6 ms·
Tex-Oberon: Make Project Oberon Pretty Again
- cstross 3y agoI can't find the bibliographic details for the 2013 edition, but the 1992 one was published by Addison-Wesley, so it's quite possible that anyone participating in this project to "liberate" the text will get a cease-and-desist from Pearson Plc's legal department/anti-piracy people. Caveat: the 2013 edition doesn't seem to be available via Amazon so may well be formally out of print. In which case, Wirth's heirs can issue a rights reversion letter to Addison-Wesley and claw the rights back, then relicense the text libre. Or they may already have other plans for re-issuing the book. Either way, it'd be polite to ask first before "liberating".
- dchest 3y agoThe book and software is under the MIT-like license https://people.inf.ethz.ch/wirth/ProjectOberon/license.txt https://people.inf.ethz.ch/wirth/ProjectOberon/license.txt
- cstross 3y agoThat's a good starting place, then. (It's still polite to ask/let the heirs know what you're doing.)
- kragen 3y agowirth has published his project under an open-source license, guaranteeing everyone everywhere the freedom to study, copy, modify, and redistribute it forever you're suggesting offering his heirs the opportunity to revoke that license how can you possibly think this is a good idea? if it became a widespread practice, it would result in a million lawsuits like the sco lawsuit, utterly destroying free software. is that what you want?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lifeisstillgood 3y agoA fantastic idea, and also the philosophy behind Oberon is something I think we shall need more of - as the operating system for a computer is now conceptually the operating system for a network, a cluster of computers, for an organisation, a government, having one company’s “operating system” not only be defined in software, but enable that software to fit in one head, that seems important in ways that otherwise make us throw up our hands and say “it’s all rigged” or “they are all the same” or “who knows, let’s just keep going”
- tcbawo 3y agoCan anyone recommend this book as a first resource for a young teenager to teach themselves about computer science and coding (with some guidance and assistance from myself)? He has a strong interest in making games, but has stalled out with his attempts at programming so far (a handful of books and YouTube videos). I think learning from first principles would be most effective, but our earlier attempt with Nand2tetris might have been a little too low level to hold his interest.
- 48864w6ui 3y agoNo (see the earlier discussion for this book's prereqs)
- tcbawo 3y agoThere have been many posts and much discussion on this book since Wirth’s passing. Looking around, I found some discussion that describes this book more as a description of a complete system than an introduction that describes how it gets there. I don’t think this necessarily disqualifies it as a beginner’s book. Having a reference description of a complete system that one can fit in one’s head might be a great resource for a beginning programmer. If anyone has read/used this book before, I would love to hear their opinion about where it best fits in their journey.
- cxr 3y agoThis is a hardcore CS book. It's not for beginners. It's not even really a good fit for an American-style CS undergrad course on operating systems. That's before getting into all the errata for the places where what was written in the book diverges from the actual system implementation.
- tcbawo 3y agoThank you for elaborating on my question. I haven’t read the book, so I have no idea where it fits into a general curriculum. Having grown up in the 8-bit home computing era where a user could wrap their head around the entire computer and OS, the idea of building a broad base of fundamentals sounds attractive. Would you put this at the same level of difficulty as SICP, which another commenter suggested?
- ajkjk 3y agoIt is still a bit irritating to see the phrasing "make X Y again" in any context ever. Would really rather not have... any of... the associations that it gives.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bob66666 3y ago[dead]
- Nadya 3y agoGiving people the power to change your way of speech or way of thinking is how you let them have power and control over you. It gives them strength when they should be seen as weak. It empowers them. If you detest what a certain phrase might stand for - work towards changing what it stands for. Don't give it away freely and without a fight. You do a disservice to yourself and everyone else.
- ajkjk 3y agoWeird reply. I can't tell, are you agreeing or disagreeing or something else?
- Nadya 3y agoDisagreeing. It's like nobody paid any attention to the gay community in the late 90s/early 00's. Words are only given power over you when you cower from them and by doing so you help show that those words can have power over others too. You only harm yourself and others by doing so. It triggers me whenever I see people ceding words like this - and this particularly annoyed me because it wasn't only ceding the phrase "makes America great again" but any phrase of the same grammatical construct! Growing up trans I was called every name and slur in the book because people learned from others that those slurs might have power over me. The bullies had learned from other trans people that those words had power. That they could make me cry or feel weak or powerless if they held those words over my head. I never gave them that satisfaction though. My response was aways "Yeah, and?" which I had learned from the gay community. And I hate, rather strongly at that, anyone who helps those words retain power so that they can continue to be used to bully other trans children. Never give words power over you. By doing so you give them power over others. If a word or phrase bothers you so strongly - reclaim it. Turn it into something you control - don't let it be wielded like a stick to hit you with. Why willingly turn it into a weapon that people can use against you? That goes as much for slurs as it does for "make X Y again". It pisses me off is all.
