8 ms·
begin this is terrible news; is there a better source than twitter (edit: https://lists.inf.ethz.ch/pipermail/oberon/2024/016856.html https://lists.inf.ethz.c
by kragen 3y ago
begin
this is terrible news;
is there a better source than twitter (edit: https://lists.inf.ethz.ch/pipermail/oberon/2024/016856.html https://lists.inf.ethz.ch/pipermail/oberon/2024/016856.html thanks to johndoe0815);
wirth was the greatest remaining apostle of simplicity, correctness, and software built for humans to understand; now only hoare and moore remain, and moore seems to have given the reins at greenarrays to a younger generation;
young people may not be aware of the practical, as opposed to academic, significance of his work, so let me point out that begin
the ide as we know it today was born as turbo pascal;
most early macintosh software was written in pascal, including for example macpaint;
robert griesemer, one of the three original designers of golang, was wirth's student and did his doctoral thesis on an extension of oberon, and wirth's languages were also a very conspicuous design inspiration for newsqueak;
tex is written in pascal;
end;
end.
- wozer 3y agoNo better source yet, I think. But it is the real account of Bertrand Meyer, creator of the Eiffel language.
- kragen 3y agoyeah, and i hope meyer would know but still, it's twitter, liable to vanish or block non-logged-in access at any moment
- PaulHoule 3y agoSince Twitter is suppressing the visibility of tweets that link outside their site I think it would be perfectly fair to block links to twitter, rewrite them to nitter, etc. There also ought to be gentle pressure on people who post to Twitter to move to some other site. I mean, even I've got a Bluesky invite now.
- rileyphone 3y agoPlease don't make dang do more work. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38847048 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38847048
- kragen 3y agobluesky seems like the site for people who think that the problem with twitter was that the wrong billionaire gets to decide which ideas to suppress (admittedly you could make the same criticism of hn; it certainly isn't decentralized and resilient against administrative censorship like usenet was)
- PaulHoule 3y agoWell I didn't mean to just endorse Bluesky but call it out as one of many alternatives. I'm actually active on Mastodon but I am thinking about getting on Instagram as well because the content I post that does the best on Mastodon would fit in there.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- johndoe0815 3y agoNiklaus Wirth's death was also announced (by Andreas Pirklbauer) an hour ago on the Oberon mailing list: https://lists.inf.ethz.ch/pipermail/oberon/2024/016856.html https://lists.inf.ethz.ch/pipermail/oberon/2024/016856.html
- kragen 3y agothank you dang, maybe we can change the url to this instead? this url has been stable for at least 14 years (http://web.archive.org/web/20070720035132/https://lists.inf.ethz.ch/pipermail/oberon/ http://web.archive.org/web/20070720035132/https://lists.inf....) and has a good chance of remaining stable for another 14, while the twitter url is likely to disappear this year or show different results to different people
- Qem 3y ago> wirth was the greatest remaining apostle of simplicity, correctness, and software built for humans to understand; now only hoare and moore remain Also Alan Kay still with us.
