12 ms·
How I Collect Passwords
- normalfaults 15y agoIt is fascinating how many passwords are available ... I wonder why websites don't stop one from using these common passwords during account setup?
- rrreese 15y agoI suspect that any sort of password enforcement would decrease sign ups in relation to its strictness. It would be an interesting thing to AB test.
- wglb 15y agoSome do, with rules about complexity: minimum length, mixture of different classes of characters (lower, upper, numeric, special). Beyond that, I am not aware of websites looking through something like his considerable list of passwords to rule out choices.
- TazeTSchnitzel 15y agoTwitter does. They banned (IIRC) the 123 most common passwords. They have a list, too.
- chrisacky 15y agoBecause it's intrusive. There are lots of opinions on how far a website should go to ensure their users select strong passwords, but I implement a strawman password roster. If some of the throwaway sites and forums that I sign up to once started forcing me to select a more secure password it would be extremely annoying and I wouldn't sign up. I'm perfectly happy with my 6 letter a-z password for one time forums, that I use anonymously, and that I might occassionally log back into twice. Incidentally, the password I use is "openit". This password means nothing to me. If you did some detective work on me I'm 100% sure that you would be able to get access to some sites that I use by entering that password. Not having to use symbols, capitals, and strong passwords for these throwaway sites, means that I can effectively maintain about 10 different password sets, where my most important "tier 1" passwords are reserved for my SSH keys and email.
- pavel_lishin 15y agoI'd be curious how many 'throwaway' passwords are "sesame".
- patio11 15y agocough $250 in sales from folks who chose "password" in 2011. I suppose I could tell them "Wait wait, put your credit card back for a second and listen to a complicated instruction designed to solve a problem you don't have.". Doesn't seem to be a huge upside, though.
- trin_ 15y agoand you know that because: a) you store cleartext passwords b) you use a static salt and have memorized the hash of the password+your salt ... or c) ???
- patio11 15y agoBecause even bcrypt doesn't make testing one candidate password against 1,500 users all that hard.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- mkjones 15y agoFacebook does - we have a blacklist of common passwords, and you cannot register an account with them or change your password to them. That being said, I think with sufficient protections against brute forcing, password complexity requirements are largely a waste of time. The percent of users' accounts you can get into with the number of attempts allowed before locking you out is so small that it's not cost-effective, and the majority of people trying to break into accounts are doing so at scale for financial gain.
- m8urn 15y agoHas Facebook ever shared that list?
- mkjones 15y agoIt's comprised in part of what we observed as the top hundred or so user passwords, so I'm hesitant to share it. I hope to do a more in-depth post about some stats we're able to run on password usage - I'll see if it makes sense to disclose (part of) our blacklist in there.
- eli 15y agooccasionally I will spend half a day leeching from these forums Man, I'm glad that's not my job
- pavel_lishin 15y agoSeems like it would be easily automatable with Greasemonkey, or dotjs.
- developer9 15y agoThe post was great, but it will only have impact if you share what you know in more detail with graphs and dataset.
- chris_wot 15y agoI have to say that I loved his other post on the TSA's ridiculous password policy... http://xato.net/passwords/worst-password-policy-ever http://xato.net/passwords/worst-password-policy-ever Their policy is: 1. Minimum password length is eight characters. 2. Passwords must contain at least one of each of the following: one alphabetic uppercase, one alphabetic lowercase, one numeric, and one special character. 3. Passwords shall not contain any two identical consecutive characters (example: 22apples, 14588904). 4. Passwords may contain no more than two identical consecutive characters in any position from the previous password. 5. Passwords shall not contain any dictionary word. 6. Passwords shall not contain any proper noun or the name of any person, pet, child, or fictional character. 7. Passwords shall not contain any employee serial number, Social Security number, birth date, phone number, or any information that could be readily guessed about the creator of the password. 8. Passwords shall not contain any simple pattern of letters or numbers, such as "qwerty" or "xyz123". 9. Passwords shall not be any word, noun, or name spelled backwards or appended with a single digit or with a two-digit "year" string, such as 98xyz123. 10. Pass phrases, if used in addition to or instead of passwords, should follow these same guidelines. 11. Passwords shall not be the same as the User 12. Password length will be selected to provide a level of protection commensurate to the value or sensitivity of the resources or data it protects, but not less than eight characters. You just can't make this stuff up!
