5 ms·

2FA is so, so, so very tiring.. all day long, 2FAing. We need to move past it. And no, I don't have an answer for it.

rafaelmn 3y ago
Passkeys ?
marcosdumay 3y ago
It just needs to be done correctly, not as a "gimme your phone number, peasant" excuse for data mining. How many computers do you use normally? How hard would it be to link them to your accounts?
- littlecranky67 3y ago
  Problem is using multiple browsers, or when a privacy-conscious user decides to delete internet history.
- oarsinsync 3y ago
  > How many computers do you use normally? How hard would it be to link them to your accounts? I use private browsing exclusively, so, I’d hope that’s difficult link to me reliably.
  - marcosdumay 3y ago
    Well, you if want to both refuse that a site reliably identify you and have a flawless process for identifying you, you'll have a hard time.
    - oarsinsync 3y ago
      > Well, you if want to both refuse that a site reliably identify you and have a flawless process for identifying you, you'll have a hard time. and yet the digital certificate the government issues me means they can flawlessly identify me, when i choose for them to be able to identify me, rather than by them permanently tracking my machine. Explicitly allowlisting a particular install of a particular browser isn’t a strong choice when we already have PKI.
  - alpaca128 3y ago
    In case you refer to incognito/private windows: that's completely useless. All you can hope to get from it is automatic deletion of cookies. Google got a huge fine for tracking everyone in private mode [0] and you can be certain everyone else who didn't yet get dragged to court is still doing it. [0] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/dec/29/google-lawsuit-settlement-incognito-mode https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/dec/29/google-la...
- crazygringo 3y ago
  It's still exhausting. Literally every time I pay for something via PayPal on my computer, I need to pull out my phone, find the authenticator app, open it, scroll to PayPal, tap it, see if there's enough time for this code or if I should wait for the next one, type the 6 digits into the site... I mean it takes half a minute, and this easily gets repeated several times a day if you engage in a lot of transaction-type things. And it's no faster if it's by SMS or by e-mail because I'm still spending 15 seconds waiting for the message, and then opening it, typing, then going back to delete the message so it doesn't clutter my inbox -- half a minute total again.
  - kaibee 3y ago
    > see if there's enough time for this code or if I should wait for the next one, type the 6 digits into the site... In my experience on most services (not sure about paypal specifically) there's a grace period where a code that just 'expired' is still valid for another ~10-30 seconds? So... at least you can skip that part.
  - vel0city 3y ago
    Sounds like a good use case for fido authenticators or passkeys.
  - mvdtnz 3y ago
    Have you ever done literally anything that is actually exhausting? Because this.... this is not exhausting.
  - wlesieutre 3y ago
    > see if there's enough time for this code I haven't tried PayPal specifically, but websites will usually still accept the previous code for at least a few seconds after a new one rolls over
  - sratner 3y ago
    Not to disagree with the cumbersome process - just want to point out that TOTP codes are valid for 30 seconds after the "expire" (60 seconds total). So as long as you are able to remember / copy the digits, there is no need to wait for the next code even if you don't have enough time to type it in. It will still work. Tangentially, I really wish authenticator apps continued to show the previous code for 30 seconds so I can continue to refer to it for apps that don't allow copy and paste.
DenisM 3y ago
A simple solution is 2FA unknown/new devices.
asimpletune 3y ago
On Apple devices it's super easy, barely an inconvenience
wolpoli 3y ago
Right now, the web experience for 2FA is very poor compared to using a mobile app. I wish I could just put my phone on an NFC reader when a site requires 2FA, and then all I have to do is to confirm on the phone itself.

Passkeys ?

It just needs to be done correctly, not as a "gimme your phone number, peasant" excuse for data mining. How many computers do you use normally? How hard would it be to link them to your accounts?

littlecranky67 3y ago
Problem is using multiple browsers, or when a privacy-conscious user decides to delete internet history.
oarsinsync 3y ago
> How many computers do you use normally? How hard would it be to link them to your accounts? I use private browsing exclusively, so, I’d hope that’s difficult link to me reliably.
- marcosdumay 3y ago
  Well, you if want to both refuse that a site reliably identify you and have a flawless process for identifying you, you'll have a hard time.
  - oarsinsync 3y ago
    > Well, you if want to both refuse that a site reliably identify you and have a flawless process for identifying you, you'll have a hard time. and yet the digital certificate the government issues me means they can flawlessly identify me, when i choose for them to be able to identify me, rather than by them permanently tracking my machine. Explicitly allowlisting a particular install of a particular browser isn’t a strong choice when we already have PKI.
- alpaca128 3y ago
  In case you refer to incognito/private windows: that's completely useless. All you can hope to get from it is automatic deletion of cookies. Google got a huge fine for tracking everyone in private mode [0] and you can be certain everyone else who didn't yet get dragged to court is still doing it. [0] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/dec/29/google-lawsuit-settlement-incognito-mode https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/dec/29/google-la...
crazygringo 3y ago
It's still exhausting. Literally every time I pay for something via PayPal on my computer, I need to pull out my phone, find the authenticator app, open it, scroll to PayPal, tap it, see if there's enough time for this code or if I should wait for the next one, type the 6 digits into the site... I mean it takes half a minute, and this easily gets repeated several times a day if you engage in a lot of transaction-type things. And it's no faster if it's by SMS or by e-mail because I'm still spending 15 seconds waiting for the message, and then opening it, typing, then going back to delete the message so it doesn't clutter my inbox -- half a minute total again.
- kaibee 3y ago
  > see if there's enough time for this code or if I should wait for the next one, type the 6 digits into the site... In my experience on most services (not sure about paypal specifically) there's a grace period where a code that just 'expired' is still valid for another ~10-30 seconds? So... at least you can skip that part.
- vel0city 3y ago
  Sounds like a good use case for fido authenticators or passkeys.
- mvdtnz 3y ago
  Have you ever done literally anything that is actually exhausting? Because this.... this is not exhausting.
- wlesieutre 3y ago
  > see if there's enough time for this code I haven't tried PayPal specifically, but websites will usually still accept the previous code for at least a few seconds after a new one rolls over
- sratner 3y ago
  Not to disagree with the cumbersome process - just want to point out that TOTP codes are valid for 30 seconds after the "expire" (60 seconds total). So as long as you are able to remember / copy the digits, there is no need to wait for the next code even if you don't have enough time to type it in. It will still work. Tangentially, I really wish authenticator apps continued to show the previous code for 30 seconds so I can continue to refer to it for apps that don't allow copy and paste.

DenisM 3y ago

A simple solution is 2FA unknown/new devices.

asimpletune 3y ago

On Apple devices it's super easy, barely an inconvenience

wolpoli 3y ago

Right now, the web experience for 2FA is very poor compared to using a mobile app. I wish I could just put my phone on an NFC reader when a site requires 2FA, and then all I have to do is to confirm on the phone itself.