3 ms·
No, how would they know this for any given password? Gashibyu@gyoryana3: is that recycled, or freshly minted?
by kazinator 3y ago
No, how would they know this for any given password?
Gashibyu@gyoryana3: is that recycled, or freshly minted?
- pompino 3y agoalso there is no way to know if the usernames from the leaks are the same person as your own users. otherwise, you’re essentially saying that you have to pick a unique password that nobody else in the world is using.
- kazinator 3y agosn*wfl@ake1
- g-b-r 3y agoIf you've got that out of a random password generator, beat yourself for not having bought a lottery ticket instead of generating a password
- feoren 3y agoIf everyone in the world were using 100 passwords, you'd need space for 800 billion passwords, which is 39.5 bits of entropy. Assuming an alphabet of 74 characters (lower + upper + digits + a few symbols), you'd need a little over 6 characters to make 800 billion unique passwords. A random password of 9 characters has a very low chance of overlapping any other password in the world: somewhere around Sqrt(74^9 / 74^6.2) ~= 0.2%. That's a 0.2% chance of overlapping any other password -- multiply that by the probability of having your password leaked for the chance that it's on the blacklist. Make it 10+ and you're fine.
- g-b-r 3y agoAnd what's controversial in picking a unique password that nobody else in the world is using? (and hasn't been leaked yet, actually)
- pompino 3y agoThere is no way to know or verify what is or isn't a real leak, and what passwords are or aren't leaked. We can't settle this in the comments, and I think it's just security theater. 1. User x signs up for Service A using pwd abcd1234 2. User y signs up for Service B using pwd abcd1234 2. User z signs up for Service C using pwd abcd1234 Service A is breached. Users x,y,z get emails forcing a reset of their password. Users x,y,z reset their password to abcd1245 and all is good (among many other permutations). Now Service B is breached, rinse and repeat. Depending on the workflow (the more automated it is the worse off we are), there are security vectors to exploit here by doing a carefully planned fake 'leak' using mostly useless emails but only a few genuine emails to trigger pw resets, etc, etc.
- g-b-r 3y agoI'm not sure what you're talking about, you definitely seem to have misconceptions about passwords, their math and services like haveibeenpwned. You seem to like simple passwords and think that people should use them so long as they're not leaked. Well no, simple passwords are never good; a probably very large number of the possible ones has already been the subject of some leak, and they're very risky in any case. Service providers (should) strive to give some protections even to users with bad passwords, but you sure can't rely on that.
- pompino 3y agoIts easy to lose track of these complex topics. Anyway another day, another time maybe I can explain it better to you.
- drdaeman 3y agohttps://haveibeenpwned.com/Passwords https://haveibeenpwned.com/Passwords > This password wasn't found in any of the Pwned Passwords loaded into Have I Been Pwned. That doesn't necessarily mean it's a good password, merely that it's not indexed on this site. But I doubt it's a common practice to do this kind of check.
- g-b-r 3y agoYeah it's sure not common yet but in a 2021 post Troy Hunt says it was already thousands: > literally thousands of other services doing everything from providing their own password checker through to checking their customers' passwords on every registration, login or password change to see if it's previously been breached (https://www.troyhunt.com/open-source-pwned-passwords-with-fbi-feed-and-225m-new-nca-passwords-is-now-live https://www.troyhunt.com/open-source-pwned-passwords-with-fb...)
- drdaeman 3y agoRight, but thousands is a minuscule number - there are myriads of services out there. While it would've been nice if 23andMe would've used a service like this, can't exactly blame them if they didn't - it's not like this is some well-established industry standard, but more like an extra effort by extra security-conscious companies.
- g-b-r 3y agoYes true What I'd blame 23andMe for, is having encouraged so much all that sharing of sensitive data with other accounts, without providing additional safeguards to access such data.
- kazinator 3y agoI don't think it's a good idea to depend on yet another third party domain in this way. The check has low value. HaveIBeenPwned only provides value when it positively informs about a pwned password, otherwise it says nothing useful. If you're already rejecting weak passwords using some heuristics, then the remaining passwords are unlikely to show up on that site, because, strong passwords are unlikely to be pwned, even if reused and subject to a breach.