that.
- peteradio 3y agoIf privacy is the concern then it seems it would need to be bound to a certain protocol where in the event of an anomaly the transcript continues on for some extremely long time effectively unbounded by typical flight scenarios. The current situation acts as a backdoor to deletion.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bpicolo 3y agoIt makes sense that retrofitting is expensive - that's labor and plane downtime for 5-7k commercial jets. This airplane was brand new. It should be using something more modern.
- smallmind 3y agoCost of retrofitting? This particular Alaska MAX 9 is a plane that was just built and delivered late 2023. The 737 MAX family only went into service in 2017. Im starting to wonder if the yet to be certified 777X will store for more than 2 hours as it takes 16 hour flights.
- hef19898 3y ago25 hours if sold (operated?) to EASA regulated carriers.
- gen3 3y agoIt doesn't need to be a cheap aliexpress recorder. Couldn't they just drop in whichever 25hr recorder is used in Europe? Already tested and probably installed in the same type of plane
- glitcher 3y ago> the longer recordings would be an invasion of worker privacy Workers responsible for multi-million dollar machines and sometimes hundreds of human lives. I doubt anyone but the pilots care one bit about their on-the-job privacy.
- hef19898 3y agoI do. Because pilots being worried about what they say in the cockpit can have a negative impact on their reaction times, behaviour and crew management. All.of ehich can negatively impact flight safety. I want my pilots to feel comfortable while flying.
- paranoidrobot 3y agoThe privacy concerns can be mitigated by some rule changes. Mandate the 25hr recording duration. Mandate that full playback can only be done for accident investigation purposes By NTSB, unless requested by the crew(s). Some limited duration carve-out to allow maintenance crews to listen to last 15 mins to verify operation.
- hef19898 3y agoAgree. And I assume that in this case unions would oppose the 25 hour recordings.
- t0mas88 3y ago
- flandish 3y ago> privacy That’s silly. And we all know it. Nothing in a cockpit is “private” in this regard when it comes to transport of hundreds of people. > cost There it is. That’s all it ever is. If the cost of doing it right is higher than the fines of gambling with doing it wrong, the wrong way will always be chosen. This is bog standard corporate life under capitalism.
- SoftTalker 3y agoThis is incorrect. It's not cost, if cost were the concern we would not have recorders at all. Cearly the cost of a longer recording is inconsequential once you have agreed to install a recorder at all. It is about privacy, it's easy to verify the history of pilot's unions concerns and objections.
- flandish 3y ago> at all Incorrect. This is a struggle of ratio between regulation and lobby..
- purpleblue 3y agoIf pilots have a privacy problem with it, then put the onus on pilots to not forget to turn off the recording. If they forget, they should be held accountable, ie lose their piloting license. Otherwise, they can't have it both ways, saying "we need our privacy" and also "it's not our fault we forgot to save the recording!"
- t0mas88 3y agoEasy to armchair quarterback. But it's quite reasonable for the overall workforce to have some objections against 24x7 recording of everything they say. I'm surprised the Hacker News crowd, often quite pro-privacy and anti tracking, does not understand that. And then suggesting to revoke the licenses of a crew that at one of the most stressful moments in their career, right after a major incident, forgets to pull a circuit breaker is ridiculous. Luckily that is not how things in the aviation industry are done.
- Ekaros 3y agoOn other hand I don't find 25 hours being recorded unreasonable with some of the very long flights we now have like 17-19 hours. Something early in flight could be critical clue in incident analysis.
- t0mas88 3y agoIndeed, the FAA has just proposed to start doing that for new aircraft. Same as Europe where this has been put in place for aircraft manufactured from 2021 onwards. The problem in the US is that there has also been more disciplinary use of the recordings (by the company, not the NTSB). In Europe things are a bit more strictly regulated and there wasn't any resistance to the 25 hour change.