5 ms·
How to get rich in the 21st century
- wslh 3y agohttps://archive.is/ix97l https://archive.is/ix97l
- ssss11 3y agoInheritance?
- wslh 3y agoThis is for sure the top. Offering alternatives to this thinking is helpful. For example, the 70s, 80s pushed some of the US middle class upwards [1] (and some not). [1] https://www.baltimoresun.com/1992/03/08/us-middle-class-shrank-during-1970s-and-1980s/ https://www.baltimoresun.com/1992/03/08/us-middle-class-shra... | https://archive.is/hgtpq https://archive.is/hgtpq
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- chris-orgmenta 3y agoUnrelated note: I notice a lot of people in the UK are angry at inheritance tax going up - Not knowing that it wouldn't impact them and only affects >1millionGBP. So the lower class is tricked (conspiratorially or otherwise) into fighting for wealth redistribution to NOT happen.
- plexman 3y agoWe should not punish savers. This "wealth redistribution" talk is bollocks.
- chris-orgmenta 3y agoSo my parents gift me money in their will, and I am owed it somehow because I share genes? I don't get it, apart from certain return for if the child did genuinely 'earn it' through caring for parents in old age etc. We need to end this divine-right thinking, IMO. I think it's the perfect place to get tax rev (it's the tax that is furthest away from 'units of work' that I can think of. Far better than getting it from an income tax). I.e. it is the tax that penalises people the least for creating value. --- I guess my current position is that 1. It is poor economic policy not to go heavy on inheritance tax (as far as emigration of the upper class remains inelastic), and 2. People claiming their relatives' estates is not compelling to me (but I am open to being compelled)
- plexman 3y agoYou should have the right to gift whatever you want to your descendants, and the general public should have no cut from your hard work and the decision not to consume it all. You paid taxes all your life. Your descendants are going to be paying taxes for the new assets. OP saying not to worry, its just a problem if you receive more than 1kk, well in 100 years with inflation i bet this will be a problem for everybody.
- chris-orgmenta 3y agoUK inheritance tax is indeed based on flat GBP amounts, and it would indeed have been less overhead to make it ratios/pegged to something. But these get reviewed and adjusted often, so the assumption that inflation would impact this is a bit premature. > You should have the right to gift whatever you want to your descendants, and the general public should have no cut from your hard work and the decision not to consume it all. > You paid taxes all your life. Your descendants are going to be paying taxes for the new assets. Yes that's the problem - This is not at all compelling to me, and vice versa I am not compelling to you. I feel that your side needs to be extra compelling too, so as to prove that it is better to take from another tax than from inheritance tax. It is very much in my interest for me to be convinced by you. I want to believe :)
- 3y ago
- gruez 3y agoIf you read past the title you'd see that the article is talking about countries getting rich, not individuals.
- anovikov 3y ago[flagged]
- wslh 3y agoBut we can also say that China, which is not a democracy, dramatically increased their middle class [1]. This is not an anti-democracy advocacy but I think we should understand the big picture. In this context, we cannot see democracy as an static thing and try to evolve. [1] "The Evolution of Middle Class Chinese Outbound Travel Preferences: An International Perspective": https://www.researchgate.net/publication/262789226_The_Evolution_of_Middle_Class_Chinese_Outbound_Travel_Preferences_An_International_Perspective https://www.researchgate.net/publication/262789226_The_Evolu...
- anovikov 3y agoThey did so by destroying their environment, and ultimately, themselves. Their reproduction rate is at best half of minimally sustaining level. It's not nearly as bad in any free country, they literally ate their own soul in pursuit of rapid economic growth pushed by dictators longing for world domination.
- gruez 3y ago>They did so by destroying their environment Isn't that a stage that all countries go through? Before the EPA the environment in the US was probably just as bad.
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoI don't think China is a counterexample (yet). They have yet to show that they can get beyond the "middle income trap". South Korea, Japan, and Singapore might be counterexamples, though.
- randomdata 3y ago> China, which is not a democracy While China is generally considered the least democratic country in the world, it does exhibit some glimmers of democracy. Democracy is most certainly not a binary state. Regardless, China is still quite poor compared to peer countries. Maybe that will change someday, but it is a long road ahead.
- thiago_fm 3y agoIndia and UAE have a long way to go and won't happen within a generation. India is a marvelous country, but there's no way it will sustain 7%+ a year. Furthermore, it's much further away than other BRICS in GDP per Capita. Let's be honest, China, even despite the recent economic turmoil, is the only country armed with the weapons needed to jump into the 20K+ GDP per Capita club soon. China is more self-sufficient than most think. Examples: Alibaba's international business is just 10%, rest is selling to Chinese. BYD builds and sells more EVs than Tesla, mostly to Chinese people. It's also heavily disciplined, low-crime rates etc. Chinese kids with access to school end up studying a lot and it's incredible the amount of talent existing there. Just read AI publications, check the authors and you'll see what I mean. Now, if you ask me whether China is a great country to live in, as it's not a democratic country and having a high GDP per Capita in such a system might not be so nice to live in, I agree. But if we are talking barely about income per Capita. It's China. China isn't that bothered about the US as well. It can do business with every other country. It has great relationships with Europe. And furthermore, it has the biggest growing consumer base in the world. Not even American businesses want to stay out of that market. Not saying China will ever surpass America in living standards or economics this century, but it has lots of potential to be extremely powerful. China is in for the long game. In around 20-30 years, India will be in a similar state, trying to avoid the middle-income trap, but that will take sometime. We still have to wait and see.
- laszlojamf 3y agoAt the same time, their population is in freefall, they have a massive housing bubble, and they import most of their energy and foodstuffs. Not saying that you're wrong, but it's definitely more complicated than what you are making it out to be.
- thiago_fm 3y agoChina has more than enough people, the challenge there is how to make them all consumers with fat wallets and raise their productivity. They indeed import most of their energy and food stuffs. Like any big exporter, see Germany for instance. Really similar, just different consuming power. For the housing bubble, it's part of planned development. It isn't as bad as a housing bubble in the US, as the government from China isn't democratic. The Chinese government can easily use its authority to tell the average Chinese to eat it up.
- nomonnai 3y agoThe article is about how countries get rich, i.e., boost their GDP. Of course, people in these countries will benefit from a growing GDP, but it's a different subject matter than amassing riches as an individual. China's (12.7) and India's (2.4) GDP per capita are very low compared with South Korea's (32.4) or Japan's (33.8). The average Chinese or Indian citizen is relatively poor compared with their peers in developed countries. Changing this requires long-term sustained growth, which is difficult to get right. China is greatly challenged by its demography and super-power ambitions with stagnating growth. India's problems have much to do with bureaucracy and lack of infrastructure, but it has shown robust growth in recent years. However, as difficult as India's problems are, China's demographic outlook and its political implications are nightmarish.