- 13rules 15y agoWow ... their online security rivals their airport security!!
- chris_wot 15y agoWith all these restrictions, I wonder how far they are reducing the possible key space? Some of these suggestions actually remove a number of permutations - like for instance you can't put in two digit years - this must remove a HUGE number of combinations! Then you remove ALL the dictionary words, all proper names, all the TSAs serial numbers, all reversed words - well, that's gotta make cracking an 8 letter password easier :-)
- JoshMock 15y ago+1 for using KeePass, 1Password, etc.
- HorizonXP 15y agoI use Revelation on Ubuntu. It hasn't been maintained in quite some time though, I should pick up the code base and update it.
- thereallurch 15y agoSurprised no one has mentioned OpLop for passwords. I keep a list of sites (containing a site nickname and a password hint). I then wrote a simple md5base64 perl script which combines the nickname and password (similar to OpLop..basically md5(nickname+pass)). Script throws the result on to my clipboard, and I hit paste. Thus, no two sites use the same password. If one site is compromised (ex: zappos.com), I just need to change that one password. Script is on my phone, desktop, and cloud drive. I use multiple passwords, a different one based off the importance of the site. I was amazed at how many sites impose a 12 character limit (Fidelity...really?).
- acheron 15y agoYeah, I was annoyed by the 12-character limit at Fidelity too. They also prevent punctuation and other characters. I think the problem is that they unify the website password with a password you can enter on the phone if you call them. I guess that makes it easier to remember for a customer so that they don't have two separate passwords, but touch tone-enterable passwords have completely different requirements from Internet passwords, so think it would be better to decouple them.
- Groxx 15y agoMy personal favorites are the ones that silently truncate your password. A few have done this to me, and it used to take a while to realize wtf was wrong when I couldn't sign in right after creating an account. Now I just start shortening the password until it works, which 'fixes' a good 99% of just-signed-up login failures.
- rch 15y ago>> "None of the passwords contain a colon, because that is the delimiter used to separate usernames and passwords in the combo lists my scripts generate." tldr; Put colons in your passwords...
- VikingCoder 15y ago>> "My scripts only grab usernames and passwords between 3 and 30 characters long, all others are thrown out." tldr; Put colons in your passwords, and make sure your password is 31 characters long. I bet it would also make sense to include "username:" in your password. For instance: username: VikingCoder password: username:CorrectHorseBatteryStaple Or how about like this: username: VikingCoder password: '); DROP TABLE Passwords;
- xanadohnt 15y agoThat's some dedication to Bobby Tables just one person. ;)
- chimeracoder 15y agoThe problem is that you may also erase the entire database of the server you're trying to log into: http://xkcd.com/327/ http://xkcd.com/327/ I guess that's one way of protecting your accounts from being hacked, though... you can't hack an account that no longer exists!
- VikingCoder 15y agoThink about it - do you really want to use a site... that's vulnerable to SQL injection attacks? If my password erases their DB, then I didn't want my password on their DB in the first place!
- chris_wot 15y agoThat's assuming they have a database table called "Password". I'd use: '); DROP DATABASE;
- 15y ago
- mjwalshe 15y agoSo you admit to a number of rather dubious practices both on an openly avaible blog and on a forum that has at least one EX NSA employee as a poster. Anyone else think this is ill advised to say the least - its just asking for your phones to work realy well "nudge nudge wink" ;-)
- zevyoura 15y agoWhat's dubious? I don't think there are many (any?) people who understand what he's talking about and would be able to implement it, but wouldn't be able to figure it out on their own. Of that set, the set of people who are malicious is even smaller, if not non-existent.
