7 ms·
Those struck me as odd. I can’t find much in the author’s experience in the defense space. Advocating for guns over missiles seemed to go against every expectat
by ceejayoz 3y ago
Those struck me as odd. I can’t find much in the author’s experience in the defense space. Advocating for guns over missiles seemed to go against every expectation I have for future naval combat, too.
- obmelvin 3y agoRange is obviously a clear advantage that missiles will basically always have over guns for anti-air, but the cost difference is also huge. This is currently a very real issue in the Red Sea - https://www.politico.com/news/2023/12/19/missile-drone-pentagon-houthi-attacks-iran-00132480 https://www.politico.com/news/2023/12/19/missile-drone-penta... Although I would agree with what I think is your implicit thought, which is that the US really needs to work on interceptors that are significantly cheaper (i.e. the Tamir used by Iron Dome)
- ckozlowski 3y agoThe US Navy is putting a lot of research into directed energy weapons (DEW) for this purpose. The primary intent behind these is to offer a low-cost and "deep magazine" for taking out missiles and drones. There's a few demonstrators out there on various ships with systems like these in the trial stage. One big advantage to DEW over interceptors which the Navy likes is that it isn't another magazine hit risk like conventional missiles and gun ammunition is. Another is that even if the ammo is cheap, it takes up space which is limited on a ship. This presents challenges when operating in areas like the South China Sea or Persian Gulf where countering attacks from land would be likely. Even if the interceptors are cheap, deeper magazines by an attacker on land can simply exhaust the supply on the naval ship. DEW has the potential to rectify this.
- obmelvin 3y agoYes, they seem promising for ships assuming the output can be increased so it doesn't require tracking the target for multiple seconds. I'm a bit less knowledgeable wether the energy requirements can easily be met for other vehicles such as Humvees with vastly different engines & fuel capacities. That said, I'm all in for laser research and the trickle down effects of things like fiber lasers!
- paganel 3y agoYou're not going to win that game with new and expensive tech, to the contrary, you need numbers, and that new and expensive tech doesn't bode well when it comes to numbers.
- ranger207 3y agoNo. Lasers are going to be much more effective than missiles. Missiles in turn were much more effective than shells in WWII.
- paganel 3y agoHow are you going to sink/take out Houthi-like troops with lasers once you approach enemy shores? Taking those people out with missiles is already too expensive and a losing game going forward.
- ranger207 3y agoYou don't shoot them with lasers of course. You can use different tools for different jobs. But for intercepting missiles like this thread is about, new high-tech equipment is going to be more effective than the old stuff
- malloryerik 3y agoAnother question, how will ships protect against incoming lasers?
- ianburrell 3y agoThe Navy tried to make gunfire support work and it was a failure with Zumwalt class. The problem is that artillery is too short range, and modern missiles make getting close to shore too dangerous. The rocket-boosted guided munitions were super expensive especially since Navy developed their own and didn't use Army ones. He is half right about ballistic missiles and glide bombs. It should be possible to launch MLRS rockets from VLS cells. The GLSDB, which is rocket boosted glide bomb would be effective. The PrSM would also be effective for quick strike. The Navy doesn't seem to be interested, but the Marines have tried using HIMARS from deck of amphibious ship. He is wrong about ballistic missiles being cheaper. Cost and size seem to scale with range. The current hypersonic missiles are basically ballistic missiles with longer range glider on them.
- paganel 3y ago> Advocating for guns over missiles seemed to go against every expectation I have for future naval combat, too. Current naval combat involves using missiles worth millions of dollars in order to take down cheap Houthis' drones worth tens of thousands of dollars at most [1]. Replace those missiles with much cheaper artillery and pound the Houthis bases located on shore from 30-40 miles out and you're back to being cost-effective again. Because the US Navy, or any navy for that matter, won't be able to play that game of very expensive missiles vs. cheap drones (or cheap Houthi "missiles") for too long. [1] https://www.politico.com/news/2023/12/19/missile-drone-pentagon-houthi-attacks-iran-00132480 https://www.politico.com/news/2023/12/19/missile-drone-penta...
- ceejayoz 3y agoThose drones can be launched from substantially more than 30-40 miles from the shore. You might use gunnery to take out individual drones coming to attack you or the ships you’re escorting, but you are not likely to manage to hit the launchers/bases.
- paganel 3y ago> Those drones can be launched from substantially more than 30-40 miles from the shore. Yeah, you're correct on that, I was probably going by the good old tactic of "bomb everything that adversarially moves on the shorelines from a relative safe distance out in the sea", which tactic was active (among many competing others) sometime at the end of the 19th century - early 20th century (Douhet partially took cues from that naval tactic when writing about his mass aerial bombardments strategy). But as some other poster mentions in a related comment, there are no definitive Houthi bases, so that leaves one with the question: What exactly to bomb? What exactly needs neutralising? The same questions would be as valid and as difficult to answer were carrier-based airplanes to be available in the vicinity.