- kragen 3y agoin the neat/scruffy divide, which goes beyond ai, wirth was the ultimate neat, and kay is almost the ultimate scruffy, though wall outdoes him alan kay is equally great, but on some axes he is the opposite extreme from wirth: an apostle of flexibility, tolerance for error, and trying things to see what works instead of planning everything out perfectly. as sicp says > Pascal is for building pyramids—imposing, breathtaking, static structures built by armies pushing heavy blocks into place. Lisp is for building organisms—imposing, breathtaking, dynamic structures built by squads fitting fluctuating myriads of simpler organisms into place. kay is an ardent admirer of lisp, and smalltalk is even more of an organism language than lisp is
- nerpderp82 3y agoI had wanted to interview Val Schorre [1], and looked him up on a business trip because I was close. Died 2017, seems like a righteous dude. https://www.legacy.com/us/obituaries/venturacountystar/name/dewey-schorre-obituary?id=10116067 https://www.legacy.com/us/obituaries/venturacountystar/name/... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/META_II https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/META_II
- kragen 3y agoyeah, i wish i had had the pleasure of meeting him. i reimplemented meta-ii 3½ years ago and would recommend it to anyone who is interested in the parsing problem. it's the most powerful non-turing-complete 'programming language' i've ever used http://www.canonical.org/~kragen/sw/dev3/meta5ixrun.py http://www.canonical.org/~kragen/sw/dev3/meta5ixrun.py (i mean i would recommend reimplementing it, not using my reimplementation; it takes a few hours or days) after i wrote it, the acm made all old papers, including schorre's meta-ii paper, available gratis; they have announced that they also plan to make them open-access, but so far have not. still, this is a boon if you want to do this. the paper is quite readable and is at https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/800257.808896 https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/800257.808896
- yawaramin 3y agoMartin Odersky, creator of the Scala language and Wirth's student, also seems to believe it: https://twitter.com/odersky/status/1742618391553171866 https://twitter.com/odersky/status/1742618391553171866
- nerpderp82 3y agoAs far as I know, Henry Baker is still with us. I had a dream where I interviewed Wirth for like 20 hrs so we could clone him with an LLM. We need to grab as much video interviews from folks as possible.
- kragen 3y agohenry baker has made many great contributions, but last time i talked to him, he was waiting for somebody to start paying him again in order to do any more research but i'm sure he'd agree his achievements are not in the same league as wirth's
- nerpderp82 3y agoI wasn't trying to compare them in any other way other than, that Henry Baker is still with us.
- kragen 3y agocool, sorry if i came across as confrontational
- rollcat 3y ago> wirth was the greatest remaining apostle of simplicity, correctness, and software built for humans to understand; And yet far from the last. Simple, correct, and beautiful software is still being made today. Most of it goes unnoticed, its quiet song drowned out by the cacophony of attention-seeking, complex, brittle behemoths that top the charts. That song never faded, you just need to tune in.
- kragen 3y agowho are today's new great minimalists?
- rollcat 3y agoIn no particular order: 100r.co, OpenBSD (& its many individual contributors such as tedu or JCS), Suckless/9front, sr.ht, Alpine, Gemini (&gopher) & all the people you can find there, Low Tech Magazine, antirez, Fabrice Bellard, Virgil Dupras (CollapseOS), & many other people, communities, and projects - sorry I don't have a single comprehensive list, that's just off the top of my head ;)
- kragen 3y agoi... really don't think kris de decker is on niklaus wirth's level. i don't think he can write so much as fizzbuzz fabrice bellard is wirth-level, it's true. not sure about tedu and jcs, because i'm not familiar enough with their work. it's absurd to compare most of the others to wirth and hoare you're comparing kindergarten finger paintings to da vinci you said wirth was "far from the last" apostle of simplicity. definition of apostle: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apostle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apostle
- rollcat 3y ago> it's absurd to compare most of the others to wirth and hoare You're the one trying to directly compare achievement, not me. If you're looking for top achievers, I'd have to name PHP or systemd, and THAT would be out of place ;) I even said "in no particular order", because I don't think any two can be easily compared. My main criterion for inclusion was the drive for simplifying technology, and publishing these efforts: > An apostle [...], in its literal sense, is an emissary. The word is [...] literally "one who is sent off" [...]. The purpose of such sending off is usually to convey a message, and thus "messenger" is a common alternative translation. Every single project, person, or community I've named here has some form of web page, blog, RSS feed, papers/presentations, and/or source code, that serve to carry their messages. Achievement can be measured, simplicity can only be appreciated.
- tahnyall 3y agoIt's OK on Hacker News to dis a reputable news source now?
- bumbledraven 3y ago> wirth was the greatest remaining apostle of simplicity, correctness, and software built for humans to understand; now only hoare and moore remain… No. There is another. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arthur_Whitney_%28computer_scientist%29 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arthur_Whitney_%28computer_s...
- vidarh 3y agoSome would dispute the "built for humans to understand". Whitney's work is brilliant, but it's far less accessible than Wirth's.