- mjwalshe 15y ago"I visit a number of public and private hacking-related forums to get wordlists and hacked passwords. I often pay for VIP memberships (usually the lifetime ones) so that I can access premium content areas. " and when the men with no sense of humor invite you for an interview with out tea and biscuits what would you say to that. ok the are grey areas and I have on behalf of a FST100 organization broken in to a system with explicit permission and clearance from v senior manger and I also had far better contacts at BT's board level to lobby in case or security dept threw a hissy fit than most people
- drucken 15y agoThere is nothing dubious about collecting information if you do it legally. Further, it is what you do with it not the potential that would get you into legal trouble, otherwise Google, Facebook and every other company would be under legal uncertainty. Indeed, your hacking actions were far more risky without prior consent from all parties involved.
- mkopinsky 15y agoJust ask Google what the consequences are of collecting payload data traveling over the open air via their Street View cars. Collecting data is not always legal, even if you don't do anything with it.
- learc83 15y agoWhat if China is using their well known hacker resources to secretly build a giant list of username password combos like this guy, but on a massive scale. They could use botnets to log in to hundreds of thousands of bank accounts and transfer money. There wouldn't be an easy way to detect them because they'd look like legitimate transactions, and the only option would be to temporarily shut down online banking transactions. I wonder how much of a disruption they could cause?
- 3pt14159 15y agoTargeted stikes, yeah, it can work. Massive downloading of gmail account passwords, NOPE. It will set off internal alarms. But yeah, to target one individual, it is indeed possible and they did a string of those when they cracked the rotating RSA key.
- mkjones 15y agoDo you have a reference for people doing an online brute force attack in the RSA attack? IIRC the only brute forcing they did was offline (i.e. cracking hashes that they had locally). Or maybe that's what you were saying, and I'm just misunderstanding you :).
- mgkimsal 15y agoIMAGE: http://michaelkimsal.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2011/06/Screen-shot-2011-04-06-at-6.34.33-PM.png http://michaelkimsal.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2011/06/Scr... "Passwords should not have more than 9 characters". This from a financial institution.
- primaryobjects 15y agoUnfortunately, many banking web sites require short passwords with no special characters. Likely, due to legacy databases and storage. I've even seen 6 character max restrictions. Or worse, the 4-digit pin ones (10,000 combinations yikes, I sure hope they have a limit and lockout for incorrect guesses).
- ch0wn 15y agoMy bank upgraded from a 4-digit pin code authentication to a 6-letter ([a-zA-Z0-9]{4,6}) system. About legacy databases ... Naturally, I complained and they told me it wasn't that big of a deal, because the actual transactions were protected by TAN generators. I had no answer to that.
- chimeracoder 15y agoMaybe I'm confused, but are they saying that you do use independent 2-factor authentication? If so, then that does reduce the risks associated with a weak password, even if it would be better to use a strong password in combination.
- ch0wn 15y agoSorry for being unclear. For the actual transactions, there is a TAN required, but for sniffing around your transactions, seeing all your bank account information and so on, all you need to log in as the 6-letter password.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- stephengillie 15y agoDoes anyone else get the "Access Restricted: you're botnet infected" page? Running virus scan... sigh
- m8urn 15y agoThat is due to the cloudflare service. You can actually leave a note, I do follow up on those. Edit: It's a good thing I'm using that too, 108K hits from this in the last four hours. CloudFlare saved my site from 800k requests and 6GB in bandwidth.
- jwallaceparker 15y agoI've been using 1Password for the past few months. It's been incredibly useful. All my passwords are exponentially more secure and synced across my devices. Can't recommend it enough.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- SCdF 15y agoAdditionally, if you want linux support and don't care so much about the web support that 1Password gives you (your password file is also a website that uses JS to decrypt your passwords) or the prettiness and would like to save US$60 KeePassX works perfectly well.
