3 ms·
> Secondly, I don't think they used the "no evidence" template so much with COVID because they were "fundamentally confused". Most of the headlines in those exa
by marcosdumay 3y ago
> Secondly, I don't think they used the "no evidence" template so much with COVID because they were "fundamentally confused". Most of the headlines in those examples are clearly politically motivated
Whence motivating the popular reaction that understands an authority claiming "no evidence" as strong evidence of the thing.
It's a correct reaction way more often than it's wrong. But it steals the possibility from scientists to claim that despite several studies looking for it, there's no evidence (e.g. of vaccines causing autism).
Or, in other words, what those politicians did is an irresponsible society-destroying act. They should be held accountable for it.
- SiempreViernes 3y agoWhat? I have no idea what you tried to say here...
- nkurz 3y agoHe's saying that in a politicized world (like the one we live in) the use of the phrase "no evidence" is a sign that the author is lying to you. He's claiming that if you if read a story by someone in power which claims "No evidence for X", you should update toward "X is probably true but politically inconvenient". He's not claiming this is logical, only that empirically it's a good strategy. A parallel might be that if the board of a company in the midst of a scandal puts out a statement saying "We have full faith in the CEO", your actual conclusion should be that the CEO is on their way out. This isn't what the words mean, but in practice it often turns out to be the right bet to make.