- tux1968 3y agoDirect link to the current release of pdf, generated from his work so far: https://github.com/guidoism/tex-oberon/releases/download/v0.9.9/oberon.pdf https://github.com/guidoism/tex-oberon/releases/download/v0....
- chrismorgan 3y ago(2022)
- jagged-chisel 3y agoCan someone detail the differences from the original? Looks subtle to me. How are we defining “pretty?”
- tux1968 3y agoBeing "pretty" seems to be an editorial comment from the person who posted this link. At least, I don't see that claim being prominent anywhere in the Github repo. The goals of the project are rather to extricate the text from pdf format, to make it more available and adaptable.
- Sardtok 3y agoThe title of the project on Github is Make Project Oberon Pretty Again, it's not something added to the HN post. "The last edition -- from 2013 -- could use some tender loving care. It should look beautiful." - the paragraph that introduces the goals of the project.
- codeflo 3y agoI'm not sure if you've found a better version of the original, but this is the document I found: https://people.inf.ethz.ch/wirth/ProjectOberon/PO.System.pdf https://people.inf.ethz.ch/wirth/ProjectOberon/PO.System.pdf It's typeset in Arial. In freaking Microsoft Word.
- codeflo 3y agoSome people rave about Oberon, and I think there are brilliant technical ideas in the system, and this is entirely subjective, but reading the language gives me a headache. At least Pascal allowed lower-case keywords. Does anyone know why Wirth never modernized his style? I wonder if there's a place for something that's equally minimalist, but more in line with current aesthetic sensibilities.
- michaelsbradley 3y agoNim? https://forum.nim-lang.org/t/10843#72291 https://forum.nim-lang.org/t/10843#72291
- thisislife2 3y ago> Does anyone know why Wirth never modernized his style? Readability. It's easier to read the source code with uppercase keywords. (I think Wirth once said that code is written once but read many times). See this source code - https://raw.githubusercontent.com/rochus-keller/OberonSystem3/master/Base64.Mod https://raw.githubusercontent.com/rochus-keller/OberonSystem... - to get an idea of this (the uppercase keywords allow you to easily scan the blocks of code). Ofcourse, one can claim that the same can be achieved better today with colour-coded keywords. If it really bothers you, I think the Oberon+ IDE - https://github.com/rochus-keller/Oberon https://github.com/rochus-keller/Oberon - gives you an option to disable this and use lowercase keywords.
- codeflo 3y ago> It's easier to read the source code with uppercase keywords. This is aesthetics, I won't claim that what I'm saying is more than a (perhaps popular) subjective opinion. But I will point out that at least the way I read programs, the KEYWORDS are the OPPOSITE of what I want to EMPHASIZE when reading code. I actually want the keywords to disappear so that my eyes can focus on the variable names and see the data flow. That, by the way, is also why punctuation to mark blocks { ... } is so much easier for me to visually parse than BEGIN ... END.
- 3y ago
- zvmaz 3y ago> Project Oberon is an amazing piece of computer science and amazing tool for teaching. The book and the code demonstrate, without any tiny amount of doubt, that it is possible to build a usable computing system small enough to fit in the head of a normal programmer. That, in my not-so-humble opinion, is a truly great achievement and I am in awe of Niklaus Wirth and Jürg Gutknecht for it. As I wrote in an earlier post, the enthusiasm of the author is contagious.
- JadeNB 3y agoThe capitalization stripped out by the title mangler is significant: Knuth's creation is called TeX, not Tex (and actually the X is a capital chi, Χ).
- namuol 3y agoA noble effort, no doubt. But it would be nice to see a web adaptation, since most of our reading happens on a multitude of screens these days. Might have a higher impact on readership than better typesetting.
- dataangel 3y agoIs there any copyright issue with the community editing and republishing as described in the README?
- cxr 3y agoIt's available under the ISC-style Project Oberon license. <http://www.projectoberon.net/wirth/ProjectOberon/license.txt http://www.projectoberon.net/wirth/ProjectOberon/license.txt>