- K2h 15y agoThank you for sharing the various methods you use to collect the passwords. That is extremely detailed. I was curious if you ever considered putting a date stamp on the log for when you found a particular password. Because you have been collecting for such a long time, you may see some interesting trending.
- m8urn 15y agoI have actually kept most of the original data since I started so I could go back and do that if I wanted. There is about 4gb of raw data there.
- HorizonXP 15y agohttp://xkcd.com/936/ http://xkcd.com/936/ I personally believe that a great startup idea is a website or app that operates like KeePass or 1Password or Revelation, and allows you to enter your passphrase like xkcd suggests, and manages all of your other passwords and logins for you. I'm guilty of using the same password for a lot of sites, and I really need to get that in order. Making it easy for regular users to adopt would be key. It's an idea, I have no idea how you'd execute it. That said, I'm developing a web-based management interface for my contract work that is only going to be used by a few key users/stakeholders. I'm trying to come up with a way incorporate xkcd passphrases into it, forcing my users to adopt it. I don't know how well it would go over though. Guess I just have to try it and see.
- wingspan 15y agoIsn't this what http://lastpass.com http://lastpass.com does?
- billybob 15y agoA sensible password-selection policy really only has two principles: 1. It shouldn't be in a dictionary, so that the only option is brute force 2. It should be very hard to brute force #1 means "don't use anything in this guy's list." For #2, the concept of "password haystacks" is useful: https://www.grc.com/haystack.htm https://www.grc.com/haystack.htm
- DanBC 15y agoSteve Gibson is not considered expert: (http://radsoft.net/rants/20010714,00.shtml http://radsoft.net/rants/20010714,00.shtml) (http://www.groklaw.net/article.php?story=20060113111825193 http://www.groklaw.net/article.php?story=20060113111825193) (http://attrition.org/errata/charlatan/steve_gibson/ http://attrition.org/errata/charlatan/steve_gibson/) etc etc.
- billybob 15y agoIs there something specifically wrong with the concept of password haystacks? I understand it as "force the attacker to search an extremely large potential keyspace." The tool I linked to simply calculates the keyspace that a given candidate password is in.
- dredmorbius 15y agoCompiling/sharing a list like this, so that it can be used in password strength checkers, would be a strong plus. The best password is one that's never been used before. Rainbow tables and other methods mean that any known password (and in a list of exhaustively compiled passwords, finding only 1.3 million distinct values is "small") can be found very quickly given access to hashes, or tried relatively quickly via brute-force. Even a series of login attempts to known / common account names with top-50 (or some n) passwords will generate many hits. I'd love to see online sites check against known lists. I've suggested it to several. One problem is coming up with a good "known list". It would be even more useful for this to be added to standard OS/system security features.
- zupreme 15y agoWith our TeddyPass app we are pretty loose on what users can use as their login password, but we employ pretty robust techniques to prevent brute-force attacks and other common methods. With our system key user data (like stored usernames, passwords, and the description of the account entry) is fully encrypted based on the user's password and other factors. As a result we can't retrieve their data even if we wanted to, so it's in our best interests to allow people to use just about any password they can comfortably remember (within reason).
- pbhjpbhj 15y agoAnyone else worried that Athena (http://www.project2025.com/athena.php http://www.project2025.com/athena.php, link in article is messed up) is actually going to start by installing a keylogger or uploading password files from ones own computer ... Paranoid? F'sure!
- is74 15y agoI thought openID would solve the password problem, because it would allow for each person to remember one password only (which is still better than password1234). What reasons prevented the widespread adoption of openID? For example, if I were a startup, I'd want to have openID on my site to make it easier for users to register, and help them to not forget their passwords. Yet for some reason there are few sites that support it. Any thoughts?
- mkopinsky 15y agoMy goto IRC password is hunter2.