4 ms·
I mean, Graeber and Marx aren't really taught in Econ degrees either. Nor is Adam Smith for that matter. They're all basically dealing with the philosophy of e
by alephnerd 3y ago
I mean, Graeber and Marx aren't really taught in Econ degrees either. Nor is Adam Smith for that matter.
They're all basically dealing with the philosophy of economics, but economics has transitioned away from being a qualitative field to a quantitative one.
Now Econ majors are expected to read Baby Rudin by their first year in top undergrad programs.
Source: attempted to become an Econ major in first year. Realized I don't have it in me to do analysis, so became a CS and PoliSci double instead, still got the Econ minor though.
Also take a look at EJMR (Econ and Finance's version of HN) - https://www.econjobrumors.com/topic/why-baby-rudin-is https://www.econjobrumors.com/topic/why-baby-rudin-is
- wheelinsupial 3y agoHas EJMR changed and started moderating? I stopped going to EJMR because it was far too much trolling, shit posting, racism, and other bad takes.
- alephnerd 3y agoNope. Still a shithole, but at least the trolls there are upfront unlike on HN where they try to hide behind psudeo-rationalism. Also, it's the only safe space for academics to vent. Plenty of professors who were sexual predators were initially outed on EJMR, so that has value. In addition, the debates about economics or econometrics related topics is much less brain dead than here.
- shove 3y agoneeding to move economics’ goalposts to the extent Marx is now considered irrelevant to the field of economics only goes to show how influential he’s been. The current practitioners disagree with him? Sure, fine, but to say he’s irrelevant is absurd. He’s easily one of the most influential thinkers in the space.
- alephnerd 3y agoHe's as irrelevant as Adam Smith is in 2023. The world is much more complex in the 21st century than it was during that time. Also, Marx and Adam Smith are as relevant to Econ in 2023 as Ada Lovelace is in CS in 2023.