- bumbledraven 3y agoThe point of Whitney's array languages is to allow your solutions to be so small that they fit in your head. Key chunks should even fit on one screen. A few years ago, Whitney reportedly started building an OS using these ideas (https://aplwiki.com/wiki/KOS https://aplwiki.com/wiki/KOS).
- vidarh 3y agoI'm aware of the idea. I'm also aware that I can read and understand a whole lot of pages of code in the amount of time it takes me to decipher a few lines of K for example, and the less dense codes sticks far better in my head. I appreciate brevity, but I feel there's a fundamental disconnect between people who want to carefully read code symbol by symbol, who often seem to love languages like J or K, or at least he better able to fully appreciate them, and people like me who want to skim code and look at the shape of it (literally; I remember code best by its layout and often navigate code by appearance without reading it at all, and so dense dumps of symbols are a nightmare to me) I sometimes think it reflects a difference between people who prefer maths vs languages. I'm not suggesting one is better than the other, but I do believe the former is a smaller group than the latter. For my part I want grammar that makes for a light, casual read, not having to decipher. I want to be able to get a rough understanding with a glance, and gradually fill in details, not read things start to finish (yes, I'm impatient) A favourite example of mije is the infamous J interpreter fragment, where I'd frankly be inclined to prefer a disassembly over the source code. But I also find the ability to sketch out such compact code amazing. I think Wirths designs very much fit in the languages that are skimmable and recognisable by shape and structure category. I can remember parts of several of Wirths students PhD theses from the 1990s by the shape of procedures in their Oberon code to this day. That's not to diminish Whitney's work, and I find that disconnect in how we process code endlessly fascinating, and regularly look at languages in that family because there is absolutely a lot to learn from them, but they fit very different personalities and learning styles.
- vidarh 3y agoI've been a massive fan of the PhD dissertation of Wirth's student Michael Franz since I first read it in '94. He's now a professor at UC Irvine, where he supervised Andreas Gal's dissertation work on trace trees (what eventually became TraceMonkey)
- kragen 3y agothank you, i definitely should have mentioned franz's work, even though i didn't know he was gal's advisor perhaps more significant than tracemonkey was luajit, which achieves much higher performance with the tracing technique
- usr1106 3y ago> tex is written in pascal; Just thought about that when Donald Knuth's Christmas lecture https://www.youtube.com/live/622iPkJfYrI https://www.youtube.com/live/622iPkJfYrI lead me to one of his first TeX lectures https://youtu.be/jbrMBOF61e0 https://youtu.be/jbrMBOF61e0 : If I install TeX on my Linux machine now, is that still compiled from the original Pascal source? Is there even a maintained Pascal compiler anymore? Well, GCC (as in GNU compiler collection) probably has a frontend, but that still does not answer the question about maintenance. These were just thoughts. Of course researching the answers would not be overly complicated.
- anon7725 3y ago> Is there even a maintained Pascal compiler anymore? Of course https://www.freepascal.org/ https://www.freepascal.org/
- usr1106 3y agoNice. Although "latest news" are from 2021.
- renewedrebecca 3y agoIt's not like Pascal changes a whole lot.
- badsectoracula 3y agoFree Pascal does very infrequent releases though the compiler is under active development and even has a bunch of new features both for the compiler (e.g. a wasm backend) and the language itself. There are always multiple daily commits in the git log by several developers.
- anta40 3y agoThe discussions in Gitlab are still active: https://gitlab.com/freepascal.org/fpc/source/-/issues https://gitlab.com/freepascal.org/fpc/source/-/issues Of course, you can always build the latest version from Git.
- rramadass 3y ago> wirth was the greatest remaining apostle of simplicity, correctness, and software built for humans to understand Absolutely! And equally important was his ability to convey/teach CS precisely, concisely and directly in his books/papers. None of them have any fluff nor unnecessary obfuscation in them. These are the models to follow and the ideals to aspire to. As an example see his book Systematic Programming: An Introduction.