6 ms·
Short sellers lost more betting against Tesla than any other company last year
- angelgonzales 3y agoI support a person or organization’s right to invest in whatever they want. I also think that maybe people are being deluded or misguided by some media outlets so they think that Tesla is in a worse position than it is, or maybe they just didn’t time the market correctly. I do think it’s un-American to short sell a great American company like Tesla though. Many people work for the company and they make great products. I’m reminded of the fact that Bill Gates was shorting Tesla while asking Elon for philanthropic donations.
- gizmo 3y agoYou can’t have a market without buyers and sellers. The only way to get tesla shares is by buying them from another person. It doesn’t matter whether the seller has 100 shares left after selling to you, or -100. The financial transaction is the same. One person believes the shares will go up and buys. The other believes the opposite and sells. It’s not “un-American”. If anything, the superstition that that short selling harms companies or the economy is “un-American”. It’s good when badly operated businesses go bankrupt. The employees can then work somewhere else where they can make a better contribution to society. Keeping zombie companies alive is bad. (And Tesla made over a million cars last year; bankwuptcy is not happening anytime soon.)
- DaveExeter 3y agoElon?
- kvdveer 3y agoFor a substantial part, Tesla stock is not valued based on its underlying fundamentals, but on its polularity as a David vs Goliath story, and on Elons charisma/character. The latter two won't likely yield actual value, so financially speaking ste stock is highly overvalued. That said, I'd never bet against it, because those two factors are entirely dominant in TSLA valuation.
- wcunning 3y ago"The market can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent" has been a financial truism for a long time. Tesla is just the most glaring and recent example of it.
- aantix 3y agoWill Tesla be the one to solve self driving?
- wyre 3y agoNo. Tesla calling their cruise control Autopilot is a gross overstatement, meanwhile Cruise and Wayne has rolled out actual driverless vehicles and Honda released the first Level 3 autonomous vehicle to Japan last March [1]. [1] https://web.archive.org/web/20210305144526/https://mainichi.jp/english/articles/20210304/p2g/00m/0bu/109000c https://web.archive.org/web/20210305144526/https://mainichi....
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoI thought calling it autopilot was an understatement. All auto pilot does on an airplane is keep the plane flying in a straight line. Cruise controls on modern cars slow down and can keep a lane. It’s telling that Tesla doesn’t call it’s FSD “autopilot”, using the term instead for modern cruise control features that most other higher end new cars have.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- grecy 3y ago> Tesla stock is not valued based on its underlying fundamentals I'm no Musk fan with his latest comments, but I disagree with this quite strongly. Have a look at how many vehicles Toyota have produced for the last 10 years, and have a look at their stock price. Take a guess at their stock price in 10 more years. It's a flat line Now have a look at the number of vehicles Tesla have produced in the last ten years. Now guess at their stock price in 10 more years. There is a chance Tesla will make 20 million vehicles by 2030. If they do, their stock price will go up a lot. There really is not much chance of Toyota doing that. (they're not trying to)
- MichaelRo 3y agoWho cares what gamblers lost? "Betting on/against" whatever company isn't trading. It's not arbitrage, it doesn't have an edge, it's just fingers crossed hope for the best gambling. And of all gambles, shorting is the worst. By all I mean "long or short", so I guess there isn't much variation left when you leave shorting out. But with going long on a company at least you can buy and forget. Maybe it bounces back up. Not today or this year but eventually. With shorting though, it's pure loss. On top of the interest the lender is charging you for the stock that they loaned to you (some 2% last time I checked, when reference rate was pretty much zero). Unlike long where you earn interest (dividends). So unless you got a really really good reason to short (insider knowledge, some solid stat arb reasoning)... don't do it. Or if you do it, I won't weep for you when you lose.
- tempestn 3y agoThis is all true, but it's a bit of a shame as it puts a limit on market efficiency. To take an extreme example, every rational person knew that Gamestop wasn't worth $20B+. (Or even close to what it's trading at now.) But given the costs and risks of shorting, there was (is) no way for most traders to profit off of that with a reasonable risk/reward, and so the mispricing persists. Tesla could be seen as a less extreme example of the same. Unlike Gamestop, it's a very successful company with a lot going for it. But was it ever really worth more than every other car company combined?
- jliptzin 3y agoIf it’s making more profit per vehicle than all other car companies combined, while continuing to grow its business at a rapid clip, then do you think that justifies the market cap? https://www.visualcapitalist.com/charted-teslas-unrivaled-profit-margins/ https://www.visualcapitalist.com/charted-teslas-unrivaled-pr... Or what about rapidly growing revenue every year, which no other car company is currently able to do? https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/TSLA/tesla/revenue https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/TSLA/tesla/revenue
- wredue 3y ago
- gizmo 3y agoThese articles never take into account what investor’s NET exposure is. An investor who has a lot of tesla shares might write calls to collect premium. Or buy puts for downside protection. Or short tesla shares to offset out-of-the-money calls. Or maybe an investor has a large position in an ETF that has a position in tesla. If the investor wants to be neutral tesla he has to short the stock in order to cancel out the tesla exposure through the ETF. I don’t know why the subject of short selling makes peoples brains melt.
- o11c 3y ago> I don’t know why the subject of short selling makes peoples brains melt. Because it's an easy target among the financial world, which is divorced from reality in general.
- jakderrida 3y ago> which is divorced from reality in general. It's not exactly divorced from reality. You can synthetically create the very same position. While it sounds like what they're doing is attacking markets and economy, that's just not the case. Unless they made both the options and derivatives markets illegal and also made borrowing and lending stock shares illegal, shorting the security is a position that can easily be created. It was organically discovered at the Amsterdam Stock Exchange within like a couple years after it was founded. The exchange didn't invent it and start offering it either. The traders simply realized that if they could borrow/lend and buy/sell, then they can take an inverse position.
- o11c 3y agoOh, I agree that the hate for short-sellers is overdone. But the financial world (and the stock market in particular) forces the detachment of "profit" from "(useful) productivity", and this is clear to everyone, even if they don't express it like that.
- nateglims 3y agoWith Tesla specifically, Elon promotes a "short sellers are evil" line.
- dachworker 3y agoWhat sets Tesla apart from other automakers is not the product, but their attitude as a company. Say tomorrow flying cars become feasible. I can believe that Toyota or BMW or Ford might get around to building a flying car. I KNOW that Tesla will jump right into building one.
- dzhiurgis 3y agoFWIW “flying car” aka evtol has recently been certified in China. If Tesla solves autonomy I can see them jump right into it.
- jddj 3y agoThe article says that as a group short sellers are estimated to have lost 12B. It then goes on to say that in '22 they, as a group, likely made 15B. Not much else to it. Attention-grabbing estimate leads to an article whose detail eventually dulls it down. News at 11.
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- __loam 3y ago"The market can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent"
- apienx 3y agoThe Tesla Model Y is 2023’s top selling vehicle model in the world. Plus, the Cybertruck is the most hyped/anticipated car in history. The current market valuation may not be rational, but betting against such a disruptive company is foolish.
- grumpyprole 3y agoThe Cypertruck design is also weird, impractical and difficult to manufacture. Maybe that's probably a good reason to bet against?
- threeseed 3y ago> Plus, the Cybertruck is the most hyped/anticipated car in history No it's not. And look at the Tesla forums around. It is a massive disappointment in terms of range, price, off-road capabilities, repairability etc.
- dzhiurgis 3y agoOn flip side - look at driving reviews and people loosing marbles how good it is.
- andrepd 3y agoThe market can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent.
- xyst 3y ago“Markets can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent”